Interobserver Variability in the Assessment of Fluorescence Angiography in the Colon.

BACKGROUND: Fluorescence angiography in colorectal surgery is a technique that may lead to lower anastomotic leak rates. However, the interpretation of the fluorescent signal is not standardised and there is a paucity of data regarding interobserver agreement. The aim of this study is to assess interobserver variability in selection of the transection point during fluorescence angiography before anastomosis. METHODS: An online survey with still images of fluorescence angiography was distributed through colorectal surgery channels containing images from 13 patients where several areas for transection were displayed to be chosen by raters. Agreement was assessed overall and between pre-planned rater cohorts (experts vs non-experts; trainees vs consultants; colorectal specialists vs non colorectal specialists), using Fleiss' kappa statistic. RESULTS: 101 raters had complete image ratings. No significant difference was found between raters when choosing a point of optimal bowel transection based on fluorescence angiography still images. There was no difference between pre-planned cohorts analysed (experts vs non-experts; trainees vs consultants; colorectal specialists vs non colorectal specialists). Agreement between these cohorts was poor (<.26). CONCLUSION: Whilst there is no learning curve for the technical adoption of FA, understanding the fluorescent signal characteristics is key to successful use. We found significant variation exists in interpretation of static fluorescence angiography data. Further efforts should be employed to standardise fluorescence angiography assessment.

Multisensor perfusion assessment cohort study: Preliminary evidence toward a standardized assessment of indocyanine green fluorescence in colorectal surgery.

BACKGROUND: Traditional methods of assessing colonic perfusion are based on the surgeon's visual inspection of tissue. Fluorescence angiography provides qualitative information, but there remains disagreement on how the observed signal should be interpreted. It is unclear whether fluorescence correlates with physiological properties of the tissue, such as tissue oxygen saturation. The aim of this study was to correlate fluorescence intensity and colonic tissue oxygen saturation. METHODS: Prospective cohort study performed in a single academic tertiary referral center. Patients undergoing colorectal surgery who required an anastomosis underwent dual-modality perfusion assessment of a segment of bowel before transection and creation of the anastomosis, using near-infrared and multispectral imaging. Perfusion was assessed using maximal fluorescence intensity measurement during fluorescence angiography, and its correlation with tissue oxygen saturation was calculated. RESULTS: In total, 18 patients were included. Maximal fluorescence intensity occurred at a mean of 101 seconds after indocyanine green injection. The correlation coefficient was 0.73 (95% confidence interval of 0.65-0.79) with P < .0001, showing a statistically significant strong positive correlation between normalized fluorescence intensity and tissue oxygen saturation. The use of time averaging improved the correlation coefficient to 0.78. CONCLUSION: Fluorescence intensity is a potential surrogate for tissue oxygenation. This is expected to lead to improved decision making when transecting the bowel and, consequently, a reduction in anastomotic leak rates. A larger, phase II study is needed to confirm this result and form the basis of computational algorithms to infer biological or physiological information from the fluorescence imaging data.

Intraoperative colon perfusion assessment using multispectral imaging.

In colorectal surgery an anastomosis performed using poorly-perfused, ischaemic bowel segments may result in a leak and consequent morbidity. Traditional measures of perfusion assessment rely on clinical judgement and are mainly subjective, based on tissue appearance, leading to variability between clinicians. This paper describes a multispectral imaging (MSI) laparoscope that can derive quantitative measures of tissue oxygen saturation (SO2 ). The system uses a xenon surgical light source and fast filter wheel camera to capture eight narrow waveband images across the visible range in approximately 0.3 s. Spectral validation measurements were performed by imaging standardised colour tiles and comparing reflectance with ground truth spectrometer data. Tissue spectra were decomposed into individual contributions from haemoglobin, adipose tissue and scattering, using a previously-developed regression approach. Initial clinical results from seven patients undergoing colorectal surgery are presented and used to characterise measurement stability and reproducibility in vivo. Strategies to improve signal-to-noise ratio and correct for motion are described. Images of healthy bowel tissue (in vivo) indicate that baseline SO2 is approximately 75 ± 6%. The SO2 profile along a bowel segment following ligation of the inferior mesenteric artery (IMA) shows a decrease from the proximal to distal end. In the clinical cases shown, imaging results concurred with clinical judgements of the location of well-perfused tissue. Adipose tissue, visibly yellow in the RGB images, is shown to surround the mesentery and cover some of the serosa. SO2 in this tissue is consistently high, with mean value of 90%. These results show that MSI is a potential intraoperative guidance tool for assessment of perfusion. Mapping of SO2 in the colon could be used by surgeons to guide choice of transection points and ensure that well-perfused tissue is used to form an anastomosis. The observation of high mesenteric SO2 agrees with work in the literature and warrants further exploration. Larger studies incorporating with a wider cohort of clinicians will help to provide retrospective evidence of how this imaging technique may be able to reduce inter-operator variability.