In vitro evaluation of the effect of fracture configuration on the mechanical properties of standard and novel interlocking nail systems in bending.

ABSTRACT

OBJECTIVE: To investigate the effect of fracture configuration on the mechanical properties of standard interlocking nails (ILNs) and a novel angle-stable ILN (ILNn) in bending. STUDY DESIGN: In vitro experimental study. SAMPLE POPULATION Synthetic tibial gap fracture bone models. METHODS: Bone models, featuring a 5 or 120 mm central defect, respectively, mimicking a simple diaphyseal and a comminuted fracture involving both metaphyses, were implanted with 6 or 8 mm screwed or bolted standard ILNs (ILN6s, ILN6b, ILN8s, ILN8b, respectively) or an ILNn. Specimens were tested in 4-point bending. Construct angular deformation (AD) and slack were statistically compared (P<.05). RESULTS: With increasing gap size, standard ILN construct AD increased significantly by approximately 27% in ILN8b and by up to 105% in ILN6s. Similarly, standard ILN construct slack significantly increased by approximately 33% in ILN8b (from approximately 4.2 degrees to approximately 5.6 degrees) and by up to approximately 130% in ILN6s (from approximately 7 degrees to approximately 16 degrees). Conversely, there was no difference in the ILNn construct AD (approximately 4 degrees) regardless of gap size. ILNn AD was the lowest of all groups and occurred without slack. CONCLUSIONS: This study demonstrated that the angle-stable ILNn provided construct stability regardless of fracture configuration, whereas the intrinsic slack of standard ILNs could jeopardize construct stability in a fracture configuration involving the metaphyses. CLINICAL RELEVANCE Use of standard ILNs may be optimal in diaphyseal fractures where circumferential nail/cortical contact could augment repair stability. Conversely, the angle-stable ILNn may represent a reliable fracture stabilization method for diaphyseal fractures as well as fractures involving the metaphyseal regions.