Effects of online frame-of-reference training on assessment accuracy in the objective structured clinical examination for physical therapy students.

Objectives: This study investigates how online frame-of-reference (FOR) training of raters of the objective structured clinical examination (OSCE) for physical therapy students affects assessment accuracy. Methods: The research was conducted in a 1-month-long randomized controlled trial. Participants: The participants were 36 physical therapists without experience assessing clinical skills using the OSCE. The training group completed the FOR training online, which was conducted once a week in two 90-minute sessions. The control group self-studied the rubric rating chart used in the assessment. As a measure of accuracy, weighted kappa coefficients were used to check the agreement between correct score and those assessment by the participant in the OSCE. Results: The scores of the training group were higher than those of the control group in both post- and follow-up assessments, showing significant differences. No significant difference was found based on the assessment time and group for the high-agreement groups. Furthermore, scores of the low-accuracy training group were higher in the post- and follow-up assessments than those in the pre-assessment, showing significant differences. Conclusions: Online FOR training of the raters of the OSCE for physical therapists improved the assessment accuracy of the raters who had low accuracy in the pre-assessment; this improvement was maintained.

Validity of quantitative assessment of posterior pelvic tilt and contralateral vaulting in hemiplegia using 3D treadmill gait analysis.

BACKGROUND: Assessing abnormal gait patterns could indicate compensatory movements, which could be an index for recovery and a process of motor learning. To quantify the degree of posterior pelvic tilt, contralateral vaulting is necessary. OBJECTIVES: This study aimed to develop and evaluate the validity of quantitative indices for posterior pelvic tilt and contralateral vaulting in hemiplegic patients. METHODS: Forty-six healthy control subjects and 112 hemiplegic patients participated in this study. Of the 112 patients, 50 were selected into each abnormal gait pattern group, with some overlap. Three experienced physical therapists observed their walking and graded the severity of the two abnormalities in five levels. An index to quantify each of the two abnormal gait patterns was calculated from the three-dimensional treadmill gait analysis. The index values of patients were compared with those of healthy subjects and with the results of observational gait assessment done by three physical therapists with expertise in gait analysis. RESULTS: The index values were significantly higher in hemiplegic patients than in healthy subjects (28.0% and 44.7% for the posterior pelvic tilt in healthy subjects and patients, respectively and 0.9 and 4.7 for the contralateral vaulting, respectively). A strong correlation was observed between the index value and the median observational rating for two abnormal gait patterns (r = -0.68 and -0.72). CONCLUSIONS: The proposed indices for posterior pelvic tilt and contralateral vaulting are useful for clinical gait analysis, and thus encouraging a more detailed analysis of hemiplegic gait using a motion analysis system.

Quantitative assessment of knee extensor thrust, flexed-knee gait, insufficient knee flexion during the swing phase, and medial whip in hemiplegia using three-dimensional treadmill gait analysis.

BACKGROUND: Most people with hemiplegia experience gait changes after a stroke. Abnormal gait patterns in stroke patients vary across subjects and this make it difficult to assess the cause of gait abnormalities. Therefore, it is necessary to quantitatively evaluate abnormal gait patterns through gait analysis for stroke patients. OBJECTIVE: To develop and evaluate the validity of quantitative assessments of the degree of knee extensor thrust, flexed-knee gait, insufficient knee flexion during the swing phase, and medial whip. METHODS: Forty-six healthy control subjects and 112 people with hemiplegia participated. From the 112 patients, 50 patients were selected into each abnormal gait pattern (knee extensor thrust, flexed-knee gait, insufficient knee flexion during the swing phase, and medial whip) with some overlap. Participants were instructed to walk on a treadmill and were recorded using a three-dimensional motion analysis system. An index to quantify each of the four abnormal gait patterns exhibited by the patients was calculated from the three-dimensional coordinate data. The indices were developed based on the definition of the abnormal gait patterns. The index values for the patients were compared with those of healthy subjects as well as with the results of observational gait assessment by three physical therapists with expertise in gait analysis. RESULTS: Strong correlation was observed between the index value and the median observational rating for all four abnormal gait patterns (-0.64 to -0.86). Most of the patients with an abnormal gait pattern had a higher index value than the healthy subjects. CONCLUSIONS: The use of these indices in gait analysis of people with hemiplegia can help to diagnose severity of gait disorder, determine the appropriate treatment, and evaluate the effectiveness of the treatment.

Quantitative assessment of retropulsion of the hip, excessive hip external rotation, and excessive lateral shift of the trunk over the unaffected side in hemiplegia using three-dimensional treadmill gait analysis.

BACKGROUND: Gait assessment is important to determine the most effective strategy to regain gait function during stroke rehabilitation. To understand the mechanisms that cause abnormal gait patterns, it is useful to objectively identify and quantify the abnormal gait patterns. Objective assessment also helps evaluate the efficacy of treatments and can be used to provide suggestions for treatment. OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the validity of quantitative indices for retropulsion of the hip, excessive hip external rotation, and excessive lateral shift of the trunk over the unaffected side in hemiplegic patients. METHODS: Forty-six healthy control subjects and 112 hemiplegic patients participated. From the 112 patients, 50 patients were selected into each abnormal gait pattern with some overlap. Participants were instructed to walk on a treadmill and were recorded using a three-dimensional motion analysis system. An index to quantify each of the three abnormal gait patterns was calculated from the three-dimensional coordinate data. The index values of patients were compared with those of healthy subjects and with the results of observational gait assessment by three physical therapists with expertise in gait analysis. RESULTS: Strong correlation was observed between the index value and the median observational rating for all three abnormal gait patterns (-0.56 to -0.74). Most of the patients with an abnormal gait pattern had a higher index value than the healthy subjects. CONCLUSIONS: The proposed indices are useful for clinical gait analysis. Our results encourage a more detailed analysis of hemiplegic gait using a motion analysis system.