An Early Cost-Utility Model of mRNA-Based Therapies for the Treatment of Methylmalonic and Propionic Acidemia in the United Kingdom.

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE: Novel messenger RNA (mRNA)-based therapies, currently in development, are emerging as a promising potential treatment modality for a broad range of life-threatening and life-limiting inherited liver diseases, including methylmalonic acidemia (MMA) and propionic acidemia (PA). However, owing in part to their complexity, they are likely to come at considerable financial cost to healthcare systems. The objective of this research was to synthesize available evidence on the costs and clinical consequences associated with MMA and PA for the purpose of exploratory economic evaluation of novel mRNA-based therapies using an early cost-utility model from the United Kingdom payer perspective. METHODS: A Markov model was constructed to simulate the costs and outcomes associated with novel mRNA therapies, compared with a combination of dietary management and organ transplantation (standard of care) among hypothetical cohorts of new-born patients with MMA and PA. Key model drivers were identified, and a price threshold analysis was performed to estimate value-based price ranges for future mRNA therapies given willingness-to-pay thresholds for orphan diseases. RESULTS: mRNA therapy was associated with an additional 5.7 and 1.3 quality-adjusted life-years (QALYs) gained per patient lifetime among patients with MMA and PA, respectively. Key drivers of cost-effectiveness were relative improvement in utility among patients who receive mRNA-based therapy and transplantation, and the cost of mRNA therapy. Assuming a willingness to pay range of £100,000-£300,000 per QALY gained, the model demonstrated mRNA therapy to be cost-effective in MMA and PA at an annual treatment cost of £70,452-£94,575 and £31,313-£36,695, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Despite the lack of a strong evidence base in MMA and PA, this model provides a useful tool to estimate the cost-effectiveness, and inform value-based pricing, of new mRNA-based therapies. Our analyses also identified areas for research that will have the greatest value in reducing uncertainty in future health economic evaluations of such treatments.

Identification of novel pathogenic variants in the GCDH gene and assessment of neurodevelopmental outcomes in 24 children with glutaric aciduria type 1.

AIM: To evaluate the pathogenic variants in GCDH gene and to assess the neurodevelopmental outcomes in children with Glutaric aciduria type 1 (GA-1). METHOD: Cross-sectional observational study between January 2019 and June 2020 in consecutive North Indian children with a clinical and biochemical suspicion of GA-1. Variants in the coding regions of GCDH gene were identified through Sanger sequencing. Neurodevelopmental and quality of life assessment was done using standardized scales. RESULTS: 24 children with GA-1 were identified. The median age at diagnosis was 12 months and the median delay in diagnosis was 3 months. Genetic analysis was done in 14 cases. It revealed 12 variants (11 missense and one nonsense) from 13 patients. Most of the pathogenic variants were in exon 9 and exon 5. Three novel variants were identified in three patients: two missense variants c.169G > A (p.Glu57Lys), c.1048T > C (p.Cys350Arg) and one nonsense variant c.331C > T (p.Lys111Ter). On neurodevelopmental assessment, majority of children with GA-1 were non ambulatory (62.5%), had limited hand skills (58.3%) and impaired communication (58.3%). Overall, poor global development was noted in 43.7%. A pre-existing developmental delay was significantly associated with impaired communication skills (p = 0.03), and the number of episodes of encephalopathy were significantly associated with impaired gross motor skill (p = 0.02). Presence of encephalopathy was significantly associated with poor performance in social emotional (p = 0.01) and cognitive (p = 0.03) domains of Developmental Profile-III scale and development of severe dystonia (p = 0.01). CONCLUSION: Our findings highlight the clinical, biochemical, radiological and genetic spectrum of GA-1 in children in North India and report the presence of novel pathogenic variations.

Improving the diagnosis of cobalamin and related defects by genomic analysis, plus functional and structural assessment of novel variants.

BACKGROUND: Cellular cobalamin defects are a locus and allelic heterogeneous disorder. The gold standard for coming to genetic diagnoses of cobalamin defects has for some time been gene-by-gene Sanger sequencing of individual DNA fragments. Enzymatic and cellular methods are employed before such sequencing to help in the selection of the gene defects to be sought, but this is time-consuming and laborious. Furthermore some cases remain undiagnosed because no biochemical methods have been available to test for cobalamin absorption and transport defects. RESULTS: This paper reports the use of massive parallel sequencing of DNA (exome analysis) for the accurate and rapid genetic diagnosis of cobalamin-related defects in a cohort of affected patients. The method was first validated in an initial cohort with different cobalamin defects. Mendelian segregation, the frequency of mutations, and the comprehensive structural and functional analysis of gene variants, identified disease-causing mutations in 12 genes involved in the absorption and synthesis of active cofactors of vitamin B12 (22 cases), and in the non-cobalamin metabolism-related genes ACSF3 (in four biochemically misdiagnosed patients) and SUCLA2 (in one patient with an unusual presentation). We have identified thirteen new variants all classified as pathogenic according to the ACGM recommendation but four were classified as variant likely pathogenic in MUT and SUCLA2. Functional and structural analysis provided evidences to classify them as pathogenic variants. CONCLUSIONS: The present findings suggest that the technology used is sufficiently sensitive and specific, and the results it provides sufficiently reproducible, to recommend its use as a second-tier test after the biochemical detection of cobalamin disorder markers in the first days of life. However, for accurate diagnoses to be made, biochemical and functional tests that allow comprehensive clinical phenotyping are also needed.

Renal involvement in lysinuric protein intolerance: contribution of pathology to assessment of heterogeneity of renal lesions.

Lysinuric protein intolerance (LPI) is a rare autosomal recessive disease caused by mutations in the SLC7A7 gene encoding the light subunit of a cationic amino acid transporter. Symptoms mimic primary urea cycle defects but dysimmune symptoms are also described. Renal involvement in LPI was first described in the 1980s. In 2007, it appeared that it could concern as much as 75% of LPI patients and could lead to end-stage renal disease. The most common feature is proximal tubular dysfunction and nephrocalcinosis but glomerular lesions are also reported. However, very little is known regarding histological lesions associated with LPI. We gathered every kidney biopsy of LPI-proven patients in our highly specialized pediatric and adult institution. Clinical, biological, and histological information was analyzed. Five LPI patients underwent kidney biopsy in our institution between 1986 and 2015. Clinically, 4/5 presented with proximal tubular dysfunction and 3/5 with nephrotic range proteinuria. Histology showed unspecific tubulointerstitial lesions and nephrocalcinosis in 3/5 biopsies and marked peritubular capillaritis in one child. Glomerular lesions were heterogeneous: lupus-like-full house membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis (MPGN) in one child evolved towards monotypic IgG1κ MPGN sensitive to immunomodulators. One patient presented with glomerular non-AA non-AL amyloidosis. Renal biopsy is particularly relevant in LPI presenting with glomerular symptoms for which variable histological lesions can be responsible, implying specific treatment and follow-up.

Essential fatty acid profiling for routine nutritional assessment unmasks adrenoleukodystrophy in an infant with isovaleric acidaemia.

We report a 16-month-old asymptomatic male with enzyme confirmed isovaleric acidaemia (IVA; isovaleryl-CoA dehydrogenase deficiency; OMIM 243500) who, upon routine nutritional follow-up, presented evidence of peroxisomal dysfunction. The newborn screen (2 days of life) revealed elevated C(5)-carnitine (2.95 µmol/L; cutoff <0.09 µmol/L) and IVA was subsequently confirmed by metabolic profiling and in vitro enzymology. Plasma essential fatty acid (EFA) analysis, assessed to evaluate nutritional status during protein restriction and L: -carnitine supplementation, revealed elevated C(26:0) (5.0 µmol/L; normal <1.3). Subsequently, metabolic profiling and molecular genetic analysis confirmed X-linked adrenoleukodystrophy (XALD). Identification of co-inherited XALD with IVA in this currently asymptomatic patient holds significant treatment ramifications for the proband prior to the onset of neurological sequelae, and critically important counselling implications for this family.

Evaluation of a mass screening program for lysinuric protein intolerance in the northern part of Japan.

Lysinuric protein intolerance (LPI:MIM 222700) is an autosomal recessive disease characterized by defective transport of the dibasic amino acids. We recently reported a local cluster of LPI in the northern part of Japan (Koizumi et al., 2000). Mutational analysis of the LPI patients in this local cluster revealed they were exclusively homozygous for the R410X mutation. The effectiveness of early intervention with citrulline therapy (200 mg/kg per day) and protein restriction (1.5 g/kg per day) was confirmed in these patients. Mass screening was conducted in 4,568 newborn babies between 1999 and 2002, which was estimated to cover 100% of almost all newborns delivered in the screened area. Forty heterozygous newborns were found (0.88%), leading to an estimated incidence of LPI of 1:51,984. The number of people that required screening to detect one case was 51,984, and the cost for mass screening was 30 cents/person (a total of dollars 15,600). This is comparable to, or even less than, the cost of currently screened diseases in Japan. Therefore, we conclude that a mass screening program for LPI can be introduced effectively and economically into an area where an LPI cluster is located as the result of a founder mutation.

A historical aspect of lysinuric protein intolerance in a northern part of Iwate, Japan.

Historical aspects of a local cluster of individuals with lysinuric protein intolerance (LPI) were studied in a sample of patients and in a mass-screened population in a northern area of Japan. The historical aspects were investigated by estimating the mutation age and analyses of haplotype diversity of the chromosome carrying the R410X mutation. This mutation occurred over 1000 years ago, and its fixation in the local cluster suggests that LPI had been a nearly neutral phenotype. The present results also give an estimate of the geographical distribution of the R410X mutation, providing a basis for targeting populations for mass screening for LPI.

Genetic epidemiology of hereditary tyrosinemia in Quebec and in Saguenay-Lac-St-Jean.

Hereditary tyrosinemia type I is an autosomal recessive disorder that was recognized in Saguenay-Lac-St-Jean (SLSJ) (Quebec) in 1967. Ninety-eight tyrosinemic children, including some of the 113 children born in the SLSJ region, have been screened by the Quebec Network of Genetic Medicine in the whole province since 1970. The geographical distribution of the 98 children screened showed the majority of them to have been born in the northeastern part of Quebec. The prevalence at birth was estimated at 1/1,846 live borns, and the carrier rate was estimated at 1/20 inhabitants in the SLSJ region. Three control groups matched to the tyrosinemic obligate-carrier couples were generated using the population register of the SLSJ region kept at SOREP. The mean coefficient of inbreeding was only slightly elevated in the tyrosinemic group compared with the control groups and was due to remote consanguinity. The mean kinship coefficient was 2.3 times higher in the tyrosinemic group than in the control groups. In the SLSJ region the places of origin of the tyrosinemic children and their parents did not show a clustered nonuniform distribution. Endogamy was not found to be higher in the tyrosinemic group than in the control groups. All these results support both the hypothesis of a founder effect for tyrosinemia and a high gene frequency in northeastern Quebec.

Screening for inherited metabolic disease by plasma chromatography (Scriver) in a large city.

Before introducing a more comprehensive screen such as plasma chromatography, with its potential to detect 20 amino-acid disorders-an advantage over screening methods which detect only phenylketonuria-the greatly increased problems of organization and the effect on the community, midwives, paediatric services, and laboratory should be considered. The three years' experience in Birmingham showed a three-fold increase in cases detected and suggests criteria for further investigation and treatment.