Proximal Row Carpectomy versus Four-Corner Arthrodesis for the Treatment of Scapholunate Advanced Collapse/Scaphoid Nonunion Advanced Collapse Wrist: A Cost-Utility Analysis.

BACKGROUND: Two mainstay surgical options for salvage in scapholunate advanced collapse and scaphoid nonunion advanced collapse are proximal row carpectomy and four-corner arthrodesis. This study evaluates the cost-utility of proximal row carpectomy versus three methods of four-corner arthrodesis for the treatment of scapholunate advanced collapse/scaphoid nonunion advanced collapse wrist. METHODS: A cost-utility analysis was performed in accordance with the Second Panel on Cost-Effectiveness in Health and Medicine. A comprehensive literature review was performed to obtain the probability of potential complications. Costs were derived using both societal and health care sector perspectives. A visual analogue scale survey of expert hand surgeons estimated utilities. Overall cost, probabilities, and quality-adjusted life-years were used to complete a decision tree analysis. Both deterministic and probabilistic sensitivity analyses were performed. RESULTS: Forty studies yielding 1730 scapholunate advanced collapse/scaphoid nonunion advanced collapse wrists were identified. Decision tree analysis determined that both four-corner arthrodesis with screw fixation and proximal row carpectomy were cost-effective options, but four-corner arthrodesis with screw was the optimal treatment strategy. Four-corner arthrodesis with Kirschner-wire fixation and four-corner arthrodesis with plate fixation were dominated (inferior) strategies and therefore not cost-effective. One-way sensitivity analysis demonstrated that when the quality-adjusted life-years for a successful four-corner arthrodesis with screw fixation are lower than 26.36, proximal row carpectomy becomes the optimal strategy. However, multivariate probabilistic sensitivity analysis confirmed the results of our model. CONCLUSIONS: Four-corner arthrodesis with screw fixation and proximal row carpectomy are both cost-effective treatment options for scapholunate advanced collapse/scaphoid nonunion advanced collapse wrist because of their lower complication profile and high efficacy, with four-corner arthrodesis with screw as the most cost-effective treatment. Four-corner arthrodesis with plate and Kirschner-wire fixation should be avoided from a cost-effectiveness standpoint.

[Occult fractures of the carpal navicular. Detection by quantitative radioscintigraphy. Social and medico-legal repercussions]. / Les fractures occultes du scaphoïde carpien Détection par la radioscintigraphie quantitative. Incidences sociales et médico-légales.

Fractures of the scaphoid of the wrist are not easily diagnosed and when they are eventually recognized due to late complications, the prognosis is much poorer than it would have been at injury. Medical negligence and poorly-performed or interpreted x-rays are frequently cited as reasons for non-diagnosis. Often these fractures are trabecular, so-called occult, and they cannot be seen on a conventional exam, even if well-performed. Tomography and tomodensitometry have yielded poor results. Quantitative radioscintigraphy (QRS), the exam we are proposing, is a modification of scintigraphy, which is a very sensitive exam (100%) but has little specificity. The first step in QRS is to quantify the fixation of the tracer on the injured side and compare it to that of the uninjured side. If the injured side fixation is double that of the uninjured side, a fracture (often scaphoid) is present. MRI is our reference. In the second step in QRS, a computer-assisted fusion is made of the scintigraphic image and the x-ray (quantitative scintigraphy has the same diagnostic value as MRI). The center of the fracture is localized, thus yielding a specificity of nearly 100% for this exam. Out of a prospective series of 154 patients who had a conventional examination: 41% were diagnosed to have a scaphoid fracture using QSR, therefore a number higher than supposed. Rare carpal fractures were also detected. The cost of this exam is low. The exam climinates non-diagnosed fractures which can lead to non-union and arthrosis. Due to the frequency of carpal trauma, this exam should have a significant effect on the individual, on social security costs and litigations.

The treatment of pseudoarthrosis of the scaphoid by bone grafting and three methods of internal fixation.

OBJECTIVES: To measure the rate of union in patients with pseudoarthosis of the scaphoid, treated with trapezoidal bone grafting as outlined by Fernandez and 1 of 3 methods of internal fixation and to compare unions versus nonunions and potential predictors of union to determine if associations exist. DESIGN: A retrospective radiologic study of scaphoid pseudoarthroses. SETTING: Division of Orthopedic Surgery, Ottawa Hospital, General Site, a tertiary care facility. PATIENTS: Thirty-four patients with nonunion of scaphoid fractures, treated between 1990 and 1997, with an average follow-up of 19.8 months. INTERVENTIONS: Trapezoidal bone grafting and internal fixation with Kirschner (K) wires, an AO cannulated screw or a Herbert screw. OUTCOME MEASURES: The time to union of scaphoid pseudoarthroses and predictors of union, including the classification, location of pseudoarthrosis, type of internal fixation and length of bone graft. RESULTS: The results showed a correlation between the classification and location of the fracture as determined radiologically, and the outcome. There was no correlation between the type of internal fixation used and the outcome, or between the length of the bone graft and the outcome. Twenty-three patients had radiologically demonstrated union after a mean time of 8.2 months; 16 of 24 patients achieved successful union when treated with K-wire implants, after a mean time of 7.2 months. CONCLUSIONS: Trapezoidal bone grafting and internal fixation with K wires is a practical technique, classification and location of the fracture notwithstanding. Time to union is long, and the results may be unpredictable. Use of K wires for internal fixation presents the clinician with an alternative to fixation with either the AO cannulated screw or the Herbert screw, and has the advantages of cost, ease of insertion and accessibility. This method may therefore be the treatment of choice in developing countries. Resection of the area of pseudoarthrosis must include all fibrous tissue and sclerotic bone. The length of graft, within the parameters of this study, did not affect the outcome.

[Comparison of various evaluation measures for assessment of treatment success after scaphoid injuries]. / Vergleich verschiedener Bewertungsmassstäbe zur Beurteilung des Behandlungserfolges nach Kahnbeinverletzungen.

Different evaluation scores have been developed in order to assess treatment outcome of carpal injuries. The available scores are not comparable and differ in type and number of parameters. This is a retrospective study of 100 patients who presented with a fracture or a pseudarthrosis of the scaphoid from 1983 to 1997. The Cooney and the Meine scores were compared with our own score. While the Cooney score and the newly developed score show an equal distribution of results in all categories, the score of Meine led to an overall better outcome assessment. The comparative evaluation of the different scores shows that the combination of only a few well defined parameters is sufficient for assessing the treatment outcome of carpal injuries.

Time off work due to scaphoid fractures and other carpal injuries in The Netherlands in the period 1990 to 1993.

This study assessed the epidemiology, treatment, disability and time off work due to carpal injuries in the Netherlands in the period from 1990 to 1993. Most injuries were scaphoid fractures and carpal instabilities were rare. The time off work was considerable (mean, 155 days; median, 105 days; range, 12-1708 days). Patients with non-scaphoid fractures had the shortest time off work, followed by those with scaphoid fractures; patients with carpal instabilities had the longest time off work. Despite the significant time off work, the prognosis for return to work was excellent.

Occult fractures of the scaphoid. The diagnostic usefulness and indirect economic repercussions of radiography versus magnetic resonance scanning.

Scaphoid fractures that are not visible on initial radiographs are notoriously difficult to diagnose. This prospective study compared four-view plain radiography at an average of 14 days after injury, with high-definition macroradiography and magnetic resonance imaging at presentation. Initial magnetic resonance imaging was superior to repeat scaphoid radiography for the confirmation or exclusion of fractures as well as for the detection of associated wrist injuries. Macroradiography was unsuitable for screening for occult scaphoid fractures.

[Traditional radiology in the assessment of posttraumatic carpal instability]. / La radiologia tradizionale nella valutazione dell'instabilità carpale post-traumatica.

INTRODUCTION: Carpal instability is a painful posttraumatic syndrome with early or late loss of the normal alignment of the carpal bones, which can be caused by a variety of injuries, from minor sprain to major fracture-dislocation of the carpal-wrist complex. If the trauma causing instability is a fracture, a severe dislocation or a fracture-dislocation, the radiographic diagnosis is not particularly difficult. The morphologic and dynamic complexity of the carpal region represents, instead, a major obstacle in the radiologic diagnosis of mild or moderate sprains because the morphologic alterations on standard static views are minimal or absent in these conditions. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We reviewed 214 injuries causing posttraumatic carpal instability including both the cases classified by the Data Analysis Center of the Istituto Ortopedico Rizzoli as carpal dislocations and fracture-dislocations from January, 1975, to July, 1996, and the more recent cases directly observed at our Casualty Clinic. In the former cases, we reviewed only the available images, while our patients were examined with comparative standard and under stress or dynamic views. RESULTS: Of 214 lesions causing posttraumatic carpal instability, 43 along the great arch were classified as severe because they were easily detectable on standard films and 171 along the small arch were classified as mild because slight/no abnormalities were detected on standard static views. Only dynamic imaging showed posttraumatic carpal instability demonstrating the integrity of the ligaments and of the carpal hinges, as well as gaps or asymmetry not detected on static views. CONCLUSIONS: We suggest the systematic use of dynamic imaging in the cases where static findings are negative or poor, in the patients with a painful wrist after an apparently minor sprain. Missed or delayed diagnoses are thus reduced, as well as the consequent joint incongruity and/or chronic subluxation which may severely impair these patients.

Magnetic resonance imaging of occult scaphoid fractures.

Occult fractures of the scaphoid bone occur frequently and may lead to nonunions. In a prospective blind study, we performed magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) examinations on 32 patients who had sustained a wrist injury and in whom a scaphoid fracture was clinically suspected, but could not be confirmed on the original set of two routine and four scaphoid view radiographs. The MRI examinations were performed an average time of 2.8 days after the trauma. This prospective study proved that MRI is able to diagnose occult scaphoid fractures without delay and without the use of radioactive diagnostic means. Sensitivity and specificity of MRI were 100%. This conventional method could save $7,200 (US) per 100,000 inhabitants in providing an immediate and correct diagnosis and avoiding unnecessary cast immobilization. Additional injuries that may be misdiagnosed by conventional radiographs are also detected with a specificity and sensitivity of 100%.

The effect of workers' or third-party compensation on return to work after hand surgery.

OBJECTIVES: To investigate the role of compensation in recovery from scaphoid internal fixation. DESIGN: Retrospective review of patients who had had scaphoid internal fixations performed by one surgeon between 1 September 1981 and 31 December 1994 with a minimum follow-up of six months. SETTING: Private practice of a specialist hand surgeon. PATIENTS: 202 patients who attended for the minimum of six months' follow-up, and for whom accurate details of return-to-work time were available. INTERVENTION: Internal fixation of scaphoid fractures using the Herbert bone screw without postoperative immobilisation. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Return-to-work time and compensation status. RESULTS: Overall, patients receiving compensation took more than twice as long as privately insured individuals to return to work after scaphoid internal fixation (7.3 v. 3.3 weeks). There was no difference for clerical workers, but for manual workers compensable individuals took significantly longer (P < 0.001) to return to work. Compensation status did not affect bony union, postoperative wrist function, pain or patient satisfaction. CONCLUSIONS: Compensation encourages a slower return to work after surgery. The current compensation system could save millions of dollars each year by incorporating incentives to return to work without sacrificing good surgical results.

Clinical assessment of scaphoid injuries and the detection of fractures.

Difficulty in interpreting X-rays following carpal injury emphasizes the importance of clinical assessment in diagnosing scaphoid fractures. The classical sign of tenderness in the anatomical snuffbox is not specific and leads to many unnecessary out-patient reviews. A prospective comparison was made between anatomical snuffbox, scaphoid tubercle and scaphoid compression tenderness as indicators of scaphoid fracture in 221 patients with suspected scaphoid injury. Swelling was determined by measuring the difference in circumference at the wrist joint to compare between fracture and soft tissue injury. Scaphoid compression tenderness was found to be the most accurate test with a sensitivity of 100% and a specificity of 80%. Swelling of the wrist joint was significantly greater when there was a fracture, compared to soft tissue injury alone, even when the initial X-ray was normal. This was independent of any physiological variation in circumference between dominant and non-dominant sides. Scaphoid compression tenderness is therefore suggested as the most accurate indicator of scaphoid fracture and marked swelling should raise suspicion even if the X-ray is normal.

Choosing a strategy for the diagnostic management of suspected scaphoid fracture: a cost-effectiveness analysis.

UNLABELLED: To assess the cost-effectiveness of various strategies for the diagnostic management of clinically suspected scaphoid fracture, a decision-analytic model was built to evaluate three strategies and to compare them with a (clairvoyant) reference diagnostic management strategy. METHODS: Evaluated strategies were: (A) repeated radiography up to 2 wk; (B) repeat radiography up to 6 wk; and (C) radiography, followed by bone scintigraphy in patients with negative initial radiographs. Therapy consisted of 12 wk of immobilization for a radiographically or scintigraphically proven fracture. Diagnostic costs, therapeutic costs, period of immobilization and nonunion rate were calculated for all three strategies. Estimates were derived from a descriptive management study using bone scintigraphy and available literature. Sensitivity analyses were performed. RESULTS: Overall costs were 273.7, 317.7 and 316.1 European Currency Units (ECU) for Strategies A, B and C, respectively (1 ECU = 1.15 U.S. dollar). Strategy B led to the longest average period of immobilization (8.6 wk), while Strategy A resulted in the highest nonunion rate (4.7%). The costs per nonunion saved for the additional use of bone scintigraphy (Strategy C) was ECU 2618 when compared to Strategy A. CONCLUSION: The use of bone scintigraphy in the diagnostic management of scaphoid fractures is accurate, convenient for patients and cost-effective.

[Scaphoid pseudarthrosis and capitate fracture]. / Kahnbeinpseudarthrose und Kopfbeinfraktur.

Two successive injuries to the same wrist of a patient led first to a scaphoid non-union and second to a capitate fracture. The case history, treatment and medicolegal implications are discussed.

Real time ultrasonography in the assessment of movement at the site of a scaphoid fracture non-union.

We investigated the use of real time linear ultrasonography in determining movement at a scaphoid fracture site in 27 patients with non-united scaphoid fractures. 24 of these patients had surgical treatment. Fracture movement was observed at the time of surgery and this was compared with the ultrasonographic findings. The technique proved to be 100% specific for visualization of movement at the fracture site and it was non-invasive. However, it was of no benefit in assessing proximal pole non-union.

Scaphoid fracture: a new method of assessment.

The value of colour flow Doppler ultrasound scanning in patients with suspected acute carpal scaphoid fracture has been examined. A prospective study of 78 patients with signs and symptoms of carpal scaphoid injury was undertaken over a period of 6 months. Both wrists of all patients were scanned within 12-72 h of injury. The radial artery and carpal scaphoid bone contours are visible using this type of imaging technique. The distance between the medial wall of the radial artery and the outer cortex of the scaphoid waist was measured. The scaphoid index is described and was calculated from this measurement. Patients were managed without knowledge of the ultrasound imaging result, using plain radiographs and clinical examination as the standard for determining the presence of a scaphoid fracture. All patients were followed to the resolution of symptoms. All 12 patients who were subsequently considered to have scaphoid fractures were identified using this imaging technique within 12-72 h after injury. We conclude that this imaging may be useful in the assessment of patients with carpal scaphoid fracture. It can be used early, as a supplementary investigation, in patients with suspected carpal scaphoid fracture in whom the initial plain radiographs are normal.

[The utility of three-phase bone scintigraphy in the assessment of fractured carpal scaphoid].

Thirty-seven joints in 36 patients with a fractured carpal scaphoid were evaluated by three-phase bone scintigraphy. They were classified into two groups according to their progress. Some were in good clinical condition and some in a non-union condition. Increased blood flow in the radial arteries and ample perfusion on and around the scaphoid bones on blood flow images suggested a good clinical course. The activity and the effectiveness of remodeling correlated well with the degree of scaphoid uptake on blood pool images taken more than seven days after the injury. Scaphoid uptake was more localized or there was almost none on blood pool images in cases with nearly complete recovery while it was amply visualized on static images. Blood pool images were indispensable for analyzing lesions and evaluating the clinical course. Two typical findings of scaphoid fractures were found on both blood pool and static images. One was diffusely increased scaphoid uptake seen in cases with a good clinical course, and the other was decreased uptake at proximal fragments seen in cases with non-union. It is concluded that three-phase bone scintigraphy provides useful information for evaluating the process of scaphoid fractures which cannot be obtained by means of conventional bone scintigraphy.

Scaphoid fractures: assessment and treatment.

The scaphoid is the most commonly fractured carpal bone. The fracture pattern and its relationship to the blood supply have significant implications regarding treatment and prognosis. Prompt recognition and treatment are fundamental to successful management.

Ultrasound assessment of the suspected scaphoid fracture.

A prospective study of 111 patients thought to have sustained a recent scaphoid fracture on clinical grounds but who were radiologically negative was undertaken over a period of 7 months. All such patients were subjected to ultrasound scanning within a week of their injury under double blind conditions. All patients were re-X-rayed 2-3 weeks after their injury. The authors' results suggest that ultrasonic diagnosis of the possibly fractured scaphoid is unreliable.