Mental health care in Italy: organisational structure, routine clinical activity and costs of a community psychiatric service in Lombardy region.

The Magenta Community Mental Health Centre (CMHC) is the public agency responsible for providing adult psychiatric care to about 85,000 adult residents. In 1995, it had 1,145 clients and incurred costs of Euro 1.9 millions. Average cost per patient and per adult resident were Euro 1,661 and Euro 22.2, respectively. These values mask large variation across diagnosis: while patients with schizophrenia and related disorders had an average cost of Euro 3,771, those with neurotic and related disorders had an average cost of Euro 439. Patients with schizophrenia and related disorders (28% of the patients) absorbed about 60% of total costs and made extensive use of several types of services (hospital, outpatient, domiciliary, social and rehabilitative care). Since integrating different types of services is the key element of Italian psychiatric care, the new fee-for-service system adopted by the NHS to fund providers does not appear appropriate, particularly for schizophrenic patients.

Health care costs of therapy-refractory schizophrenic patients treated with clozapine: a study in a community psychiatric service in Italy.

This study evaluates the utilization of clozapine in the treatment of therapy-refractory schizophrenia in terms both of patterns of care and of health care costs in a community psychiatric service in Italy. Data covering the year prior to commencing clozapine and the year following the initiation of the therapy were collected. Clinical outcome was assessed by means of the Clinical Global Impression (CGI) and Global Assessment of Functioning (GAF) scales. Cost analysis followed a two-step procedure: (i) to record all health care services provided to patients and (ii) to assign a monetary value to each service. Three of the 15 patients enrolled in the study dropped out before the end of the 12-month period of therapy. Considering the 12 patients on clozapine treatment for at least 1 year, clinical improvements are associated with a substantial modification of the pattern of care. While patients in the pre-clozapine period were mainly managed in hospital settings, patients on clozapine were prevalently placed in the community and participated in intensive rehabilitative programmes. The higher costs of drug therapy and community services in the post-clozapine period were more than offset by the lower costs of acute hospital care.

[Cost of psychiatric patients by disability type]. / Il costo dei pazienti psichiatrici per classi di gravità.

OBJECTIVE: The study of the relation between treatment costs and disability of psychiatric patient groups. DESIGN: Perspective assessment of costs and disability of 1371 adult psychiatric patients in charge at two Operative Psychiatric Units (OPU), followed during an average period of 9 months. Data are related to all OPU's psychiatric services, including ambulatory, full or half-residential and psychiatric departments of acute hospital services. SETTING: OPUs of Magenta (MI) and Desio (MI). METHOD: The disability level has been measured by Health of the Nation Outcome Scales (HoNOS) filled in at the inclusion of the patient in the study and every three-months on average thereafter. Besides other HoNOSs have been filled in both at admission and discharge from psychiatric departments of acute hospitals, Residential Centres of psychiatric Therapies and Rehabilitation and Guarded Communities. All patients have been grouped using the main psychiatric diagnosis (first digit ICD-10) and the maximum disability level shown in the whole period of the study. Direct costs of publicly financed psychiatric services have only been considered. Their attribution to each patient has been made applying standard costs or tariffs (diagnostic procedures) to the data perspectively collected by the regional Register and a purposely designed protocol. RESULTS: Total cost of 1371 patients has been 9771.1 million lire with a cost per patient of 7,127,000 lire (sd 19,499,000) and a cost per "day in charge" of 27,172 lire (sd 68,358). The cost per day has been found unrelated with the length of observed time frame. At the inclusion the mean level of disability has been 4.26 points (sd 3.73) and 3.19 points (sd 3.26) at the end of the study. Its value, measured at maximum level shown by each problem in the whole period of study, has been 6.00 points (sd 4.64). Disability and treatment cost of each patient did result directly related (r = 0.626, p = 0.0001). All patients have been grouped in 12 classes with a significant (p = 0.0001) overall difference on both their disability level and treatment cost. CONCLUSIONS: All adult psychiatric patients could be grouped in disability related classes which sometimes have also a different treatment cost. A study on a greater number of patients is needed to confirm these results. It may also provide a more reliable basis for a new financing system of psychiatric services.

[Costs of psychiatric services: a study performed at a public mental center in the Lombardy Region, Italy]. / I costi delle prestazioni in psichiatria: un'analisi condotta in un Centro Psico-Sociale (CPS) pubblico in Lombardia.

OBJECTIVE: The implementation of a simple methodology to estimate full costs of services provided by a public mental health centre. SETTING: CPS (NHS Mental Centre) Ussl 35, Magenta, Lombardy Region. METHOD: To estimate full costs of 16 types of service we followed a two step procedure. The first step was to estimate all costs attributable to the CPS. In the second one, we allocated this estimate to each type of service provided. We attributed to the CPS the following cost items: personnel, utilities (telephone, electricity, water, heating and cleaning), land & building, transports (for services provided outside the clinic) and a share of general cost of the USSL to which the CPS belongs. Full cost of each service was then calculated on the base of the yearly number of services provided and the time spent by each health professional. RESULTS: In 1995, the CPS provided 14,562 services. Total costs amounted to L 1,356 million, and more than three quarters of this amount was attributable to the personnel working at the CPS. Unit costs ranged from L 5,300 (drug administration) to L 442,400 (family therapy involving two professionals for 90 minutes) The unit cost of psychiatric visits, psychologist consultations and nurse domiciliary visits were L 105,300, L 106,600 and L 78,000, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: This approach requires accessible data and is relatively simple to manage. Some refinements are required, especially to improve the methodology for the determination and the allocation of overheads. However, we are convinced that this cost accounting procedure provides acceptable estimates of the services provided by the CPS. These estimates suggest that charges to be used to fund NHS providers may be too low, especially if fee-for-service will be the main funding source.

Food and nutrient consumption of two rural Italian population groups followed for twenty years.

The food and nutrient consumption was examined in two rural population groups of 22 middle age men of Italy in connection with a longitudinal study of coronary heart disease. Most of the data were collected with use of the individual weighing method. In the 20 year interval increases and decreases were observed in the consumption of various foods, reflecting the influence of economic and biological factors. In regard to nutrients, in Crevalcore (Bologna) the original high level of some macronutrients and vitamin A progressively decreased. In Montegiorgio (Marche) the original high level of fat intake - in relation to recommended intake - progressively increased, while energy was throughout close to recommended values. The endemic deficit in riboflavin intake progressively decreased, while that for vitamin A remained practically constant.