Accuracy of CBCT images in the assessment of buccal marginal alveolar peri-implant defects: effect of field of view.

OBJECTIVES: To investigate the reliability and accuracy of cone beam CT (CBCT) images obtained at different fields of view in detecting and quantifying simulated buccal marginal alveolar peri-implant defects. METHODS: Simulated buccal defects were prepared in 69 implants inserted into cadaver mandibles. CBCT images at three different fields of view were acquired: 40 × 40, 60 × 60 and 100 × 100 mm. The presence or absence of defects was assessed on three sets of images using a five-point scale by three observers. Observers also measured the depth, width and volume of defects on CBCT images, which were compared with physical measurements. The kappa value was calculated to assess intra- and interobserver agreement. Six-way repeated analysis of variance was used to evaluate treatment effects on the diagnosis. Pairwise comparisons of median true-positive and true-negative rates were calculated by the χ² test. Pearson's correlation coefficient was used to determine the relationship between measurements. Significance level was set as p < 0.05. RESULTS: All observers had excellent intra-observer agreement. Defect status (p < 0.001) and defect size (p < 0.001) factors were statistically significant. Pairwise interactions were found between defect status and defect size (p = 0.001). No differences between median true-positive or true-negative values were found between CBCT field of views (p > 0.05). Significant correlations were found between physical and CBCT measurements (p < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: All CBCT images performed similarly for the detection of simulated buccal marginal alveolar peri-implant defects. Depth, width and volume measurements of the defects from various CBCT images correlated highly with physical measurements.

Array geometry for assessment of mandibular implant position using tuned aperture computed tomography (TACT).

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate observer faciolingual depth and vertical depth reading errors when using various X-ray beam array geometries to make basis images for tomosynthetic reconstruction using tuned aperture computed tomography (TACT). MATERIALS AND METHODS: Tissue-equivalent models were constructed to replicate the position of dental implants in relation to simulated mandibular canals. X-ray beam geometries used to acquire the basis images for TACT(TM) integration included horizontal linear, vertical linear, and symmetric and asymmetric conical arrays. Twenty-one dentists trained in the use of TACT acted independently as observers. Tasks included: (1) determination of the relative position of the implant in relation to the simulated canal; and (2) measurement of the vertical depth and faciolingual (lateral) depth dimensions between these two structures. As the study did not involve repeated measures (only one measure was obtained from each observer on each of the two dependent variables), data for faciolingual depth and vertical depth reading errors were analysed using a one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) with Tukey's honestly significant different (HSD) procedure. RESULTS: Errors in determining the relative position of the implant to the simulated canal were most frequent when the linear horizontal projection geometry was employed for producing basis images (57% error for model #2 where the implant was lingually placed). The mean measurement errors for TACT images constructed using the various different projection arrays depended both on the structural relationship of anatomic features and the employed beam array geometry. CONCLUSION: Conical beam arrays are preferred over linear beam arrays for constructing basis images used with TACT for the purpose of correlating the position of a mandibular dental implant in relation to the mandibular canal. They more consistently allowed the observers to establish a measurement of the faciolingual relationship of the implant to the canal. For vertical depth measurement of the relationship of a mandibular dental implant to the mandibular canal, TACT does not appear to have any advantage over individual simple transmission radiographic images.

Extraoral and panoramic systems.

Digital solutions for extraoral and panoramic radiology have been available for more than 15 years. The costs, however, have been too high for adoption in private dental practice. The past 2 years have seen tremendous growth in the number of relatively cost-effective digital options available to the dentist and dental specialist. Furthermore, computer speed and data storage capacities have progressed. This article presents an overview of systems available at present, and their enabling technologies and enhancement capabilities.

In vivo accuracy and reliability of color-coded image enhancements for the assessment of periradicular lesion dimensions.

OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to compare dimensions on charge-coupled device-acquired images under various enhancements with dimensions on film radiographs and in vivo dimensions with respect to the linear measurement of periradicular radiolucent lesions. STUDY DESIGN: The dimensions of 25 lesions imaged by means of a charge-coupled device-based digital receptor and Ektaspeed Plus radiographic film were measured and compared with dimensions as actually measured on impressions of the lesions taken during surgery. Digital images were displayed in unenhanced, equalized, and equalized/color-coded modes. The color-coding protocol was repeated to determine the method error, and each image treatment was also remeasured to determine intrarater reliability. Differences were compared through use of a Friedman 2-way analysis of variance with a follow-up Wilcoxon signed rank test (alpha = 0.01). RESULTS: Actual lesion dimensions were larger than dimension estimates obtained with digital images (range, 23% to 35%) and film radiographs (range, 29% to 43%). Color-coded images were significantly less accurate than equalized images and unenhanced images. Images equalized through use of the measurement algorithm of the resident software provided estimates that were more accurate than estimates made with film radiographs and a standard millimeter rule. Intrarater variability was low. The application of color coding was found to be unreliable. CONCLUSIONS: When applied to intraoral images, color-coded image processing of digital images had limited value in the estimation of periradicular lesional dimensions.

Observer differentiation of mechanical defects versus natural dental caries cavitations on monitor-displayed images with imaging plate readout.

OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to compare the ability of dentists to detect mechanically created defects vs natural dental caries cavitations on the proximal surfaces of extracted teeth by means of storage phosphor imaging plate technology. STUDY DESIGN: Fifty-two extracted molar and premolar teeth were blocked into sets for bitewing radiographs through use of the DIGORA digital imaging system. Sixteen natural caries cavities and 28 artificial lesions were present in the 80 proximal surfaces included in the study. A group of 16 dentists assessed proximal lesions on unenhanced images on the monitor and 1 month later on contrast-enhanced images. A different group of 16 dentists assessed proximal lesions on contrast-enhanced images and 1 month later on unenhanced images. The Mann-Whitney U test was used to check for a reading-order effect. The Zelen test of odds ratio was used to test for homogeneity, and the Mantel-Haenszel analysis or stratified logistic regression was used for inference about the common odds ratio. Alpha was set at P < .05. RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS: With the DIGORA system, there was little difference between the detection rates of mechanical defects and natural carious cavities with unenhanced images, but the mechanical defects were more readily detected when contrast-enhanced images were used. Cavity depth positively affected the odds of diagnosis of lesions, with deeper lesions being more readily detected than more superficial ones irrespective of whether they were natural or artificial. In comparison with findings of previous studies in which film and a charge-coupled device detector were used, the overall detection rate for natural dental caries was remarkably constant across the modalities.

In vivo comparison of Visualix-2 and Ektaspeed Plus in the assessment of periradicular lesion dimensions.

UNLABELLED: Accurate assessment of intraosseous lesion dimensions is useful in determining strategies for treatment of periradicular pathoses of dental causation. OBJECTIVES: To compare the efficacy of digital versus analog imaging for the measurement of mesiodistal and vertical dimensions of periapical lesions in patients that require apical surgery. METHODS: Fourteen examiners assessed the dimensions of 28 lesions with a millimeter ruler and Ektaspeed Plus radiographs (Eastman Kodak, Rochester, N.Y.), and with the Visualix-2 (Gendex/Dentsply, Milan, Italy) in unenhanced, contrast-stretched and equalized modes with proprietary software mouse-driven measurement algorithm. Impregum F (Premier Dental Products) impressions at surgery were used as the "gold standard." Ten randomly chosen images were reread 2 weeks later to assess intra-operator reliability. As the Mauchly sphericity test was significant for all tests, a multivariate analysis of variance was used to assess accuracy. To explain the exact difference between means, the Bonferroni test was applied. Intra-observer reliability was assessed with Friedman's two-way analysis of variance; inter-observer effects were determined with Cronbach's alpha. RESULTS: For accuracy in measurement, the closest to the "gold standard" were achieved with the Visualix-2 with image equalization. The contrast-stretched Visualix-2 and unenhanced Visualix-2 measurements were less accurate; conventional film was consistently the least accurate (p < 0.002). On the other hand, subjective preference placed film radiographs above the unenhanced Visualix-2 images; contrast-stretched Visualix-2 images were preferred over all other modalities. CONCLUSIONS: Charge-coupled device-based images with the Visualix-2 are preferable to film-based radiographs for measuring periapical lesion dimensions.

Low-cost teleradiology for dentistry.

The performance of a low-cost teleradiology system was studied. The time needed for radiographic transmission between computers and the image integrity following transmission were measured. The image resolution was analyzed with a line-pair test chart. Images were transmitted through computers that had a video-processing board and a modem at both the transmission and receiving sites. Intraoral radiographs were captured with a black and white charge-coupled device camera. The time required for image transmission was less than 1 minute (46 to 56 seconds), an effective transmission speed of 1.73 kbyte/s (13.9 kbit/s). No changes were observed in pixel value distributions; hence, there was no loss of image detail. The maximal resolution of the system was 4 line-pairs/mm. The performance of the teleradiology system demonstrated its potential as an effective, low-cost telenetwork for dentistry.

Quantitative assessment of image quality using niobium filtration for cephalometric radiography.

The effect of added niobium filtration on image quality in cephalometric radiography was quantitatively evaluated using the Modulation Transfer Function (MTF). A conventional full-wave cephalometric X-ray generator (Quint Sectograph) and a constant potential, high frequency X-ray generator (Orthophos CD) were compared with respect to the effects on the MTF of the added filtration. There was a slight reduction in image quality with both machines when adding niobium filtration.

Expediting prior approval and containing third-party costs for dental care.

Dental insurance carriers frequently require referral of radiographs for determination of prior approval. Radiographs are also often used for obtaining expert opinions before finalizing diagnoses and establishing treatment plans. Traditionally, such referrals have been carried out using the original or duplicate films transmitted through the postal system. Studies concerning alternative communication media for data transmission are presented, namely, the use of switched-digital telephone lines and of electronic mail networks.