Factors predicting prolonged length of stay after carotid endarterectomy.

BACKGROUND: Over the last several years, implementation of critical pathways in patients undergoing carotid endarterectomy has decreased postoperative length of stay significantly. Discharge the day after surgery has become commonplace in many centers, including our own. Unfortunately, managed care may interpret this refinement as a standard of care and limit reimbursement or even disallow admissions extending beyond 1 day. We therefore examined our carotid registry to identify risk factors associated with postoperative length of stay exceeding 1 day. METHODS: We retrospectively reviewed all patients undergoing carotid endarterectomy at our academic center from May 1996 through April 1999. Combined procedures and patients undergoing subsequent noncarotid-related procedures on those admissions were excluded. The charts were inspected for atherosclerosis risk factors, including sex and age, specific attending surgeon, side of the surgery, use of intravenous vasoactive drugs, actual preoperative blood pressure, and presence of neurologic symptoms or postoperative complications. Multiple regression analysis was performed on all collected variables. Statistical significance was inferred for P less than.05. RESULTS: A total of 188 patients met the study criteria and had complete, retrievable medical records. A mean postoperative length of stay of 1.65 +/- 0.08 days and a mean total length of stay of 2.17 +/- 0.14 days were observed. Fifty-seven percent of patients went home the day after surgery. There was a 1.6% stroke-mortality rate. Significant predictors of a prolonged stay, listed in order of decreasing importance on the basis of their calculated contribution to prolonging the postoperative length of stay, are as follows (P value; beta coefficient): postoperative complications (<.0001; 1.03), age > 79 years (.008; 0.547), diabetes mellitus (.011; 0.407), female sex (.007; 0.398), and intravenous vasodilator requirement (. 035; 0.382). Other atherosclerosis risk factors, prior neurologic symptoms, the postoperative use of vasopressors, and reoperative surgery did not contribute to extended length of stay. CONCLUSIONS: Discharge on the first postoperative day is feasible in many, but not all, patients undergoing carotid endarterectomy. Our data help define subsets of patients at risk for prolonged postoperative stay. Targeting these subsets for preoperative medical and social interventions may allow safe early discharge more frequently.

The Balanced Budget Act: potential implications for the practice of vascular surgery.

PURPOSE: Previous study results have shown a favorable impact on stroke rate with an increasing hospital volume of carotid endarterectomies (CEAs). This is not only the most frequently performed peripheral vascular procedure in the United States but also perhaps the most widely dispersed procedure relative to hospital type. Medical centers have adopted various strategies to lower the cost of hospitalization by reducing the length of stay (LOS), the major component of hospital cost. By 2002, the Balanced Budget Act is projected to reduce Medicare provider payments to academic medical centers (AMCs) by 15.5%, a reduction that is twice that for minor or nonteaching hospitals. We assessed the relationships between hospital costs, CEA volume, and stroke-mortality rates in AMCs and non-AMCs in Massachusetts. METHODS: With patient level data from the Massachusetts Division of Health Care Finance and Policy and with hospital cost and charge reports from the Health Care Financing Administration, HealthShare Technology provided data for all the patients discharged from a Massachusetts hospital who underwent CEA (n = 10,211) during the fiscal years 1995, 1996, and 1997, including cost, LOS, and disposition. The outcomes were further defined with in-hospital stroke and mortality rates. Five high volume AMCs (HVAMCs) were compared with all other nonacademic hospitals, which were further subdivided by annual volume into high volume non-AMCs (> or =50 cases), medium volume non-AMCs (24-49 cases), and low volume non-AMCs (12-23 cases). Statistical analysis was performed with analysis of variance to compare the means of all the cost and LOS data, and chi(2) test was used for comparison of incidence (significance assumed for P < or =. 05). RESULTS: Hospital costs were comparable among the four hospital types during individual years and averaged $6200, but HVAMCs were significantly more expensive overall, with a mean cost of $7882. The only centers to decrease their costs during the years evaluated were the HVAMCs, from $8706 to $6784. Length of stay did not differ among the groups in any year or overall, with a mean of 3.8 days, but did decrease between years at HVAMCs from 3.9 to 2.5 days. The combined stroke-mortality rates were significantly less at the HVAMCs (0.9%) than at either the high volume non-AMCs (1.9%) or the medium volume non-AMCs (2.5%). There was no significance in the analysis results of all the data within the low volume non-AMCs. CONCLUSION: Patients in HVAMCs have the best outcomes after CEA. Despite the achievement of significant efficiencies, AMCs have a small cushion to reduce further either LOS or resources to maintain a competitive cost position and to compensate for the fixed expenses of academic medicine. The Balanced Budget Act raises an equity concern for AMCs because it differentially affects the centers with the best outcomes. The financial implication of this may be a direct incentive for procedures to be done in centers with less optimal outcomes.

Reduction of hospital resources utilization in vascular surgery: a four-year experience.

PURPOSE: Managed care whether through risk or through capitated contracts results in reduction in resources, reduced length of hospital stay, and reduced utilization of hospital resources (collectively referred to as resource reductions). These resource reductions will become even more noticeable as a greater proportion of Medicare patients who need vascular operations select a managed-care senior product. We examined the results of a 4-year experience with resource management in an academic vascular surgery practice during which best practice plans were developed and implemented. METHODS: We analyzed hospital cost data, which included both total hospital and intensive care unit length of stay, average units per operation for laboratory, pharmacy, and radiology services and operating room and direct hospital costs for 257 carotid endarterectomies performed over fiscal years (FY) 1994, 1995, 1996, and 1997 (6 month data) and 175 infrainguinal bypass procedures performed during the same period. RESULTS: For carotid endarterectomy, length of stay decreased 66% over the 4-year period to an average of 2.07 days in FY97. Both radiology and pharmacy utilization were reduced after the first year of institution of best practice plans (56% and 32% respectively) with 4-year total reductions of 86% and 55% by FY97. The most notable changes included elimination of routine postoperative laboratory testing, use of aspirin rather than low-molecular-weight dextran, emphasis on oral rather than intravenous vasoactive drugs, and routine use of duplex scanning alone rather than angiography for diagnosis after FY94-95. The length of operating room time for carotid endarterectomy remained relatively constant from FY94 to FY97. As a result of these multiple factors, our study showed a 30% decrease in total average direct hospital costs for carotid endarterectomy from $9974 to $7002 in this 4-year period. Infrainguinal bypass graft procedures showed a progressive decrease in total cost of 28% for patients without complications to $15,186 but remained unchanged for those with complications. Laboratory use, pharmacy use, and radiology use were not significantly different. CONCLUSIONS: Case management for patients undergoing carotid endarterectomy and infrainguinal bypass grafting involving an integrated team of vascular surgeons, surgical house staff, a dedicated vascular nurse, and a social work case manager resulted in dramatic reductions both in length of stay and hospital resource utilization. As these costs decreased, operating room expenses assumed increasing importance. Operating room costs account for 60% of the direct costs of carotid endarterectomy and a comparable percentage for uncomplicated infrainguinal bypass grafting. Further substantial reductions in direct hospital costs will depend primarily on reductions in operating room costs, particularly those related to length of time in the operating room.

Subfascial endoscopic perforator ligation: an analysis of early clinical outcomes and cost.

PURPOSE: Early results of subfascial endoscopic perforator surgery (SEPS) were examined. Data on ulcer healing, complications, and costs are presented. METHODS: Data were prospectively collected for all patients who underwent SEPS at our institution. A concurrent control group was not available because primary open perforator ligation is no longer performed at our hospital. Preoperative assessment included duplex scanning (valve closure times and perforator mapping), plethysmography, and phlebography. Completeness of therapy was assessed with postoperative duplex mapping of perforating veins. Clinical status was monitored after surgery, and actual costs, including equipment, personnel, and facilities management, are reported. RESULTS: Eighteen procedures were performed in 15 patients (mean age, 52 years; range, 42 to 65 years). Two patients underwent bilateral SEPS, and one patient underwent a second procedure on the same leg. Active ulceration (class 6) was present in 14 of 18 limbs (78%), recently healed ulcers (class 5) in two of 18 (11%), and lipodermatosclerosis with edema (class 4) in two. Deep venous insufficiency was present in 14 of 18 (78%). The number of perforating veins ligated per leg ranged from 0 to 12 (mean, 4.3). Follow-up ranged from 3 to 64 weeks (mean, 22 weeks). Complete ulcer healing occurred in eight of 14 limbs (57%) at a mean of 14 weeks. Reduction in ulcer size was noted in four of 14 (29%), and two limbs were not improved. There were no new ulcers. Residual perforating veins were noted in four of 18 limbs. None of the limbs with residual perforating veins had complete healing of ulceration. Operating room costs were higher than those associated with limited-incision open perforator ligation ($2570 vs $1883). CONCLUSION: These preliminary data suggest that when used as part of a treatment plan to correct deep and superficial venous insufficiency SEPS results in a high rate of wound healing, with no recurrent ulceration in this series. Increased operating room costs associated with longer operations and greater disposable expenses will likely be overcome by shortened length of stay and diminished wound complications. These findings emphasize the importance of ligating all incompetent perforating veins, as ulcer healing was never achieved when residual perforating veins were found at follow-up.

Duplex assessment of venous reflux and chronic venous insufficiency: the significance of deep venous reflux.

PURPOSE: This study was undertaken to examine the role of superficial and deep venous reflux, as defined by duplex-derived valve closure times (VCTs), in the pathogenesis of chronic venous insufficiency. METHODS: Between January 1992 and November 1995, 320 patients and 500 legs were evaluated with clinical examinations and duplex scans for potential venous reflux. VCTs were obtained with the cuff deflation technique with the patient in the upright position. Imaging was performed at the saphenofemoral junction, the middle segment of the greater saphenous vein, the lesser saphenous vein, the superficial femoral vein, the profunda femoris vein, and the popliteal vein. Not all patients had all segments examined because tests early in the series did not examine the profunda femoris or lesser saphenous vein and because some patients had previous ligation and stripping or venous thrombosis. VCTs were examined for individual segment reflux, grouped into superficial and deep systems, and then correlated with the clinical stage as defined by the SVS/ISCVS original reporting standards in venous disease. Segment reflux was considered present if the VCT was greater than 0.5 seconds, and system reflux was considered present if the sum of the segments was greater than 1.5 seconds. Between-group differences were analyzed with analysis of variance and post hoc tests where appropriate. RESULTS: Sixty-nine limbs studied were in class 0, 149 limbs were in class 1, 168 limbs were in class 2, and 114 limbs were in class 3. VCTs in the superficial veins were significantly lower in class 0 than in the other clinical classes. There was no difference in superficial reflux in the symptomatic limbs (classes 1 to 3). Reflux VCTs in the superficial femoral and popliteal veins increased as the clinical symptoms progressed, with a significant increase in class 3 ulcerated limbs when compared with nonuclerated limbs. The incidence of deep venous reflux was 60% in class 3 limbs, compared with 29% in class 2 limbs, whereas the incidence of superficial venous reflux did not differ among the symptomatic limbs. Isolated superficial femoral and popliteal vein reflux was uncommon, even in class 3 limbs, but combined superficial femoral and popliteal vein reflux was found in 53% of class 3 limbs, compared with 18.5% of class 2 limbs. CONCLUSIONS: Reflux in the deep venous system plays a significant role in the progression of chronic venous insufficiency. Deep system reflux increases as clinical changes become more severe, with significant axial reflux contributing to ulcer formation.

Who needs surveillance of the contralateral carotid artery?

BACKGROUND: Although the value of carotid endarterectomy has been proven, postoperative surveillance remains controversial. The purpose of this study was to determine the natural history of disease progression in the contralateral carotid artery by duplex surveillance, and to assess the cost of stroke prevention on this contralateral side. METHODS: Vascular laboratory records were reviewed to identify carotid endarterectomy patients who had two or more duplex studies between 1984 and 1995. Critical stenosis was defined as > or = 75% area reduction. RESULTS: In all, 324 patients were followed up with duplex scans for 1 month to 11 years (mean 30.3 months). The only factors that correlated with progression to critical stenosis were age and initial stenosis. Overall, 19.5% of patients progressed to critical stenosis within 5 years while the high-risk groups with age > 65 years or initial stenosis > or = 50% progressed to critical disease in 27% and 39%, respectively (P < or = 0.05). The cost per stroke prevented ranged from $143,500 to $418,200 when stratified by initial stenosis. CONCLUSION: Patients who have undergone a carotid endarterectomy demonstrate a propensity for progression of carotid stenosis in the unoperated (contralateral) artery. The cost/benefit ratio may be improved by varying the intensity of duplex surveillance of the contralateral carotid based on the patient's age and initial degree of stenosis.

An assessment of the positive predictive value and cost-effectiveness of dipyridamole myocardial scintigraphy in patients undergoing vascular surgery.

PURPOSE: The approach to cardiac risk stratification of patients undergoing vascular surgery continues to be controversial. The success of algorithms that use clinical risk factors to determine cardiac risk have been inconsistent. Dipyridamole myocardial scintigraphy (DMS) has been accepted as a sensitive, noninvasive approach to risk stratification with excellent negative predictive value. Low positive predictive value (PPV) of abnormal DMS scans is a shortcoming that contributes to extensive preoperative cardiac evaluation and intervention with associated morbidity, mortality, and cost in most patients who undergo uncomplicated vascular procedures, regardless of DMS results. METHODS: Over 6 years, 237 patients underwent DMS before surgical management of infrarenal aortic aneurysm, aortoiliac, or infrainguinal occlusive disease. The value of multiple clinical factors and DMS were assessed retrospectively for the prediction of perioperative myocardial infarction (MI), heart-related death, or preoperative selection for myocardial revascularization. Only congestive heart failure and two or more reversible defects on DMS were statistically significant on logistic regression analysis. RESULTS: The PPV of DMS was 19% for all patients with reversible defects, 12% for patients with one reversible defect, and 36.7% for patients with two or more reversible defects. The rates of cardiac death and MI were 1.3% and 5.9%, respectively. Perioperative echocardiography revealed unchanged postinfarction ejection fraction in most patients who experienced MI. Cost-effectiveness of DMS screening was evaluated. CONCLUSIONS: The costs per MI and cardiac death averted suggest a decline in cost-effectiveness of screening with DMS over time, assuming improving cardioprotective strategies of patient care. Clinical risk factors were minimally useful in the prediction of perioperative MI, heart-related death, or need for myocardial revascularization. The PPV of DMS is low, and the majority of MIs may be clinically insignificant. The cost-effectiveness of cardiac screening with DMS may not be justifiable given current trends of health care reform.

The economic implications of high-risk abdominal aortic aneurysms.

Financial data of 102 patients undergoing elective and emergent abdominal aortic aneurysm repair over a 3-year period were evaluated in terms of postoperative length of stay, net revenue, total standard cost, and net margin. Cost reimbursement was based on diagnosis related group payments. Aneurysm repairs were classified as emergent, high-risk elective, or low-risk elective. A net loss of $409,459 was noted for the entire series. Emergent repairs, although only 12% of the population, accounted for 73% of total losses, with a mean loss of $24,655/patient. The mean net loss in the high-risk elective group was $3590/patient, and a net gain of $1132/patient was noted in the low-risk elective group. Length of stay outliers, defined as length of stay greater than 28 days, contributed to the bulk of the losses in the elective series and were predominant in the high-risk group. No preoperative comorbidity, other than high-risk classification, predicted outlier status. Length of stay correlated with total standard costs in all categories of aneurysm repair. Third party payment for length of stay outliers was inadequate; the diagnosis related group system warrants revision so that outlier reimbursement will be based on a tiered system derived from length of stay.

The costs of surgery for limb-threatening ischemia.

The clinical courses of 106 patients with limb-threatening ischemia were traced for as long as 5 years to determine the cost of their care. Seventy-eight patients initially treated with vascular reconstruction accrued an average of $40,769 +/- $3726 in costs over a mean follow-up period of 805 +/- 57 days, during which they had an average of 2.4 +/- 0.2 hospitalizations or 67 +/- 6 inpatient days. Twenty-eight high-risk patients treated with primary amputation accrued $40,563 +/- $4729 in costs over a mean follow-up period of 663 +/- 97 days, during which they had an average of 2.2 +/- 0.3 hospitalizations or 85 +/- 10 inpatient days. Successful revascularization resulted in lower costs ($28,374) than did primary amputation ($40,563) or failed reconstruction ($56,809). Patients with ischemic tissue loss accrued costs more rapidly than did patients with rest pain only. The high cost of providing care for these patients and the advent of diagnosis related group reimbursement mandate that proposed treatment protocols be evaluated not only for their effectiveness but also for their cost-effectiveness.

The economic impact of acute variceal bleeding: cost-effectiveness implications for medical and surgical therapy.

The hospital costs and its respective components for 32 patients with acute variceal bleeding were determined. The average total cost for treating the 32 patients was $35,000. The cost for those patients who underwent elective surgery ($53,000) was approximately twofold that of the elective medical group. Nutritional and metabolic rehabilitation that prolonged hospitalization, reutilization of the intensive care unit, and perioperative blood requirements were the significant factors that increased the cost of treating the surgically treated patients. Derivation of the cost/benefit ratio, however, showed that the decreased rehospitalization rate of the surgically treated group and the apparent better "quality of life" almost offset the increased initial hospital costs for this group.

Diagnosis of deep venous thrombosis in the outpatient by venography.

One hundred and two patients, presenting at the outpatient departments of two Boston teaching hospitals, underwent clinical examination and venography. History, physical examination and presence of risk factors were unreliable in the diagnosis of deep venous thrombosis. Seventy-two per cent of the patients with deep venous thrombosis had a proximal extension of the thrombus to the femoral vein or higher. The outpatient with deep venous thrombosis appears to differ from the more frequently studied inpatient in the time of diagnosis and its anatomic extent. The high incidence of false-positive clinical examination results has important cost-benefit implications.

Assessment of abdominal aortic aneurysm size.

Because of the importance of size in the decision for elective operation in patients with abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA) and the need to identify accurately even small aneurysms, a prospective study was carried out to compare currently available diagnostic methods. A series of 78 patients with AAA underwent evaluation by physical examination, lateral lumbar spine X-ray, aortic ultrasound, and aortography. Measurements were compared to aneurysm size at operation. Physical examination was most variable, and tended to overestimate size by approximately 20%. Lateral spine X-ray was useful in three of every four patients and in these cases it was reliable and reasonably accurate. Ultrasonography was most widely applicable and very reliable for diagnosis. Its tendency to underestimate aneurysm size in our experience may be improved by use of gray-scale units, which better define aneurysm wall thickness. The anatomic information provided by aortography was of great value in the surgical management of patients with AAA, but aortography was of limited value in accurate measurement and should not be employed for this purpose.