RESUMO
PURPOSE: Preclinical studies have shown a preferential normal tissue sparing effect of FLASH radiation therapy with ultra-high dose rates. The aim of the present study was to use a murine model of acute skin toxicity to investigate the biologic effect of varying dose rates, time structure, and introducing pauses in the dose delivery. METHODS AND MATERIALS: The right hind limbs of nonanaesthetized mice were irradiated in the entrance plateau of a pencil beam scanning proton beam with 39.3 Gy. Experiment 1 was with varying field dose rates (0.7-80 Gy/s) without repainting, experiment 2 was with varying field dose rates (0.37-80 Gy/s) with repainting, and in experiment 3, the dose was split into 2, 3, 4, or 6 identical deliveries with 2-minute pauses. In total, 320 mice were included, with 6 to 25 mice per group. The endpoints were skin toxicity of different levels up to 25 days after irradiation. RESULTS: The dose rate50, which is the dose rate to induce a response in 50% of the animals, depended on the level of skin toxicity, with the higher toxicity levels displaying a FLASH effect at 0.7-2 Gy/s. Repainting resulted in higher toxicity for the same field dose rate. Splitting the dose into 2 deliveries reduced the FLASH effect, and for 3 or more deliveries, the FLASH effect was almost abolished for lower grades of toxicity. CONCLUSIONS: The dose rate that induced a FLASH effect varied for different skin toxicity levels, which are characterized by a differing degree of sensitivity to radiation dosage. Conclusions on a threshold for the dose rate needed to obtain a FLASH effect can therefore be influenced by the dose sensitivity of the used endpoint. Splitting the total dose into more deliveries compromised the FLASH effect. This can have an impact for fractionation as well as for regions where 2 or more FLASH fields overlap within the same treatment session.
Assuntos
Terapia com Prótons , Pele , Animais , Camundongos , Pele/efeitos da radiação , Terapia com Prótons/efeitos adversos , Terapia com Prótons/métodos , Relação Dose-Resposta à Radiação , Feminino , Fatores de Tempo , Membro Posterior/efeitos da radiação , Lesões Experimentais por Radiação , Dosagem RadioterapêuticaRESUMO
PURPOSE: The aim of this work was to investigate the ability of a biological oxygen enhancement ratio-weighted dose, DOER, to describe acute skin toxicity variations observed in mice after proton pencil beam scanning irradiations with changing doses and beam time structures. METHODS AND MATERIALS: In five independent experiments, the right hind leg of a total of 621 CDF1 mice was irradiated previously in the entrance plateau of a pencil beam scanning proton beam. The incidence of acute skin toxicity (of level 1.5-2.0-2.5-3.0-3.5) was scored for 47 different mouse groups that mapped toxicity as function of dose for conventional and FLASH dose rate, toxicity as function of field dose rate with and without repainting, and toxicity when splitting the treatment into 1 to 6 identical deliveries separated by 2 minutes. DOER was calculated for all mouse groups using a simple oxygen kinetics model to describe oxygen depletion. The three independent model parameters (oxygen-depletion rate, oxygen-recovery rate, oxygen level without irradiation) were fitted to the experimental data. The ability of DOER to describe the toxicity variations across all experiments was investigated by comparing DOER-response curves across the five independent experiments. RESULTS: After conversion from the independent variable tested in each experiment to DOER, all five experiments had similar MDDOER50 (DOER giving 50% toxicity incidence) with standard deviations of 0.45 - 1.6 Gy for the five toxicity levels. DOER could thus describe the observed toxicity variations across all experiments. CONCLUSIONS: DOER described the varying FLASH-sparing effect observed for a wide range of conditions. Calculation of DOER for other irradiation conditions can quantitatively estimate the FLASH-sparing effect for arbitrary irradiations for the investigated murine model. With appropriate fitting parameters DOER also may be able to describe FLASH effect variations with dose and dose rate for other assays and endpoints.
Assuntos
Oxigênio , Terapia com Prótons , Pele , Animais , Camundongos , Pele/efeitos da radiação , Terapia com Prótons/efeitos adversos , Terapia com Prótons/métodos , Lesões Experimentais por Radiação/prevenção & controle , Fatores de Tempo , Relação Dose-Resposta à Radiação , Radiodermite/etiologia , Radiodermite/patologia , Feminino , Membro Posterior/efeitos da radiação , Camundongos Endogâmicos , Prótons/efeitos adversosRESUMO
BACKGROUND: The spatial and temporal dose rate distribution of pencil beam scanning (PBS) proton therapy is important in ultra-high dose rate (UHDR) or FLASH irradiations. Validation of the temporal structure of the dose rate is crucial for quality assurance and may be performed using detectors with high temporal resolution and large dynamic range. PURPOSE: To provide time-resolved in vivo dose rate measurements using a scintillator-based detector during proton PBS pre-clinical mouse experiments with dose rates ranging from conventional to UHDR. METHODS: All irradiations were performed at the entrance plateau of a 250 MeV PBS proton beam. A detector system with four fiber-coupled ZnSe:O inorganic scintillators and 20 µs temporal resolution was used for dose rate measurements. The system was first characterized in terms of precision and stem signal. The detector precision was determined through repeated irradiations with the same field. The stem signal contribution was quantified by irradiating two of the detector probes alongside a bare fiber (fiber without a coupled scintillator). Next, the detector system was calibrated against an ionization chamber (IC) with all four detector probes and the IC placed in a water bath at 2 cm depth. A scan pattern covering 9.6 × 9.6 cm was used. Multiple irradiations with different requested nozzle currents provided instantaneous dose rates at the detector positions in the range of 7-1270 Gy/s. The correspondence of the detector signal (in Volts) to the instantaneous dose rate (in Gy/s) was found. The instantaneous dose rate was calculated from the beam current and the spot-to-detector distance assuming a Gaussian beam profile at distances up to 8 mm from the spot. Afterwards, the calibrated system was used in vivo, in mouse experiments, where mouse legs were irradiated with a constant dose and varying field dose rates of 0.7-87.5 Gy/s. The instantaneous dose rate was measured for each delivered spot and the delivered dose was determined as the integrated instantaneous dose rate. The spot dose profile and PBS dose rate map were calculated. The dose contamination to neighbouring mice were measured together with the upper limit of the dose to the mouse body. RESULTS: The detectors showed high precision with ≤0.4% fluctuations in the measured dose. The stem signal exceeded 10% for spots <5 mm from the optical fiber and >18 mm from the scintillator. It contributed up to 0.2% to the total dose, which was considered negligible. All four detectors showed a non-linear relation between signal and instantaneous dose rate, which was modelled with a polynomial response function. In the mouse experiments, the measured scintillator dose showed 1.8% fluctuations, independent of the field dose rate. The in vivo measured spot dose profile had tails that deviated from a Gaussian profile with measurable dose contributions from spots up to 85 mm from the detector. Neighbour mouse irradiation contributed â¼1% of the total mouse dose. The upper limit of the mouse body dose was 6% of the mouse leg dose. CONCLUSIONS: A fiber-coupled inorganic scintillator-based detector system can provide high precision in vivo measurements of the instantaneous dose rate if correction for the non-linear dose rate dependency is applied.
Assuntos
Terapia com Prótons , Prótons , Radiometria , Dosagem RadioterapêuticaRESUMO
PURPOSE: Preclinical studies indicate a normal tissue sparing effect when ultra-high dose rate (FLASH) radiation is used, while tumor response is maintained. This differential response has promising perspectives for improved clinical outcome. This study investigates tumor control and normal tissue toxicity of pencil beam scanning (PBS) proton FLASH in a mouse model. METHODS AND MATERIALS: Tumor bearing hind limbs of non-anaesthetized CDF1 mice were irradiated in a single fraction with a PBS proton beam using either conventional (CONV) dose rate (0.33-0.63 Gy/s field dose rate, 244 MeV) or FLASH (71-89 Gy/s field dose rate, 250 MeV). 162 mice with a C3H mouse mammary carcinoma subcutaneously implanted in the foot were irradiated with physical doses of 40-60 Gy (8-14 mice per dose point). The endpoints were tumor control (TC) assessed as no recurrent tumor at 90 days after treatment, the level of acute moist desquamation (MD) to the skin of the foot within 25 days post irradiation, and radiation induced fibrosis (RIF) within 24 weeks post irradiation. RESULTS: TCD50 (dose for 50% tumor control) was similar for CONV and FLASH with values (and 95% confidence intervals) of 49.1 (47.0-51.4) Gy for CONV and 51.3 (48.6-54.2) Gy for FLASH. RIF analysis was restricted to mice with tumor control. Both endpoints showed distinct normal tissue sparing effect of proton FLASH with MDD50 (dose for 50% of mice displaying moist desquamation) of <40.1 Gy for CONV and 52.3 (50.0-54.6) Gy for FLASH, (dose modifying factor at least 1.3) and FD50 (dose for 50% of mice displaying fibrosis) of 48.6 (43.2-50.8) Gy for CONV and 55.6 (52.5-60.1) Gy for FLASH (dose modifying factor of 1.14). CONCLUSIONS: FLASH had the same tumor control as CONV, but reduced normal tissue damage assessed as acute skin damage and radiation induced fibrosis.
Assuntos
Terapia com Prótons , Prótons , Camundongos , Animais , Camundongos Endogâmicos C3H , Recidiva Local de Neoplasia , Terapia com Prótons/efeitos adversos , Terapia com Prótons/métodos , Pele/efeitos da radiação , Dosagem RadioterapêuticaRESUMO
PURPOSE: Key factors in FLASH treatments are the ultra-high dose rate (UHDR) and the time structure of the beam delivery. Measurement of the time structure in pencil beam scanning (PBS) proton FLASH treatments is challenging for many types of detectors since high temporal resolution is needed. In this study, a fast scintillator detector system was developed and used to measure the individual spot durations as well as the time when the beam moves between two positions (transition duration) during PBS proton FLASH and UHDR treatments. The spot durations were compared with machine log-file recordings. METHODS: A detector system based on inorganic scintillating crystals was developed. The system consisted of four detector probes made of a sub-millimeter ZnSe:O crystal that was coupled via an optical fiber to an optical reader with 50 kHz sampling rate. The detector system was used in two experiments, both performed with a PBS proton beam with 250 MeV beam energy and 215 nA requested nozzle beam current. The sampling rate enabled multiple measurements during each spot delivery and during the beam transition between spots. First, the detector was tested in a phantom experiment, where a total of 305 scan sequences were delivered to the four detectors. The number of spots delivered without beam interruption in a single scan sequence ranged from one to 35. The spot duration and transition duration were measured for each individual spot. Secondly, the detector system was used in vivo in preclinical experiments with FLASH irradiation of mouse legs placed in the entrance plateau of the beam. A single detector was placed 1 cm downstream of the irradiated mouse leg. The mouse dose ranged from 30.5 to 44.2 Gy and the field consisted of 35 spots. The spot durations as well as the mean dose rate (field dose divided by the measured field duration) for each mouse were determined using the detector and then compared with the corresponding log files. RESULTS: The phantom experiment showed that the logged total duration of an uninterrupted spot sequence was consistently shorter than the measured duration with a difference of -0.252 ms (95% confidence interval: [-0.255, -0.249 ms]). This corresponded to 0.05%-0.07% of the spot sequence duration in the mice experiments. For individual spots, the mean ± 1SD difference between logged and measured spot duration was -0.39 ± 0.05 ms for the first spot in a sequence, 0.13 ± 0.04 ms for the last spot in a sequence, and -0.0017 ± 0.09 ms for the intermediate spots in a sequence. The measured spot transition durations were 0.20 ± 0.04 ms (5.1 mm horizontal steps) and 0.50 ± 0.04 ms (5.0 mm vertical steps). For the mouse experiments, the mean dose rate calculated from the measured field duration was 84.1-92.5 Gy/s. It agreed with log files with a root mean square difference of 0.02 Gy/s. CONCLUSIONS: Fiber-coupled scintillator detectors were designed with sufficient temporal resolution to measure the spot and transition duration during PBS proton UHDR deliveries. Their small volume makes them feasible for in vivo use in preclinical FLASH studies. The logged spot durations were in excellent agreement with measurements but showed small systematic errors in the logged duration for the first and last spot in a sequence.