Heart failure in primary care: co-morbidity and utilization of health care resources.

BACKGROUND: In order to ensure proper management of primary care (PC) services, the efficiency of the health professionals tasked with such services must be known. Patients with heart failure (HF) are characterized by advanced age, high co-morbidity and high resource utilization. OBJECTIVE: To ascertain PC resource utilization by HF patients and variability in the management of such patients by GPs. METHODS: Descriptive, cross-sectional study targeting a population attended by 129 GPs over the course of 1 year. All patients with diagnosis of HF in their clinical histories were included, classified using the Adjusted Clinical Group system and then grouped into six resource utilization bands (RUBs). Resource utilization and Efficiency Index were both calculated. RESULTS: One hundred per cent of patients with HF were ranked in RUBs 3, 4 and 5. The highest GP visit rate was 20 and the lowest in excess of 10 visits per year. Prescription drug costs for these patients ranged from €885 to €1422 per patient per year. Health professional efficiency varied notably, even after adjustment for co-morbidity (Efficiency Index Variation Ratio of 28.27 for visits and 404.29 for prescription drug cost). CONCLUSIONS: Patients with HF register a high utilization of resources, and there is great variability in the management of such patients by health professionals, which cannot be accounted for by the degree of case complexity.

Hospitalizations for ambulatory care sensitive conditions and quality of primary care: their relation with socioeconomic and health care variables in the Madrid regional health service (Spain).

BACKGROUND: Hospitalizations for ambulatory care sensitive conditions (ACSH) have been proposed as an indirect indicator of the effectiveness and quality of care provided by primary health care. OBJECTIVE: To investigate the association of ACSH rates with population socioeconomic factors and with characteristics of primary health care. RESEARCH DESIGN: Cross-sectional, ecologic study. Using hospital discharge data, ACSH were selected from the list of conditions validated for Spain. SETTING: All 34 health districts in the Region of Madrid, Spain. SUBJECTS: Individuals aged 65 years or older residing in the region of Madrid between 2001 and 2003, inclusive. MEASURES: Age- and gender-adjusted ACSH rates in each health district. RESULTS: The adjusted ACSH rate per 1000 population was 35.37 in men and 20.45 in women. In the Poisson regression analysis, an inverse relation was seen between ACSH rates and the socioeconomic variables. Physician workload was the only health care variable with a statistically significant relation (rate ratio of 1.066 [95% CI; 1.041-1.091]). These results were similar in the analyses disaggregated by gender. In the multivariate analyses that included health care variables, none of the health care variables were statistically significant. CONCLUSIONS: ACSH may be more closely related with socioeconomic variables than with characteristics of primary care activity. Therefore, other factors outside the health system must be considered to improve health outcomes in the population.

Geographic variations in avoidable hospitalizations in the elderly, in a health system with universal coverage.

BACKGROUND: The study of Hospitalizations for ambulatory care sensitive conditions (ACSH) has been proposed as an indirect measure of access to and receipt of care by older persons at the entryway to the Spanish public health system. The aim of this work is to identify the rates of ACSH in persons 65 years or older living in different small-areas of the Community of Madrid (CM) and to detect possible differences in ACSH. METHODS: Cross-sectional, ecologic study, which covered all 34 health districts of the CM. The study population consisted of all individuals aged 65 years or older residing in the CM between 2001 and 2003, inclusive. Using hospital discharge data, avoidable ACSH were selected from the list of conditions validated for Spain. Age- and sex-adjusted ACSH rates were calculated for the population of each health district and the statistics describing the data variability. Point graphs and maps were designed to represent the ACSH rates in the different health districts. RESULTS: Of all the hospitalizations, 16.5% (64,409) were ACSH. Globally, the rate was higher among men: 33.15 per 1,000 populations vs. 22.10 in women and these differences were statistically significant (p < 0.05) in each district. For men the range was 70.82 and the coefficient of variation (CV) was 0.47, while for women the range was 43.69 and the CV was 0.48. In 93.1% of cases, the ACSH were caused by hypertensive cardiovascular disease, heart failure or pneumonia. A centripetal pattern can be observed, with lower rates in the districts in the center of the CM. This geographic distribution is maintained after grouping by sex. CONCLUSION: A significant variation is demonstrated in "preventable" hospitalizations between the different districts. In all the districts the men present rates significantly higher than women. Important variations in the access are observed the Primary Attention in spite of existing a universal sanitary cover.

[Health system interventions assessment in Spain: an approach through the analysis of the time trends and the geographical variability of avoidable mortality between 1986 -2001]. / Medida del resultado de las intervenciones sanitarias en España: una aproximación mediante el análisis temporal y espacial de la mortalidad evitable entre 1986-2001.

BACKGROUND: Many studies have proposed Avoidable Mortality (ME) to monitor the performance of health services although its usefulness is limited by the multiplicity of the avoidable mortality lists being used. Time trends from 1986-2001 and the geographical distribution of avoidable mortality by provinces, are presented for Spain. METHODS: An Avoidable Mortality consensus list is being used. It includes avoidable mortality through the intervention of health services (ISAS in Spanish) and through health policy interventions (IPSI in Spanish). Time trends are analyzed adjusting Poisson or Joinpoint regression models and the annual percentages of change (APC) are estimated. Changes in geographical distribution between the first half of the analysed period and the second are tested by means of standard mortality ratios (SMR) and comparative mortality rates (CMR) for each province. RESULTS: Between 1986 and 2001 avoidable mortality decreased (APC: -1.68; CI: -1.99 and -1.38) slightly more than non-avoidable mortality (APC: -1.28; CI: -1.40 and -1.17). Higher reduction was observed for ISAS mortality (APC: -2.77; CI: -2.89 and -2.65) and an irregular trend for IPSI (between 1986-1990 increase APC: 4.86; CI: 3.32 and 6.41, between 1990-95 stabilization APC: -0.03; CI: -2.32 and 2.31 and finally 1995-2001 decrease APC: -3.57; CI: -4.72 and -2.40). CONCLUSIONS: Avoidable mortality decreased more than non avoidable mortality and important geographical variability can be observed among provinces which should be monitored in order to identify the health services weaknesses. The higher ISAS mortality was observed in southern provinces and the higher IPSI mortality in some areas on the coast. The pattern is somewhat similar for both analyzed periods.