Investigation of alkyl, aryl, and chlorinated OPFRs in sediments from estuarine systems: Seasonal variation, spatial distribution and ecological risks assessment.

Estuaries in South Africa are very important for biodiversity conservation and serve as focal points for leisure and tourism activities. The organophosphate flame retardants (OPFRs) levels in these aquatic systems haven't been documented in any studies as of yet. Due to the negative effects of persistent organic pollutants in South African estuaries, we examined the occurrence of eight OPFRs in sediments of two estuaries by studying their spatiotemporal distribution, season variation, and ecological risks. The Sundays Estuary (SDE), a semi-urbanized agricultural surrounding system, recorded an ∑8OPFR concentration in sediments that ranged from 0.71 to 22.5 ng/g dw, whereas Swartkops Estuary, a largely urbanized system, recorded a concentration that ranged from 0.61 to 119 ng/g dw. Alkyl-OPFRs were the prevalent homologue in both estuaries compared to the chlorinated and aryl groups. While TBP, TCPP, and TCrP were the most abundant compounds among the homologue groups. There was no distinct seasonal trend of ∑8OPFR concentration in either estuary, with summer and autumn seasons recording the highest concentrations in SDE and SWE, respectively. Ecological risks in the majority of the study sites for the detected compounds were at low (RQ < 0.1) and medium levels (0.1 ≤ RQ < 1) for certain species of fish, Daphnia magna and algae. However, the cumulative RQs for all the compounds had ∑RQs ≥1 for most sites in both estuaries, indicating that these organisms, if present in both estuaries, may be exposed to potential ecological concerns due to accumulated OPFR chemicals. The scope of future studies should be broadened to include research areas that are not only focus on the bioaccumulation patterns of these compounds but also find sustainable ways to reduce them from these estuarine environments.

Ecological risk assessment of metal pollutants in two agriculturally impacted estuaries.

A focused diagnosis of ecosystem health in two South African estuaries (Kromme and Gamtoos) was conducted. Four pollution indices were used, i.e., geoaccumulation (Igeo), ecological risk (RI), contamination factor (CF) and pollution load index (PLI), to assess toxicity levels of metal contaminants in relation to background values. The Igeo results (11.1 %) can be classified as contaminated, with Cd, the only element with high values in both estuaries. Likely sources (herbicides, pesticides) of Cd are used in the agricultural dominated catchments. There was a high concentration of Mn (13.4 ± 2.51 and 12.3 ± 1.13 µg·g-1) and Fe (1289 ± 243 and 1291 ± 130 µg·g-1) at site 4 for Gamtoos and Kromme estuary respectively compared to the other metal elements. Although results indicate low metal contamination, with increasing global anthropogenic pressure, continuous monitoring should be prioritised to assist in managing estuarine systems that support a wide range of socio-economic and ecosystem services.

Tissue distribution, dietary intake and human health risk assessment of organophosphate pesticides in common fish species from South African estuaries.

This study assessed the tissue distribution, dietary intake, and potential health risks of eight OPPs in Pomadasys commersonnii (Spotted grunter) and Mugil cephalus (Flathead mullet) from the Sundays and Swartkops estuaries in South Africa. The highest concentration in fish tissues was found in muscles of M. cephalus (178 ± 80.4 ng/g ww) and P. commersonnii (591 ± 280 ng/g ww) from Sundays Estuary. The ∑6OPPs concentration in muscles from both fish species was higher in muscles than in the gills with fenitrothion dominating the distribution profile. Results from the path analysis indicate that lipid, weights, and length of the fish species do not influence the concentration of OPPs in the studied fish species. The calculated hazard ratios, which represent the non-carcinogenic risks, were less than one for all OPPs, indicating that the concentration of OPPs detected in fish muscles had negligible consequences on human health.

Organophosphate pesticides in South African eutrophic estuaries: Spatial distribution, seasonal variation, and ecological risk assessment.

The seasonal variation, spatial distribution, and ecological risks of thirteen organophosphate pesticides (OPPs) were studied in the Sundays and Swartkops estuaries in South Africa. Ten pesticides were detected in surface water samples from both estuaries, while all OPPs were detected in sediments. The highest concentration of OPPs (18.8 µg pyrazophos L-1) was detected in surface water samples from Swartkops Estuary, while 48.7 µg phosalone kg-1 dw was the highest in sediments collected from Sundays Estuary. There was no clear seasonal pattern in OPPs occurrence in surface water from both systems. However, their occurrence in sediments was in the following order: winter > autumn > summer > spring, perhaps indicating major pesticide input in the winter seasons. Results from ecological risk assessment showed that pyraclofos and chlorpyrifos (CHL) in surface water from both systems are respectively likely to cause high acute and chronic toxicity to fish (risk quotient - RQ > 1). For sediments of both estuaries, the highest acute and chronic RQs for fish were calculated for isazophos and CHL respectively. The majority of the detected OPPs in sediments posed potential high risks to Daphnia magna from both systems. These results suggest that these aquatic organisms (fish, and Daphnia), if present in the studied estuaries, can develop certain forms of abnormalities due to OPP exposure. To this end, proper measures should be taken to reduce OPP input into the estuarine systems.

Assessing and planning future estuarine resource use: A scenario-based regional-scale freshwater allocation approach.

Rapid urbanisation and industrial growth in South Africa increases the need for proactive allocation of freshwater resources on a regional scale. A nine-step method is described that sets long-term targets for water resource condition and future use with a focus on estuary water quantity and quality requirements. The approach specifically focuses on the environmental flow allocation to estuaries, nested within a broader, regional (multi-catchment and multi-estuary) water resource landscape. The method differs to most other approaches in that the responses of multiple estuaries to escalating future development in a region are coherently quantified (versus only considering a single estuary in a single catchment). A case study that assessed the health, biodiversity importance and resilience to current and future pressures of 64 estuaries is used to illustrate the method. Projected growth in the study area was integrated into a range of future dam development and wastewater discharge scenarios. The results showed that estuaries around the urban centres were in poor condition, but those in the more rural areas in a more natural state. As a result of their small size, most of the estuaries in the region had little resilience to changes in freshwater quantity and nutrient loading. In contrast, the larger systems, targeted for dam development, only showed sensitivity to water abstraction during low-flow periods when base-flow reduction caused mouth closure and changes in nutrient processes. Broadly, the approach aimed to find a balance between ecological requirements and socio-economic development, which meant that maintaining larger systems in relatively good condition would be at the expense of smaller systems that are already in a poor condition. The approach developed was successful in quantifying the responses of multiple estuaries to escalating future pressures on a regional scale, and could be replicated to assist in managing water resources elsewhere in data-limited environments.

Comparative assessment of two agriculturally-influenced estuaries: Similar pressure, different response.

This study compared the spatio-temporal dynamics in two agriculturally-influenced South African estuaries - Gamtoos and Sundays - to investigate how contrasting hydrological alterations influence physical, chemical and biological responses. With the Gamtoos Estuary experiencing regular high flow conditions, a key difference between the two systems is the propensity for natural flushing events to occur; a mechanism largely eliminated from the highly-regulated Sundays Catchment. Phytoplankton blooms (>20Chl-aµgl-1) were persistent and seasonal in the Sundays, inducing summer bottom-water hypoxia (<2mgl-1), whilst those in the Gamtoos were episodic and flow-dependent. Of concern in the Sundays Estuary, was the magnitude (>550µgl-1) and recurrent nature of two harmful algal bloom (HAB) species. This study provides the first account of HAB persistence and seasonal hypoxia in a South African estuary, demonstrating the possible consequences of shifting an ecosystem into a new stable state.