Causality assessment of adverse effects: when is re-challenge ethically acceptable?

One of the most difficult tasks in the evaluation of a medicine is whether it causes a particular rare and unusual (idiosyncratic) adverse effect. Such causality assessments are sometimes done by drug de-challenge and re-challenge. When the adverse effect is potentially serious, there is clearly an important decision to be made as to whether the re-challenge is justifiable and hence ethical. The recent controversy about the potential cardiotoxicity of fexofenadine, the fatalities associated with penicillin re-challenge and the fatalities associated with abacavir re-challenge highlight some of the potential serious risks of drug re-challenge. The associated important ethical issues are discussed. In particular, there is the need to ensure respect for the patient and to consider the scientific and social value of the re-challenge. A framework for evaluating and assessing the appropriateness of a particular drug re-challenge is proposed in the light of recent as well as long-standing discussions of drug re-challenge, patient informed consent and the ethics of human experimentation, in general. It is suggested that a drug re-challenge should be approached with the same rigour and standards of documentation as are currently required of clinical trials. Given the potential conflicts of interest inherent with any drug study, it is argued that the safeguards, as may be provided by scrutiny by an ethics committee, are necessary for a drug re-challenge. For the investigator contemplating the conduct of a drug re-challenge we would recommend the following: (i) a careful risk-benefit assessment as part of the decision-making process; (ii) careful scientific preparation, including appropriate expert support and emergency back-up facilities, if re-challenge is deemed necessary; (iii) the writing of a detailed protocol for independent approval and for safeguarding all concerned; and (iv) meticulous record keeping.

Therapeutic advances: donepezil for the treatment of Alzheimer's disease.

Until recently, few drugs have been available for the treatment of Alzheimer's disease. The first such drug to be launched in the U.K. was the acetylcholinesterase inhibitor, donepezil. The limited published data on donepezil shows only modest cognitive benefit in patients with Alzheimer's disease. The cost of diagnosis and drug treatment, the distressing nature of the disease and the limited evidence available, pose difficult decisions for the introduction of new drugs and the management of this condition.

Cost analysis of once-daily ISMN versus twice-daily ISMN or transdermal patch for nitrate prophylaxis.

OBJECTIVE: To compare the costs and outcomes of treating exercise-induced angina with once- or twice-daily isosorbide mononitrate (ISMN) or transdermal patch. METHOD: A decision-analytic model was designed based on published literature showing compliance and increasing symptoms and estimates from physicians on treatment patterns and worsening symptoms. RESULTS: Data show that patients are more compliant with once-daily ISMN (Imdur, Astra Hässle, Mölndal, Sweden) and patch regimens than with twice-daily dose. Based upon the assumption that more compliant patients are better controlled, the model found that fewer medical care resources were consumed by patients treated with the once-daily and the patch regimens. The unit cost of the twice-daily ISMN regimen is 40% of the unit cost of the once-daily. Annual costs of treating an exercise-induced angina patient are 248 pounds for Imdur compared to 250 pounds for the twice-daily ISMN and 299 pounds for the transdermal patch. CONCLUSION: Unit prices alone are not good indicators for estimating medical management costs.

Growth hormone treatment for growth hormone deficient adults.

Growth hormone (GH) deficiency in adults is now recognized as a clinical syndrome with characteristic signs and symptoms. Numerous trials with daily subcutaneous biosynthetic human growth hormone (hGH) have been conducted in this patient group. Generally, improvements in insulin-like growth factor levels, decreases in total fat mass and increases in lean body mass are recorded with no overall effect on total body weight. Variable effects on serum cholesterol, bone mineral density and quality of life have also been reported. The true place of GH replacement therapy in adults has yet to be defined. Several questions relating to the dose, duration of treatment, long-term side-effects, quality of life changes and health economic implications of treatment still need to be assessed.

Therapeutic advances: riluzole for the treatment of motor neurone disease.

Amyotrophic laterial sclerosis is a fatal neurogenerative disorder, for which only symptomatic treatment was previously available. Riluzole was recently launched in the U.S.A. and Europe. This is the first drug to produce a modest increase in survival (approximately 3 months) in patients with this disease. Unfortunately, treatment causes a number of side-effects of which asthenia is particularly troublesome. Between 10 and 20 per cent of patients can be expected to withdraw from treatment due to these adverse effects. Data on the real time survival advantage and quality of life that can be expected whilst on treatment are needed to identify the place of riluzole in the management of this distressing disease.

A risk-benefit assessment of celiprolol in the treatment of cardiovascular disease.

Celiprolol is a third-generation beta-adrenoceptor blocker with selective beta 1-antagonist, partial beta 2-agonist and mild alpha 2-antagonist actions. It seems to be as effective as other beta-blockers in the treatment of hypertension and angina pectoris. beta-Blockers have many cardioprotective effects and have been shown to reduce the morbidity and mortality from coronary artery disease in a number of trials. However, there is no good clinical evidence that celiprolol itself has specific cardioprotective properties other than those attributable to this class of drugs. Because of its pharmacological profile, celiprolol is less likely to cause bradycardia, deterioration in cardiac function and other adverse effects mainly caused by beta 2-blockade. Unlike most other beta-blockers, celiprolol has no adverse effects on plasma lipids. It seems to be well tolerated in diabetic patients and patients with renal dysfunction.

A metabolic assessment of the beta 1 selectivity of bisoprolol.

Twelve healthy volunteers were given single oral doses of bisoprolol 5 mg, 10 mg and 20 mg and atenolol 50 mg and 100 mg in a randomised, placebo-controlled study. The effects of these drugs on beta 2-stimulated hypokalaemia and hyperglycaemia (produced by intravenous terbutaline infusion) were studied. Comparable beta-blockade was achieved with bisoprolol 20 mg, and atenolol 50 mg and 100 mg as measured by attenuation of exercise heart rate. Measurements of areas under or over the curve (AUC and AOC) of hypokalaemic or hyperglycaemic response to terbutaline infusion showed that bisoprolol (10 mg and 20 mg) and atenolol (50 mg and 100 mg) were significantly less beta 1 selective than 5 mg bisoprolol. Furthermore, there was a trend towards decreasing beta 1 selectivity with increasing doses of bisoprolol. Bisoprolol, an effective once daily antihypertensive and antianginal treatment, has comparable beta 1 selectivity to atenolol as measured by metabolic response. At a dose of 5 mg, bisoprolol has a measurable impact on beta 1 receptors but minimal effect on beta 2 receptors.

Assessment of beta-1 selectivity of bisoprolol and atenolol by means of their influence on the lipolytic response to an infusion of terbutaline.

We have investigated the beta-1 selectivity of a new beta-blocker, Bisoprolol, by comparing its effect on lipolysis induced by intravenous terbutaline infusion with that of Atenolol. At a dose of 5 mg, Bisoprolol had virtually no beta-2 blocking activity as measured by free fatty acid (FFA) release during terbutaline infusion. At a dose of 10 mg, Bisoprolol had a small but statistically insignificant effect on FFA release similar to 50 mg Atenolol. At a dose of 20 mg, Bisoprolol had significant beta-2 blocking activity. At lower doses, therefore, Bisoprolol is a very selective beta-blocker.

A pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic assessment of a combined slow-release metoprolol-chlorthalidone preparation.

Beta adrenoceptor blocking drugs and diuretics are frequently given together to control hypertension and increasingly the two agents are being combined in a single preparation. Possible interactions between the two agents are therefore of interest. In this study the addition of chlorthalidone has been shown not to influence the plasma levels or beta-blocking action of a sustained release form of metoprolol. In addition, when the combination product containing sustained release metoprolol and chlorthalidone is given over 21 days, the plasma levels of each drug are similar to those reported for each drug when given alone.

Assessment of rheumatoid activity based on clinical features and blood and synovial fluid analysis.

Joint inflammation in rheumatoid arthritis has been assessed, and the most useful guides to disease activity were determined by analysis of synovial fluid and blood together with the history of joint disability. The patient's own evaluation of the amount of pain suffered was the most useful clinical assessment. Differential cell count and glucose estimations were the most helpful guides in the synovial fluid, while C-reactive protein in the serum most accurately reflected disease activity. The effects of systemic steroids on these indices were studied, and the differences between seronegative and seropositive patients noted.

A single dose study of trazodone with an assessment of its effect on mood and arousal.

1 A pharmacokinetic study of a single oral dose of a new antidepressant (trazodone) is described, linked to an attempt to measure changes in mood and arousal induced by the drug in normal subjects. 2 The drug had a measurable effect on arousal, but not on mood. It caused bradycardia (compared with placebo) and this persisted through the following night's sleep. This effect has not been completely explained. 3 The technique of mood and arousal measurement employed in this study seems potentially useful.

An assessment of gastric emptying by breathalyser.

1 A breathalyser has been used to measure blood alcohol levels at short intervals to produce an absorption curve which we have shown is reproducible. 2 Changes in the rate of absorption which reflect changes in gastric emptying times produced by metoclopromide and propantheline have been demonstrated. 3 The breathalyser technique described appears to offer a simple method of studying the effects of drugs on the rate of gastric emptying.