A new corneal epithelial biomimetic 3D model for in vitro eye toxicity assessment: Development, characterization and applicability.

In vitro eye toxicity assessment using reconstructed corneal epithelial models has emerged highlighting its applicability domain for Classification and Labeling of products and chemicals. However, due to bureaucratic issues, such models are not commercially available in Brazil and Latin America. In this work, we developed, characterized and evaluated the applicability of a new corneal epithelial biomimetic model using a cell lineage for in vitro eye toxicity assessment. The reconstructed tissue was obtained through the cultivation of HaCaT cells in an air-liquid interface, which presented morphology and biomarkers expression such as cytokeratin, CD44, and Ki-67 similar to human tissue. Furthermore, tissue viability was evaluated after exposure of the epithelial model to isolated chemicals from different Globally Harmonized System (GHS) eye irritation categories, and it has been demonstrated to be a suitable endpoint for classification of test materials, allowing discrimination between irritant and non-irritant chemicals. Furthermore, the model showed suitability for testing "real-life mixtures", once it identified irritant products between the analyzed eyebrow henna samples commercially labeled as non-irritants. This reproducible and low-cost epithelial corneal model presents features very important for Brazil and South America for R&D&I with no unnecessary animal experimentation.

Establishment and performance assessment of an in-house 3D Reconstructed Human Cornea-Like Epithelium (RhCE) as a screening tool for the identification of liquid chemicals with potential eye hazard.

The objective of this project was to develop an in-house 3D Reconstructed Human Cornea-Like Epithelium (RhCE) to be used as a screening tool in early stages of product development. This study reports the establishment of the experimental procedure and the performance assessment of the model to discriminate liquid chemicals classified as causing serious eye damage/irritation (UN-GHS Category 1/2) from liquid chemicals not requiring such hazard classification (UN-GHS No Category). Histological examination of this ocular equivalent model, based on Normal Human Keratinocytes (NHK) cultured in a chemically defined medium, revealed a stratified and well-organized tissue construct. Moreover, barrier robustness and functionality were demonstrated by the effective time-50 (ET50) of Triton X-100 measurement. The prediction model is based on cytotoxicity assessment following a test chemical exposure. When the mean tissue viability was over 60%, the chemical was defined as No Category; otherwise, it was classified as Category 1/2. In accordance with the applicable OECD guidance document (ENV/JM/MONO (2015)23), the performance of the model for eye hazard identification was evaluated with the minimum list of reference chemicals. As a result, the method scored 84.4% Accuracy, 70.8% Specificity, 100% Sensitivity and 93.3% for Concordance, demonstrating prediction performances close to those of Validated Reference Methods that are commonly used for regulatory purposes. Finally, these results suggest that this in-house RhCE based test method is a qualitative and accurate screening tool for eye hazard identification of liquid chemicals.

Statistical analysis of the reproducibility and predictive capacity of MCTT HCE™ eye irritation test, a me-too test method for OECD TG 492.

We aimed to conduct additional statistical analysis of the reproducibility and predictive capacity of MCTT HCE™ eye irritation test (EIT), a me-too test method for OECD TG 492 with the data generated during the validation study in which 30 reference chemicals were tested in three repeated runs by three independent laboratories. We evaluated the within-laboratory reproducibility (WLR) and the between-laboratory reproducibility (BLR) through tabulation and graphs and presented the concordance of eye irritancy prediction with 95% Wilson's confidence intervals (CIs). Also, the analyses of the Intra-Class Correlation Coefficient (ICC) and Bland-Altman plot were applied to confirm the reproducibility and the comparability, referring to the validated methods of OECD TG 492. Kappa analysis was also performed to check the degree of agreement of the within- and between-laboratory reproducibility and agreement between MCTT HCE™ EIT and the reference methods. We calculated the predictive capacity via misprediction over total prediction method. The predictive capacity (sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy) was presented with 95% of Wilson's CIs. Also, bootstrap resampling was performed to express the 95% CI by the simple percentile methods for 30 chemicals and 141 reference chemicals additionally tested. Collectively, WLR (92.2%) and BLR (93.3%) met the criteria of the performance standards (WLR ≥ 90% and BLR ≥ 85%), and the results of ICC analysis and the Bland-Altman plot suggested an acceptable WLR and BLR and comparability to other validated methods of OECD TG 492. Also, the predictive capacity results for the 30 reference chemicals confirmed the good performance of the MCTT HCE™ EIT by satisfying the criteria of sensitivity, specificity, and the accuracy stated in the PS. The bootstrap resampling method showed a predictive capacity, sufficiently satisfying the criteria stated in the Performance Standards.

Medical devices biocompatibility assessment on HCE: Evidences of delayed cytotoxicity of preserved compared to preservative free eye drops.

A multiple endpoint analysis (MEA) approach on human reconstructed corneal epithelium (HCE) model has been applied to assess the biocompatibility (cytotoxicity and irritation potential) of medical devices (MD): ophthalmology literature clearly shows the need to better assess these products to exclude any potential chronic damage to the ocular surface. Preserved eye drops (Artelac Multidose, Optive multidose and Artelac Rebalance Multidose) and the same without preservative (Artelac Edo, Optive Unidose, Artelac Rebalance Unidose) and Thealoz Duo were tested after acute (24 h + 16 h post incubation) and repeated (2 applications/day for 72 h) exposure using BAK 0.01% as positive control on HCE. Cellular viability, trans-epithelial electrical resistance measurements, LDH release and occludin gene expression were evaluated for each product to discriminate the potential toxicity of preservatives. The BAK 0.01% toxicity on HCE was confirmed following both exposures. The analysis of the same parameters reveals that the 72 h exposure was suitable to identify toxicity and damages to the ocular surface even for 'soft' preserved MD. The results confirm the reliability, sensitivity and predictivity of the MEA on HCE in detecting subclinical signs of cellular toxicity: 'soft' preservatives resulted toxics suggesting that delayed toxicity should be integral part of the biocompatibility assessment of ophthalmic formulations intended for long-term use.

Corneal epithelial permeability to fluorescein in humans by a multi-drop method.

PURPOSE: The permeability of the corneal epithelium to fluorescein Pdc is an indicator of the health of the ocular surface. It can be measured in a clinical setting by determining the accumulation of fluorescein in the stroma following administration of the dye on the ocular surface. Here we demonstrate a new multi-drop method for the measurement of Pdc by a spot fluorometer. METHODS: Twenty-nine healthy participants were recruited for this study. First, a probe-drop of fluorescein (0.35%, 2 µL) was instilled on the conjunctiva. The clearance of the dye from the tears was immediately measured using the fluorometer. Following this, two loading drops (2%; 6 µL each) were administered 10 min apart. Fifteen minutes later, the ocular surface was washed and fluorescence from the stroma Fs was measured. Permeability was calculated using Pdc = (Q x Fs)/ (2 x AUC), where Q is the stromal thickness and AUC is the area under the fluorescence vs. time curve for the loading drops. RESULTS: After the probe drop, the tear fluorescence followed an exponential decay (elimination rate constant; kd = 0.41 ± 0.28 per min; 49 eyes of 29 subjects), but the increase in Fs was negligible. However, after the loading drops, the measured Fs was ~ 20-fold higher than the autofluorescence and could be recorded at a high signal to noise ratio (SNR > 40). The intra-subject variability of kd was insignificant. Since fluorescein undergoes concentration quenching at > 0.5%, the value of AUC for the loading drops was estimated by scaling the AUC of the probe drop. The calculated Pdc was 0.54 ± 0.54 nm/sec (n = 49). A Monte Carlo simulation of the model for the multi-drop protocol confirmed the robustness of the estimated Pdc. CONCLUSIONS: The new multi-drop method can be used in place of the single-drop approach. It can overcome a lack of sensitivity in fluorometers of high axial resolution. The Pdc estimated by the multi-drop method is ~ 11-fold higher than previously reported but closer to the value reported for other drugs with equivalent octanol/water partition coefficient.

Skin and Eye Irritation Assessment of Oil Palm ( Elaeis guineensis) Leaf Extract for Topical Application.

Many types of phytochemicals have been found to be present in oil palm leaf and could potentially be used as functional ingredients for skincare product. However, as of today, there is no published report on hazard identification and safety assessment of oil palm ( Elaeis guineensis) leaf extract (OPLE), particularly on skin and eye irritation. In this study, potential hazard of OPLE on skin and eye irritation was evaluated as an initial step to the safety assessment of OPLE. In vitro cell viability study of OPLE on normal human dermal fibroblasts showed that OPLE was nontoxic to the cells with percentage viability more than 90% after 24 and 48 hours of incubation. Skin irritation potential of OPLE was evaluated using in vitro SkinEthic reconstructed human epidermis (RHE) model (Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development [OECD] Test Guideline 439, 2015), while eye irritation potential was evaluated using in vitro SkinEthic Human corneal epithelium (HCE) model (OECD test guideline 492, 2017). Hazard identification results showed that OPLE at 1%, 5%, and 10% (wt/wt) was classified as nonirritant to the skin and eye where mean tissue viabilities of SkinEthic RHE and SkinEthic HCE were more than 50% and 60%, respectively. Therefore, we recommend a further safety assessment, such as human patch testing, to confirm the nonirritant of OPLE.

Ezrin as a complementary marker in ocular toxicity assessment using a three-dimensional reconstructed human corneal-like epithelium model, EpiOcular™.

INTRODUCTION: A variety of in vitro tests to replace the Draize test have been developed; however, there is no available method for assessing the full spectrum of Globally Harmonized System (GHS) categories. Human cornea-like three-dimensional (3D) reconstructed tissue models are the most promising in vitro systems. The objective of this study was to evaluate the ocular toxicity of 11 test substances using the EpiOcular™ model after performing proficiency tests. We further evaluated the effectiveness of ezrin staining as a complementary marker in histological analysis to overcome the limitation of eye irritation tests using 3D reconstructed human corneal epithelium models. METHODS: The assessment of ocular toxicity was performed by the suggested OECD TG 492 procedure. After treatment with proficiency test chemicals and 10 test substances, EpiOcular™ tissue models were stained with hematoxylin and eosin and ezrin, and the histological changes were observed by immunofluorescence microscopy. RESULTS: The ocular toxicity assessment of 10 test chemicals using the EpiOcular™ eye irritation test were in accordance with the UN GHS classification of test chemicals. Histological analysis of ezrin staining showed that the cell membranes of models treated with 10 out of 11 non-irritant chemicals were maintained, whereas those of models treated with 14 eye irritant substances resulted in the apparent translocation of ezrins from the cell membrane to the cytoplasm or nucleus by destruction of cell membrane. DISCUSSION: Ezrin may be used as a complementary marker to more accurately assess ocular toxicity using 3D reconstructed human cornea-like epithelium models.

Assessment of DNA Damage and Cell Senescence in Corneal Epithelial Cells Exposed to Airborne Particulate Matter (PM2.5) Collected in Guangzhou, China.

PURPOSE: To assess the genotoxic effect of airborne particulate matter on corneal epithelial cells and investigate the role of reactive oxygen species (ROS) formation in this process. METHODS: Immortalized human corneal epithelial cells (HCECs) and primary bovine corneal epithelial cells were exposed to airborne particulate matter collected from Guangzhou for 24 hours. The cell viability and toxicity were measured by the CCK-8 test and lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) release, respectively. The DNA breaks and DNA repair were examined by alkaline comet assay and by immunofluorescence staining of the phosphorylated histone variant H2AX (γH2AX), respectively. Reactive oxygen species production was assessed by the fluorescent probe, CM-H2DCFDA. Cell senescence was evaluated with senescence-associated ß-Galactosidase staining, and cell ultrastructure was observed with transmission electron microscopy. RESULTS: Exposure to PM2.5 at the concentration of 20 µg/mL to 200 µg/mL decreased cell viability and increased LDH release. Remarkably increased DNA double-stand breaks, increased expression of DNA repair-related protein γH2AX, elevated ROS formation, and altered cell ultrastructure were observed in HCECs after treatment with PM2.5. The genotoxic effect of PM2.5 was attenuated by the ROS inhibitor N-acetyl-l-cysteine (NAC). CONCLUSIONS: Particulate matter 2.5 could induce DNA damage and cell senescence in corneal epithelial cells, probably by promoting ROS formation. Thus, whether long-term exposure of PM2.5 might be related to potential risk of abnormality in corneal epithelium renewal and regeneration should be further investigated.

Application of cyclic biamperometry to viability and cytotoxicity assessment in human corneal epithelial cells.

The application of cyclic biamperometry to viability and cytotoxicity assessments of human corneal epithelial cells has been investigated. Electrochemical measurements have been compared in PBS containing 5.0 mM glucose and minimal essential growth medium. Three different lipophilic mediators including dichlorophenol indophenol, 2-methyl-1,4-naphthoquinone (also called menadione or vitamin K3) and N,N,N',N'-tetramethyl-p-phenylenediamine have been evaluated for shuttling electrons across the cell membrane to the external medium. Transfer of these electrons to ferricyanide in the extra cellular medium results in the accumulation of ferrocyanide. The amount of ferrocyanide is then determined using cyclic biamperometry and is related to the extent of cell metabolic activity and therefore cell viability. To illustrate cytotoxicity assessment of chemicals, hydrogen peroxide, benzalkonium chloride and sodium dodecyl sulfate have been chosen as sample toxins, the cytotoxicities of which have been evaluated and compared to values reported in the literature. Similar values have been reported using colorimetric assays; however, the simplicity of this electrochemical assay can, in principle, open the way to miniaturization onto lab-on-chip devices and its incorporation into tiered-testing approaches for cytotoxicity assessment.

Efficacy of ophthalmic viscosurgical devices in maintaining corneal epithelial hydration and clarity: in vitro assessment.

PURPOSE: To determine the efficacy of hydroxypropyl methylcellulose (HPMC) and hyaluronic acid (HA) in maintaining corneal hydration and optical clarity. SETTING: Department of Ophthalmology, Medical University of Vienna, Vienna, Austria. DESIGN: Experimental study. METHODS: In porcine autopsy eyes, the effect of 13 ophthalmic viscosurgical devices (OVDs) (5 formulations of HPMC; 8 formulations of HA) in maintaining corneal hydration and optical clarity was tested. The main outcome variables were the time to reach optical clarity of the cornea during dissipation of the OVD and duration of corneal hydration. These variables were assessed after the first application of the OVD, after balanced salt solution application to rehydrate the gel matrix, and after the second application of OVD on top of the first layer. RESULTS: The study used 57 porcine eyes. High-molecular-weight HA 1.5% (zero shear viscosity [ZSV] 55,122 millipascal seconds [mPa.s]) took a significantly shorter time to reach optical clarity than HA 1.4% (ZSV 36,882 mPa.s) (P=.04). Hyaluronic acid 1.4% and HA 1.5% maintained corneal hydration significantly longer than HPMC 2.0% (P<.001). CONCLUSIONS: For corneal hydration during short-lasting surgical procedures such as cataract surgery, the results suggest using HPMC because it distributes quickly and provides an adequate duration of sufficient corneal hydration. For corneal hydration during prolonged surgical procedures, such as vitreoretinal surgery, results suggest using HA 1.5% in the formulation because it provides long-lasting corneal hydration. FINANCIAL DISCLOSURE: Dr. Prinz has a proprietary interest in Croma Pharma GmbH, Leobendorf, Austria. Dr. Findl is a scientific advisor to Croma Pharma GmbH. No other author has a financial or proprietary interest in any material or method mentioned.

In vitro biocompatibility assessment of multipurpose contact lens solutions: effects on human corneal epithelial viability and barrier function.

PURPOSE: To explore the in vitro effects of multipurpose contact lens solutions (MPSs) on corneal epithelial barrier function and viability. METHODS: Human corneal epithelial cells (HCEpiC) were exposed to 50% MPSs A-G. Viability was determined using metabolic activity, protease release and caspase assays. Barrier function was evaluated using immunostaining for the tight junction protein zonnula occludens-1 (ZO-1) and resistance measurements. RESULTS: MPS A and G did not affect HCEpiC monolayer viability after 2 h, while MPSs B-F significantly decreased viability. There was a significant decrease in stratified HCEpiC viability after exposure to MPSs B-E for 2 h, while there was no effect of MPS A. After exposure of HCEpiC monolayers to MPS A, F or G for 30 min, ZO-1 staining appeared similar to control. HCEpiC exposed to MPSs B and C demonstrated tight junction breakdown. There was no significant change in HCEpiC monolayer resistance after exposure to MPS A or F for 2 h, while MPSs B-E and G reduced resistance. After exposure to MPS A-E, stratified HCEpiC resistance was significantly decreased after 2 or 4 h. The decrease in resistance was significantly less with MPS A as compared to the other MPSs. CONCLUSIONS: MPSs caused varying modifications to cell viability and barrier function in monolayer and stratified HCEpiC. MPS A did not alter monolayer HCEpiC viability or barrier function, while MPSs B-G caused significant decreases of at least one parameter. Furthermore, MPS A had significantly less effect than MPSs B-E on viability and barrier function of stratified HCEpiC.

Ocular irritation reversibility assessment for personal care products using a porcine corneal culture assay.

Personal care product manufacturers have used a broad spectrum of alternative ocular irritation assays during the past two decades because these tests do not require the use of live animals, they provide reliable predictive data, and they are relatively inexpensive to conduct. To complement these assays, the ex vivo Porcine Corneal Opacity Reversibility Assay (PorCORA) was recently developed using a corneal culture model to predict reversibility of ocular irritants. Three commercially available consumer products (a shampoo, a hair color glaze, and a hair colorant system containing 12% hydrogen peroxide) were each tested in two PorCORA study replicates in order to assess potential ocular damage reversibility for surfactant-, propylene carbonate-, and peroxide-based formulations, respectively. Under the exaggerated, in vitro study conditions, the surfactant-based shampoo may cause irreversible porcine corneal damage (histological changes in the epithelial squamous cell and/or basal cell layers), whereas the hair color glaze and 12% hydrogen peroxide product caused fully reversible ocular irritation (microscopic changes only in the superficial squamous cell layer). The hair color glaze and peroxide product results correlate with established in vivo data for similar compounds, but the shampoo results contradicted previous BCOP results (expected to be only a mild irritant). Therefore, although the PorCORA protocol shows promise in predicting the extent and reversibility of potential ocular damage caused by accidental consumer eye exposure to personal care products, the contradictory results for the surfactant-based shampoo indicate that more extensive validation testing of the PorCORA is necessary to definitively establish the protocol's reliability as a Draize test replacement.

In vitro assessment of eye irritancy using the Reconstructed Human Corneal Epithelial SkinEthic HCE model: application to 435 substances from consumer products industry.

The 7th amendment of the EU Cosmetics Directive led to the ban of eye irritation testing for cosmetic ingredients in animals, effective from March 11th 2009. Over the last 20years, many efforts have been made to find reliable and relevant alternative methods. The SkinEthic HCE model was used to evaluate the in vitro eye irritancy potential of substances from a cosmetic industry portfolio. An optimized protocol based on a specific 1-h treatment and a 16-h post-treatment incubation period was first assessed on a set of 102 substances. The prediction model (PM) based on a 50% viability cut-off, allowed to draw up two classes (Irritants and Non-Irritants), with good associated sensitivity (86.2%) and specificity (83.5%). To check the robustness of the method, the evaluated set was expanded up to 435 substances. Final performances maintained a high level and were characterized by an overall accuracy value > 82% when using EU or GHS classification rules. Results showed that the SkinEthic HCE test method is a promising in vitro tool for the prediction of eye irritancy. Optimization datasets were shared with the COLIPA Eye Irritation Project Team and ECVAM experts, and reviewed as part of an ongoing progression to enter an ECVAM prospective validation study for eye irritation.

Cytometric assessment of cytostatic and cytotoxic effects of topical glaucoma medications on human epithelial corneal line cells.

BACKGROUND: The long-term-treatment of glaucoma with topical medications is associated with side effects involving cornea damage. We examined the effect of glaucoma topical medications (bimatoprost, travoprost, latanoprost, timolol, betaxolol, dorzolamide, brinzolamide, brimonidine) on growth of cells of three human epithelial corneal lines. METHODS: The cells were cultured in 8-chamber slides, treated with different concentrations of the medications, and fixed at 24, 48, and 72 h. Cell number on slides to estimate viability and growth curves, frequency of apoptosis (FLICA and caspase-3 activation probes), and proliferation (BrdU incorporation assay) were measured by laser scanning cytometry (LSC). RESULTS: Depending on concentration all examined medications induced cell necrosis or apoptosis and suppressed proliferation. Significant variability in proliferation and apoptosis was observed within the same cultures depending on local cell density, with cells in high density areas being more resistant. The data indicate that commonly used topical medications exert cytostatic and cytotoxic effects in cultures of corneal cells and suggest that caution should be exercised in their use, particularly, when the corneal diseases are accompanied by cell proliferation and regeneration, in long-term-treatment. CONCLUSIONS: The present approach of using LSC makes it possible to assess and compare cytostatic and cytotoxic effects of different topical medications on the respective target cells.

Confocal assessment of the effects of fourth-generation fluoroquinolones on the cornea.

PURPOSE: To evaluate the toxicity of fourth-generation fluoroquinolone antibiotic solutions on the rabbit corneal epithelium. METHODS: In vivo confocal microscopy was used to assess epithelial structure in 18 rabbits, and tight junction integrity of superficial epithelial cells was evaluated with ZO-1 labeling in 10 rabbits. Eyes were bathed with commercial solutions of moxifloxacin (Vigamox) or gatifloxacin (Zymar) solution for 3 minutes, rinsed with balanced salt solution, and immediately examined. Balanced salt solution rinsing alone served as the control. RESULTS: A decrease in epithelial cell size was observed after treatment with Zymar (P < 0.05, two-way repeated-measures analysis of variance), but not with Vigamox or the control. Normal ZO-1 organization was observed in controls and eyes treated with Vigamox. ZO-1 staining in eyes treated with Zymar was disrupted, patchy, and generally weaker than that in control eyes. CONCLUSIONS: After short-term, intensive exposure to Vigamox, corneal epithelial integrity and tight junction organization are maintained. Zymar induces a loss of superficial epithelial cells and breakdown of tight junctions under similar conditions.

[In vivo assessment of corneal epithelial toxicity of timolol with benzalkonium chloride using very-high-frequency ultrasound imaging]. / Evaluation in vivo par échographie à très haute fréquence des modifications épithéliales cornéennes induites par un bêta-bloquant avec 0,01% de chlorure de benzalkonium.

PURPOSE: To assess in vivo the corneal epithelial damage caused by a topical toxic medication using a 60-MHz ultrasound device. MATERIAL: and methods: A solution of timolol with 0.01% benzalkonium chloride (BAC) was applied twice a day in the test eyes of ten rabbits, and a BAC-free solution of timolol in the control eyes, for 56 days. We used a 60-MHz ultrasound device to evaluate the epithelial damage in BAC-exposed eyes, compared to control eyes. The clinical and ultrasound examinations were performed every week, and the histological analysis at the end of the experiment. RESULTS: The clinical findings were conjunctival redness, corneal staining and instability of the tear film. In vivo VHF ultrasound revealed a thinning of the epithelium of test eyes (from 40.9+/-1,6 microm at D0 to 31.8+/-3.4 microm at D56; p=0.0006 for D0 vs D56), while the epithelium of control eyes remained unchanged. Ultrasound epithelial thickness was correlated with corneal staining (at D34 and D56; p=0.0025 and 0.0377, respectively) and histological epithelial pachymetry (p=0.0176 for control and 0.0505 for tested epithelium). Moreover, we report qualitative VHF ultrasound imaging of early epithelial damage. CONCLUSION: This new device could be very useful in ocular toxicity evaluation as a reproducible and reliable tool for multicentric clinical research.

Reconstituted human corneal epithelium: a new alternative to the Draize eye test for the assessment of the eye irritation potential of chemicals and cosmetic products.

The aim of this study was to evaluate the interest of a new three-dimensional epithelial model cultivated from human corneal cells to replace animal testing in the assessment of eye tolerance. To this end, 65 formulated cosmetic products and 36 chemicals were tested by means of this in vitro model using a simplified toxicokinetic approach. The chemicals were selected from the ECETOC data bank and the EC/HO International validation study list. Very satisfactory results were obtained in terms of concordance with the Draize test data for the formulated cosmetic products. Moreover, the response of the corneal model appeared predictive of human ocular response clinically observed by ophthalmologists. The in vitro scores for the chemicals tested strongly correlated with their respective scores in vivo. For all the compounds tested, the response of the corneal model to irritants was similar regardless of their chemical structure, suggesting a good robustness of the prediction model proposed. We concluded that this new three-dimensional epithelial model, developed from human corneal cells, could be promising for the prediction of eye irritation induced by chemicals and complex formulated products, and that these two types of materials should be tested using a similar protocol. A simple shortening of the exposure period was required for the chemicals assumed to be more aggressively irritant to the epithelial tissues than the cosmetic formulae.