The socioeconomic burden of patients affected by hemophilia with inhibitors.

Hemophilia is associated with a high financial burden on individuals, healthcare systems, and society. The development of inhibitors significantly increases the socioeconomic burden of the diseases. This study aimed to review and describe the burden of hemophilia with inhibitors, providing a reference scenario to assess the impact of new products in the real word. Two systematic literature reviews were performed to collect data on (i) health economics and (ii) health-related quality of life evidences in hemophilic patients with inhibitors. The costs associated with patients with hemophilia and inhibitors are more than 3 times greater than the costs incurred in those without inhibitors, with an annual cost per patient that can be higher than €1 000 000. The costs of bypassing agents account for the large majority of the total healthcare direct costs for hemophilia treatment. The quality of life is more compromised in patients with hemophilia and inhibitors compared to those without inhibitors, in particular the physical domains, whereas mental domains were comparable to that of the general population. The development of an inhibitor has a high impact on costs and quality of life. New treatments have the potential to change positively the management and socioeconomic burden of hemophilia with inhibitors.

Methodologies for data collection in congenital haemophilia with inhibitors (CHwI): critical assessment of the literature and lessons learned from recombinant factor VIIa.

AIMS: To systematically review the effectiveness of on-demand treatment with recombinant coagulation factor VIIa (rFVIIa) in congenital haemophilia with inhibitors and, if feasible, perform a meta-analysis of the data. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Publications from Embase® , MEDLINE® , MEDLINE® In-Process and the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials were searched. Selected publications were reviewed for inclusion by two independent expert reviewers. Discrepancies were reconciled by a third independent reviewer. Data from selected studies were extracted using a predefined grid to ensure uniform and comparable results were captured. RESULTS: A systematic search (cut-off date of 2 May 2016) identified 20 studies (13 observational; seven randomized controlled trials). All studies were of sufficient quality to include in this analysis and comprised 1221 participants, with 5981 bleeds in 746 individuals treated with rFVIIa. Haemostatic overall effectiveness of the individual studies identified ranged from 68% to 100% at ≤12 hours, 86% to 96% at 13-24 hours and 76% to 99% at 24-48 hours with rFVIIa <100 µg/kg, with similar rates reported for the ≥250 µg/kg dose. However, heterogeneity between the studies precluded pooling of results. CONCLUSIONS: Data from the individual studies confirmed that rFVIIa is an effective therapy for the on-demand treatment of bleeds in congenital haemophilia with inhibitors. However, the high levels of heterogeneity between studies precluded pooling of results for a valid, reliable or precise summary measure. There remains a need to implement standardized clinical definitions and measurements for the effectiveness and safety of haemophilia therapies in future clinical trials.

Costs and utilization of hemophilia A and B patients with and without inhibitors.

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the health system costs among patients with hemophilia A and B with and without inhibitors over 5 years. METHODS: This was a retrospective, observational study utilizing medical and pharmacy electronic medical records and administrative encounters/claims data tracking US patients between 2006-2011. Patients with diagnosis codes for hemophilia A and B were identified. Patients with inhibitors were characterized by utilization of bypassing agents activated prothrombin complex concentrate or factor VIIa on two or more distinct dates. Severity was classified as mild, moderate, or severe based on laboratory tests of clotting factor. RESULTS: There were 160 hemophilia A patients and 54 hemophilia B patients identified. From this group, seven were designated as patients with inhibitors (five with hemophilia A and two with hemophilia B). Hemophilia A patients without inhibitors reported 65 (41.9%) as being severe, 19 (12.3%) as moderate, and 71 (45.8%) as mild. Hemophilia B patients without inhibitors reported nine (17.3%) had severe, 13 (25.0%) had moderate, and 30 (57.7%) had mild hemophilia. All patients with inhibitors had been hospitalized in the previous 5 years compared to 64 (41.3%) with hemophilia A without inhibitors and 22 (42.3%) with hemophilia B without inhibitors. The median aggregate cost per year (including factor and health resource use) was $325,780 for patients with inhibitors compared to $98,334 for hemophilia A patients without inhibitors and $23,265 for hemophilia B patients without inhibitors. CONCLUSIONS: The results suggest that, while the frequency of inhibitors within the hemophilia cohort was low, there was a higher frequency of hospitalizations, and the associated median aggregate costs per year were 3-fold higher than those patients without inhibitors. In contrast, hemophilia B patients experience less severe disease and account for lower aggregate yearly costs compared to either patients with hemophilia A or patients with inhibitors.

How we use recombinant activated Factor VII in patients with haemophilia A or B complicated by inhibitors. Working group of hematology experts from Australia and New Zealand, Melbourne, April 2011.

The management of bleeds in patients with haemophilia A or B complicated by inhibitors is complex. Recombinant activated Factor VII (rFVIIa; NovoSeven RT) is an established therapy in these patients. To develop a consensus-based guide on the practical usage of rFVIIa in haemophilia complicated by inhibitors, nine expert haemophilia specialists from Australia and New Zealand developed practice points on the usage of rFVIIa, based on their experience and supported by published data. Practice points were developed for 13 key topics: control of acute bleeding; prophylaxis; surgical prophylaxis; control of breakthrough bleeding during surgery or treatment of acute bleeds; paediatric use; use in elderly; intracranial haemorrhage; immune tolerance induction; difficult bleeds; clinical monitoring of therapy; laboratory monitoring of therapy; concomitant antifibrinolytic medication; practical dosing. Access to home therapy with rFVIIa is important in allowing patients to administer treatment early in bleed management. In adults, 90-120 µg/kg is the favoured starting dose in most settings. Initial dosing using 90-180 µg/kg is recommended for children due to the effect of age on the pharmacokinetics of rFVIIa. In the management of acute bleeds, 2-hourly dosing is appropriate until bleeding is controlled, with concomitant antifibrinolytic medication unless contraindicated. The practice points provide guidance on the usage of rFVIIa for all clinicians involved in the management of haemophilia complicated by inhibitors.

Healthcare expenditures for males with haemophilia and employer-sponsored insurance in the United States, 2008.

Although hemophilia has a potentially high economic impact, published estimates of health care costs for Americans with hemophilia are sparse and non-specific as to the non-bleeding complications of the disease. The objective of this study is to estimate average annual health care expenditures for people with hemophilia covered by employer-sponsored insurance, stratified according to the influence of age, type of hemophilia [A (factor VIII deficiency) versus B (factor IX)], presence of neutralizing alloantibody inhibitors and exposure to blood-borne viral infections. Data from the MarketScan Commercial and Medicare Research Databases were used for the period 2002-2008 to identify cases of hemophilia and to estimate mean and median medical expenditures during 2008. A total of 1,164 males with hemophilia were identified with continuous enrollment during 2008, 933 with hemophilia A and 231 with hemophilia B. Mean health care expenditures were $155,136 [median $73,548]. Mean costs for 30 (3%) males with an inhibitor were 5 times higher than for males without an inhibitor, approximately $697,000 [median $330,835] and $144,000 [median $73,321], respectively. Clotting factor concentrate accounted for 70%-82% of total costs. Average costs for 207 adults with HCV or HIV infection were 1.5 times higher than those for adults without infection. Hemophilia treatment is costly, particularly for individuals with neutralizing alloantibody inhibitors who require bypassing agents. Efforts to understand the cause of inhibitors are needed so that prevention strategies can be implemented and the excess costs resulting from this serious complication of hemophilia care can be avoided.

Future characteristics of bypassing agents to improve care of hemophilia inhibitor patients: an economic and health-related quality of life perspective.

Treatment for hemophilia inhibitor patients has improved substantially since the 1980s and 1990s. However, from a health economic perspective, an unmet need persists for better treatment options in terms of health-related quality of life (HRQOL) and cost savings. Hemostatic products alone account for the biggest expense in the care of hemophilia patients. Congenital hemophilia with inhibitors involves lifelong treatment and, with it, substantial long-term costs and lowered HRQOL. To counteract these costs to payers (society) and to improve patient outcomes, improved treatments could increase HRQOL. This could be achieved with factor VIII and factor IX bypassing agents that have greater convenience through subcutaneous administration (less painful injections and avoidance of infusions) and a faster onset through a fast-acting recombinant activated factor VII analog (faster resolution of bleeding episodes leading to faster pain relief, sustained control and less dosing). In short, improved factor VIII/IX bypassing agents for treatment of hemophilia patients with inhibitors would be a cost-effective option for society, improving HRQOL associated with the clinical condition, which further decreases the already limited budget impact because costs per patient are reduced for the 3500 hemophilia inhibitor patients worldwide.

Haemophilia B: Christmas disease.

Haemophilia B is an inherited bleeding disorder associated with a deficiency of coagulation factor IX. The hallmark of the severe phenotype is recurrent and spontaneous bleeding into joints, which can lead to joint deformity and arthritis at an early age. Recombinant factor IX is now increasingly regarded as the treatment of choice because it does not transmit human pathogens. All patients in the UK now receive this product exclusively. Conventional treatment now consists of the administration of recombinant factor IX concentrate on a prophylactic basis to prevent bleeds and, hence, minimise disability in the long term. Trials of gene therapy are also underway, but these are in the very early stages and will not be a realistic option for at least another 20 years.

Cost-utility analysis of recombinant factor VIIa (NovoSeven) in six children with long-standing inhibitors to factor VIII or IX.

The high cost of treating patients with inhibitors in an environment of restricted budgets warrants consideration of cost-effectiveness. We determined the clinical response, effect on quality of life and the cost-effectiveness of treatment with rFVIIa in six boys with long-standing inhibitors to factors VIII or IX, compared with other treatment regimes previously used in these patients. The study used a longitudinal before-and-after design and was conducted in three phases. Phase 1 was 6 months preceding the introduction of rFVIIa, during which patients received on-demand 'usual care' with other treatment regimes; phase 2 was 6 months treatment on rFVIIa assessed retrospectively; and phase 3 was 6 months on rfVIIa treatment assessed prospectively. Treatment with rFVIIa was reserved for intrarticular, compartment, psoas, mucosal and suspected intracranial bleeding. Treatment outcomes were obtained by interview using structured questionnaires, the quality-of-life instruments CHQ CF-80 and CHQ PF-50, patient self-reporting diary, interrogation of hospital records, and the EuroQoL EQ-5D for utility valuations. Our results confirm that rFVIIa is clinically effective and resulted in 63-92% reductions in the number of re-treatments, duration of painful episodes, delay to initiation of treatment, days requiring wheelchair or crutches, emergency room visits and lost carer time compared with the patients' other therapies. Quality-of-life improvements were observed in several important areas as perceived by both patients and their families, at an incremental cost per QALY of A$51 533.

Immune tolerance therapy for haemophilia.

The development of anti-factor VIII and anti-factor IX allo-antibodies in haemophilia A and B, respectively, remains a serious complication of treatment for these two X-linked haemostatic disorders, with major clinical and economic consequences. Treatment of this potentially fatal complication remains one of the greatest challenges facing haematologists at the beginning of the 21st century. Immune tolerance induction (ITI) therapy has been generally accepted as the best available treatment, extinguishing the inhibitor and permitting a resumption of standard dosing schedules. Although there have been several established protocols for ITI therapy developed over the last quarter century, the optimal scheme in terms of safety, clinical efficacy and pharmacoeconomic considerations has yet to be determined.

Hemophilia. Treatment of patients with inhibitors: cost issues.

The management of bleeding episodes and surgery in haemophilia patients who develop inhibitors is specially difficult and also has major impact on therapeutic costs. We assessed the costs of coagulation factors in noninhibitor haemophilia A and B patients (0 Inh; n=103), patients with low responding inhibitors (LR; n=24), patients with high responding inhibitors (HR; n=17) in our centre between 1988 and 1998 during two periods: 1988-1995 and 1996-1998, before and after the introduction of recombinant factor VIIa in France (1996). From 1988 to 1995 the mean annual cost of 0 inh and LR patients was 43 234 and 49 422, respectively, with more than 90% as home treatment, whereas the mean cost of HR patients was 56 262 (1.3 time more than 0 Inh), half of this cost being related to treatment administered in hospital. From 1996 to 1998, the mean cost of HR patients was 186 482, approximately three times more than that of 0 Inh (59 887) and LR patients (54 226) with half of the cost due to treatment administered in hospital. So rFVIIa seems to exert a major economic effect on both the cost of home treatment and treatment administered in hospital. It must be pointed out that particularly severe bleeding episodes were effectively treated with rFVIIa during this period and that rFVIIa allowed surgery to be undertaken: including two elective orthopaedic surgeries. So there is no doubt that rFVIIa offers new perspectives in the therapeutic management of HR patients, but creates a new economic situation which needs further evaluation.

[Prospective matched control study concerning the treatment and quality of life of hemophiliacs with inhibitors].

Factor VIII (IX) inhibitors represent one of the most serious problems for the treatment of patients with hemophilia. The Blood Products Research Organization (Japan) has supported a study group for treatment of hemophiliacs with inhibitors. In 1995 the study group started a prospective matched control study of hemophiliacs with and without inhibitors and compared such factors as quality of life and economic cost. Each inhibitor patient was matched with a control patient in terms of age, type of hemophilia, and severity of hemophilia. A total of 136 patient-pairs were enrolled. Bleeding episodes were more frequent in the control group than in the inhibitor group. Days of hospitalization, days in wheelchairs, and the number of impaired joints were significantly higher for the inhibitor group. Number of blood-product infusions, days of bed rest at home, and days of brace use were the same for both groups. Blood-product expenditures were significantly higher for the inhibitor group than for the control group (yen 10,872,283/patient/year vs. yen 4,327,542/patient/year). Our study highlighted the higher cost of treatment and lower quality of life for hemophiliaes with Factor VII inhibitors.

How will immune tolerance protocols affect self-sufficiency goals?

Inhibitor development is a serious complication in haemophilia, and its treatment, immune tolerance therapy, is an expensive part of haemophilia treatment. However, the therapy can lead to an increased lifespan and improved quality of life. If commenced sufficiently early in the disease, it can help to reduce the overall amount of factor VIII concentrate, or other plasma derived therapeutic agents required during life.