Historical Development of Diagnostic Criteria for NF2-related Schwannomatosis.

NF2-related schwannomatosis (NF2; previously termed neurofibromatosis type 2) is a tumor-prone disorder characterized by development of multiple schwannomas and meningiomas. The diagnostic criteria of NF2 have been regularly revised. Clinical criteria for NF2 were first formulated at the National Institutes of Health Consensus Conference in 1987 and revised in 1990. Revised criteria were also proposed by the Manchester group in 1992 and by the National Neurofibromatosis Foundation (NNFF) in 1997. The 2011 Baser criteria improved the sensitivity of diagnostic criteria, particularly for patients without bilateral vestibular schwannomas. Revisions to the Manchester criteria were published in 2019, with replacement of "glioma" by "ependymoma," removal of "neurofibroma," addition of an age limit of 70 years for development of vestibular schwannomas, and introduction of molecular criteria, which led to the most widely used criteria. In 2022, the criteria were reviewed and updated by the international committee of NF experts. In addition to changes in diagnostic criteria, the committee recommended the use of "schwannomatosis" as an umbrella term for conditions that predispose to schwannomas. Each type of schwannomatosis was classified by the gene containing the disease-causing pathogenic variant. Molecular data from NF2 patients led to further clarification of the diagnostic criteria for NF2 mosaic phenotypes. Given all these changes, the diagnostic criteria of NF2 may be confusing. Herein, to help healthcare professionals who diagnose NF2 conditions in the clinical setting, we review the historical development of diagnostic criteria.

Early history of the different forms of neurofibromatosis from ancient Egypt to the British Empire and beyond: First descriptions, medical curiosities, misconceptions, landmarks, and the persons behind the syndromes.

The earliest examples of neurofibromatosis (in this case type 1, NF1) can be traced in the Ebers Papyrus (Ancient Egypt, 1.500 B.C.), in a Hellenistic statuette (Smyrna, 323 B.C.), in the coinage of the Parthians kings (247 B.C.) and in some 13th century monks' drawings. These earlier examples are somewhat less well defined as compared to the most recent better defined reports credited as having NF1 including an Inca child mummy (1480-1650 AD), Ulisse Aldrovandi's homuncio ("Monstrorum Historia", 1592 A.D.) with mosaic NF1 or the illustrations seen in the 18th century "Buffon's Histoire Naturelle" and "Cruveilhier's Anatomie Pathologique du Corps Human". The first English language report on NF1 was made by Akenside in 1768 and the first systematic review by Robert William Smith in 1849, while Virchow's pupil, Friedrich Daniel von Recklinghausen, in 1882, was the first to understand the origin of skin tumors and to name them neurofibromas. The touching story of Joseph C. Merrick (the "Elephant man," (who had Proteus syndrome and not NF1), in 1884, played an important role in the later misconception of NF1, as did the novel by Vicotr Hugo on the hunchback Quasimodo. The studies by van der Hoeve (1921), Yakovlev and Guthrie (1931), and Van Bogaert (1935), categorized "von Recklinghausen's" neurofibromatosis among the phakomatoses and the neurocutaneous syndromes. The first known mention of an acoustic neuroma (at autopsy) is attributed to Eduard Sandifort (1777 AD) while John H. Wishart made the earliest autoptic description of neurofibromatosis type 2 (NF2), in 1822, in a 21-year-old man with bilateral acoustic neuromas, who manifested signs since his infancy (Wishart subtype NF2). Smith likely described the first case of schwannomatosis in 1849. Older, Virchow, von Recklinghausen, and Verocay first classified "neuromas" and Masson and Penfield first used the word "schwannoma" taking it from Theodore Schwann's works. In 1903 Henneberg and Koch described NF2 in detail. Young, Eldridge, and Gardner, in the late '70, established NF2 as a distinct familial entity (Gardner subtype NF2). Schwannomatosis, the late entry of the different forms of neurofibromatosis, was credited in the middle '90.

Rediagnosing one of Smith's patients (John McCann) with "neuromas tumours" (1849).

In 1849, the Irish Professor of Surgery, Sir Robert William Smith, by publishing his "Treatise on the Pathology, Diagnosis and Treatment of Neuroma", collected six previous examples of "general development of neuromatous tumours" and reported three further cases (two personal and one referred) of what is nowadays known as neurofibromatosis. Among these latter cases, there was a 35-year-old cattle-driver, John McCann, who was first admitted at hospital in 1840 because of a large tumour on the right side of his neck thought to be malignant (and a second tumour sublingually) but not operated. McCann was readmitted in 1843 ("in an emaciated state"), because of an immense tumour in his thigh dying few months later "with hepatic symptoms". Smith's post-mortem examination revealed dozens of smaller additional tumours. Based on application of modern diagnostic criteria (to McCann's portrait at second referral) and on pathological grounds (reconsideration of the histopathological report of McCann's neuroma of the thigh), we tentatively hypothesise that this patient could be the earliest (illustrated) example of either: (1) a malignant peripheral nerve sheath tumour (MPNST); (2) neurofibromatosis type 2 (NF2); or (3) schwannomatosis (SWNTS). The progressively enlarging masses, the emaciated state and the later death are in favour of a MPNST (against is the lack of malignant appearance at histopathology); the clinical (and gross pathological) appearance of the tumours as large, rounded, encapsulated, eccentric lesions deflecting the parent nerve over the surface of the tumour is typical of schwannomas (thus, in favour of NF2 or SWTNS). Whatever diagnosis we could consider these tumours could be secondary to a (local) mosaic loss of heterozygosity and ultimately represent type 2 segmental manifestations superimposed on an ordinary autosomal dominant trait (i.e., NF1, NF2 or SWTNS).

Neurofibromatosis: chronological history and current issues.

Neurofibromatosis, which was first described in 1882 by Von Recklinghausen, is a genetic disease characterized by a neuroectodermal abnormality and by clinical manifestations of systemic and progressive involvement which mainly affect the skin, nervous system, bones, eyes and possibly other organs. The disease may manifest in several ways and it can vary from individual to individual. Given the wealth of information about neurofibromatosis, we attempted to present this information in different ways. In the first part of this work, we present a chronological history, which describes the evolution of the disease since the early publications about the disorder until the conclusion of this work, focusing on relevant aspects which can be used by those wishing to investigate this disease. In the second part, we present an update on the various aspects that constitute this disease.

Neurofibromatosis: chronological history and current issues / Neurofibromatose: histórico cronológico e aspectos atuais

Neurofibromatosis, which was first described in 1882 by Von Recklinghausen, is a genetic disease characterized by a neuroectodermal abnormality and by clinical manifestations of systemic and progressive involvement which mainly affect the skin, nervous system, bones, eyes and possibly other organs. The disease may manifest in several ways and it can vary from individual to individual. Given the wealth of information about neurofibromatosis, we attempted to present this information in different ways. In the first part of this work, we present a chronological history, which describes the evolution of the disease since the early publications about the disorder until the conclusion of this work, focusing on relevant aspects which can be used by those wishing to investigate this disease. In the second part, we present an update on the various aspects that constitute this disease.

A neurofibromatose, descrita inicialmente em 1882 por Von Recklinghausen, é uma doença genética caracterizada por uma anormalidade neuroectodérmica e por manifestações clínicas de envolvimento sistêmico e progressivo, que acometem principalmente a pele, o sistema nervoso, ossos, olhos e eventualmente outros órgãos, podendo apresentar uma grande diversidade de manifestações que variam de indivíduo para indivíduo. Diante da riqueza de informações encontradas a respeito da neurofibromatose, buscamos apresentá-la sob diversos aspectos, organizando os conhecimentos a respeito dessa doença. Na primeira parte desse trabalho, apresentamos um histórico cronológico, relatando a evolução dessa doença desde os primórdios das publicações a ela referentes até o momento do término desse trabalho, dando ênfase aos fatos relevantes ao seu conhecimento e que possam ser utilizados por aqueles que pretendam pesquisar a respeito dessa afecção. Na segunda parte, apresentamos uma atualização sobre os diversos aspectos que compõem essa doença.

Inherited predisposition to cancer: a historical overview.

The hereditary predisposition to cancer dates historically to interest piqued by physicians as well as family members wherein striking phenotypic features were shown to cluster in families, inclusive of the rather grotesque cutaneous findings in von Recklinghausen's neurofibromatosis, which date back to the sixteenth century. The search for the role of primary genetic factors was heralded by studies at the infrahuman level, particularly on laboratory mouse strains with strong susceptibility to carcinogen-induced cancer, and conversely, with resistance to the same carcinogens. These studies, developed in the 19th and 20th centuries, continue today. This article traces the historical aspects of hereditary cancer dealing with identification and ultimate molecular genetic confirmation of commonly occurring cancers, particularly of the colon in the case of familial adenomatous polyposis and its attenuated form, both due to the APC germline mutation; the Lynch syndrome due to mutations in mismatch repair genes, the most common of which were found to be MSH2, MLH1, and MSH6 germline mutations; the hereditary breast-ovarian cancer syndrome with BRCA1 and BRCA2 germline mutations; the Li-Fraumeni (SBLA) syndrome due to the p53 mutation; and the familial atypical multiple mole melanoma in association with pancreatic cancer due to the CDKN2A (p16) germline mutation. These and other hereditary cancer syndromes have been discussed in some detail relevant to their characterization, which, for many conditions, took place in the late 18th century and, in the more modern molecular genetic era, during the past two decades. Emphasis has been placed upon the manner in which improved cancer control will emanate from these discoveries.

[Peripheral, central neurofibromatosis and multiplex meningiomas (a historical review)]. / TT

Despite that the neurofibromatosis and the multiplex meningiomas have been known for centuries, it is hardly during the last decade that a significant progress has been achieved in the understanding of their etiology and pathogenesis. The development of the concept for NF is being followed from the time of the first descriptions till today.