Malpractice claims against emergency physicians in Massachusetts: 1975-1993.

This study reviewed 549 malpractice claims filed against emergency physicians in Massachusetts from 1975 through 1993, with a total of $39,168,891 of indemnity and expense spent on the 549 closed claims. High-risk diagnostic categories (chest pain, abdominal pain, wounds, fractures, pediatric fever/meningitis, epiglottitis, central nervous system bleeding, and abdominal aortic aneurysm) accounted for 63.75% of all closed claims and 64.23% of the total indemnity and expense spent on closed claims. Missed myocardial infarction (chest pain) claims accounted for 25.47% of the total cost of closed claims but only 10.38% of closed claims. The number of claims for missed myocardial infarction increased in the post-1988 closed claim group compared to the pre-1988 group; fractures and wounds were significantly less frequent in the post-1988 group. The frequency of high-risk claims decreased in the post-1988 group, largely because of the decline in fracture and wound claims. The category of missed myocardial infarction had a larger percentage of claims closed with indemnity payment than without indemnity payment. This parameter may serve as a marker for the overall seriousness of claims associated with a particular allegation, unlike the average cost per claim, which may be skewed by a few large awards.

Massachusetts emergency medicine closed malpractice claims: 1988-1990.

STUDY PURPOSE: To describe the characteristics of malpractice claims against emergency physicians and to identify causes and potential preventability of such claims. POPULATION: Malpractice claims closed in 1988, 1989, and 1990 against emergency physicians insured by the Massachusetts Joint Underwriters Association were compared with claims closed from 1980 to 1987 as investigated in our previous study. METHODS: Retrospective review of malpractice claim files by board-certified emergency physicians. RESULTS: The average indemnity and expense per claim were higher in the current study population than in our previous study population (P = .05). Claims in eight high-risk diagnostic areas (chest pain, abdominal pain, fractures, wounds, pediatric fever/meningitis, subarachnoid hemorrhage, aortic aneurysm, and epiglottitis) accounted for 50.8% of claims in this study and 55.5% of total monetary losses. Four claims in this study were related to two instances of failure of an emergency department radiograph follow-up system. The evaluation of patients who were intoxicated contributed to major monetary losses, especially in cases of fractures and head injury. CONCLUSION: Emergency physicians must have a particular awareness of their great risk exposure for missed myocardial infarction. Addition of dictation or voice-activated record generation systems, departmental protocols for radiograph follow-ups, and holding and re-evaluation of the intoxicated patient will help provide systems supports for reducing the liability of individual emergency physicians.

Hybrid approach offers option for long term older adult care.

Hospitals in the future will be called on increasingly to administer to the medical needs of an aging population. But what are alternative forms of care beyond nursing homes and what must hospitals do to position themselves with those alternatives? In the following article, the author discusses the advantages of a "hybrid approach" to caring for older patients.

Preventability of malpractice claims in emergency medicine: a closed claims study.

We conducted a retrospective study of 262 malpractice claims against emergency physicians insured in Massachusetts by the state-mandated insurance carrier; these 262 claims were closed in the years 1980 through 1987. A total of $11,800,156 in indemnity and expenses was spent for these 262 claims. In 211 cases, the allegation was failure to diagnose a medical or surgical problem. One hundred eighty-four of these cases were included in the following eight diagnostic categories: chest pain, abdominal pain, wounds, fractures, pediatric fever/meningitis, aortic aneurysm, central nervous system bleeding, and epiglottitis. These eight categories accounted for 66.44% of the total dollars spent for the 262 claims. Because of the high incidence and dollar losses attached to these eight diagnostic categories, the Massachusetts Chapter of the American College of Emergency Physicians (MACEP) has developed clinical guidelines for the evaluation of these high-risk areas. Of the 184 high-risk claims, 99 claim files were reviewed; 45 of these reviewed claims were judged by physician reviewers as preventable by the application of the MACEP high risk clinical guidelines. From 22.26% to 46.4% of the $11,800,156 spent on the 262 claims could have been saved by the application of the MACEP clinical guidelines.

Medication errors: 1977 to 1988. Experience in medical malpractice claims.

MIIENJ has paid $30,144,636 in indemnity from 1977 through 1988 for medical malpractice suits arising from medication errors. A review of these files revealed that patients incurred death and serious morbidity, and that several specific behavior errors accounted for the majority of patient injury. Among the damages that occurred during that time period were 88 deaths, 15 patients with profound brain damage, 15 patients who alleged that they had become addicted to medications prescribed for pain, 10 patients who required amputations of limbs, and 12 patients who suffered some degree of hearing loss or decreased visual acuity. The predominant categories where insureds incurred difficulty were in disregarding patient allergies to specific drugs (acetylsalicylic acid (aspirin), penicillin and its derivatives); prescribing drugs without consideration of the patient's medical history; failing to monitor therapy with anticoagulants, nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, digitalis derivatives, theophylline, and aminoglycoside antibiotics; antibiotic therapy; and errors in the writing of prescriptions. In order to reduce the number of patient injuries and accompanying medical malpractice suits from medication errors, the following suggestions are offered: 1. Heed the patient's warning regarding drug allergies and prescribe a substitute drug, especially if the drug is aspirin or penicillin (and derivatives) or if the patient gives a history of having asthma. If the patient gives a history of aspirin sensitivity, make certain the drug you are prescribing does not contain aspirin as one of its components. Often physicians stated that they were not aware that aspirin was contained in the drug they prescribed for patients with a documented allergy to aspirin.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

In vivo assessment of precursor induced prostaglandin release within the rat gastric lumen.

Gastroprotection associated with the intragastric administration of prostaglandin (PG) precursor fatty acids such as linoleic (LA), gamma-linolenic (GLA), and arachidonic acid (AA) has been reported to be mediated via their conversion to PGs. This report examines the relationship between gastroprotection and the extent/rate of PG-release in rats intragastrically administered PG biosynthetic precursors: LA, AA, dihomo-gamma-linolenic acid (DHGL) or oleic acid (OA, a nonprecursor fatty acid). At various times following intragastric administration of a fatty acid, gastric fluid was collected, extracted, chromatographed, and assayed for PGE1 or PGE2 by specific radioimmunoassay. AA and DHGL dose dependently elevated gastric PGE2 and PGE1 levels, respectively. Maximal PGE elevation, 200-400 ng/stomach, was over 400-fold above basal values, and observed within 5-10 minutes of administration. Conversely, OA and LA elicited only a minor (2-10 fold) stimulation of PGE release. In contrast to effects on PG release, all four fatty acids protected the gastric mucosa against macroscopic damage induced by ethanol. The apparent rank order of potency was AA greater than DHGL = LA greater than OA (the difference in potency between DHGL or LA and OA was not significant). Since LA and OA (a nonprecursor) only marginally elevated lumenal PGs relative to DHGL or AA, yet were equally efficacious in the gastroprotection assay, it is likely that other fatty acid-related mechanisms play an important role in protecting the stomach against ethanol-induced injury.