An analysis of glaucoma repeat measures assessment results: Are core competencies enough?

PURPOSE: The need to validate core competency skills in qualified optometrists wishing to take part in extended roles in glaucoma care has been questioned. This analysis examines the ability of qualified optometrists to perform relevant core competency skills under standardised objective assessment conditions to explore whether such validation is justified. It also investigates if there are associations between performance, gender and length of time since qualification. METHODS: Anonymised data from the Cardiff University assessment programme for the Wales Optometry Postgraduate Education Centre (WOPEC) Local Optical Committee Support Unit glaucoma referral filtering and monitoring pathway delivered between January 2017 and March 2020 were analysed. Results were combined with demographic data from the General Optical Council register of optometrists in the UK to investigate associations between performance and practitioner characteristics, namely length of time since qualification and gender. RESULTS: The assessment results of 2215 optometrists practising in England (approximately 15% of all UK registered optometrists and 30% of all optometrists registered in England) were analysed. Failure rates for first time assessment in each of five objective structured clinical examination style practical assessments were 8.5% (van Herick); 8.8% (slit lamp binocular indirect ophthalmoscopy); 10.1% (Goldmann applanation tonometry calibration); 21.9% (Goldmann applanation tonometry) and 23.3% (case scenario interpretation and management). There were either no associations or at most very weak associations between performance and practitioner characteristics. CONCLUSIONS: Our results suggest that these competencies are not universally present in optometrists practising in England and that ongoing training and assessment of these competencies is justified for entry into extended roles. There are no meaningful associations between performance in these assessments and gender or time since qualification.

Delisted routine eye examinations for nonrefractive eye conditions: a comparative analysis.

BACKGROUND: In 2004, Ontario delisted routine eye examinations for people aged 20-64 years, potentially encouraging patients seeking eye care to visit government-insured primary care providers (PCPs) rather than optometrists whose services had been deinsured. We investigated if utilization of PCP services for nonrefractive eye conditions increased after 2004 among Ontarians who were affected by the delisting. METHODS: We conducted a comparative analysis of the utilization of PCP services for nonrefractive eye conditions in Ontario using administrative data from 2000 to 2014. We included participants without a visit to government-insured optometrists or ophthalmologists in the year before the study year; we excluded participants with existing diabetes. Changes in utilization before and after delisting were statistically assessed using segmented regression analysis in subgroups stratified by age, sex, rurality and neighbourhood income. RESULTS: A significant increase in utilization of PCP services for nonrefractive ocular diagnoses after 2004 was documented among people affected by the delisting: 17.8% (95% confidence interval [CI] 17.0% to 18.7%) for people aged 20-39 years and 11.6% (95% CI 10.6% to 12.5%) for people aged 40-64 years. This corresponds to an increase in the number of patients who visited PCPs for nonrefractive ocular diagnoses of 10 690 (95% CI 321 to 21 059) for people aged 20-39 years and 20 682 (95% CI -94 to 41 457) for people aged 40-64 years. Among people aged 65 years and older (an age group not affected by the delisting), utilization of PCP services for nonrefractive ocular diagnoses was stable (p = 0.95) throughout the study period. Changes in utilization of PCP services for nonocular diagnoses were nonsignificant among people aged 0-19, 40-64 and 65 years and older. INTERPRETATION: After delisting, utilization of the services of government-funded PCPs for nonrefractive ocular diagnoses significantly increased among Ontarians affected by the delisting. The impact on ocular outcomes and the cost-effectiveness of increased use of PCPs for ocular management warrants further investigation and policy-makers' consideration.

Determinantes sociales de la salud y la enfermedad visual en caficultores de Caldas, Colombia / Social Determinants of Health and Visual Disease in Coffee Harvesters from Colombia

Introducción: Aunque existen iniciativas globales que buscan mejorar la salud visual en las poblaciones y alcanzar una mayor inclusión social de las personas afectadas con pérdida de la visión, coexisten barreras importantes como la poca accesibilidad y equidad de los servicios de salud y las diferencias económicas y de género que impiden obtener mejores indicadores. Objetivo: Establecer la asociación entre los determinantes sociales de la salud y la enfermedad visual en una comunidad de caficultores en el Departamento de Caldas, Colombia. Métodos: Estudio descriptivo correlacional en el que participaron 1387 caficultores. La información se recolectó en el momento de la valoración por optometría. Se aplicó un cuestionario para explorar los determinantes sociales de la salud estructurales e intermedios y datos relacionados con salud visual. La asociación entre las variables fue establecida a través de la prueba de chi cuadrado. Resultados: La edad promedio fue de 57 años ± 10,7 años, 77,3 por ciento hombres, el 97,2 por ciento pertenecía al estrato socioeconómico bajo y un 73 por ciento habían realizado estudios primarios. Las enfermedades visuales más frecuentes fueron los trastornos de refracción en un 85,7 por ciento, el principal diagnóstico fue la presbicia con una prevalencia de 75,8 por ciento (IC 95 por ciento: 73,5 por ciento; 78,03 por ciento). En el análisis bivariado se encontró asociación estadísticamente significativa (p < 0,05) entre el diagnóstico de optometría y los determinantes sociales de la salud estructurales e intermedios: sexo, estado civil, grupo de edad, nivel educativo, estrato socioeconómico y ocupación. Conclusiones: La enfermedad visual en caficultores se encuentra influenciada por determinantes sociales de la salud estructurales e intermedios, modificables con acciones intersectoriales y transectoriales como el nivel educativo, estrato socioeconómico y la ocupación, los que deben ser incorporados a las políticas públicas para mejorar su calidad de vida y reducir la ceguera prevenible(AU)

Introduction: Although there are global initiatives aimed at improving visual health in populations and at achieving greater social inclusion of people affected with vision loss, important barriers coexist such as poor accessibility and equity of healthcare services and economic and gender-related differences that prevent obtaining better indicators. Objective: To establish the association between the social determinants of health and visual disease in a community of coffee harvesters in the department of Caldas, Colombia. Methods: Descriptive and correlational study with the participation of 1,387 coffee harvesters. The information was collected at the time of optometric assessment. A questionnaire was applied to explore the structural and intermediate social determinants of health and data related to visual health. The association between the variables was established through the chi-square test. Results: The average age was 57 years ± 10.7 years, 77.3 percent were men, 97.2 percent belonged to the low socioeconomic stratum and 73 percent had completed elementary school. The most frequent visual diseases were refractive disorders, account ting for 85.7 percent; and the main diagnosis was presbyopia, with a prevalence of 75.8 percent (95 percent CI: 73.5 percent; 78.03 percent). The bivariate analysis showed a statistically significant association (p<0.05) between the diagnosis of optometry and the structural and intermediate social determinants of health: sex, marital status, age group, educational level, socioeconomic status, and occupation. Conclusions: Visual disease in coffee harvesters is influenced by structural and intermediate social determinants of health, modifiable with intersector and cross-sector actions such as educational level, socioeconomic stratum, and occupation, which must be incorporated into public policies to improve their quality of life and to reduce preventable blindness(AU)

Supporting Dry Eye Diagnosis with a New Method for Noninvasive Tear Film Quality Assessment.

SIGNIFICANCE: Noninvasive high-speed videokeratoscopy equipped with specific software has shown potential for assessing the homeostasis of tear film, providing clinicians with a fast and consistent tool for supporting dry eye diagnosis and management. PURPOSE: The purpose of this study was to evaluate the efficacy of a recently proposed method for characterizing tear film dynamics using noninvasive high-speed videokeratoscopy in assessing the loss of homeostasis of tear film. METHODS: Thirty subjects from a retrospective study, of which 11 were classified as dry eye and 19 as healthy, were included. High-speed videokeratoscopy measurements were performed using E300 videokeratoscope (Medmont Pty., Ltd., Melbourne, Australia). Raw data were analyzed using a recently proposed method to estimate the dynamics of the tear film based on a fractal dimension approach. This method provides three time-varying indicators related to the regularity of the reflected rings: tear film surface quality indicator, breaks feature indicator, and distortions feature indicator. From each indicator, five parameters were extracted and analyzed, including noninvasive breakup time, mean value of the indicator in the stability phase, mean value of the indicator in the whole interblink interval, mean value of the indicator in the leveling phase, and the general trend of the time series. Receiver operating characteristic curves were used to determine the sensitivity and specificity of each parameter in dry eye detection. RESULTS: The best discrimination performance between dry eye and healthy subjects was achieved with the breaks feature indicator noninvasive breakup time parameter, with an area under the curve of 0.85. For a cutoff value of 10 seconds, the sensitivity was 100% and the specificity was 84%. CONCLUSIONS: The analyzed method improves the assessment of tear film homeostasis in comparison with previous high-speed videokeratoscopy methods showing higher potential in assisting dry eye diagnosis.

Assessment of near visual acuity in 0-13 year olds with normal and low vision: a systematic review.

BACKGROUND: The inclusion for rehabilitation of visually impaired children is partly based on the measurement of near vision, but guidelines for near visual acuity assessment are currently lacking. The twofold purpose of this systematic review was to: (i) provide an overview of the impact of the chart design on near visual acuity measured, and (ii) determine the method of choice for near vision assessments in children of different developmental ages. METHODS: A literature search was conducted by using the following electronic databases: PubMed, Cochrane Library, and EMBASE. The last search was run on March 26th 2016. Additional studies were identified by contacting experts and searching for relevant articles in reference lists of included studies. Search terms were: vision test(s), vision assessment(s), visual acuity, chart(s) and near. RESULTS: For children aged 0-3 years the golden standard is still the preferential looking procedure. Norms are available for this procedure for 6-36 month old children. For 4-7 year olds, we recommend using the LEA symbols, because these symbols have been properly validated and can be used in preliterate children. Responses can be verbal or by matching the target symbol. In children aged 8-13 years, the recommended method is the ETDRS letter chart, because letter acuity is more predictive for functional vision and reading than symbol acuity. In 8-13 year olds, letter acuity is 0.1-0.2 logMAR poorer than symbol acuity. CONCLUSIONS: Chart design, viewing distance, and threshold choice have a serious impact on near visual acuity measurements. Near visual acuity measured with symbols is lower than near visual acuity measured with gratings, and near visual acuity measured with letters is lower than near visual acuity measured with symbols. Viewing distance, chart used, and letter spacing should be adapted to the child's development and reported in order to allow comparisons between measurements.

Influence of education and diagnostic modes on glaucoma assessment by optometrists.

PURPOSE: To evaluate the influence of different clinical examination techniques, including optic nerve head (ONH) photography, visual field tests, and adjunct imaging on the diagnosis of glaucoma by Australian and New Zealand optometrists. The effect of a short-term, didactic teaching module on these is also explored. METHODS: Clinical data of 30 patients previously seen at the Centre for Eye Health was collected and compiled into glaucoma diagnostic assessment modules. Each of six modules contained different combinations of clinical examination results and required a classification of the cases as normal, suspicious or glaucoma. A cohort of 54 Australian and New Zealand optometrists were recruited for the study and allocated into two cohorts. The intervention group completed a glaucoma training course prior to the assessment while the control group completed the assessment without additional training. Diagnostic accuracy was compared between modules and optometrist groups. RESULTS: High false negative rates were observed with ONH photography, which were drastically reduced with the addition of visual field, albeit at the cost of increased false positive rates. Addition of adjunct imaging techniques partially compensated for the increase in the false positive rate from the visual field, but had limited effect on false negative rate. Educational intervention resulted in larger improvement in the diagnostic ability when multiple imaging modalities were provided. CONCLUSION: The study highlighted the importance of combining both structural and functional assessments in glaucoma. Current imaging technology demonstrated limited usefulness for event diagnosis due to the persistent difficulties of defining structural and functional loss in glaucoma, thus highlighting the need for new glaucoma assessment techniques. Short-term didactic teaching programs may only result in limited improvement of glaucoma diagnostic ability in optometrists, and hence, it may need to be combined with long-term and/or non-didactic training components to obtain a greater effect.

Application of clinical techniques relevant for glaucoma assessment by optometrists: concordance with guidelines.

PURPOSE: Guidelines for the screening, prognosis, diagnosis, management and prevention of glaucoma were released by the Australian National Health and Medical Research Council in 2010. Comparable guidance has been made available by respective bodies in the USA and UK at a similar time. Key to successful translation of guidelines into clinical practice includes clinicians having the necessary skills to perform required tests. Optometrists in Australia and New Zealand were invited to participate in an online survey exploring these aspects. The results provide insights for improving glaucoma diagnosis and management by optometric primary eye care practitioners. METHODS: An online questionnaire was developed to investigate glaucoma assessment of optometrists as a function of demographic details, educational background and experience. Key points to ascertain compliance with current guidelines were the availability of equipment, procedural confidence in techniques, and preferences in visual field tests. Chi square statistics was employed to support similarity to national averages and highlight differences between the two countries. Multivariate linear regression analysis identified variables significantly associated with individual tests being available to optometrists and their confidence in applying them. RESULTS: Thirteen per cent of all Australian and 36% of the New Zealand optometrists responded to the survey in 2013, which reflected the demographics/geography of the practising populations. Techniques considered essential or preferred for glaucoma assessment were widely available in both countries with the exception of gonioscopy and pachymetry. After correcting for availability, regression models highlighted therapeutic endorsement and knowledge of glaucoma guidelines as the main variables to maintain high diagnostic confidence. Correlations to number of years in optometric practice mirrored a changed emphasis in teaching and technology over the past 10-15 years. CONCLUSIONS: Australian and New Zealand optometrists were well equipped to perform glaucoma assessments with the possible exception of gonioscopy. Advanced imaging modalities were not yet fully integrated into optometric practice, although optical coherence tomography has shown use by 23-32% of optometrists. A marked increase in use, availability and procedural confidence of gonioscopy and other techniques with therapeutically endorsed optometrists demonstrates the advantage and importance of additional training.

Population-based assessment of sensitivity and specificity of a pinhole for detection of significant refractive errors in the community.

BACKGROUND: Measurements of refractive errors through subjective or automated refraction are not always possible in rapid assessment studies and community vision screening programs; however, measurements of vision with habitual correction and with a pinhole can easily be made. Although improvements in vision with a pinhole are assumed to mean that a refractive error is present, no studies have investigated the magnitude of improvement in vision with pinhole that is predictive of refractive error. The aim was to measure the sensitivity and specificity of 'vision improvement with pinhole' in predicting the presence of refractive error in a community setting. METHODS: Vision and vision with pinhole were measured using a logMAR chart for 488 of 582 individuals aged 15 to 50 years. Refractive errors were measured using non-cycloplegic autorefraction and subjective refraction. The presence of refractive error was defined using spherical equivalent refraction (SER) at two levels: SER greater than ± 0.50 D sphere (DS) and SER greater than ±1.00 DS. Three definitions for significant improvement in vision with a pinhole were used: 1. Presenting vision less than 6/12 and improving to 6/12 or better, 2. Improvement in vision of more than one logMAR line and 3. Improvement in vision of more than two logMAR lines. RESULTS: For refractive error defined as spherical equivalent refraction greater than ± 0.50 DS, the sensitivities and specificities for the pinhole test predicting the presence of refractive error were 83.9 per cent (95% CI: 74.5 to 90.9) and 98.8 per cent (95% CI: 97.1 to 99.6), respectively for definition 1. Definition 2 had a sensitivity 89.7 per cent (95% CI: 81.3 to 95.2) and specificity 88.0 per cent (95% CI: 4.4 to 91.0). Definition 3 had a sensitivity of 75.9 per cent (95% CI: 65.5 to 84.4) and specificity of 97.8 per cent (95% CI: 95.8 to 99.0). Similar results were found with spherical equivalent refraction greater than ±1.00 DS, when tested against the three pinhole-based definitions. CONCLUSION: Refractive error definitions based on improvement in vision with the pinhole shows good sensitivity and specificity at predicting the presence of significant refractive errors. These definitions can be used in rapid assessment surveys and community-based vision screenings.

Intraocular lens implantation position sensitivity as a function of refractive error.

PURPOSE: To quantify the change in ocular aberrations due to intraocular lens (IOL) implantation position errors for pseudo-phakic eyes with different refractive errors. METHODS: The theoretical part of this work was based on ray-tracing in emmetropic and myopic eye models. The possible misalignments i.e. the decentration, tilt and axial translation, of the IOLs were statistically combined together and analysed using Monte-Carlo simulations. Spherical IOLs with a 3 and 5 mm pupil and an aspheric IOL with a 5 mm pupil were analysed as a function of refractive error. In the experimental part of the work, we built an IOL optical test bench including a model eye. The white light discrete point spread functions of misaligned IOLs were recorded by a CCD and we compared the change of the spread function as a result of misalignments for two spherical IOLs with different optical powers. RESULTS: The Monte-Carlo simulations showed that the average root-mean-square spot size at the retinal plane decreased with increasing myopic refractive error, i.e. lower power IOL. The experiments showed that a lower optical power spherical IOL had a less distributed point spread function than a higher optical power IOL, which supported the results of the simulation. CONCLUSION: Regarding IOLs designed for myopic patients, low power IOLs (for high myopes) were shown to be less sensitive to the misalignment than high power ones. Aspheric IOLs were more sensitive to position errors than spherical IOLs under the same conditions.