A multicentred study to validate a consensus bleeding assessment tool developed by the biomedical excellence for safer transfusion collaborative for use in patients with haematological malignancy.

BACKGROUND: There continues to be uncertainty about the optimal approach to documenting bleeding data in platelet transfusion trials, with a desire to apply a common assessment tool across all trials. With this in mind, a consensus bleeding assessment tool (BAT) has been developed by the Biomedical Excellence for Safer Transfusion (BEST) collaborative, based on review of data collection forms used in published randomized trials and following content validation with a range of healthcare professionals at seven haematology centres through BEST members. This study aimed to evaluate reliability and reproducibility of the consensus BAT. METHODS: Replicated clinical assessments of bleeding were undertaken by participants with haematological malignancies recruited at four haematology centres in an international, multicentred, observational study. Concordance of repeat assessments was calculated for agreement in site and grade of bleeding observed. RESULTS: Forty patients consented to participate, and 13 trained bleeding assessors collected these data. Bleeding assessments were carried out on 113 separate days. Of all 225 bleeding assessments, 204 were compared for grade concordance, and 160 were compared for site concordance. There was very good grade concordance (83%, 95% confidence interval 74-93%) and good bleeding site concordance (69%, 95% confidence interval 57-79%) in observations of bleeding. Discordance was primarily in relation to assessing skin bleeding. CONCLUSIONS: Alongside a structured training programme, levels of concordance for a consensus BAT were high. Researchers using assessment tools for bleeding need to balance comprehensive data collection against potential loss of accuracy for some types of bleeding, such as skin findings.

Methods for the analysis of bleeding outcomes in randomized trials of PLT transfusion triggers.

BACKGROUND: A number of methodologic challenges arise in the analysis of bleeding data from clinical trials of PLT transfusion triggers. It is important to understand the assumptions and role of the various methods of analysis to interpret published trials and to design future studies appropriately. STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS: The methods of analysis used for testing the effectiveness and safety of transfusion strategies are reviewed from several recent PLT transfusion trigger trials. The underlying assumptions of these methods are discussed, as well as the clinical interpretations of the resulting summary statistics. Four methods of analysis were applied to data from a large PLT transfusion trigger study to illustrate the differences in the interpretations that can arise from various approaches. RESULTS: PLT transfusion trigger trials of patients with leukemia have based their primary analyses on 1) simple dichotomous classifications of whether or not at least 1 day of clinically important bleeding was experienced; 2) the time to the first day of clinically important bleeding; and 3) the proportion of days at risk with clinically important bleeding. Recurrent event methods provide a robust alternative approach to the analysis of this kind of data and should be considered if interest is in capturing the overall burden of bleeding over time. These four methods differ in the extent to which they utilize information on the number of days with bleeding and the temporal variation in bleeding patterns. Inferences drawn regarding the relative safety and efficacy of different transfusion triggers can vary depending on the method of analysis. CONCLUSION: To rigorously design and analyze future PLT transfusion studies based on bleeding outcomes, it is important to have a clear understanding of the interpretation of the different ways of analyzing bleeding outcomes. The analysis strategy should be selected based on the clinical question being addressed.

The use of electron microscopy in the investigation of the ultrastructural morphology of immune thrombocytopenic purpura platelets.

Ultrastructural studies have proven useful for the accurate identification and classification of certain lymphoid and hematopoietic disorders; however, the value of electron microscopy in the diagnosis and clinical management of platelet pathology is less well defined. Electron microscopy has been used to evaluate inherited platelet disorders. In these disorders, certain platelet structural defects can be characteristic. Recently, we investigated the ultrastructural morphology and immunogold localization of IgG in platelets from patients with idiopathic thrombocytopenic purpura (ITP). The accelerated platelet destruction of ITP is mediated by antiplatelet autoantibodies directed against platelet surface glycoproteins and by the functional capacity of the reticuloendothelial system. The basic dysregulation that occurs in these patients remains unexplained. Traditionally, laboratory investigation of ITP has focused on the development of serologic assays to measure the autoantibodies. As an alternative investigative approach, determination of the immunomorphologic characteristics of platelet-associated IgG (PAIgG) in ITP platelets may prove useful in the diagnosis or clinical management of patients with ITP. Our results showed that the ultrastructural morphology of ITP platelets is similar to that observed for normal platelets. No structural abnormalities are observed in ITP platelets. Immunogold labeling of IgG within alpha-granules of ITP platelets is significantly higher than that of normal platelets. Additionally, in some ITP platelets, immunogold labeling is also observed on the platelet surface and within channels of the open-cannalicular system. In comparison, immunogold labeling of these structures in normal platelets, is rare, or absent. In conclusion, electron microscopic studies should contribute to furthering our understanding of this common autoimmune disorder, and may provide possible biological explanations for the increased levels of PAIgG in platelets from patients with ITP.