RESUMO
OBJECTIVE: We investigated the medical costs and effects of ofloxacin drops (OFLX), gelatin sponge patches, spontaneous healing, and endoscopic myringoplasty on healing in large tympanic membrane perforations (TMPs). METHODS: In total, 100 patients with large traumatic TMPs involving >50% of the eardrum were randomly assigned to OFLX, gelatin sponge, spontaneous healing, or endoscopic myringoplasty treatment groups. Medical costs, closure times, and closure rates were compared among groups at 6â¯months. RESULTS: The closure rates in the OFLX, gelatin sponge, spontaneous healing, and endoscopic myringoplasty groups were 95.7%, 82.6%, 58.3%, and 91.7%, respectively (Pâ¯=â¯0.05). The mean closure time was 13.73⯱â¯6.14â¯days in the OFLX group, 15.89⯱â¯4.95â¯days in the gelatin sponge group, 48.36⯱â¯10.37â¯days in the spontaneous healing group, and 12â¯days in the endoscopic myringoplasty group (Pâ¯<â¯0.001). The mean medical costs in US dollars were $15.53⯱â¯3.15, $103.64⯱â¯111.58, $11.17⯱â¯1.33, and $715.90 in the OFLX, gelatin sponge, spontaneous healing, and endoscopic myringoplasty groups, respectively (Pâ¯<â¯0.001). CONCLUSION: Although the gelatin sponge and myringoplasty treatments significantly shortened the closure time compared with spontaneous healing, the gelatin sponge patch did not significantly improve the closure rate, and the medical cost of myringoplasty was significantly higher than that of the other treatments. In contrast, OFLX significantly shortened closure time and had a higher closure rate than spontaneous healing, and the medical costs were lower than those of the gelatin sponge and myringoplasty procedures.
Assuntos
Endoscopia/economia , Esponja de Gelatina Absorvível/economia , Custos de Cuidados de Saúde , Miringoplastia/economia , Ofloxacino/economia , Perfuração da Membrana Timpânica/terapia , Adulto , Antibacterianos/economia , Antibacterianos/uso terapêutico , Feminino , Esponja de Gelatina Absorvível/uso terapêutico , Hemostáticos/economia , Hemostáticos/uso terapêutico , Humanos , Masculino , Pessoa de Meia-Idade , Ofloxacino/uso terapêutico , Perfuração da Membrana Timpânica/economia , Cicatrização , Adulto JovemRESUMO
OBJECTIVE: This study investigated the influence of the degree of bleeding from the remnant eardrum on the spontaneous healing of human traumatic tympanic membrane perforations (TMPs). STUDY DESIGN: A case series with chart review. SETTING: A tertiary university hospital. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The clinical records of traumatic TMP patients who met the case selection criteria were retrieved and categorized into two groups based on the documented degree of bleeding from the remnant eardrum: with and without bleeding. The demographic data and spontaneous healing outcomes (i.e., healing rate and duration) of these two TMP types were analyzed using the chi-squared test or t-test. RESULTS: One-hundred and eighty-eight cases met the inclusion criteria and were analyzed. Of these, 58.5% had perforations without bleeding and the remaining 41.5% had perforations with bleeding. The overall closure rate at the end of the 3-month follow-up period was 90.9% for perforations without bleeding and 96.2% for perforations with bleeding; the difference was not statistically significant (P>0.05). However, the average closure time differed significantly between the two groups (P<0.05): 29.4±3.7days for perforations without bleeding and 20.6±9.2days for perforations with bleeding. The closure rate was significantly different between the groups (62 vs. 15.6%, P<0.01) within 2weeks for medium-sized perforations. In total, 11 (39.3%) large-sized perforations achieved complete closure in the group with bleeding, while none of the large-sized perforations closed in the group without bleeding within 2weeks. The closure rate of medium-sized perforations was not significantly different (79.2 vs. 92%, P>0.05) between the groups without and with bleeding within 4weeks, while the closure rate of large-sized perforations was significantly different between the groups without and with bleeding (27.2 vs. 75%, P=0.0). CONCLUSION: This study shows that traumatic TMPs with bleeding significantly shortened the closure time compared to TMPs without bleeding. This finding indicates a significant correlation between the prognosis of traumatic TMPs and the degree of eardrum bleeding: severe bleeding from and a hematoma in the remnant eardrum appear to be good signs.