Ethambutol and visual assessment in England: current practice and recommendations.

BACKGROUND: Standard treatment for tuberculosis (TB) in children and adults includes an initial two-month course of ethambutol, a drug that in rare cases can cause optic neuropathy and irreversible vision loss. There is a lack of clear guidance on what vision assessments are needed before and during treatment with ethambutol, with the Royal College of Ophthalmologists, National Institute for Health and Care Excellence, British National Formulary and British Thoracic Society offering different guidance. We aimed to assess how vision is routinely tested in patients treated with ethambutol in TB services across England. METHODS: An online survey developed by Public Health England was sent to all TB services in England in 2018 to assess current practice and inform the development of best practice recommendations for visual assessment of patients treated with ethambutol for TB. RESULTS: Sixty-six TB professionals from across England responded, a response rate of 54%. The results showed variations in practice, including when to omit ethambutol from treatment, the timing and frequency of visual assessment, the type of visual assessment, referral processes and management of visual changes. CONCLUSION: This national survey highlights the need for clear guidelines on the testing of vision for patients taking ethambutol at recommended doses, before and during treatment. We suggest a pragmatic approach to visual assessment to reduce variation in practice, proposing a stepwise pathway for patients on standard TB treatment for local adaptation.

Comparing cost-effectiveness of standardised tuberculosis treatments given varying drug resistance.

There is a growing need to identify appropriate standardised treatment strategies that will adequately treat various forms of drug-resistant tuberculosis (TB) and prevent multidrug-resistant (MDR)-TB. A Markov model estimated treatment-related acquired MDR-TB, mortality, disability-adjusted life years and costs in settings with different prevalence of isoniazid monoresistant TB and MDR-TB. We compared four treatment strategies: 1) the standard World Health Organization recommended treatment strategy; 2) adding ethambutol throughout the 6-month treatment of new cases; 3) using a strengthened standardised retreatment regimen; and 4) using standardised MDR treatment for failures of initial treatment. Treatment-related outcomes were derived from the published literature, and costs from direct surveys. A strengthened retreatment regimen, which could achieve lower failure, relapse and acquired MDR rates in isoniazid monoresistant cases, was predicted to be the most cost-effective strategy in all modelled settings. Empirical MDR treatment of failures of initial treatment was the most costly strategy but resulted in the fewest deaths. Adding ethambutol throughout initial treatment would be most effective in preventing acquired MDR, but would lead to excess cases of blindness. A high priority should be given to improving the standardised retreatment regimen, as this is predicted to produce greater benefits than other recently recommended strategies.

Assessment of protective role of polyherbal preparation, Livina, against anti-tubercular drug induced liver dysfunction.

The present study evaluated the possible protective role of Livina (a polyherbal preparation) against anti-tubercular therapy (ATT)-induced liver dysfunction in patients of pulmonary tuberculosis. Patients were given intensive phase treatment with 4-drugs (rifampicin, INH, pyrazinamide and ethambutol) used for anti-tubercular therapy for 2 months, followed by a 4-month continuous phase treatment with 2 drugs (rifampicin and INH) under clinical advice and supervision. Both qualitative and quantitative measures of liver function were assessed, at different time intervals, before and after ATT. Analysis of data showed that the incidence of qualitative manifestations of liver dysfunction were greater in the placebo treated group as compared to the test drug group. None of the patients of either group showed clinical jaundice. Most signific changes ant were observed in the SGOT and SGPT levels in the placebo group, wherein the levels of both enzymes were higher at 4 and 8 weeks post-ATT, as compared to the respective baseline (0 week) values. When Livina (2 capsules twice daily) was given with ATT drugs, incidence of qualitative manifestation of liver dysfunction was insignificant and SGOT and SGPT levels were also significantly lower than the placebo+AITT drugs treated group. These results indicate that the test drug (Livina) was efficacious, against ATT-induced hepatic dysfunction in patients of pulmonary tuberculosis.

Assessment of in vivo antimalarial activity of rifampicin, isoniazide, and ethambutol combination therapy.

The existing armament of drugs for the treatment and prevention of malaria is inadequate due to development of resistance. In addition to this due to lack of economic enticement the rate of new drug development and new drug discovery in the segment of parasitic diseases is very low as compared to the other segments. This has necessitated the better deployment and usage of existing antimalarial drugs as well as discovery of antimalarial activity of drugs which are well characterized for other diseases; these approaches help to reduce the time and cost required for new drug discovery. The present study evaluated the antimalarial activity of antituberculosis drugs rifampicin, isoniazide, and ethambutol in monotherapy and combination in Plasmodium berghei-infected mice. Animals were observed for mortality, parasite progression, and toxicity for a period of 1 month. Rifampicin + isoniazide and rifampicin + isoniazide + ethambutol treatment resulted in an overall survival rate of 60% compared to 0% in vehicle-fed animals by 4 weeks after post-infection without showing any toxicity.

[Assessment of the use of a multicomponent drug in the treatment of new cases of pulmonary tuberculosis]. / Otsenka primeneniia mnogokomponentnogo preparata v lechenii vpervye vyiavlennykh bol'nykh tuberkulezom legkikh.

The multicomponent drug Mairin-P that contains isoniazid, 60 mg, rifampicin, 120 mg, pyrazinamide, 300 mg, and ethambutol hydrochloride, 225 mg, has been pharmacokinetically and clinically studied. There was no significant difference in the pharmacokinetic parameters of rifampicin as a component of Mairin-P and in combination with antitubercuous agents as free dosage forms. Treatment of first detected patients with pulmonary tuberculosis who isolate drug-sensitive Mycobacterium tuberculosis with Mairin-P is as effective as conventional treatment regimens with antituberculous drugs. Adverse reactions, including non-correctable one, due to the use of Mairin-P occur less frequently than to that of antituberculous drugs.

[Severe course and contingent risk factors in optic neuropathy and myelopathy after tuberculostatics]. / Schwerwiegender Verlauf und belastende Faktoren bei Optikusneuropathie und Myelopathie durch Tuberkulostatika.

A male patient with tuberculous lymphadenopathy was treated with a four-fold therapy of ethambutol, isoniacide, rifampicin and pyracinamide. After 10 weeks the patient suffered from photophobia. Although ethambutol was discontinued vision decreased and visual field defects occurred as well as signs of myelopathy. Isoniacide was then discontinued and in the subsequent phase the vision was slowly restored over a period of 36 months. The combined toxicity of ethambutol and isoniacide seems to have been the main cause of the severe and protracted optic neuropathy.

Four-month, four-drug preventive therapy for inactive pulmonary tuberculosis.

Standard preventive therapy for inactive pulmonary tuberculosis (TB) is 12 mo of isoniazid. Shorter multiple-drug preventive regimens have been proposed. From December 1993 through January 1996 we evaluated a 4-mo, four-drug regimen of preventive therapy for patients with inactive TB, mostly newly arriving immigrants from countries with high rates of TB and of isoniazid resistance. Fifty-three evaluable patients received a 4-mo regimen of isoniazid, rifampin, ethambutol, and pyrazinamide. We compared their completion rate, side effects, and cost of treatment with those of 108 age-matched patients who had received 12 mo of isoniazid at an earlier time. Sixty-eight percent of patients on the 4-mo regimen completed treatment; 69% of those on the 12-mo regimen completed treatment (p = 0.9393). Side effects were more frequent for the 4-mo regimen (30.2%) compared with 12 mo of isoniazid (11.1%) (p = 0. 0027). The cost of providing an uncomplicated, self-supervised regimen was estimated to be almost four times greater for the four-drug regimen compared with isoniazid. These results show that, in terms of compliance, a four-drug, 4-mo regimen had no advantage over standard preventive therapy for persons with inactive pulmonary TB. On the other hand, the shorter, more intensive regimen was associated with more frequent adverse effects and was more costly.