Can Emergency Medicine Residents Predict Cost of Diagnostic Testing?

INTRODUCTION: Diagnostic testing represents a significant portion of healthcare spending, and cost should be considered when ordering such tests. Needless and excessive spending may occur without an appreciation of the impact on the larger healthcare system. Knowledge regarding the cost of diagnostic testing among emergency medicine (EM) residents has not previously been studied. METHODS: A survey was administered to 20 EM residents from a single ACGME-accredited three-year EM residency program, asking for an estimation of patient charges for 20 commonly ordered laboratory tests and seven radiological exams. We compared responses between residency classes to evaluate whether there was a difference based on level of training. RESULTS: The survey completion rate was 100% (20/20 residents). We noted significant discrepancies between the median resident estimates and actual charge to patient for both laboratory and radiological exams. Nearly all responses were an underestimate of the actual cost. The group median underestimation for laboratory testing was $114, for radiographs $57, and for computed tomography exams was $1,058. There was improvement in accuracy with increasing level of training. CONCLUSION: This pilot study demonstrates that EM residents have a poor understanding of the charges burdening patients and health insurance providers. In order to make balanced decisions with regard to diagnostic testing, providers must appreciate these factors. Education regarding the cost of providing emergency care is a potential area for improvement of EM residency curricula, and warrants further attention and investigation.

Adapting the HCUP QIs for hospital use: the experience in New York State.

BACKGROUND: The Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality developed the Healthcare Cost and Utilization Project (HCUP) quality indicators (QIs) in 1994. The Healthcare Association of New York State (HANYS; Albany), which represents more than 500 nonprofit and public hospitals, long-term care facilities, and home health care agencies, has adapted the HCUP QIs since 1997 to produce annual comparative reports for its member hospitals. Specifically designed for internal use, the reports have been well received and have drawn interest from other hospital associations and state health departments. METHODS: The HCUP QIs were applied to the New York State hospital discharge abstract. A risk adjustment model was constructed for each complication measure. Measures of utilization and access to care were adjusted for differences in patient demographics and payer status by indirect standardization. Data are presented in graphic format. Each hospital receives its own report (in both paper copy and CD-ROM) with comparisons to statewide norms, regional averages, and peer group averages. Report prepared for hospital systems include data for each affiliated hospital. CONCLUSIONS: When used appropriately, the HCUP QIs provide valuable information for individual hospitals to assess quality of care and target potential areas for improvement. The HCUP QIs also give hospitals a broad perspective to look beyond their own institutions and develop community-based quality improvement initiatives. Nevertheless, given the limitations that commonly exist with administrative databases and the lack of standard risk adjustment systems, the HCUP QIs are best used for internal purposes and not for public reporting.

Socio-economic and behavioural risk factors for tooth loss from age 18 to 26 among participants in the Dunedin Multidisciplinary Health and Development Study.

OBJECTIVE: To determine the risk factors associated with tooth loss between the ages of 18 and 26. METHODS: Dental examinations at ages 18 and 26 were conducted on Study members in the Dunedin Multidisciplinary Health and Development Study, and sociodemographic and dental service use data were collected using a self-report questionnaire. At age 15, an estimate of socio-economic status (SES) for each Study member had been obtained by classifying the occupation of the male parent. A case of tooth loss was defined as an individual who had lost one or more teeth (excluding third molars) due to caries between ages 18 and 26. Logistic regression and Poisson analysis were used to model the occurrence of tooth loss. RESULTS: Among the 821 study members who were examined at both ages, one or more teeth were lost because of caries by 85 (10.3%). After controlling for sex, SES and visiting pattern, baseline caries experience predicted subsequent tooth loss, with the odds increasing by 2.8 for every increase by 1 in the number of decayed surfaces present at age 18. Episodic dental visitors had 3.1 times the odds of their routine visiting counterparts of losing a tooth over the observation period. The number of teeth lost was, on average, 2.3 times higher among episodic dental visitors. CONCLUSIONS: Socio-economic inequalities in tooth loss appear to begin early in the life course, and are modified by individuals' SES and dental visiting patterns.

9:45-10:00. Superimposition of EBCT Determined Coronary Calcium Deposits onto Myocardial PET Perfusion Images by Rubidium-82 and Nitrogen-13 Ammonia for Assessment of Flow Limiting Defects.

Calcium localization by Electron Beam CT (EBCT) in the coronary arteries is becoming an important non-invasive method for screening asymptomatic patients for early coronary atherosclerosis. However, the relationship between coronary artery calcium deposits and myocardial perfusion abnormalities has not been established. We have developed software to superimpose location of coronary calcium by EBCT onto PET myocardial perfusion images, so that we can determine the role of location and amount of calcium in the arteries to flow-limiting perfusion defects by PET.EBCT and PET transaxial images are each first converted to three-dimensional arrays of 1 mm voxels. The resulting two image volumes sets are displayed so that a vertical line can be drawn from the clavicle to the spine for proper rotation of the body. The rotated images are then displayed superimposed and are shifted in the vertical, horizontal, and the long axis directions to co-register the EBCT and PET images. The EBCT images are windowed for calcium Houndsfield numbers and calcium location is added to the PET images as a maximum intensity value in the image. The modified PET image volume is then translated back to the PET data format and reprocessed using cardiac analysis software such that the calcium location is superimposed on the PET myocardial perfusion images.Preliminary results of the PET-EBCT superimposition program correlate with location of coronary calcium by EBCT and PET perfusion defects following stress. This technique may be useful for identifying flow-limiting calcium deposits in the coronary arteries.

Anonymous HIV testing: the impact of availability on demand in Arizona.

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the impact of anonymous testing availability on human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) test demand in Arizona. Testing patterns before and after the introduction of anonymous testing were compared. Client knowledge of new test policy and delay in testing until an anonymous option was available were assessed. Test numbers among men who have sex with men showed a statistically significant increase after introduction of an anonymous testing option. Arizona continues to maintain anonymous testing availability. Public health agencies should consider how test policy may influence people's HIV test decisions.

Socioeconomic differences among people with AIDS: results from a Multistate Surveillance Project.

To characterize the socioeconomic status of persons with acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS), 11 U.S. state and city health departments interviewed 2,898 persons > or = 18 years of age reported with AIDS between June 1, 1990, and January 31, 1993. Among men who have sex with men, white men reported the lowest percentage (9%), and Central/South American (50%) and Mexican men (40%) reported the highest percentages not completing 12 years of school. Among intravenous drug users (IDUs), 35% of white men, 64% of black men, 67% of Puerto Rican men, 29% of white women, and 63% of black women had not completed 12 years of school. Overall, 77% of the men and 90% of the women were unemployed; we also found racial/ethnic differences by employment but to a lesser degree than differences in education. Among women, but not among men, differences in household income by race and ethnicity were marked; 76% of white and 91% of black female IDUs reported a household income of $10,000. Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) prevention programs must be targeted toward the educational level of the populations served, and HIV services must adapt to the financial circumstances of their clientele.

In vivo assessment of left ventricular wall and chamber dynamics during transient myocardial ischemia using cine computed tomography.

Using a new computed tomographic (CT) scanner design that uses a rapidly moving focused electron beam, 50-ms CT scans were obtained at 2 axial levels simultaneously through the hearts of 6 dogs in order to analyze left ventricular (LV) wall thickness and cross-sectional chamber area after acute occlusion of the left anterior descending coronary artery (LAD). Ten or fifteen 50-ms CT scans (rate of 17 scans/s through the middle of the left ventricle were performed in 1 second (cine acquisition) during intravenous administration of contrast medium at rest, 60 seconds after acute occlusion of the LAD, and 60 seconds after release of the occlusion. The percent extent of systolic wall thickening of the potentially ischemic anterior segment was 37 +/- 15% (+/- standard deviation) in the control state and -5 +/- 6.5% during LAD occlusion (p less than 0.01). There was no significant difference in the percent change in LV luminal area from end-diastole to end-systole between the control state (50 +/- 19%) compared with LAD occlusion (47 +/- 21%). There were no significant differences in the extent of systolic wall thickening or LV luminal area between the control state and 60 seconds after release of occlusion. The alterations in regional myocardial function during acute ischemia are characterized by wall thinning during systole in the jeopardized segment and no significant change in global LV function. These features can be assessed by cine computed tomography during a solitary heart cycle.

Measurements of serum gentamycin levels by rapid tests.

Gentamicin is a very useful antimicrobial agent for the treatment of serious infections caused by gram-negative bacteria. However, it's low therapeutic index and potential ototoxic and nephrotoxic side effects necessitate frequent determinations of serum concentration to assist in maintaining therapeutic levels and avoiding toxic levels. Two bioassays and a latex agglutination inhibition card (LAIC) test were evaluated to determine gentamicin levels in nearly 100 patient sera. Results were compared with a radioimmunoassay (RIA). Two bioassays, the Bio-Monitor and the GentaSak, gave correlation coefficients of 0.987 and 0.982, respectively. The correlation coefficient for the LAIC test was 0.987. All three tests compared well with RIA in accurately detecting gentamicin levels in patients as well as simulated sera. The LAIC test, however, was more rapid, giving results within half an hour whereas bioassays required 6--8 hours for completion. The LAIC test was also found to be more economical. It provides a suitable alternative to RIA procedures in small laboratories and for performing 'stat' tests since batching is not necessary.

Development of a computed tomographic scanner for radiation therapy treatment planning.

The authors describe a low-cost CT scanner integrated with a radiotherapy simulator and designed for treatment planning. The standard rotational gantry and x-ray tube of the simulator are used with a multiwire xenon lonization chamber and simple current-proportional readout system to measure patient attenuation, avoiding problems associated with diagnostic CT scanners in treatment planning. Although design constraints limit performance, software compensation techniques have reduced artifacts and given satisfactory images.