In support of the Choosing Wisely campaign: Perceived higher risk leads to unnecessary imaging in accelerated partial breast irradiation?

Accelerated partial breast irradiation (APBI) is an increasingly utilized modality for early stage breast cancer as part of breast conservation therapy (BCT). There remains concern regarding local recurrence, requiring more frequent post-radiation surveillance imaging. The purpose of this study is to determine clinical significance of frequent surveillance in this perceived higher risk population. Patients treated at a community academic medical center from 2005 to 2013 with partial breast radiation were retrospectively identified. All patients were treated with lumpectomy followed by balloon based APBI. Diagnostic, clinical, radiographic, and outcomes data were collected. One hundred and sixty-nine patients were identified. Median age at time of diagnosis was 63. Stage was 0, I, and II in 27%, 64%, and 9%, respectively. Most patients had pure invasive ductal cancer. Ninety-two percent and 99% of patients had imaging performed by 6 and 12 months (± 3 months) respectively. Median interval between end of radiation and first image, and subsequent 3 images were 6, 6, 9, and 12 months, respectively. Median follow-up was 49 months for all patients (range 7-106). Six patients experienced local recurrence: 4 invasive, all clinically detected, and none within the first 2 years. One patient had mammographically detected recurrent ductal carcinoma in situ. No mammographic images within the first year lead to diagnosis of recurrent cancer. APBI via balloon base brachytherapy offered women excellent locoregional control rates. Frequent mammographic surveillance did not result in increased detection of early recurrent disease. The result of our study are in line with the Choosing Wisely campaign recommendations to perform no more than annual follow-up for women who have completed radiation as part of BCT, with first imaging done at 6-12 months. We recommend mammographic surveillance be performed no more frequently than annually, with first image after BCT to be done 12 months from completion of radiation.

The Clinical Utility and Cost of Postoperative Mammography Completed within One Year of Breast Conserving Therapy: Is It Worth It?

Breast conserving therapy (BCT), lumpectomy followed by radiotherapy, is an effective treatment for a majority of breast cancers. According to the National Comprehensive Cancer Network, mammographic imaging should be completed at least six months after completion of radiation. This study evaluates the clinical significance and financial cost of postoperative breast imaging within one year of BCT. Patients treated with BCT between 2014 and 2016 at an academic center were identified retrospectively. The medical records were reviewed to identify the timing and type of the first imaging study after BCT. This study evaluated the clinical significance and the cost of postoperative imaging. A total of 128 patients were included into the study. Seventy-six patients received mammograms 3 to 12 months after BCT. Six of the 76 postoperative mammograms required additional imaging/intervention for a total of seven additional imaging studies and three procedures, all of which revealed benign findings. None of these patients had physical examination findings that were of clinical concern. The total cost of postoperative imaging and procedures performed less than a year after BCT was estimated to be $32,506. Postoperative imaging performed on breast cancer patients less than a year after BCT proved to be of no medical benefit and revealed no additional significant pathology. The mammographic surveillance in this study did not lead to the diagnosis of recurrent malignancy or second primary lesions and placed additional financial burden on the patient population. This study demonstrates that breast imaging within a year after BCT had no clinical impact and resulted in increased cost of care.

Presenting Stage in Colon Cancer Is Associated with Insurance Status.

Colorectal cancer continues to be the third most common cause of cancer death in the United States. Access to health care is also a nationwide problem. The purpose of the current study is to see if insurance status is associated with stage of colon cancer at presentation. The tumor registry was queried for all patients with colon cancer from 2009 to 2014. Demographics, including insurance status was statistically analyzed to determine if an association existed between insurance status and stage of colon cancer at the time of presentation. There were 434 patients identified that underwent colonic resection during the study period; 224 were female and 210 were male. Of the 434 patients, 388 were insured and 46 were uninsured. When insurance status was compared with stage at diagnosis there was a statistically significant difference between the two groups. For patients that were uninsured, 13.01 per cent presented with stage I disease, 15.22 per cent with stage II disease, 34.78 per cent with stage III disease, and 36.96 with stage IV disease. For insured patients, 24.03 per cent present with stage I disease, 26.10 with stage II disease, 23.26 per cent with stage III disease, and 29.61 per cent with stage IV disease (P = 0.047). Access to health care continues to be a large problem and results in patients without insurance presenting with a high stage of disease.

Evaluation of Cardiopulmonary Complication Rates after Port Insertion: Is a Postoperative X-Ray Needed?

It is customary for a postoperative chest radiograph to be obtained after fluoroscopic guided port insertion to exclude acute complications. In this review, we provide a cost-benefit analysis by examination of acute postoperative complications detected by postoperative port insertion chest films at our institution. We conducted a retrospective chart review of complications associated with port insertion procedures performed over a 5-year period. Our study included only ultrasound-assisted internal jugular venous or landmark guided subclavian ports placed with the assistance of fluoroscopy. A total of 519 port insertions were reviewed and there was noted to be a postoperative complication rate of 0.58 per cent. The operative note for each complication described a procedural abnormality that suggested a chest film would be of medical benefit. The total price of postoperative chest radiographs was $179,400. Performing chest X-ray films on asymptomatic patients after fluoroscopic guided placement of ports proved to be of no medical advantage to 516 out of 519 patients. Given the extremely low complication rate and financial burden placed on the patient population, we propose discontinuing routine use of postoperative port placement chest radiographs as a way to alleviate unwarranted medical cost.

Development of a neural network approach to characterise (226)Ra contamination at legacy sites using gamma-ray spectra taken from boreholes.

There are a large number of sites across the UK and the rest of the world that are known to be contaminated with (226)Ra owing to historical industrial and military activities. At some sites, where there is a realistic risk of contact with the general public there is a demand for proficient risk assessments to be undertaken. One of the governing factors that influence such assessments is the geometric nature of contamination particularly if hazardous high activity point sources are present. Often this type of radioactive particle is encountered at depths beyond the capabilities of surface gamma-ray techniques and so intrusive borehole methods provide a more suitable approach. However, reliable spectral processing methods to investigate the properties of the waste for this type of measurement have yet to be developed since a number of issues must first be confronted including: representative calibration spectra, variations in background activity and counting uncertainty. Here a novel method is proposed to tackle this issue based upon the interrogation of characteristic Monte Carlo calibration spectra using a combination of Principal Component Analysis and Artificial Neural Networks. The technique demonstrated that it could reliably distinguish spectra that contained contributions from point sources from those of background or dissociated contamination (homogenously distributed). The potential of the method was demonstrated by interpretation of borehole spectra collected at the Dalgety Bay headland, Fife, Scotland. Predictions concurred with intrusive surveys despite the realisation of relatively large uncertainties on activity and depth estimates. To reduce this uncertainty, a larger background sample and better spatial coverage of cores were required, alongside a higher volume better resolution detector.

Ethical management of conflict of interest: proposed standards for academic surgical societies.

BACKGROUND: A significant increase in industry support of professional medical associations coupled with data suggesting that gifts from industry have significant clinical influence have prompted calls from the Institute of Medicine and physician leaders to identify and manage conflicts of interest that stem from financial support of professional medical associations by industry. STUDY DESIGN: A joint task force of members appointed by the Association for Academic Surgery and the Society of University Surgeons was convened in July 2009. Recommendations were developed regarding management of all potential conflicts of interest that can arise within the context of an academic surgical society, with specific focus on relationships with industry. Task force members reached consensus around each recommendation and the guidelines were subsequently adopted by the Executive Councils of both societies. RESULTS: The committee identified 4 primary areas of need for transparent and definitive management of conflict of interest: 1) individual society activities, including general budget support, society endorsements, and journal affiliation; 2) individual personnel conflicts such as society leadership and standards for disclosure of conflict; 3) meeting activities including budgetary support, program committee associations, and abstract review process; and 4) foundation support and research and travel awards. The resulting guidelines aim to protect the societies and their membership from undue bias that may undermine the credibility and mission of these associations. CONCLUSIONS: Policy guidelines to mitigate conflict of interest are necessary to protect the integrity of the work of academic surgical societies and their fiduciary duty to members and patients. Guidelines created and adopted by the Association for Academic Surgery and Society of University Surgeons form an effective model for academic surgical societies and their members.