Cost-Analyses Studies in Barrett's Esophagus: What Is Their Utility?

Approximately 10% to 15% of the chronic gastroesophageal reflux disease population is at risk for the development of Barrett's esophagus, particularly in the setting of other risk factors, including male gender, Caucasian race, age more than 50, and central obesity. The risk of cancer progression for patients with nondysplastic BE has been estimated to be approximately 0.2% to 0.5% per year. Given these low progression rates and the high cost of endoscopic surveillance, cost-effectiveness analyses in this area are useful to determine appropriate resource allocation.

Review article: management of oesophageal adenocarcinoma -- control of acid, bile and inflammation in intervention strategies for Barrett's oesophagus.

Oesophagitis is associated with Barrett's metaplasia in about 10% of individuals. The UK has one of the highest world-wide prevalences of Barrett's metaplasia, with 1% of adults having the condition, resulting in an incidence of oesophageal adenocarcinoma two to three times that seen in either Europe or North America. In addition, the conversion rate to cancer in individuals with Barrett's metaplasia in UK surveillance programmes is twice that observed in the USA (0.96% per year vs. 0.4% per year), lending further support to the notion that the UK is a high-risk region. The evidence base on what can be achieved with medical therapy to reduce the risk of dysplasia or the development of adenocarcinoma needs to be strengthened with data from randomized controlled trials, as existing data have many limitations. Patients with Barrett's metaplasia respond variably to proton pump inhibitor therapy (even high-dose therapy 'normalizes' acid reflux in only 85% of cases), and symptom control is a poor determinant of the adequacy of suppression of acid reflux. Gastro-oesophageal reflux is implicated in the pathogenesis of Barrett's metaplasia, and ex vivo and in vitro evidence suggests that its attenuation reverses proliferation and biological variables over days, and perhaps the metaplastic histology to a degree over years. The effect of proton pump inhibitor therapy on cancer risk in the long term is essentially unknown. Acid suppressant therapy or anti-reflux surgery on its own does not result in the complete regression of the metaplastic epithelium. Bile acids, present especially frequently in the refluxate of Barrett's oesophagus patients, are also likely to influence the development and persistence of metaplasia. Barrett's metaplasia is replaced by a squamous epithelium when acid reflux is well controlled and the epithelium is physically destroyed by ablation with argon plasma coagulation or photodynamic therapy. These modalities are invasive and are not likely to be useful in the routine management of patients with Barrett's oesophagus without dysplasia or cancer. Why metaplasia does not fully regress once external initiating stimuli are removed is a mystery. There is some evidence to implicate a variety of molecules, including cyclo-oxygenase-2, tumour necrosis factor-alpha, beta-catenin nuclear translocation and mitogen-activated protein kinase signalling, because they are expressed preferentially in metaplastic rather than normal or inflamed squamous oesophageal mucosa. The use of non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, including aspirin, is associated with a decreased incidence of oesophageal adenocarcinoma. There is therefore a great need for randomized controlled trials to assess the outcomes of such chemopreventive therapy in patients with Barrett's metaplasia.

Review article: screening and surveillance of Barrett's oesophagus: what is a cost-effective framework?

There is a strong association between symptomatic gastro-oesophageal reflux and oesophageal adenocarcinoma. With this in mind, the American College of Gastroenterology has recently revised its practice guidelines for the screening of patients with chronic gastro-oesophageal reflux disease (GERD) to identify those at risk of oesophageal adenocarcinoma, and recommends surveillance to identify curable oesophageal neoplasms in patients with established Barrett's oesophagus. Patients with chronic GERD symptoms, particularly those aged over 50 years, should undergo upper endoscopy. Patients found to have Barrett's oesophagus should be treated with acid suppression for GERD symptoms and then undergo regular surveillance endoscopy. Surveillance endoscopy every 3 years is recommended for those without dysplasia. For patients with verified low-grade dysplasia, yearly surveillance endoscopy is recommended. For those with focal high-grade dysplasia (defined as high-grade dysplastic changes involving fewer than five crypts), the condition may be followed with endoscopic surveillance performed at 3-month intervals. If there is verified, multifocal high-grade dysplasia, intervention (e.g. oesophagectomy) may be considered. Both observational and computer models suggest a benefit associated with screening and surveillance. Endoscopic screening and surveillance for Barrett's oesophagus compares favourably with mammography for the detection of breast cancer and other accepted medical practices.

Cost effectiveness of detecting Barrett's cancer.

BACKGROUND: Screening Barrett's oesophagus is controversial owing to a large variation in the reported incidence of neoplastic change and lack of evidence that screening improves tumour prognosis. AIMS: To determine the incidence of Barrett's cancer, its cost of detection, and stage of disease at time of diagnosis. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Data from our surveillance programme have been reviewed to assess the incidence of malignant change, tumour stage at diagnosis, and the cost per cancer detected. RESULTS: 166 patients had annual endoscopic surveillance. Six patients (five men) developed cancer-an incidence of one cancer per 59 male and 167 female patient-years of follow up. The screened group had a significantly earlier stage than a control group of unscreened cancers (p < 0.05). The cost of detecting one cancer was Pounds 14 868 for men and Pounds 42 084 for women. CONCLUSIONS: The cost of screening for Barrett's cancer is high but may be justified on the basis of the high incidence of detecting early stage disease.

Oesophageal carcinoma: the need for screening.

Oesophageal cancer is a substantial cause of mortality in the Western world and recent data indicate that the incidence is increasing. Despite better understanding of the pathogenesis and in the surgical management of the disease, little improvement in the survival rates has been achieved anywhere in the world, especially because screening for detection of premalignant lesions cannot, at present, be adequately applied to populations at risk. The present review summarizes current knowledge of the use of conventional screening methods as well as possible applications of new techniques to targeted populations to permit earlier diagnosis of premalignant lesions of the oesophagus.