Neurotrauma, COVID and the rationing of intensive care: an ethical approach.

The advent of the COVID-19 pandemic with its extreme pressure on resources and intensive care beds has prompted many healthcare providers to consider more fully the potentially futile nature of some treatments and how resources might be better managed. This is especially relevant in the context of neurosurgery which is highly resource dependent in terms of technology, funding, and manpower and it may be difficult to balance fair, equitable and sustainable resource allocation, especially in circumstances where those healthcare resources become limited or completely exhausted. Indeed, it may be necessary to consider limiting the availability of certain neurosurgical services or perhaps reconsider the utility or otherwise of performing procedures that commit very restricted resources, such as intensive care beds, to patients who are arguably receiving limited long-term benefit. In these circumstances, the decision-making paradigm is challenging and there are several ethically disparate viewpoints that need to be reconciled. These include but are not limited to, Futility, Utilitarianism and the Rule of rescue.

An assessment of the utility and functionality of wearable head impact sensors in Australian Football.

OBJECTIVES: To assess the utility and functionality of the X-Patch® as a measurement tool to study head impact exposure in Australian Football. Accuracy, precision, reliability and validity were examined. DESIGNS: Laboratory tests and prospective observational study. METHODS: Laboratory tests on X-Patch® were undertaken using an instrumented Hybrid III head and neck and linear impactor. Differences between X-Patch® and reference data were analysed. Australian Football players wore the X-Patch® devices and games were video-recorded. Video recordings were analysed qualitatively for head impact events and these were correlated with X-Patch® head acceleration events. Wearability of the X-Patch® was assessed using the Comfort Rating Scale for Wearable Computers. RESULTS: Laboratory head impacts, performed at multiple impact sites and velocities, identified significant correlations between headform-measured and device-measured kinematic parameters (p<0.05 for all). On average, the X-Patch®-recorded peak linear acceleration (PLA) was 17% greater than the reference PLA, 28% less for peak rotational acceleration (PRA) and 101% greater for the Head Injury Criterion (HIC). For video analysis, 118 head acceleration events (HAE) were included with PLA ≥30g across 53 players. Video recordings of X-Patch®-measured HAEs (PLA ≥30g) determined that 31.4% were direct head impacts, 9.3% were indirect impacts, 44.1% were unknown or unclear and 15.3% were neither direct nor indirect head impacts. The X-Patch® system was deemed wearable by 95-100% of respondents. CONCLUSIONS: This study reinforces evidence that use of the current X-Patch® devices should be limited to research only and in conjunction with video analysis.

Accelerometers for the Assessment of Concussion in Male Athletes: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis.

BACKGROUND: Concussion is common in the sporting arena and is often challenging to diagnose. The development of wearable head impact measurement systems has enabled measurement of head kinematics in contact sports. OBJECTIVES: The objective of this systematic review was to determine the characteristics of head kinematics measured by an accelerometer system among male athletes diagnosed with concussion. METHODS: A systematic search was conducted in July 2015. Inclusion criteria were English-language studies published after 1990 with a study population of male athletes, in any sport, where objectively measured biomechanical forces were reported in the setting of a concussive event. The random effects meta-analysis model was used to combine estimates of biomechanical force measurements in concussed athletes. RESULTS: Thirteen studies met the inclusion criteria, the majority of which were conducted with high school and college football teams in the US. Included studies measured a combination of linear and rotational acceleration. The meta-analysed mean peak linear head acceleration associated with a concussive episode was 98.68 g (95 % CI 82.36-115.00) and mean peak rotational head acceleration was 5776.60 rads/s2 (95 % CI 4583.53-6969.67). The estimates of the biomechanical forces were consistent across studies, with I 2 values of 0 % for both meta-analyses. CONCLUSIONS: Head impact monitoring through accelerometery has been shown to be useful with regard to characterising the kinematic load to the head associated with concussion. Future research with improved clinical outcome measures and head kinematic data may improve accuracy when evaluating concussion, and may assist with both interpretation of biomechanical data and the development and utilisation of implementation strategies for the technology.

Implementing evidence-based recommended practices for the management of patients with mild traumatic brain injuries in Australian emergency care departments: study protocol for a cluster randomised controlled trial.

BACKGROUND: Mild head injuries commonly present to emergency departments. The challenges facing clinicians in emergency departments include identifying which patients have traumatic brain injury, and which patients can safely be sent home. Traumatic brain injuries may exist with subtle symptoms or signs, but can still lead to adverse outcomes. Despite the existence of several high quality clinical practice guidelines, internationally and in Australia, research shows inconsistent implementation of these recommendations. The aim of this trial is to test the effectiveness of a targeted, theory- and evidence-informed implementation intervention to increase the uptake of three key clinical recommendations regarding the emergency department management of adult patients (18 years of age or older) who present following mild head injuries (concussion), compared with passive dissemination of these recommendations. The primary objective is to establish whether the intervention is effective in increasing the percentage of patients for which appropriate post-traumatic amnesia screening is performed. METHODS/DESIGN: The design of this study is a cluster randomised trial. We aim to include 34 Australian 24-hour emergency departments, which will be randomised to an intervention or control group. Control group departments will receive a copy of the most recent Australian evidence-based clinical practice guideline on the acute management of patients with mild head injuries. The intervention group will receive an implementation intervention based on an analysis of influencing factors, which include local stakeholder meetings, identification of nursing and medical opinion leaders in each site, a train-the-trainer day and standardised education and interactive workshops delivered by the opinion leaders during a 3 month period of time. Clinical practice outcomes will be collected retrospectively from medical records by independent chart auditors over the 2 month period following intervention delivery (patient level outcomes). In consenting hospitals, eligible patients will be recruited for a follow-up telephone interview conducted by trained researchers. A cost-effectiveness analysis and process evaluation using mixed-methods will be conducted. Sample size calculations are based on including 30 patients on average per department. Outcome assessors will be blinded to group allocation. TRIAL REGISTRATION: Australian New Zealand Clinical Trials Registry ACTRN12612001286831 (date registered 12 December 2012).

Health resource utilisation costs in acute patients with persistent midline cervical tenderness following road trauma.

INTRODUCTION: The costs associated with patients discharged with isolated clinician-elicited persistent midline tenderness and negative computed tomography (CT) findings have not been reported. Our aim was to determine the association of acute and post-acute patient and injury characteristics with health resource costs in such patients following road trauma. METHODS: In a prospective cohort study, road trauma patients presenting with isolated persistent midline cervical tenderness and negative CT, who underwent additional acute imaging with MRI, were recruited. Patients were reviewed in the outpatient spine clinic following discharge, and were followed up at 6 and 12 months post-trauma. Multivariate linear regression was used to assess the association of injury mechanism, clinical assessment, socioeconomic factors and outcome findings with health resource costs generated in the acute hospital and post-acute periods. RESULTS: There were 64 patients recruited, of whom 24 (38%) had cervical spine injury detected on MRI. Of these, 2 patients were managed operatively, 6 were treated in cervical collars and 16 had the cervical spine cleared and were discharged. At 12 months, there were 25 patients (44%) with residual neck pain, and 22 (39%) with neck-related disability. The mean total cost was AUD $10,153 (SD=10,791) and the median was $4015 (IQR: 3044-6709). Transient neurologic deficit, which fully resolved early in the emergency department, was independently associated with higher marginal mean acute costs (represented in the analysis by the ß coefficient) by $3521 (95% CI: 50-6880). Low education standard (ß coefficient: $5988, 95% CI: 822-13,317), neck pain at 6 months (ß coefficient: $4017, 95% CI: 426-9254) and history of transient neurologic deficit (ß coefficient: $8471, 95% CI: 1766-18,334) were associated with increased post-acute costs. CONCLUSION: In a homogeneous group of road trauma patients with non fracture-related persistent midline cervical tenderness, health resource costs varied considerably. As long term morbidity is common in this population, a history of resolved neurologic deficit may require greater intervention to mitigate costs. Additionally, adequate communication between acute and community care providers is essential in order to expedite the recovery process through early return to normal daily activities.

Assessment of cerebral autoregulation from respiratory oscillations in ventilated patients after traumatic brain injury.

Phase shift (PS) between oscillations in arterial blood pressure (ABP) and transcranial Doppler (TCD) cerebral blood flow velocity (CBFV) is thought to describe cerebral autoregulation. Ventilated patients show high amplitude and regular respiratory oscillations in ABP and CBFV, allowing reliable PS measurement. We analysed recordings of ABP, CBFV and intracranial pressure (ICP) from 187 TBI patients treated at Addenbrooke's Hospital, Cambridge, UK, from 1993 to 1998. Monitored data were recorded and PS, TCD autoregulation (Mx) and pressure reactivity (PRx) were calculated using ICM+. PS was computed by peak detection in the ABP/CBFV cross-spectrum. Recordings with low coherence (<0.5), unstable respiratory rate (RR), or PS wraparound were excluded. Median RR was 14 bpm (range 10-20 bpm). Group median PS was 13° (range -37-56°). Average PS (PSa) correlated with RR (Spearman's R = -0.302, p < 0.01, and cerebral perfusion pressure (R = -0.373, p < 0.01). Correlations of PS with Mx and PRx were weak but significant (p < 0.01). Kruskal-Wallis test for outcome vs. PS was non-significant (PSa: p = 0.14, minimum PS (PSm): p = 0.27). Mann-Whitney test for mortality vs. PS was significant (p < 0.05) for PSm only. Respiratory PS responds to changes in CPP and RR and correlates weakly with CA. Respiratory PS may have some prognostic value for patients with TBI.

The Ethics of the Treatment of Spinal Cord Injury: Stem Cell Transplants, Motor Neuroprosthetics, and Social Equity.

The intense desire for a "cure" in individuals with spinal cord injury (SCI) has resulted in the transplantation of stem cells and embryonic and other cell types into the injured spinal cord to enable limb function. We review the ethical issues concerning the procurement and use of embryonic stem cells. A brief survey of the current state of human SCI transplantation is presented. We explore the interface between basic science and the clinical management of SCI and discuss the ethical issues of therapy. At what point is it ethical to conduct human experiments when the experimental data is still at an early stage of development? Is it ethical to perform these operations on a vulnerable group of patients without adequate scientific controls and analysis of the results? Motor neuroprosthetics is developing rapidly and will enable limb movement controlled by the paralyzed patient and other device control such as wheelchairs and communication boards. How can there be a more equitable distribution of such expensive technology and other treatments of SCI? Both clinicians and scientists should be mindful of these complex ethical issues when undertaking pioneering therapies for patients with SCI.

Cervical spine assessment in the unconscious trauma patient: a major trauma service's experience with passive flexion-extension radiography.

BACKGROUND: There is no consensus on the most appropriate method of cervical spine assessment in unconscious trauma patients. Passive flexion-extension imaging is one option for further investigating unconscious patients whose plain cervical radiographs are normal. This study examines the usefulness of this passive imaging in investigating for occult cervical injury. METHODS: All unconscious patients admitted to The Alfred Trauma Intensive Care Unit over 1 year (January 1-December 31, 1998), who could not be clinically assessed within 48 hours in regard to their cervical spine, were identified. Results of passive flexion-extension radiography were compared with final injury status and clinical outcome as determined by retrospective review of the imaging reports, radiographic films, and case notes. RESULTS: One hundred twenty-three patients with normal three-view plain radiographs proceeded to passive functional investigation. These were false-negative in four of the seven patients with cervical spine injuries at presentation. No patients suffered any adverse neurologic events from their delayed diagnoses or from the flexion-extension procedure. CONCLUSION: Passive flexion-extension imaging has inadequate sensitivity for detecting occult cervical spine injuries. Although no patients suffered adverse neurologic complications, the potential for devastating consequences from missed cervical injury has resulted in the removal of passive flexion-extension imaging from the screening protocol.