Septate uterus according to ESHRE/ESGE, ASRM and CUME definitions: association with infertility and miscarriage, cost and warnings for women and healthcare systems.

OBJECTIVES: To estimate the differences in frequency of diagnosis of septate uterus using three different definitions and determine whether these differences are significant in clinical practice, and to examine the association between diagnosis of septate uterus, using each of the three definitions, and infertility and/or previous miscarriage as well as the cost of allocation to surgery. METHODS: This was a secondary analysis of data from a prospective study of 261 consecutive women of reproductive age attending a private clinic focused on the diagnosis and treatment of congenital uterine malformations. Reanalysis of the datasets was performed according to three different means of defining septate uterus: following the recommendations of the American Society for Reproductive Medicine (ASRM), a 2016 update of those of the American Fertility Society from 1988 (ASRM-2016: internal fundal indentation depth ≥ 1.5 cm, angle of internal indentation < 90° and external indentation depth < 1 cm); following the recommendations of the European Society of Human Reproduction and Embryology/European Society for Gynaecological Endoscopy (ESHRE/ESGE), published in 2013 and reaffirmed in 2016 (ESHRE/ESGE-2016: internal fundal/uterine indentation depth > 50% of uterine-wall thickness and external indentation depth < 50% of uterine-wall thickness, with uterine-wall thickness measured above interostial/intercornual line); and using a definition published last year which was based on the decision made most often by a group of experts (Congenital Uterine Malformation by Experts; CUME) (CUME-2018: internal fundal indentation depth ≥ 1 cm and external fundal indentation depth < 1 cm). We compared the rate of diagnosis of septate uterus using each of these three definitions and, for each, we estimated the association between the diagnosis and infertility and/or previous miscarriage, and anticipated the costs associated with their implementation using a guesstimation method. RESULTS: Although 32.6% (85/261) of the subjects met the criteria for one of the three definitions of septate uterus, only 2.7% (7/261) of them were defined as having septate uterus according to all three definitions. We diagnosed significantly more cases of septate uterus using ESHRE/ESGE-2016 than using ASRM-2016 (31% vs 5%, relative risk (RR) = 6.7, P < 0.0001) or CUME-2018 (31% vs 12%, RR = 2.6, P < 0.0001) criteria. We also observed frequent cases that could not be classified definitively by ASRM-2016 (gray zone: neither normal/arcuate nor septate; 6.5%). There were no significant differences (P > 0.05) in the prevalence of septate uterus in women with vs those without infertility according to ASRM-2016 (5% vs 4%), ESHRE/ESGE-2016 (35% vs 28%) or CUME-2018 (11% vs 12%). Septate uterus was diagnosed significantly more frequently in women with vs those without previous miscarriage according to ASRM-2016 (11% vs 3%; P = 0.04) and CUME-2018 (22 vs 10%; P = 0.04), but not according to ESHRE/ESGE-2016 (42% vs 28%; P = 0.8) criteria. Our calculations showed that global costs to the healthcare system would be highly dependent on the criteria used in the clinical setting to define septate uterus, with the costs associated with the ESHRE/ESGE-2016 definition potentially being an extra US$ 100-200 billion over 5 years in comparison to ASRM-2016 and CUME-2018 definitions. CONCLUSIONS: The prevalence of septate uterus according to ESHRE/ESGE-2016, ASRM-2016 and CUME-2018 definitions differs considerably. An important limitation of the ASRM classification, which needs to be addressed, is the high proportion of unclassifiable cases originally named, by us, the 'gray zone'. The high rate of overdiagnosis of septate uterus according to ESHRE/ESGE-2016 may lead to unnecessary surgery and therefore unnecessary risk in these women and may impose a considerable financial burden on healthcare systems. Efforts to define clinically meaningful and universally applicable criteria for the diagnosis of septate uterus should be encouraged. Copyright © 2019 ISUOG. Published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd.

Útero septo según las definiciones de ESHRE/ESGE, ASRM y CUME: la relación con la infertilidad y el aborto espontáneo, el costo y advertencias para las mujeres y los sistemas de salud OBJETIVO: Evaluar el rendimiento de la velocidad sistólica máxima de la arteria cerebral media fetal (MCA-PSV, por sus siglas en inglés) ≥1,5 múltiplos de la mediana (MdM) para la predicción de la anemia moderada-severa en fetos sometidos a transfusión y no sometidos. MÉTODOS: Se realizó una búsqueda sistemática para identificar estudios observacionales relevantes reportados en el período 2008-2018 que evaluaron el rendimiento de la MCA-PSV, utilizando un umbral de 1,5MdM para la predicción de la anemia fetal. El diagnóstico de la anemia fetal mediante la toma de muestras de sangre fue el estándar de referencia. Se utilizaron modelos de efectos aleatorios para la elaboración de una curva jerárquica resumen de las características operativas del receptor (hSROC, por sus siglas en inglés). Se realizaron análisis de subgrupos y metarregresión, según el número de transfusiones intrauterinas previas. RESULTADOS: En el metaanálisis se incluyeron doce estudios y 696 fetos. El área bajo la curva (ABC) hSROC para la anemia moderada-severa fue del 83%. La sensibilidad y especificidad agrupadas (IC 95%) fueron del 79% (70-86%) y 73% (62-82%), respectivamente, y los cocientes de verosimilitud positivos y negativos fueron 2,94 (IC 95%: 2,13-4,00) y 0,272 (IC 95%: 0,188-0,371). Cuando solo se consideraron los fetos no sometidos a transfusión, la predicción mejoró, pues se logró un ABC del 87%, una sensibilidad del 86% (IC 95%: 75-93%) y una especificidad del 71% (IC 95%: 49-87%). Se observó una disminución en la sensibilidad de la predicción de la anemia moderada-severa mediante la MCA-PSV ≥1.5MdM (estimación, -5,5% (IC 95%: -10,7 a -0,3%), P=0,039) en función del aumento del número de transfusiones previas. CONCLUSIONES: El uso de la MCA-PSV ≥1.5MdM para la predicción de la anemia moderada-severa en fetos no sometidos a transfusión muestra una precisión moderada (86% de sensibilidad y 71% de especificidad), que disminuye con el aumento del número de transfusiones intrauterinas.

Assessing the influence of payment on motivations of women participating as oocyte donors.

We report on the motivations of potential ovum donors entering an assisted reproduction program and discuss the potential ramifications of escalating payments to donors. From July 1995 to July 1998, recruitment of ovum donors was directed at healthy women between 21 and 34 years of age. Financial remuneration for services rendered was USD 2,500 from July 1995 through March 1998 and increased to USD 5,000 after that. Donors were screened and consented according to established SART guidelines. The demographic background of the women was similar for women paid USD 2,500 to those receiving USD 5,000. The financial motivation was greater in those receiving USD 5,000 (68%) than USD 2,500 (39%). Some form of expressed altruism was similarly present in both groups (USD 5,000 90%, and USD 2,500 91%). However, altruism expressed as the sole motivation occurred more in those receiving USD 2,500 (61%) compared to USD 5,000 (32%). Financial reimbursement has escalated for the services of ovum donors in order to maintain the increasing demand. While money has become a dominant factor motivating ovum donors, its seductive nature requires even greater attention to adequate informed consent. Young donors may be unable to adequately weigh the risks of ovarian hyperstimulation and oocyte retrieval against the monetary reward.

Operative hysteroscopy in the office setting.

STUDY OBJECTIVE: To describe the feasibility of operative hysteroscopy in the office setting. DESIGN. Descriptive study (Canadian Task Force classification II-2). SETTING: University-based private practice. PATIENTS: Women undergoing assisted reproduction in whom diagnostic evaluation revealed uterine cavity pathology. INTERVENTION: Patients were offered office hysteroscopy and allowed to choose between paracervical block anesthesia supplemented with mild intravenous sedation or full conscious sedation, administered by an anesthesiologist. A MicroSpan Hysteroscopy system or HysteroSys Flexible Hysteroscope system was used for diagnostic purposes. When pathology was identified, resection was performed with 2-mm operative instruments or a VersaPoint hysteroscopic electrosurgical electrode using bipolar coagulation through an expandable operating channel. MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: Of 69 women with abnormal sonohysterographic and hysterosalpingogram studies, 44 agreed to office hysteroscopy. Thirty-three (48%) underwent VersaPoint resection and/or scissors resection, which was successfully accomplished in 32 (97%). Significant cervical stenosis in one woman precluded resection because of concern of creating a false passage. Concomitant diagnostic laparoscopy and operative hysteroscopy was performed in one patient. Average operating and anesthesia times were 45.2 +/- 20.3 minutes and 67.2 +/- 28.4 minutes, respectively. One uterine perforation occurred (3.3%) during resection of intrauterine adhesions. CONCLUSION: Office hysteroscopy is a time-efficient and cost-effective procedure, made possible by the development of small instruments. Proper patient selection and training of office personnel are mandatory to minimize complications and maximize efficacy.

Chronic pelvic pain: presumptive diagnosis and therapy using GnRH agonists.

Chronic pelvic pain has a prevalence of 15% to 30% of reproductive-age women. It causes a sizable minority of all gynecological visits, and is responsible for much physical and psychological suffering. Although laparoscopic inspection, plus treatment, for pelvic pain has been considered ideal, it is often unnecessary, fruitless, and even hazardous, besides being expensive. Therefore, empirical medical therapy has much to recommend it. Foremost is the fact that endometriosis is the most frequent source of chronic pelvic pain, and responds well to medical treatment. In fact, GnRH analogs (agonists) used for 6 months can reduce AFS endometriosis scores by one-half, with cure rates at 5 years of three-fourths of responders who had minimal disease and one-third of responders with severe disease. Danazol and oral contraceptives plus NSAIDs have been used, too. The latter treatment is best reserved for cases involving dysmenorrhea. The objections to empirical treatment-lack of exact knowledge of the entity being treated and the potential of overlooking cancer-are discussed here in the context of pain treatment, with an emphasis on history taking, diagnostic imaging, and careful observation.

Recruitment and screening policies and procedures used to establish a paid donor oocyte registry.

We have reviewed the demographic characteristics of, and report abnormalities noted in, the de-novo growth and development of a paid oocyte donation programme. The personal profiles of all prospective oocyte donors were reviewed. Acceptance or rejection of candidates was based upon screening the results of medical, genetic and psychological testing. A total of 603 candidates initially responded to our advertisement. From this pool, 313 individuals were considered suitable and contacted by telephone. Following further conversation, 176 women were scheduled an entry interview. On completion of the formal screening process, 17.6% (n = 31) of those actually interviewed were denied entry. Thus, from the initial interested parties, only 23% of women wishing to participate in oocyte donation were considered suitable candidates. Given the high attrition rate, we concluded that the need for rigorous and thorough medical, psychological and genetic testing is mandatory for the establishment of a donor registry. Furthermore, professional counselling of prospective donors with respect to the results of tests and the implications of test results with respect to their future medical and reproductive health, are important parts of providing comprehensive care.