Testing for inherited thrombophilias in arterial stroke: can it cause more harm than good?

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Despite a paucity of evidence supporting a true association of ischemic stroke and the inherited thrombophilias, it is common practice for many neurologists to order these tests as part of the work-up of ischemic stroke, especially in young patients. Treatment with oral anticoagulation is often used in patients with positive results for the inherited thrombophilias. METHODS: We reviewed the literature focusing on case-control studies of the 5 most commonly inherited disorders of coagulation: protein C deficiency, protein S deficiency, antithrombin deficiency, and the factor V Leiden and prothrombin gene mutations in patients with stroke. We also analyzed the available data on stroke patients with inherited thrombophilia and patent foramen ovale. RESULTS: Multiple case-control studies have not convincingly shown an association of the inherited thrombophilias with ischemic stroke, even in young patients and patients with patent foramen ovale. CONCLUSIONS: If there is an association between the inherited thrombophilias and arterial stroke, then it is a weak one, likely enhanced by other prothrombotic risk factors. The consequences of ordering these tests and attributing causality to an arterial event can result in significant costs to the health care system and pose a potential risk to patients, because this may lead to inappropriate use of long-term oral anticoagulants, exposing patients to harm without a clearly defined benefit.

Protein C and protein S assessment in hospital laboratories: which strategy and what role for DNA sequencing?

This paper presents a critical assessment of protein C (PC) and protein S (PS) functional and immunological approaches with regard to DNA sequencing in a large hospital recruitment for thrombosis exploration in more than 1700 consecutive patients. After examination of clinical status and PC and PS phenotype, a genotypic study was implemented for 17 PC-deficient and 28 PS-deficient patients (activity < 70%). Sixty-five percent of the genotyped PC-deficient patients were found to have heterozygous mutations. Among the < 70% values, decreases in PC activity without gene mutation were always slight (mean value 64 +/- 7%) while patients presenting a PC gene mutation had a mean 50 +/- 17% activity (P < 0.05). Among the eight PC mutations found, only one has previously been described. A novel mutation in the promoter region (-1522), located in the HNF-1 site and associated with the Y226H heterozygous mutation, was found in a 9-month-old girl with 4% PC activity. Determination of PS functional activity was considerably improved by contemporaneous measurement of calibration and samples in a single step. Only 50% of the genotyped PS-deficient patients demonstrated heterozygous alterations of the gene. The benefit of sequencing to identify putative causal mutations was only 39% in PS-deficient women, while it was 90% in men. Among the nine PS mutations found, six have not yet been published. In the present paper, we explain our methodological choices and diagnostic strategy.

Duration of oral anticoagulant treatment in patients with venous thromboembolism and a deficiency of antithrombin, protein C or protein S--a decision analysis.

Patients with a first venous thromboembolic event and a deficiency of the coagulation inhibitors antithrombin, protein C or protein S have an increased risk of recurrent venous thromboembolism compared to patients without such a deficiency. A decision analysis was performed to assess the effect of continuing treatment with vitamin K antagonists on mortality by a reduction in fatal recurrent pulmonary embolism and an induction of fatal haemorrhages associated with their use. The treatment decision involves continuation or discontinuation of vitamin K antagonists in patients with a first spontaneous or secondary venous thromboembolism and an antithrombin, protein C or S deficiency. Although the efficiency of oral anticoagulation is high in all age groups early after the first thromboembolic event, it decreases over time. Our analysis indicates that the optimal treatment duration will vary, depending on the type of the initial event (spontaneous or secondary; deep venous thrombosis or pulmonary embolism), age, and time passed since the initial thromboembolic episode. Moreover, life-long duration of the prophylaxis seems not warranted in all patients.