RESUMO
BACKGROUND: The triple lumen Inoue balloon is routinely used for balloon mitral valvotomy (BMV) in India. Its major limitation is the high cost. The double lumen Accura balloon is less expensive, making it an attractive alternative in the developing countries. The study was meant to assess the safety, efficacy and midterm results of Accura balloon with respect to the Inoue balloon. PATIENTS AND METHODS: 816 consecutive patients, who underwent elective BMV in this Institute from 1997 to 2003, were included in the study. The data of 487 patients who underwent BMV with Accura balloon was compared with 329 patients who underwent BMV with Inoue balloon. The clinical, echocardiographic, and hemodynamic data of these patients were analyzed retrospectively to assess the safety and efficacy of Accura balloon with respect to the Inoue balloon. RESULTS: Immediate procedural success (93.9% in Inoue group and 91.6% in Accura group p. NS) and complications (6.6% in Inoue group and 5.6% in Accura group p. NS) were comparable between the study groups. The two study population had similar restenosis rate and events at 1 year after BMV. Both balloons could be reused multiple times without compromising on the safety and effectiveness. Accura balloons were less costly than Inoue balloon. The reusability with Accura was slightly more and found to be more cost-effective. CONCLUSIONS: Both Accura and Inoue balloon mitral valvotomy balloons are effective in providing relief from hemodynamically significant mitral stenosis in terms of gain in valve area and reduction in trans mitral gradient. Both groups have similar procedural success and complication rates, restenosis, and follow-up events at 1 year. Both balloons could be reused multiple times and Accura balloon is found to be more cost effective.
Assuntos
Valvuloplastia com Balão/instrumentação , Cateteres Cardíacos , Estenose da Valva Mitral/terapia , Valva Mitral , Adulto , Valvuloplastia com Balão/efeitos adversos , Valvuloplastia com Balão/economia , Cateteres Cardíacos/economia , Distribuição de Qui-Quadrado , Redução de Custos , Ecocardiografia Doppler , Desenho de Equipamento , Reutilização de Equipamento , Feminino , Hemodinâmica , Custos Hospitalares , Humanos , Índia , Masculino , Valva Mitral/diagnóstico por imagem , Valva Mitral/fisiopatologia , Estenose da Valva Mitral/diagnóstico por imagem , Estenose da Valva Mitral/economia , Estenose da Valva Mitral/fisiopatologia , Recidiva , Estudos Retrospectivos , Fatores de Tempo , Resultado do Tratamento , Adulto JovemRESUMO
AIMS: TTK Chitra heart valve prosthesis (CHVP), a tilting disc mechanical heart valve of low cost and proven efficacy, has been in use for the last 15 years. Although various studies substantiating its long-term safety and efficacy are available, no study had assessed its echocardiographic characteristics. The purpose of this study was to determine the normal Doppler parameters of CHVP in the mitral position and to assess whether derivation of mitral valve area (MVA) using the continuity equation (CE) and more commonly used pressure half-time (PHT) method is comparable in the functional assessment of this tilting disc mitral prosthesis. METHODS AND RESULTS: Doppler echocardiography was performed in 40 consecutive patients with CHVP in the mitral position. All patients were clinically stable, without evidence of prosthetic valve dysfunction such as significant obstruction or regurgitation, endocarditis, left ventricular dysfunction (ejection fraction <40%), or significant aortic regurgitation. Valve sizes studied included 25, 27, and 29 mm. Mitral valve area was derived both by the PHT method and by the CE, using the stroke volume measured in the ventricular outflow tract divided by the time-velocity integral of CHVP jet. The peak Doppler gradient ranged from 5 to 21 (mean 11.0) mmHg, and the mean gradient ranged from 1.7 to 9.2 (mean 4.1) mmHg. Mean gradient negatively correlated with an increase in the actual orifice area (AOA) derived from the valve orifice diameter given by the manufacturer (r = -0.45, P = 0.004). Mitral valve area calculated by both PHT and CE increased significantly with an increase in the AOA (r = 0.42, P = 0.007 and r = 0.32, P = 0.046, respectively). Mitral valve area by the CE averaged 1.55 +/- 0.36 cm(2) (range 0.85 cm(2) for a 25 mm valve to 2.41 cm(2) for a 29 mm valve) and was smaller than by PHT (mean 2.04 +/- 0.41 cm(2), range 1.40-3.14 cm(2); P = 0.0001; t-test), irrespective of whether PHT is less than or >110 ms. CONCLUSION: The Doppler parameters obtained with CHVP in the mitral position are comparable with those obtained with the different prosthetic valves in common use. In the selected group of patients with CHVP, assessment of MVA by the PHT method is comparable with that by the CE. Areas by both methods were smaller than the AOA provided by the manufacturer, as seen in other similar design valves.