Short-term costs of conventional vs laparoscopic assisted surgery in patients with colorectal cancer (MRC CLASICC trial).

The short-term clinical results of the CLASICC trial indicated that clinical outcomes were similar between laparoscopic and open approaches. This study presents the short-term (3 month) cost analysis undertaken on a subset of patients entered into the CLASICC trial (682 of 794 patients). As expected the costs associated with the operation were higher in the 452 patients randomised to laparoscopic surgery (lap) compared with the 230 randomised to open procedure (open), Pounds 1703 vs Pounds 1386. This was partially offset by the other hospital (nontheatre) costs, which were lower in the lap group (Pounds 2930 vs Pounds 3176). The average cost to individuals for reoperations was higher in the lap group (Pounds 762 vs Pounds 553). Overall costs were slightly higher in the lap group (Pounds 6899 vs Pounds 6631), with mean difference of Pounds 268 (95%CI -689 to 1457). Sensitivity analysis made little difference to these results. The cost of rectal surgery was higher than for colon, for lap (Pounds 8259 vs Pounds 5586) and open procedures (Pounds 7820 vs Pounds 5503). The short-term cost analysis for the CLASICC trial indicates that the costs of either laparoscopic or open procedure were similar, lap surgery costing marginally more on average than open surgery.

Assessing the relative costs of standard open surgery and laparoscopic surgery in colorectal cancer in a randomised controlled trial in the United Kingdom.

The role of laparoscopic surgery for the treatment of colorectal cancer is being explored in a multi-centre, randomised clinical trial in the UK, the MRC CLASICC Trial (Conventional versus Laparoscopic-assisted Surgery in Colorectal Cancer). An important end-point of the trial is the cost-effectiveness of laparoscopic surgery compared with that of conventional open surgery. The economic evaluation of this trial has been modelled on that in a similar trial being conducted in the USA in colon cancer. The aim of this paper is to discuss the rationale for modelling the UK trial on the US trial, and to describe the adaptations necessary for the UK trial. The parallel design of the economic evaluation in both trials will provide a unique opportunity to compare the cost implications of incorporating laparoscopic surgery in the UK and the USA, and to determine any cross-cultural differences. The UK trial will also provide information about the cost-effectiveness of laparoscopic surgery in rectal cancer.

Dynamic contrast-enhanced MR imaging and dual-phase helical CT in the preoperative assessment of suspected pancreatic cancer: a comparative study with receiver operating characteristic analysis.

OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to compare dynamic contrast-enhanced MR imaging and dual-phase helical CT in the preoperative assessment of patients with suspected pancreatic carcinoma. SUBJECTS AND METHODS: Thirty-three consecutive surgical candidates (20 men, 13 women; 39-81 years old) were included. MR imaging comprised fast spin-echo (TR/TE 4000/91), fat-suppressed T1-weighted spin-echo (500/15), and T1-weighted breath-hold gradient-echo fast low-angle shot (100/4; flip angle, 80 degrees) images before and after the administration of gadopentetate dimeglumine. Helical CT used 5-mm collimation with a pitch of 1:1.5-1.7; images were obtained 20 and 65-70 sec after injection of 150 ml of contrast material. Two pairs of interpreters who were unaware of the results of the other imaging method independently scored each examination for the presence of a lesion and for surgical resectability using a five-point scale. Results were correlated with surgery (n = 25) or consensus review (n = 8). Receiver operating characteristic methodology was used to analyze the results for resectability, and positive predictive values were calculated. RESULTS: Both MR imaging and helical CT revealed 29 of 31 lesions. In determining lesion resectability, the mean areas under the receiver operating characteristic curves were 0.96 and 0.81 (p = .01) and the positive predictive values were 86.5% and 76% (p = .02) for MR imaging and helical CT, respectively. CONCLUSION: MR imaging and helical CT performed equally well in lesion detection. MR imaging was significantly better in the assessment of resectability of pancreatic tumors.

Assessment of resectability of pancreatic cancer with dynamic contrast-enhanced MR imaging: technique, surgical correlation and patient outcome.

The aim of our work was to investigate the use of a dynamic contrast-enhanced MR (DCEMR) technique for staging apparently localised pancreatic cancer, and to determine the patterns of tumour and vascular enhancement with this technique. Thirty-five consecutive patients were examined. The MR findings were correlated with surgical findings in 13 patients and with clinical outcome in 22 patients. Breath-hold gradient-echo fast low angle shot (TR = 100, TE = 4, flip angle 80 degrees ) acquisitions were obtained at 10 and 40 s (right anterior coronal oblique plane) and at 90 s (axial plane) following intravenous gadolinium. Mean contrast-to-noise ratio was higher on the first than the second acquisition (p < 0. 001) and higher on the second acquisition than the third (p < 0.005). Tumour conspicuity was greatest and arterial anatomy was best demonstrated on the first acquisition and the portal venous anatomy on the second. Small tumours were isointense by the third acquisition. Maximal intensity projections were helpful. The MR findings correctly predicted the surgical findings in 11 of 13 cases (85 %) and the clinical course in the other 22 patients. The DCEMR imaging technique is valuable in the staging of patients with pancreatic cancer. Capillary and portal venous phase images are both required for complete local staging.

Laparoscopic colorectal surgery.

Laparoscopic surgery has been readily adapted to the management of patients with colorectal disease without any large-scale randomized clinical studies to support its use, particularly in patients with colorectal cancer. This overview analyses the currently available data and highlights the areas where caution is merited and optimism encouraged.

Clinical economics review: the health-care economic implications of minimal access gastrointestinal surgery.

This article reviews some of the health-care economic data that have been acquired in recent assessments of minimal access surgery of the digestive tract, with particular reference to laparoscopic cholecystectomy and laparoscopic surgery for gastro-oesophageal reflux disease.

Nutritional and immunological assessment of patients with anorexia nervosa.

The nutritional and immunological status of patients with anorexia nervosa was assessed. Anthropometric measurements were found to be lowered as were the serum levels of zinc (p<0.01), copper (p<0.01) and ceruloplasmin (p<0.05) in comparison with the control group. However the serum levels of albumin, pre-albumin, transferrin and retinol binding protein, vitamins A and D and leucocyte vitamin C were generally found to be within normal limits. Lymphocyte transformation was measured in response to stimulation with the mitogens Con A, PHA and PWM. Responses were normal in all patients with the exception of one who showed a depressed response to Con A. Natural killer cell activity was measured against the target cell line K562 and was not found to differ significantly from controls. It is suggested that the relatively normal protein and vitamin status is responsible for maintaining the apparently normal cellular immune function in patients with anorexia nervosa.