Results of a Pilot External Quality Assessment Scheme for Genetic Testing of Newborns with Spinal Muscular Atrophy.

BACKGROUND: This study aims to evaluate the ability of laboratories to perform spinal muscular atrophy (SMA) genetic testing in newborns based on dried blood spot (DBS) samples, and to provide reference data and advance preparation for establishing the pilot external quality assessment (EQA) scheme for SMA genetic testing of newborns in China. METHODS: The pilot EQA scheme contents and evaluation principles of this project were designed by National Center for Clinical Laboratories (NCCL), National Health Commission. Two surveys were carried out in 2022, and 5 batches of blood spots were submitted to the participating laboratory each time. All participating laboratories conducted testing upon receiving samples, and test results were submitted to NCCL within the specified date. RESULTS: The return rates were 75.0% (21/28) and 95.2% (20/21) in the first and second surveys, respectively. The total return rate of the two examinations was 83.7% (41/49). Nineteen laboratories (19/21, 90.5%) had a full score passing on the first survey, while in the second survey twenty laboratories (20/20, 100%) scored full. CONCLUSIONS: This pilot EQA survey provides a preliminary understanding of the capability of SMA genetic testing for newborns across laboratories in China. A few laboratories had technical or operational problems in testing. It is, therefore, of importance to strengthen laboratory management and to improve testing capacity for the establishment of a national EQA scheme for newborn SMA genetic testing.

Result of a Pilot External Quality Assessment Scheme for Clinical Diagnosis of Inherited Metabolic Disorders in China.

BACKGROUND: We aimed to evaluate the diagnostic capabilities of Chinese laboratories for inherited metabolic disorders (IMDs) using gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS) on urine samples. Meanwhile, based on the result of the pilot external quality assessment (EQA) scheme, we hope to establish a standardized and reliable procedure for future EQA practice. METHODS: We recruited laboratories that participated in the EQA of quantitative analysis of urinary organic acids with GC-MS before joining the surveys. In each survey, a set of five real urine samples was distributed to each participant. The participants should analyze the sample by GC-MS and report the "analytical result", "the most likely diagnosis", and "recommendation for further tests" to the NCCL before the deadline. RESULTS: A total of 21 laboratories participated in the scheme. The pass rates were 94.4% in 2020 and 89.5% in 2021. For all eight IMDs tested, the analytical proficiency rates ranged from 84.7% - 100%, and the interpretational performance rate ranged from 88.2% - 97.0%. The performance on hyperphenylalaninemia (HPA), 3-methylcrotonyl-CoA carboxylase deficiency (MCCD), and ethylmalonic encephalopathy (EE) samples were not satisfactory. CONCLUSIONS: In general, the participants of this pilot EQA scheme are equipped with the basic capability for qualitative organic acid analysis and interpretation of the results. Limited by the small size of laboratories and samples involved, this activity could not fully reflect the state of clinical practice of Chinese laboratories. NCCL will improve the EQA scheme and implement more EQA activities in the future.

Analysis of External Quality Assessment of Maternal Serum Prenatal Screening for Down Syndrome in the First Trimester in China.

BACKGROUND: We analyzed the 2019 external quality assessment (EQA) results to evaluate the analytical performance of maternal serum prenatal screening for Down Syndrome (DS) in the first trimester in China. METHODS: In each round, five lyophilized EQA samples with detailed clinical information were distributed to participants and used to test the concentration of human chorionic gonadotropin free beta subunits (free ß-HCG) and pregnancy-associated plasma protein-A (PAPP-A) to calculate the risk value of DS. The robust coefficient of variability (CV) was calculated or test results for free ß-HCG and PAPP-A using analytes and major measurement platforms. For DS risk values, the robust CV was calculated using a professional calculation platform. Failed EQA results were analyzed using serum marker testing results and DS risk values. RESULTS: EQA results were collected from 242 laboratories in round 1 and 239 laboratories in round 2. Total acceptable rates of testing results for free ß-HCG and PAPP-A ranged from 95.04% to 97.91%. Overall acceptable rates of DS risk values ranged from 97.52% to 97.90%. The proportion of laboratories exhibiting satisfactory performance was higher in round 2 than in round 1 for serum marker testing results and DS risk values. The robust CV for risk values for each sample were significantly higher than those of serum markers. Three EQA result failure types were found, including result reporting errors, serum marker concentration testing errors, and DS risk calculation errors. CONCLUSIONS: The analytical performance of maternal serum prenatal screening for DS in the first trimester in China can be improved further.

National Program for External Quality Assessment of Chinese Newborn Screening Laboratories.

OBJECTIVES: To analyze the coefficient of variation (CV) of external quality assessment (EQA) in Chinese newborn screening (NBS) laboratories. METHOD: EQA's robust CV was analyzed by the Clinet-EQA evaluation system. RESULTS: Participating laboratories of the EQA program increased annually. There was more than a 11-fold increase in phenylalanine (Phe) and thyroid stimulating hormone (TSH). It has shown a declining robust CV, which has tended to level off in recent years. The interquartile range (IQR) of Phe and TSH's robust CV has decreased from 15.5% to 1.5% and from 22.8% to 1.8%, respectively. Compared to bacterial inhibition assay (BIA), the robust CV of Phe has been shown to be relatively reduced in the fluorescence assay and quantitative enzymatic assay (QEA). The robust CV by ELISA was relatively unstable compared to DELFIA and FEIA. In addition, the robust CVs of glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase (G6PD) and 17-alpha-hydroxy progesterone (17-OHP) by Genetic Screening Processor (GSP) were lower than other systems. The median of robust CV by non-derivatized MS/MS (Fenghua) in Phe and free carnitine were around 2.2-4.7% and 2.6-5.2%. CONCLUSION: Neonatal screening has developed rapidly in China and the majority of participant laboratories had satisfactory performance for the quantitative results.

Mortality trends of liver cancer among patients with type 2 diabetes at the global and national level.

BACKGROUND: Primary liver cancer (PLC) is a commonly diagnosed malignancy, especially in developing countries. Diabetes is one of the well-determined risk factors for PLC. We aimed to describe the temporal trends of PLC mortality among diabetic patients. METHODS: We retrieved the PLC mortality data among diabetic patients from the Global Burden of Disease (GBD) study 2017 online database. Estimated average percentage change (EAPC) was used to quantify the PLC age-standardized mortality rate (ASMR) trends, by sex and country, between 1990 and 2017. RESULTS: Globally, the number of PLC related deaths increased from 3732.1 in 1990 to 9506.4 in 2017, with the ASMR increased from 0.09/100,000 to 0.12/100,000 (EAPC = 0.98, 95% CI 0.82, 1.14) among diabetic patients. Both the ASMR of PLC and its temporal trend were highly heterogeneous across the world. Between 1990 and 2017, a total of 135, 19, and 41 countries or territories experienced a significant increase, remained stable, and experienced a significant decrease in PLC ASMR, respectively. The greatest increase was mainly detected in developed countries, such as the USA, the UK, and Australia. By contrast, the most pronounced decrease was majorly found in developing regions. CONCLUSIONS: In diabetic patients, the PLC mortality was significantly increased at the global level and in approximately 70% of countries or territories over the last three decades. The increasing trend indicated that diabetes is an increasingly important risk factor for PLC and suggested that more tailored prevention strategies are needed for each country.

External Quality Assessment Program for Newborn Screening of Acylcarnitine in China, 2018.

BACKGROUND: The aim of this study was to analyze the 2018 external quality assessment (EQA) results of newborn screening by MS/MS of acylcarnitine by Chinese National Center for Clinical Laboratories and to determine the performance of clinical laboratories. METHODS: Five dried blood spots were distributed to participants every round. Satisfactory performance was defined as scores more than 80 of acceptable results within the evaluation criterion. The robust coefficient of variability (RCV) of each sample was calculated by measurement systems. The chi-square (2) test was used to compare the correct recognition rates. RESULTS: EQA results were collected from 150 laboratories for 15 different acylcarnitines between C0 - C18. The overall acceptable rates of the qualitative results were between 81.21% and 96.67%, and the proportion of acceptable quantitative results were between 78.38% and 93.24%. There were significant differences in the rates of acceptable quantitative results among different items and between the four methods. CONCLUSIONS: Most of the participant laboratories had satisfactory performance for the quantitative results in this EQA scheme. But for qualitative assessment, a laboratory should re-evaluate and validate their reference intervals on a regular basis to improve the consistency of clinical assessment.

External Quality Assessment Program for Newborn Screening of Amino Acids in China.

BACKGROUND: To analyze the 2017 external quality assessment (EQA) results of newborn screening by MS/MS of amino acids by Chinese National Center for Clinical Laboratories, this study aimed to reflect the performance of clinical laboratories. METHODS: Five dried blood spots were distributed to participants every round. Satisfactory performance was defined as scores more than 80 of acceptable results within the evaluation criterion. The robust coefficient of variability (RCV) of each sample was calculated by measurement systems. The chi-square () test was used to compare the correct recognition rates. RESULTS: EQA results were collected from 150 laboratories for Ala, Val, Arg, Leu, Met, Phe, Tyr, Cit. The overall acceptable rates of the qualitative results were 87.42%, 92.72%, 73.33%, 94.04%, 92.72%, 94.70%, 92.72%, 94.04%, respectively, and the proportion of acceptable quantitative results were 76.51 %, 91.95%, 78.38 %, 92.62%, 93.29%, 93.29%, 94.63%, 91.28%, respectively. There were significant differences in the rates of acceptable quantitative results among different items and between four methods. CONCLUSIONS: Most of the participant laboratories had satisfactory performance for the quantitative results in this EQA scheme. But for qualitative assessment, the laboratory should re-evaluate and validate their reference intervals on a regular basis to improve the consistency of clinical assessment.

Quality assessment of interpretative commenting and competency comparison of comment providers in China.

Background This study aimed to evaluate the ability of comment providers who were responsible for interpreting results in clinical laboratories in China and to improve the quality of interpretative comments. Methods Basic information and interpretative comments for five cases of 1912 routine chemistry External Quality Assessment (EQA) participant laboratories were collected by web-based EQA system in May 2018. EQA organizers assigned scores to each key phrase of comments based on predetermined marking scale and calculated total scores for each participant's answer. Final scores and ranking were calculated according to scores of cases. Finally, we comprehensively analyzed the type of hospital and the professional title of participants. Results In total, 772 clinical laboratories, 1472 participants, from different Chinese provinces submitted interpretative comments. Median scores, interquartile ranges and score ranges of the five cases were 13 (11-15, 1-20), 13 (10-16, 0-20), 15 (12-17, 0-21), 7 (5-9, -2 to 14) and 12 (10-13, -2 to 18). The final scores and ranking of participants that came from tertiary hospitals were higher than those from secondary and other hospitals; however, there were no significant differences (0.774). When grouped by professional title, we found that although no significant variability existed among senior, intermediate, junior and others (0.699), it existed between laboratory physicians and technicians, as the median final scores of the former were higher than the latter. Conclusions Practice and quality of interpretative comments are indeed different among different laboratories and participants in China. Laboratories should train and assess the interpretative ability of personnel. EQA organizers should also improve the scoring method and establish peer assessors team through this survey.

Analysis and evaluation of the external quality assessment results of quality indicators in laboratory medicine all over China from 2015 to 2018.

Background This study aimed to comprehensively evaluate laboratory quality in China and explore factors affecting laboratory errors through analyzing the external quality assessment (EQA) results of quality indicators (QIs). Methods According to model 3 (interpretive) of the proficiency testing scheme, the National Center for Clinical Laboratories of China (CNCCL) developed a questionnaire for 15 QIs. Clinical laboratories from different provinces of China participated in the EQA program of QIs annually and submitted data via an online reporting system named Clinet-EQA. The results of QIs were expressed in percentage and sigma value or minute. Three levels of quality specifications (QSs) were defined based on percentile values. Furthermore, the QIs were analyzed by disciplines, hospital scales and information construction levels of participant laboratories. Results A total of 3450 laboratories nationwide continuously attended the EQA program and submitted complete data from 2015 to 2018. The performance of most QIs has improved year by year. QIs in post-analytical gained the best performance with sigma values that varied from 5.3σ to 6.0σ. The comparison of results among different disciplines showed significant differences for five QIs. More than half of QIs had statistical differences among different hospital scales measured by hospital grades and number of hospital beds. The performance of nine QIs were influenced by information construction levels of participant laboratories. Conclusions The overall laboratory quality in China has improved since the initiation of EQA program for QIs, but the performance of some QIs was still unsatisfactory. Therefore, laboratories should make efforts for continuous quality improvement based on information provided by QSs.