Epidemiology of corneal transplantation before achieving the Zero Queue / Epidemiologia do transplante de córnea antes de atingir a Fila Zero

ABSTRACT Objective: To outline the epidemiological profile of cornea donors and recipients before reaching queue zero. Methods: Epidemiological study, of quantitative approach, with transversal, analytical design, analyzing database records from the Health Secretary of the State of Ceará, from 2013 to 2015. Results: We obtained 1,558 cornea donors and 2,287 cornea recipients from 2013 to 2015. Most donors were male, capital residents, from 21 to 40 years old. Of donated eyeballs, 14.52% were disposed, due to poor condition, infiltration or positive serology. The recipients were predominantly women over 60 years old. The procedures were mostly elective, due to bullous keratopathy (28%). Regarding emergency transplants, ulcer (38.51%) and retransplant (35.14%) were most prevalent. Predominantly, transplants were funded by the Unified Health System. Conclusion: The majority of patients who were submitted to corneal transplantation are senile, especially females, therefore should be cautiously observed. On the other hand, donors are mainly male and young, reflecting the high number of tragic accidents. The surgery for bullous keratopathy is the most frequent among elective transplants, while the ulcer surgery is the main cause of emergency procedures. The fact that most surgeries were financed by the Unified Health System reflects the importance of this system.

RESUMO Objetivo: Traçar o perfil epidemiológico dos doadores e receptores de córnea antes de atingir a Fila Zero. Métodos: Estudo epidemiológico, de abordagem quantitativa, com delineamento transversal e analítico, analisando registros da base de dados da Secretaria de Saúde do Estado do Ceará, de 2013 a 2015. Resultados: Foram obtidos 1.558 doadores de córnea e 2.287 receptores de córnea, de 2013 a 2015. A maioria dos doadores era homem, procedente da capital, de 21 a 40 anos. Dentre os globos oculares doados, 14,52% foram descartados por má condição, infiltração ou sorologia positiva. Os receptores eram predominantemente mulheres acima de 60 anos de idade. Os procedimentos foram majoritariamente eletivos, devido à ceratopatia bolhosa (28%). Já para transplantes de emergência, a úlcera (38,51%) e o retransplante (35,14%) foram os mais prevalentes. Em geral, os transplantes foram custeados pelo Sistema Único de Saúde. Conclusão: A maioria dos pacientes submetidos a transplantes de córnea foram do grupo etário senil, principalmente do sexo feminino, devendo esse grupo ser observado com cautela. Em contrapartida, os doadores eram, principalmente, homens e jovens, refletindo o alto número de pessoas que morrem devido a acidentes trágicos. A cirurgia de ceratopatia bolhosa foi a mais frequente dentre os transplantes eletivos; já a de úlcera foi a principal causa dos procedimentos de emergência. O fato de a maioria das cirurgias ter sido financiada pelo Sistema Único de Saúde reflete a importância desse sistema.

Análise crítica das diferentes fontes de dados sobre transplante de córnea no Brasil / Critical analysis of the different data sources on corneal transplantation in Brazil

Resumo As doenças da córnea são responsáveis por cerca de 4 a 5% da cegueira reversível no mundo. O transplante de córnea é o tecido mais transplantado em todo o mundo e o único tratamento amplamente aceito para promover a transparência corneana e restaurar a visão. O monitoramento incorporou-se ao campo da Saúde Pública, com o objetivo de acompanhar sistematicamente a atuação das equipes e os dados de produção, por meio da criação de normas, inspeções de avaliação periódicas e acompanhamento dos indicadores de qualidade. As análises críticas dos resultados objetivam apontar falhas e riscos envolvidos no processo, e empreender ações capazes de modificar os achados negativos, a fim de aprimorar a qualidade dos serviços prestados à população. No Brasil, existem diferentes fontes de dados sobre transplantes de córnea e bancos de tecidos oculares. Nesta revisão, foi avaliada a precisão dos dados e a confiabilidade das informações divulgadas pelo Sistema Nacional de Transplantes, pela Associação Brasileira de Transplante de Órgãos e pela Agência Nacional de Vigilância Sanitária sobre a situação do transplante de córnea no Brasil, a fim de nortear governos, gestores em saúde pública e pesquisadores.

Abstract Corneal diseases account for about 4 to 5% of reversible blindness in the world. Corneal transplantation is the most transplanted tissue in the world and the only widely accepted treatment to promote corneal transparency and restore vision. Monitoring was incorporated into the field of Public Health, with the objective of systematically monitoring teams' performance and production data, through the creation of norms, periodic evaluation inspections and monitoring of quality indicators. The critical analyzes of the results aim to point out flaws and risks involved in the process, and to undertake actions capable of modifying the negative findings, in order to improve the quality of the services provided to the population. In Brazil, there are different sources of data on corneal transplants and ocular tissue banks. In this review, the accuracy of the data and the reliability of the information disclosed by the National Transplant System by the Brazilian Organ Transplant Association and the National Sanitary Surveillance Agency on the situation of corneal transplantation in Brazil were evaluated in order to guide governments, public health managers and researchers.

Doação e fila de transplante de córnea no Estado do Rio de Janeiro / Donation and waiting list for corneal transplantation in the State of Rio de Janeiro

O presente trabalho objetiva descrever o processo de doação, captação, fila de espera e transplante de órgãos e tecidos como uma das políticas de saúde no Brasil e no Estado do Rio de Janeiro, com ênfase nos procedimentos relativos aos transplantes de córnea. A baixa notificação de possíveis doadores e a alta taxa de negativa familiar na doação associado ao insuficiente número de córneas disponibilizadas por Banco de Olhos são os principais fatores que limitam o aumento do número dos transplantes de córnea no Brasil. A criação do Banco de Olhos do Rio de Janeiro, associado a politicas que estimulam o aumento da notificação e captação de córneas visa diminuir a fila de espera para transplante de córnea no Estado.

This paper aims to describe the process of organ and tissue donation, tissue harvesting, queue and transplants as a health policy in Brazil and in the State of Rio de Janeiro, with emphasis on procedures for corneal transplantation. The low reporting of possible donors associated with a high rate of negative family in donation, associated with the insufficient number of corneas provided by Eye Banks are the main factors limiting the increase in the number of corneal transplants in Brazil. The creation of the Rio de Janeiro Eye Bank associated with policies that encourage increased reporting and collection of corneas aims to reduce the waiting list for corneal transplantation in Rio de Janeiro State.

Achados histopatológicos em 431 córneas de receptores de transplantes no Rio de Janeiro / Histopathology finds in 431 corneas from transplant receptors in Rio de Janeiro

Foram examinadas 431 córneas de receptores de transplantes no Rio de Janeiro recebidas em sua maioria do Banco de Olhos associado à Sociedade Brasileira de Oftalmologia (SBO) e, as últimas, do Rio-transplante, após o fechamento temporário do Banco de Olhos. É notável a diferença entre os percentuais e o ordenamento das principais causas de transplante achadas neste levantamento, todos por comprovação histopatológica dos diagnósticos, e as citadas em bibliografia encontradas em Sorocaba, Porto Alegre, Florianópolis, Manaus e Recife baseadas apenas no levantamento dos prontuários clínicos.

Four hundred and thirty one cornea from transplant receptors in Rio de Janeiro were analised, most of them received from Banco de Olhos, associated to Brazilian Society of Ophtalmology (SBO) and from Rio-transplante, after temporary closing of Banco de Olhos. There is a markable difference between the percentual and incidence from the most important causes founded in this work, all of them prooved by histopathology, and the causes reported in bibliography at Sorocaba, Porto Alegre, Florianópolis, Manaus and Recife, based only in clinical archives.

Eye bank tissue utilization between endothelial keratoplasty and penetrating keratoplasty.

PURPOSE: To determine rates of tissue use for corneal transplants via endothelial keratoplasty (EK) relative to penetrating keratoplasty (PK). METHODS: Retrospective chart review of all cornea tissues (n = 3669) distributed from the Lions Eye Bank of Wisconsin for EK or PK from August 1, 2004 through July 31, 2009 (60 months). Rates of tissue use for EK relative to PK were determined both on a yearly basis and for the overall study period. Replacement frequency and time to subsequent surgery were established for each group. Donor tissue and recipient characteristics were compared between groups. RESULTS: Donor characteristics did not differ between the 2 groups; 11.9% of EK tissues failed and were replaced during the study period compared with 5.1% of PK tissues (P < 0.0001). Additional tissue for the same eye came at a mean of 174 days after an EK surgery compared with 558 days after a PK (P < 0.0001). Surgeons requesting tissue for EK increased each year, whereas the number of repeat tissue requests decreased over time. CONCLUSIONS: Additional tissues were required for recipients of EK more than twice as often as for recipients of PK, and replacement of EK grafts occurred at a mean of more than 1 year before replacement of PK grafts. This pattern of tissue utilization during the first 5 years of distribution for EK did not negatively affect the Lions Eye Bank of Wisconsin from meeting the surgeon demand for tissue in its service area. Eye banks may wish to monitor tissue utilization as part of their quality assurance program.

Impact of surgeon acceptance parameters on cost and availability of corneal donor tissue for transplantation.

OBJECTIVE: To examine the effects of more restrictive donor corneal parameters on the cost and availability of transplantable tissue. METHODS: Corneal tissue data from the Midwest Eye-Banks were collected from 2008 through 2011. Endothelial cell density (ECD) and donor age were arbitrarily restricted in a statistical model based on donor tissue availability. A hypothetical baseline corneal donor tissue fee of $3000 was used for the model. RESULTS: Overall, 19,990 tissues were recovered from 10,668 donors and met Food and Drug Administration and Eye Bank Association of America donor eligibility criteria and current age and ECD criteria for surgical use for corneal transplantation. The mean corneal ECD of screened corneas was 2694 ± 338 cells per square millimeter (range, 2000-4694 cells/mm2). The average age of the recovered donor corneas eligible for surgery was 55.6 ± 14.4 years. Donors aged 51 to 75 years contributed 70.5% of the surgical tissue. In this model, a minimum ECD restriction of 2300, 2500, or 2800 cells per square millimeter would reduce the corneal tissue availability to 87.7%, 70.6%, or 36.5% of current levels, respectively. If donor age were restricted to ≤ 70, ≤ 65, or ≤ 60 years, the percentage of corneal tissue available would decrease to 89.5%, 74.3%, or 57.5% of current levels, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Tissue criteria restrictions would affect corneal surgeons and eye banks. Restrictions on donor age and ECD would decrease the availability of surgically suitable tissue and increase the costs of cornea transplant tissue.

Sustainability of Routine Notification and Request legislation on eye bank tissue supply and corneal transplantation wait times in Canada.

OBJECTIVE: To assess whether provinces with Routine Notification and Request (RNR) legislation have sustained increases in corneal tissue supply and decreases in wait times for corneal transplantation surgery. DESIGN: Cross-sectional survey of Canadian corneal transplant (CT) surgeons and eye banks. PARTICIPANTS: Canadian CT surgeons and representatives from the 10 Canadian eye banks. METHODS: Voluntary and anonymous surveys were distributed between July and October 2009. Eligible CT surgeons were defined as ophthalmologists who practice in Canada; currently perform Penetrating keratoplasty (PKP), Deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty (DALK), Deep lamellar endothelial keratoplasty (DLEK), Descemet stripping endothelial keratoplasty (DSEK), or Descemet membrane endothelial keratoplasty (DMEK); and have obtained tissues from a Canadian eye bank. RESULTS: From 2006 to 2009, for provinces with RNR legislation and where data are available, mean wait times from date of diagnosis to date of CT surgery have increased: in Ontario, from 31 ± 34 weeks to 36 ± 27 weeks; in British Columbia, from 39 ± 20 weeks to 42 ± 35 weeks; in Manitoba, from 32 ± 23 weeks to 49 ± 36 weeks. In addition, the amount of corneal tissue in RNR provinces suitable for transplant, with the exception of British Columbia, has declined between 2006 and 2008: in Ontario, 1186 tissues to 999 tissues (16% decline); in Manitoba, 92 tissues to 83 tissues (10% decline); in New Brunswick, 129 tissues to 98 tissues (24% decline). CONCLUSION: Although initially effective, RNR legislation has not sustained an increase in corneal tissue availability nor has it shortened wait times in most provinces. Incorporation of community hospitals into the RNR catchment, improved enforcement, and continued education of hospital staff regarding the RNR process may be effective in making this legislation more sustainable in the long term.

[The 2009 performance report of the German cornea banks]. / Leistungsbericht der Deutschen Hornhautbanken 2009.

BACKGROUND: In Germany, human tissue for corneal and amniotic transplantation is supplied by 27 cornea banks. METHODS: The Section for Tissue Transplantation and Biotechnology of the German Ophthalmological Society records the cornea banks' activities by means of an annual questionnaire. RESULTS: In 2009, a total of 4,818 corneal grafts were processed by 21 responding cornea banks, and 57% were deemed suitable for transplantation. This ratio is slightly higher than the European average. In addition, German cornea banks released 1,257 amniotic grafts in 2009. DISCUSSION: German cornea banks are currently facing new regulatory issues due to updated legislation regarding tissue transplantation. Recent updates in European law have limited the cutoff time for postmortem blood sampling to 24 h, and this regulation may lead to a significant reduction in potential donors.

Efficacy of Routine Notification and Request on reducing corneal transplantation wait times in Canada.

OBJECTIVE: To determine whether the implementation of Routine Notification and Request (RNR) has been effective in increasing the amount of donor corneal tissue available and reducing wait times for corneal transplant (CT) surgeries. DESIGN: Survey of the CT surgeons and eye banks in Canada. PARTICIPANTS: CT surgeons and representatives of the 10 eye banks in Canada. METHODS: Voluntary, anonymous questionnaires were distributed between May 1 and September 30, 2006. RESULTS: Following the implementation of RNR, 3 eye banks had an increase in the amount of corneal tissue available: Manitoba, 81% (from 42 tissues in 2004 to 76 tissues in 2006); Ontario, 25% (from 1304 tissues in 2005 to 1626 tissues in 2006); New Brunswick, 129% (from 86 tissues in 2005 to 197 tissues in 2006). British Columbia, where RNR was implemented in 1999, had a 6% increase (from 766 in 2005 to 812 in 2006). There has been a significant decrease in wait times from the time of diagnosis by CT surgeons to the time of surgery in British Columbia (from 48+/-18 weeks in 2004 to 39+/-20 weeks in 2006), Manitoba (from 82+/-56 weeks in 2004 to 32+/-23 weeks in 2006), Ontario (from 82+/-56 weeks in 2004 to 31+/-34 weeks in 2006), and Nova Scotia (from 44+/-12 weeks in 2004 to 32+/-28 weeks in 2006). CONCLUSIONS: RNR has been effective in increasing corneal tissue availability and decreasing wait times in provinces where it has been implemented. We recommend similar legislative changes to be considered in those provinces where corneal tissue shortage is delaying the availability of CT surgery.

[Strategies to resolve the problem of lack of keratoplasty materials in China].

Keratoplasty is the major option for the treatment of blindness due to corneal diseases. Lack of donors' cornea for keratoplasty remains the major obstacle for the treatment of blindness due to corneal diseases in China. In order to obtain sufficient cornea available for transplantation, it is necessary to have a comprehensive approach improving the awareness of the public by strengthening the publicity, encouraging people to participate in the donation of cornea, appealing for the establishment of transplantation laws, establishing a legal and transparent organ donation system as well as to establish standardized eye banks. In addition, more attention should be paid on the selection of suitable surgery approaches and indications of keratoplasty, the improvement of peri-operation management, to utilize any possible way to improve the cornea diseases-induced blindness patients' sight, to improve the successful rate of transplantation as well as to reduce the waste of corneal grafts. At the meantime, it is necessary to study and to develop new corneal materials, especially by tissue engineering methods, to relieve the problem of deficiency of cornea grafts in China.

Papel dos médicos intensivistas no processo de doaçäo de córnea na cidade de Curitiba / Intensive care physicians role in cornea donation in Curitiba

É analisado o papel dos médicos intensivistas bem como suas opiniöes em relaçäo a doaçäo e transplante de córnea em Curitiba. Este estudo foi realizado através da análise de questionários respondidos por 93 médicos intensivistas que mostraram-se todos favoráveis à doaçäo de córnea. Apesar disso, 59,1 por cento dos médicos nunca o solicitaram a retirada de córnea, justificando tal comportamento pelo esquecimento em solicitar a doaçäo frente aos familiares e pela falta de conhecimento em saber como proceder frente a um potencial doador. 93,55 por cento dos médicos entrevistados gostariam de receber informaçöes sobre o processo de doaçäo e transplante. Estes resultados indicam que os médicos intensivistas säo favoráveis à doaçäo de córnea. Porém grande parte esquece da importância em solicitar a doaçäo ou näo sabe como proceder frente a um potencial doador, tanto por desconhecimento, quanto por falta de orientaçäo básica

Resultados de queratoplastía penetrante con donantes ancianos / Results of penetrating keratopaties with donars aged

Presentamos los resultados de 13 queratoplastías penetrantes provenientes de córneas de donadores con edades de 61-83 años. Todas ellas fueron preservadas en medio M-K y tomadas del cadáver antes de las primeras 96 horas de ocurrida la defunción (con una media de 56 horas). El 84% de los trasplantes permanecieron claros, después de un seguimiento de 11 meses. El promedio del grosos corneal durante la primera semana postoperatoria fue de 0.635 mm y la medida media al mayor tiempo de seguimiento fue de 0.556 mm. Los botones corneales provenientes de córneas de donadores con una edad de 60 a 70 años (media de 64 años) fueron comparadas con las de provenientes de donadores con edades de 70 a 83 años (media de 80 años). El grosor corneal en los dos grupos al máximo tiempo de seguimiento no tuvo significancia estadística diferente (0.574 en el primer grupo de 0.563 en el segundo)