SHoC-IVC: Does assessment of the inferior vena cava by point-of-care ultrasound independently predict fluid status in spontaneously breathing patients with undifferentiated hypotension?

BACKGROUND: Accurately determining the fluid status of a patient during resuscitation in the emergency department (ED) helps guide appropriate fluid administration in the setting of undifferentiated hypotension. Our goal was to determine the diagnostic utility of point-of-care ultrasound (PoCUS) for inferior vena cava (IVC) size and collapsibility in predicting a volume overload fluid status in spontaneously breathing hypotensive ED patients. METHODS: This was a post hoc secondary analysis of the SHOC-ED data, a prospective randomized controlled trial investigating PoCUS in patients with undifferentiated hypotension. We prospectively collected data on IVC size and collapsibility for 138 patients in the PoCUS group using a standard data collection form, and independently assigned a fluid status (volume overloaded, normal, volume deplete) from a composite clinical chart review blinded to PoCUS findings. The primary outcome was the diagnostic performance of IVC characteristics on PoCUS in the detection of a volume overloaded fluid status. RESULTS: One hundred twenty-nine patients had completed determinant IVC assessment by PoCUS, with one hundred twenty-five receiving successful final fluid status determination, of which one hundred and seven were classified as volume deplete, thirteen normal, and seven volume overloaded. A receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve was plotted using several IVC size and collapsibility categories. The best overall performance utilized the combined parameters of a dilated IVC (> 2.5 cm) with minimal collapsibility (less than 50%) which had a sensitivity of 85.7% and specificity of 86.4% with an area under the curve (AOC) of 0.92 for predicting an volume overloaded fluid status. CONCLUSION: IVC PoCUS is feasible in spontaneously breathing hypotensive adult ED patients, and demonstrates potential value as a predictor of a volume overloaded fluid status in patients with undifferentiated hypotension. IVC size may be the preferred measure.

RéSUMé: CONTEXTE: La détermination précise de l'état du liquide d'un patient pendant la réanimation au service des urgences (SU) aide à guider l'administration appropriée du liquide dans le cadre d'une hypotension indifférenciée. Notre objectif était de déterminer l'utilité diagnostique de l'échographie au point de soins (PoCUS) pour la taille de la veine cave inférieure (IVC) et l'collapsibilité dans la prédiction d'un état de liquide de surcharge volumique chez les patients souffrant d'une hypotension respiratoire spontanée. MéTHODES: Il s'agissait d'une analyse secondaire post-hoc des données SHOC-ED, un essai contrôlé randomisé prospectif examinant PoCUS chez des patients atteints d'hypotension indifférenciée. Nous avons collecté prospectivement des données sur la taille et la collapsibilité des IVC pour 138 patients du groupe PoCUS à l'aide d'un formulaire de collecte de données standard, et attribué indépendamment un état de fluide (volume surchargé, normal, épuisement du volume) à partir d'une revue de dossier clinique composite mise en aveugle aux résultats PoCUS. Le résultat principal était la performance diagnostique des caractéristiques IVC sur PoCUS dans la détection d'un état de fluide surchargé en volume. RéSULTATS: 129 patients avaient terminé l'évaluation IVC des déterminants par PoCUS, dont 125 ont reçu une détermination finale du statut hydrique, dont 107 ont été classés comme étant une diminution du volume, 13 normaux et 7 surchargés. Une courbe des caractéristiques de fonctionnement du récepteur (ROC) a été tracée en utilisant plusieurs catégories de taille et d'affaissement IVC. La meilleure performance globale a utilisé les paramètres combinés d'une IVC dilatée (> 2,5 cm) avec une collapsibilité minimale (moins de 50%) qui avait une sensibilité de 85,7% et une spécificité de 86,4% avec une zone sous la courbe (AOC) de 0,92 pour prédire un état de fluide surchargé en volume. CONCLUSION: IVC PoCUS est faisable chez les patients adultes souffrant d'une hypotension respiratoire spontanée et démontre une valeur potentielle en tant que prédicteur d'un état de liquide surchargé en volume chez les patients atteints d'hypotension indifférenciée. La taille IVC peut être la mesure préférée.

Access to Top-Cited Emergency Care Articles (Published Between 2012 and 2016) Without Subscription.

INTRODUCTION: Unrestricted access to journal publications speeds research progress, productivity, and knowledge translation, which in turn develops and promotes the efficient dissemination of content. We describe access to the 500 most-cited emergency medicine (EM) articles (published between 2012 and 2016) in terms of publisher-based access (open access or subscription), alternate access routes (self-archived or author provided), and relative cost of access. METHODS: We used the Scopus database to identify the 500 most-cited EM articles published between 2012 and 2016. Access status was collected from the journal publisher. For studies not available via open access, we searched on Google, Google Scholar, Researchgate, Academia.edu, and the Unpaywall and Open Access Button browser plugins to locate self-archived copies. We contacted corresponding authors of the remaining inaccessible studies for a copy of each of their articles. We collected article processing and access costs from the journal publishers, and then calculated relative cost differences using the World Bank purchasing power parity index for the United States (U.S.), Germany, Turkey, China, Brazil, South Africa, and Australia. This allows costs to be understood relative to the economic context of the countries from which they originated. RESULTS: We identified 500 articles for inclusion in the study. Of these, 167 (33%) were published in an open access format. Of the remaining 333 (67%), 204 (61%) were available elsewhere on the internet, 18 (4%) were provided by the authors, and 111 (22%) were accessible by subscription only. The mean article processing and access charges were $2,518.62 and $44.78, respectively. These costs were 2.24, 1.75, 2.28 and 1.56 times more expensive for South African, Chinese, Turkish, and Brazilian authors, respectively, than for U.S. authors (p<0.001 all). CONCLUSION: Despite the advantage of open access publication for knowledge translation, social responsibility, and increased citation, one in five of the 500 EM articles were accessible only via subscription. Access for scientists from upper-middle income countries was significantly hampered by cost. It is important to acknowledge the value this has for authors from low- and middle-income countries. Authors should also consider the citation advantage afforded by open access publishing when deciding where to publish.

Getting It Right the First Time: Defining Regionally Relevant Training Curricula and Provider Core Competencies for Point-of-Care Ultrasound Education on the African Continent.

Significant evidence identifies point-of-care ultrasound (PoCUS) as an important diagnostic and therapeutic tool in resource-limited settings. Despite this evidence, local health care providers on the African continent continue to have limited access to and use of ultrasound, even in potentially high-impact fields such as obstetrics and trauma. Dedicated postgraduate emergency medicine residency training programs now exist in 8 countries, yet no current consensus exists in regard to core PoCUS competencies. The current practice of transferring resource-rich PoCUS curricula and delivery methods to resource-limited health systems fails to acknowledge the unique challenges, needs, and disease burdens of recipient systems. As emergency medicine leaders from 8 African countries, we introduce a practical algorithmic approach, based on the local epidemiology and resource constraints, to curriculum development and implementation. We describe an organizational structure composed of nexus learning centers for PoCUS learners and champions on the continent to keep credentialing rigorous and standardized. Finally, we put forth 5 key strategic considerations: to link training programs to hospital systems, to prioritize longitudinal learning models, to share resources to promote health equity, to maximize access, and to develop a regional consensus on training standards and credentialing.