Variations in leaf phyllosphere microbial communities and development of tobacco brown spot before and after fungicide application.

In recent years, STROBY (50% Kresoxim-methyl) has been widely used to control tobacco brown spot in Guizhou Province, China. As a broad-spectrum fungicide, STROBY targets not only phytopathogens, but also affects many other microorganisms including those pathogenic, beneficial, or neutral to the plant hosts. To understand the effects of STROBY on the phyllosphere microbial communities of tobacco leaves during the development of tobacco brown spot, the fungal and bacterial communities of symptomatic and asymptomatic leaves at four time points, before spraying (August 29) and after spraying (September 3, 8, and 13), were investigated using the Illumina high-throughput sequencing. The results showed that STROBY had significant effects on the phyllosphere microbial communities of tobacco leaves. Microbial communities in asymptomatic leaves were more greatly affected than their counterparts in symptomatic leaves, and fungal communities were more sensitive than bacterial communities. Throughout the experiment, the most common genera in symptomatic leaves were Alternaria, Pseudomonas, Pantoea, and Sphingomonas, and in asymptomatic leaves, these were Golubevia and Pantoea. After spraying, the alpha diversity of fungal communities increased in symptomatic leaves and decreased in asymptomatic leaves, while the alpha diversity of bacteria increased in both types of leaves. Beta diversity showed that in asymptomatic leaves, the fungal communities in the first stage was significantly different from the remaining three stages. In contrast, the fungal communities in symptomatic leaves and the bacterial communities in all leaves did not fluctuate significantly during the four stages. Before spraying (August 29), the dominant functions of the fungal community were animal pathogen, endophyte, plant pathogen, and wood saprotroph. Whereas after spraying (September 3, 8, and 13), the proportion of the above fungal functions decreased and the unassigned functions increased, especially in asymptomatic leaves. This study describes the effects of STROBY application and tobacco brown spot presence in shaping the leaf phyllosphere microbial communities, and provides insights into the microbial community effects on tobacco leaves of a strobilurin fungicide.

Analysis of Phyllosphere Microorganisms and Potential Pathogens of Tobacco Leaves.

In the tobacco phyllosphere, some of the microbes may have detrimental effects on plant health, while many may be neutral or even beneficial. Some cannot be cultivated, so culture-independent methods are needed to explore microbial diversity. In this study, both metagenetic analysis and traditional culture-dependent methods were used on asymptomatic healthy leaves and symptomatic diseased leaves of tobacco plants. In the culture-independent analysis, asymptomatic leaves had higher microbial diversity and richness than symptomatic leaves. Both asymptomatic and symptomatic leaves contained several potentially pathogenic bacterial and fungal genera. The putative bacterial pathogens, such as species of Pseudomonas, Pantoea, or Ralstonia, and putative fungal pathogens, such as species of Phoma, Cladosporium, Alternaria, Fusarium, Corynespora, and Epicoccum, had a higher relative abundance in symptomatic leaves than asymptomatic leaves. FUNGuild analysis indicated that the foliar fungal community also included endophytes, saprotrophs, epiphytes, parasites, and endosymbionts. PICRUSt analysis showed that the dominant functions of the bacterial community in a symptomatic leaf were cellular processes and environmental information processing. In the other five foliar samples, the dominant functions of the bacterial community were genetic information processing, metabolism, and organismal systems. In the traditional culture-dependent method, 47 fungal strains were isolated from 60 symptomatic tobacco leaf fragments bearing leaf spots. Among them, 21 strains of Colletotrichum (29%), Xylariaceae (14%), Corynespora (14%), Pestalotiopsis (10%), Alternaria (10%), Epicoccum (10%), Byssosphaeria (5%), Phoma (5%), and Diaporthe (5%) all fulfilled Koch's postulates and were found to cause disease on detached tobacco leaves in artificial inoculation tests. Symptoms on detached leaves caused by three strains of Corynespora cassiicola in artificial inoculation tests were similar to the original disease symptoms in the tobacco field. This study showed that the combined application of culture-dependent and independent methods could give comprehensive insights into microbial composition that each method alone did not reveal.

First Report of Target Spot Caused by Rhizoctonia solani AG-6 in Tobacco in China.

Tobacco is an annual and solanaceous crop, which is widely produced in China. In July 2020, tobacco target spot was observed on 50% of tobacco plants in a 5-ha commercial field of Bijie (27.32° N, 105.29° E), Guizhou province, China. Typical symptoms firstly appeared on the old leaves as round watery spots. Then the spots became a diameter of 2 to 20 cm, with concentric ring lines and dead spots. Fifteen small pieces (5 × 5 mm) of leaf tissue were cut from the edge of the lesions, surface sterilized and placed on potato dextrose agar (PDA) medium amended with kanamycin (0.1 mg/ml). Isolate J136, one of five isolates with similar morphology, was selected for pathogen identification. The culture of the isolate on PDA was brown and exhibited radial mycelial growth after incubation at 28 oC in darkness for 5 days. Hyphae of the fungus were white at the beginning, turned light brown to brown at the later stages, and finally became thick and separated. Sclerotia were brown and produced on PDA after 25 days of incubation in the dark. These characteristics were similar to the colony characteristics of R. solani. The genomic DNA of Isolate J136 was extracted using the CTAB method. PCR analyses were conducted using the following primers specifically designed for the detection of individual AGs or subgroups of R. solani: AG-1 IA, IB and IC (Kuninaga 2003), AG-2-1, AG-2-2, IIIB, IV and LP (Carling et al. 2002), AG-3 PT (Misawa 2015), AG-4 HG-I and HG-II (Kuninaga 2003), and AGs-5-6 (Arakawa and Inagaki 2014). Among the 12 specific primer pairs, only AG-6-specific primers amplified a fragment of ca. 230 bp product, indicating that the tested strain belonged to R. solani AG-6. The sequence was deposited in GenBank with accession no. MZ379468. Using BLASTN search, the sequence of the gene was aligned with the voucher specimen, R. solani AG-6. A phylogenetic tree was constructed based on these sequences. After wards, Isolate J136 was tested for hyphal anastomosis reaction using the R. solani AG-6 standard strain according to the method described by Ogoshi (1987). The hyphal diameter at the point of anastomosis was reduced, with obvious anastomosis point, and the death of adjacent cells, indicating their anastomosis reactions (Anderson 1982). Thus, based on the morphological and genetic analyses, the fungus was identified as R. solani AG-6. To verify its pathogenicity, six plants (cv. Yunyan87) at the 5-to-6 leaf stage were inoculated with mycelial PDA plugs (5 mm in diameter). Leaves inoculated with PDA-only plugs served as the controls. Treated tobacco plants were maintained at a temperature range of 15 to 25 oC in a greenhouse with 85% relative humidity. After 5 days inoculation, typical symptoms were observed on the inoculated leaves, whereas no symptoms were observed on the control leaves. Koch's postulates were fulfilled by re-isolation of the pathogen from the diseased leaves. R. solani AG-2-2 is the only previously reported group of R. solani, which causes tobacco target spot in the field (Gonzalez et al. 2011). Therefore, to our knowledge, this is the first report of R. solani AG-6 causing target spot of tobacco in the field in China. Since considerable losses caused by the disease have frequently happened in this region, addition of this new group pathogen in the disease pool can be more problematic. Proper disease control strategies are in need to be developed to prevent further losses.

Effect of azoxystrobin on tobacco leaf microbial composition and diversity.

Azoxystrobin, a quinone outside inhibitor fungicide, reduced tobacco target spot caused by Rhizoctonia solani by 62%, but also affected the composition and diversity of other microbes on the surface and interior of treated tobacco leaves. High-throughput sequencing showed that the dominant bacteria prior to azoxystrobin treatment were Methylobacterium on healthy leaves and Pseudomonas on diseased leaves, and the dominant fungi were Thanatephorous (teleomorph of Rhizoctonia) and Symmetrospora on healthy leaves and Thanatephorous on diseased leaves. Both bacterial and fungal diversity significantly increased 1 to 18 days post treatment (dpt) with azoxystrobin for healthy and diseased leaves. For bacteria on healthy leaves, the relative abundance of Pseudomonas, Sphingomonas, Unidentified-Rhizobiaceae and Massilia declined, while Methylobacterium and Aureimonas increased. On diseased leaves, the relative abundance of Sphingomonas and Unidentified-Rhizobiaceae declined, while Methylobacterium, Pseudomonas and Pantoea increased. For fungi on healthy leaves, the relative abundance of Thanatephorous declined, while Symmetrospora, Sampaiozyma, Plectosphaerella, Cladosporium and Cercospora increased. On diseased leaves, the relative abundance of Thanatephorous declined, while Symmetrospora, Sampaiozyma, Plectosphaerella, Cladosporium, Phoma, Pantospora and Fusarium, increased. Compared to healthy leaves, azoxystrobin treatment of diseased leaves resulted in greater reductions in Thanatephorous, Sphingomonas and Unidentified-Rhizobiaceae, a greater increase in Methylobacterium, and similar changes in Phoma, Fusarium, Plectosphaerella and Cladosporium. Azoxystrobin had a semi-selective effect altering the microbial diversity of the tobacco leaf microbiome, which could be due to factors, such as differences among bacterial and fungal species in sensitivity to quinone outside inhibitors, ability to use nutrients and niches as certain microbes are affected, and metabolic responses to azoxystrobin.

Effect of disease severity on the structure and diversity of the phyllosphere microbial community in tobacco.

Tobacco target spot is a serious fungal disease and it is important to study the similarities and differences between fungal and bacterial community under different disease severities to provide guidance for the biological control of tobacco target spot. In this study, tobacco leaves at disease severity level of 1, 5, 7 and 9 (S1, S5, S7, and S9) were collected, both healthy and diseased leaf tissues for each level were sampled. The community structure and diversity of fungi and bacteria in tobacco leaves with different disease severities were compared using high-throughput sequencing technology. The results indicated that there was a significant differences in the community structure of fungi and bacteria for both healthy and diseased samples depending on the disease severity. In both healthy and diseased tobacco leaves for all four different disease severities, the most dominant fungal phylum was Basidiomycota with a high prevalence of genus Thanatephorus. The relative abundance of Thanatephorus was most found at S9 diseased samples. Proteobacteria represent the most prominent bacterial phylum, with Pseudomonas as predominant genus, followed by Pantoea. The relative abundance of Pseudomonas was most found at S7 healthy samples. In fungal community, the Alpha-diversity of healthy samples was higher than that of diseased samples. In contrast, in bacterial community, the Alpha-diversity of healthy samples was lower than that of diseased samples. LEfSe analysis showed that the most enrich fungal biomarker was Thanatephorus cucumeris in diseased samples. Clostridium disporicum and Ralstonia pickettii were the most enrich bacterial biomarker in healthy samples. FUNGuild analysis showed that the pathotroph mode was the most abundant trophic modes. The relative abundance of pathotroph mode in diseased samples changes insignificantly, but a peak at S5 was observed for healthy samples. PICRUSt analysis showed that most bacterial gene sequences seem to be independent of the disease severity. The results of this study provide scientific references for future studies on tobacco phyllosphere microecology aiming at prevention and control of tobacco target spot.

Phyllospheric Microbial Composition and Diversity of the Tobacco Leaves Infected by Didymella segeticola.

A Myriad of biotic and abiotic factors inevitably affects the growth and production of tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L.), which is a model crop and sought-after worldwide for its foliage. Among the various impacts the level of disease severity poses on plants, the influence on the dynamics of phyllospheric microbial diversity is of utmost importance. In China, recurring reports of a phyto-pathogen, Didymella segeticola, a causal agent of tobacco leaf spot, accentuate the need for its in-depth investigation. Here, a high-throughput sequencing technique, IonS5TMXL was employed to analyze tobacco leaves infected by D. segeticola at different disease severity levels, ranging from T1G (least disease index) to T4G (highest disease index), in an attempt to explore the composition and diversity of phyllospheric microbiota. In all healthy and diseased tobacco leaves, the most dominant fungal phylum was Ascomycota with a high prevalence of genus Didymella, followed by Boeremia, Meyerozyma and Alternaria, whereas in the case of bacterial phyla, Proteobacteria was prominent with Pseudomonas being a predominant genus, followed by Pantoea. The relative abundance of fungi, i.e., Didymella and Boeremia (Ascomycota) and bacteria, i.e., Pseudomonas and Pantoea (Proteobacteria) were higher in diseased groups compared to healthy groups. Healthy tissues exhibited relatively rich and diverse fungal communities in contrast with diseased groups. The infection of D. segeticola had a complex and significant effect on fungal as well as bacterial alpha diversity. FUNGuild analysis indicated that the relative abundance of pathotrophs and saprotrophs in diseased tissues proportionally increased with disease severity. PICRUSt analysis of diseased tissues indicated that the relative abundance of bacterial cell motility and membrane transport-related gene sequences elevated with an increase in disease severity from T1G to T3G and then tended to decrease at T4G. Conclusively, the current study shows the typical characteristics of the tobacco leaf microbiome and provides insights into the distinct microbiome shifts on tobacco leaves infected by D. segeticola.