Medicare costs in urban areas and the supply of primary care physicians.

BACKGROUND: The supply of primary care physicians may be important determinants of health care costs. We examined the association between primary care physician supply and geographic location with respect to variation in Medicare Supplementary Medical Insurance (Part B) reimbursement. METHODS: We performed an analysis of data from all US metropolitan counties. Physician supply data were derived from the American Medical Association Masterfile. Medicare Part B reimbursements and enrollment data came from the Health Care Financing Administration. Physician supply was calculated for family practice, general internal medicine, and non-primary care specialties. Linear regression was used to test the association of physician supply and Medicare costs and to adjust for potential confounding variables. RESULTS: The average Medicare Part B reimbursement per enrollee was $1283. After adjusting for local price differences and county characteristics, a greater supply of family physicians and general internists was significantly associated with lower Medicare Part B reimbursements. The reduction in reimbursements between counties in the highest quintile of family physician supply and the lowest quintile was $261 per enrollee. In contrast, a greater supply of general practitioners and non-primary care physicians was associated with higher reimbursements per enrollee. CONCLUSIONS: These results add to the evidence than an increased supply of primary care physicians is associated with lower health care costs. If this association is causal, it supports the theory that increasing the number of primary care physicians may lower health care costs.

Minimal increase in use of breast-conserving surgery from 1986 to 1990.

Substantial geographic and hospital-based variations have been documented in the use of breast-conserving surgery (BCS) in 1986. The authors studied the patterns of adoption of this procedure from 1986 to 1990. National Medicare inpatient claims were used to study women aged 65 to 79 who underwent an operation for local or regional breast cancer in 1986 (38,679 patients) or 1990 (43,083 patients). Breast-conserving surgery was used for 5,509 (14.1%) of the Medicare patients in 1986 and 6,476 (15.0%) in 1990. The only region with an increase in BCS use from 1986 to 1990 was New England. Many hospitals had low volumes of operations, with a median of six to seven patients annually. Ten percent of the hospitals performed 55% of the conservative operations. Large hospitals, urban hospitals, and those with higher patient volumes or a cancer center were somewhat more likely to have increased use of BCS by 1990. Despite the substantial evidence supporting BCS as an alternative to mastectomy, the overall use of BCS in Medicare inpatients increased minimally from 1986 to 1990. Many patients are treated in hospitals with little experience with BCS. Hospitals using more BCS in 1986 were somewhat more likely to increase the use of BCS by 1990.

The relationship between adjusted hospital mortality and the results of peer review.

This study assessed the relationship between the Health Care Financing Administration adjusted mortality rate for a hospital and the errors in care found by the peer review process. The three data sets used were: (1) the 1987-1988 completed reviews from 38 peer review organizations (PROs) of 4,132 hospitals and 2,035,128 patients; (2) all 1987 hospital mortality rates for Medicare patients as adjusted by HCFA for patient mix; and (3) the 1986 American Hospital Association Survey. The PRO data were used to compute the percentage of cases reviewed from each hospital confirmed by a reviewing physician to have a quality problem. The average percentage of confirmed problems was 3.73 percent with state rates ranging from 0.03 percent to 38.5 percent. The average within-state correlation between the problem rate and the adjusted mortality rate for all PROs was .19 (p < .0001), but the correlations were much higher for relatively homogeneous groups of hospitals, .42 for public hospitals and .36 for hospitals in large metropolitan statistical areas (MSAs). These results suggest that the HCFA adjusted hospital mortality rate and the PRO-confirmed problem rate are related methods to compare hospitals on the basis of quality of care. Both methods may compare quality better if used within a group of homogenous hospitals.

Hospitalization with vertebral fracture among the aged: a national population-based study, 1986-1989.

Whereas fractures related to osteoporosis have become a pressing public health concern, relatively few epidemiologic studies have focused on vertebral fractures. To shed further light on the occurrence of this injury, we collected data from the Health Care Financing Administration on 151,986 discharges listing a diagnosis of vertebral fracture over a 4-year period. After adjusting for age, white women experienced the highest rates of discharge, at 17.1 per 10,000 per year, followed by white men (9.9 per 10,000), black women (3.7 per 10,000), and black men (2.5 per 10,000). Among white women, discharge rates rose exponentially from 5.3 discharges per 10,000 population at age 65 to nearly 47.8 per 10,000 at age 90. White men, black women, and black men experienced less dramatic age-related increases in discharge rates. The similarity of these patterns to discharge rates for hip fracture suggests that the race-sex differences in vertebral fracture discharge rates may be due to differences in the incidence of vertebral fracture.

Outcome and cost analysis of scheduled versus emergency scleral buckling surgery.

BACKGROUND: Retinal detachments are usually considered to be a surgical emergency. However, there are additional risks and costs for unnecessary emergency surgeries. The purpose of this study is to evaluate whether the conventional wisdom for treating all retinal detachments as emergencies needs to be re-examined. METHODS: Forty-eight patients who had an emergency scleral buckle and 89 patients who had a scheduled procedure were randomly selected from 884 consecutive patients who had a primary scleral buckling procedure during a 4 1/2-year period. The medical records of each patient were used to obtain detailed information related to prognosis. The visual acuity measurements of each patient, taken 6 months after the procedure, were obtained from the records of the ophthalmologist following the patient. Linear regression analysis was used to compare the final visual outcome for patients who had emergency surgery with patients who had scheduled surgery after taking into account patient factors related to prognosis. RESULTS: Patients selected for emergency surgery had better visual prognoses than scheduled patients but had the same risk of systemic complications and the same extent of detachment if the macula was not involved. None of the 18 patients with an attached macula experienced macular involvement while awaiting scheduled surgery. There were no differences between emergency and scheduled patients in ocular or systemic complications, rate of reattachment, rate of decreased visual acuity after surgery, visual outcome adjusted for prognosis, or, since 1985, length of hospital stay. A greater cost was incurred for the patients having emergency surgery due to difference in pay scales for support personnel. CONCLUSIONS: Because the study is not large and the patients were not randomized to treatment, the results are not definitive. However, they suggest that emergency surgery is unnecessary for many patients with a detached retina.

The relationship of hospital characteristics and the results of peer review in six large states.

To determine which characteristics of hospitals may be related to a higher quality of care, the association of hospital characteristics with the outcomes of medical record review by state Peer Review Organizations (PROs) was studied. The two data sources were: 1) the AHA 1986 Annual Survey of Hospitals and 2) reviews completed between July 1987 through June 1988 from six large PROs. For each hospital the percentage of cases that failed physician review (the confirmed problem rate) was computed. Hospital characteristics evaluated included financial status, ownership, medical training, technological sophistication, and size. The following characteristics were significantly associated with a lower confirmed problem rate: a higher occupancy rate, greater payroll expenses per bed, a higher proportion of physicians who were board-certified specialists, greater technological sophistication, a higher number of beds, a higher proportion of nurses who were registered, and membership in the Council of Teaching Hospitals. Public hospitals had higher problems rates than private not-for-profit hospitals. All characteristics significantly related to higher confirmed problem rates were also related to higher adjusted mortality rates in a previous study of 3,100 U.S. hospitals. The results suggest that hospital resources, including financial status, training of medical personnel, and availability of sophisticated equipment, are related to the quality of care provided by the hospital.

Outcome and cost analysis of scheduled versus emergency scleral buckling surgery.

Conventional wisdom holds that a retinal detachment of recent onset should be regarded as a surgical emergency. A delay in surgery may result in an extension of detachment for patients with an attached macula and a worse visual outcome for patients with a detached macula. However, the potential disadvantages of performing surgery on an emergency basis must be weighed against the risks of delaying surgery; disadvantages include a greater frequency of operative complications resulting from fatigue factors among the operating personnel, an increased anesthetic risk due to inadequate time to assess and stabilize coexisting medical problems, and higher hospital costs. In this retrospective study covering 4 1/2 years, we compared the risks, benefits, length of hospitalization, and costs of scleral buckling surgery for retinal detachments performed as an emergency procedure or on the day following admission. After a 15% random selection from 884 consecutive operations, 48 emergency procedures were compared with 89 scheduled procedures. Patients selected for emergency surgery had better visual prognoses than scheduled patients. The potential for risk of systemic complications was not a reason for postponing surgery. None of the 18 patients with an attached macula experienced macular involvement while awaiting scheduled surgery. There were no differences between emergency and scheduled patients in ocular or systemic complications, rate of reattachment, rate of decreased visual acuity following surgery, visual outcome adjusted for prognosis, or, since 1985, length of hospital stay. Cost was greater for patients having emergency surgery, because of a difference in pay scales for support personnel.