Can MIBG scan replace the need for bone marrow assessment at diagnosis and reassessment in stage 4 neuroblastomas?

UNLABELLED: Complete staging (extensive marrow investigation and meta-iodo benzylguanine (MIBG) scan) is considered as mandatory both at diagnosis and after chemotherapy for assessment of metastases in neuroblastomas. However the correlation between bone marrow invasion and uptake of MIBG at metastatic sites remains unclear. This study investigates whether MIBG alone is sufficiently sensitive to make these procedures redundant. PATIENTS AND METHODS: 20 children over one year of age, with histologically proven metastatic neuroblastoma were studied. Extensive bone marrow assessment and MIBG bone scan performed both at diagnosis and after completion of induction chemotherapy were reviewed. RESULTS: At diagnosis metastases were detected by marrow investigation alone in 2, MIBG alone in 2 and both procedures in 16. After induction chemotherapy metastases were detected by only marrow investigation in 2, by only MIBG in 3, by both procedures in 6 patients, and by none in 9. CONCLUSIONS: Whether marrow investigations and MIBG scan explore the same phenomenon remains unclear. However it appears that marrow disease that is histologically detectable may remain MIBG negative both at diagnosis and after treatment. Both procedures are still justified at time of diagnosis and evaluation of response.

Assessment of osteosarcoma response to neoadjuvant chemotherapy: comparative usefulness of dynamic gadolinium-enhanced spin-echo magnetic resonance imaging and technetium-99m skeletal angioscintigraphy.

The aim of this work was to study and compare the usefulness of dynamic contrast-enhanced spin-echo MR imaging with high temporal resolution hydroxymethylene diphosphonate technetium-99 m skeletal angioscintigraphy in predicting the osteosarcoma histological response to neoadjuvant chemotherapy. Twelve patients with resectable osteosarcoma were prospectively monitored with dynamic MR imaging and skeletal scintigraphy before start of neoadjuvant chemotherapy, after two cycles of therapy and before surgery. Neoplasm signal intensity and activity intensity were plotted against time, and slopes were calculated for percentage increase over baseline values in the first minute. Stability and increase in slope values during or after chemotherapy were defined as a "radiological non-response". Changes in slopes were compared with the "histological response" (Huvos grading). At midpoint of the chemotherapy, these two imaging modalities failed in predicting final histological response. After the completion of the chemotherapy, these imaging modalities allowed the prediction of histological response with the same accuracy (91 %). In this series, dynamic MR imaging and technetium skeletal scintigraphy provide similar results regarding the prediction of final histological response during neoadjuvant chemotherapy; these results cannot be used to modify the therapeutic protocol at midpoint of chemotherapy; these imaging tools predict accurately the histological response at the end of chemotherapy. These latter results may permit anticipation of the adjuvant chemotherapy strategy during decalcification procedures in resected osteosarcoma and thus to monitor chemotherapy in non-surgical osteosarcoma.