Ethical and Equity Guidance for Transplant Programs Considering Thoracoabdominal Normothermic Regional Perfusion (TA-NRP) for Procurement of Hearts.

Donation after circulatory determination of death (DCDD) is an accepted practice in the United States, but heart procurement under these circumstances has been debated. Although the practice is experiencing a resurgence due to the recently completed trials using ex vivo perfusion systems, interest in thoracoabdominal normothermic regional perfusion (TA-NRP), wherein the organs are reanimated in situ prior to procurement, has raised many ethical questions. We outline practical, ethical, and equity considerations to ensure transplant programs make well-informed decisions about TA-NRP. We present a multidisciplinary analysis of the relevant ethical issues arising from DCDD-NRP heart procurement, including application of the Dead Donor Rule and the Uniform Definition of Death Act, and provide recommendations to facilitate ethical analysis and input from all interested parties. We also recommend informed consent, as distinct from typical "authorization," for cadaveric organ donation using TA-NRP.

Assessment of Mitochondrial Respiration During Hypothermic Storage of Liver Biopsies Following Normothermic Machine Perfusion.

Organ quality can be assessed prior to transplantation, during normothermic machine perfusion (NMP) of the liver. Evaluation of mitochondrial function by high-resolution respirometry (HRR) may serve as a viability assessment concept in this setting. Freshly collected tissue is considered as optimal sample for HRR, but due to technical and personnel requirements, more flexible and schedulable measurements are needed. However, the impact of cold storage following NMP before processing biopsy samples for mitochondrial analysis remains unknown. We aimed at establishing an appropriate storage protocol of liver biopsies for HRR. Wedge biopsies of 5 human livers during NMP were obtained and assessed by HRR. Analysis was performed after 0, 4, 8, and 12 h of hypothermic storage (HTS) in HTK organ preservation solution at 4°C. With HTS up to 4 h, mitochondrial performance did not decrease in HTS samples compared with 0 h (OXPHOS, 44.62 [34.75-60.15] pmol·s-1·mg wet mass-1 vs. 43.73 [40.69-57.71], median [IQR], p > 0.999). However, at HTS beyond 4 h, mitochondrial respiration decreased. We conclude that HTS can be safely applied for extending the biopsy measurement window for up to 4 h to determine organ quality, but also that human liver respiration degrades beyond 4 h HTS following NMP.

Machine perfusion in liver transplantation: recent advances and coming challenges.

PURPOSE OF REVIEW: Machine perfusion has been adopted into clinical practice in Europe since the mid-2010s and, more recently, in the United States (US) following approval of normothermic machine perfusion (NMP). We aim to review recent advances, provide discussion of potential future directions, and summarize challenges currently facing the field. RECENT FINDINGS: Both NMP and hypothermic-oxygenated perfusion (HOPE) improve overall outcomes after liver transplantation versus traditional static cold storage (SCS) and offer improved logistical flexibility. HOPE offers additional protection to the biliary system stemming from its' protection of mitochondria and lessening of ischemia-reperfusion injury. Normothermic regional perfusion (NRP) is touted to offer similar protective effects on the biliary system, though this has not been studied prospectively.The most critical question remaining is the optimal use cases for each of the three techniques (NMP, HOPE, and NRP), particularly as HOPE and NRP become more available in the US. There are additional questions regarding the most effective criteria for viability assessment and the true economic impact of these techniques. Finally, with each technique purported to allow well tolerated use of riskier grafts, there is an urgent need to define terminology for graft risk, as baseline population differences make comparison of current data challenging. SUMMARY: Machine perfusion is now widely available in all western countries and has become an essential tool in liver transplantation. Identification of the ideal technique for each graft, optimization of viability assessment, cost-effectiveness analyses, and proper definition of graft risk are the next steps to maximizing the utility of these powerful tools.

Moving Boundaries for Improving Organ Transplant Availability.

This brief overview is designed to address the options for increasing organ transplant rates to between 100 and 120 transplanted organs per million population globally. The focus of this review is the data produced through the World Health Organization's Global Observatory on Donation and Transplantation, with consideration for the issues that different countries need to address to achieve higher transplant rates. Without both optimized living donation and optimized deceased donation, rates of transplant are not sufficient to provide for a level of self-dependency for transplant therapy. Deceased donation comprises both donation from donors declared dead after cessation of all functions of the brain and donors declared dead from irreversible cessation of circulation of the blood. The preservation strategies that hold the greatest chance of increasing the utility of marginal and older donors involve normothermic circulation to prevent ischemic damage and potentially restore function of damaged organs. Normothermic in situ perfusion of abdominal organs has demonstrated utility, and consideration must be given to normothermic perfusion of the thoracic organs to improve heart and lung transplants, but this may challenge the legal definitions of death. Each nation must endeavor to increase organ donation capacity across the spectrum of donor types and must address the opportunities that normothermic perfusion of organs at retrieval may offer to alleviate shortages of organs for transplant and provide selfdependency for the communities.

Viability assessment of the liver during ex-situ machine perfusion prior to transplantation.

PURPOSE OF REVIEW: In an attempt to reduce waiting list mortality in liver transplantation, less-than-ideal quality donor livers from extended criteria donors are increasingly accepted. Predicting the outcome of these organs remains a challenge. Machine perfusion provides the unique possibility to assess donor liver viability pretransplantation and predict postreperfusion organ function. RECENT FINDINGS: Assessing liver viability during hypothermic machine perfusion remains challenging, as the liver is not metabolically active. Nevertheless, the levels of flavin mononucleotide, transaminases, lactate dehydrogenase, glucose and pH in the perfusate have proven to be predictors of liver viability. During normothermic machine perfusion, the liver is metabolically active and in addition to the perfusate levels of pH, transaminases, glucose and lactate, the production of bile is a crucial criterion for hepatocyte viability. Cholangiocyte viability can be determined by analyzing bile composition. The differences between perfusate and bile levels of pH, bicarbonate and glucose are good predictors of freedom from ischemic cholangiopathy. SUMMARY: Although consensus is lacking regarding precise cut-off values during machine perfusion, there is general consensus on the importance of evaluating both hepatocyte and cholangiocyte compartments. The challenge is to reach consensus for increased organ utilization, while at the same time pushing the boundaries by expanding the possibilities for viability testing.

Impact of Back-to-Base Normothermic Machine Perfusion on Complications and Costs: A Multicenter, Real-World Risk-Matched Analysis.

OBJECTIVE: Assess cost and complication outcomes after liver transplantation (LT) using normothermic machine perfusion (NMP). BACKGROUND: End-ischemic NMP is often used to aid logistics, yet its impact on outcomes after LT remains unclear, as does its true impact on costs associated with transplantation. METHODS: Deceased donor liver recipients at 2 centers (January 1, 2019, to June 30, 2023) were included. Retransplants, splits, and combined grafts were excluded. End-ischemic NMP (OrganOx-Metra) was implemented in October 2022 for extended-criteria donation after brain death (DBDs), all donations after circulatory deaths (DCDs), and logistics. NMP cases were matched 1:2 with static cold storage controls (SCS) using the Balance-of-Risk [donation after brain death (DBD)-grafts] and UK-DCD Score (DCD-grafts). RESULTS: Overall, 803 transplantations were included, 174 (21.7%) receiving NMP. Matching was achieved between 118 NMP-DBDs with 236 SCS; and 37 NMP-DCD with 74 corresponding SCS. For both graft types, median inpatient comprehensive complications index values were comparable between groups. DCD-NMP grafts experienced reduced cumulative 90-day comprehensive complications index (27.6 vs 41.9, P =0.028). NMP also reduced the need for early relaparotomy and renal replacement therapy, with subsequently less frequent major complications (Clavien-Dindo ≥IVa). This effect was more pronounced in DCD transplants. NMP had no protective effect on early biliary complications. Organ acquisition/preservation costs were higher with NMP, yet NMP-treated grafts had lower 90-day pretransplant costs in the context of shorter waiting list times. Overall costs were comparable for both cohorts. CONCLUSIONS: This is the first risk-adjusted outcome and cost analysis comparing NMP and SCS. In addition to logistical benefits, NMP was associated with a reduction in relaparotomy and bleeding in DBD grafts, and overall complications and post-LT renal replacement for DCDs. While organ acquisition/preservation was more costly with NMP, overall 90-day health care costs-per-transplantation were comparable.

Thoraco-abdominal normothermic regional perfusion for thoracic transplantation in the United States: current state and future directions.

PURPOSE OF REVIEW: To provide an update regarding the state of thoracoabdominal normothermic regional perfusion (taNRP) when used for thoracic organ recovery. RECENT FINDINGS: taNRP is growing in its utilization for thoracic organ recovery from donation after circulatory death donors, partly because of its cost effectiveness. taNRP has been shown to yield cardiac allograft recipient outcomes similar to those of brain-dead donors. Regarding the use of taNRP to recover donor lungs, United Network for Organ Sharing (UNOS) analysis shows that taNRP recovered lungs are noninferior, and taNRP has been used to consistently recover excellent lungs at high volume centers. Despite its growth, ethical debate regarding taNRP continues, though clinical data now supports the notion that there is no meaningful brain perfusion after clamping the aortic arch vessels. SUMMARY: taNRP is an excellent method for recovering both heart and lungs from donation after circulatory death donors and yields satisfactory recipient outcomes in a cost-effective manner. taNRP is now endorsed by the American Society of Transplant Surgeons, though ethical debate continues.

Financial impact of donation after circulatory death heart transplantation: A single-center analysis.

INTRODUCTION: Clinical success of donation after circulatory death (DCD) heart transplantation is leading to growing adoption of this technique. In comparison to procurement from a brain-dead donor, DCD requires additional resources. The economic impact of DCD heart transplantation from the hospital perspective is not well known. METHODS: We compared the financial data of patients who received DCD allografts to those who received a DBD organ at our institution from January 1, 2021 to December 31, 2022. We also compared the cost of ex-situ machine perfusion to in-situ organ perfusion employed during DCD recovery. RESULTS: We performed 58 DBD and 22 DCD heart-alone transplantations during the study period. Out of 22 DCD grafts, 16 were recovered with thoracoabdominal normothermic regional perfusion (TA-NRP) and six with direct procurement followed by normothermic machine perfusion (DP-NMP). The contribution margin per case for DBD versus DCD was $234,362 and $235,440 (P = .72). The direct costs did not significantly differ between the two groups ($171,949 and 186,250; P = .49). In comparing the two methods of procuring hearts from DCD donors, the direct cost of TA-NRP was $155,955 in comparison to $223,399 for DP-NMP (P = .21). This difference translated into a clinically meaningful but not statistically significant greater contribution margin for TA-NRP ($242, 657 vs. $175,768; P = .34). CONCLUSIONS: Our data showed that the adoption of DCD procurement did not have a negative financial impact on the contribution margin in our institution. Programs considering starting DCD heart transplantation, and those who are currently performing DCD procurement should evaluate their own financial situation.

Twenty-four-hour Normothermic Ex Vivo Heart Perfusion With Low Flow Functional Assessment in an Adult Porcine Model.

BACKGROUND: Cold static storage and normothermic ex vivo heart perfusion are routinely limited to 6 h. This report describes intermittent left atrial (LA) perfusion that allows cardiac functional assessment in a working heart mode. METHODS: Using our adult porcine model, general anesthesia was induced and a complete cardiectomy was performed following cardioplegic arrest. Back-table instrumentation was completed and normothermic ex vivo heart perfusion (NEHP) was initiated in a nonworking heart mode (Langendorff). After 1 h of resuscitation and recovery, LA perfusion was initiated and the heart was transitioned to a coronary flow-only working heart mode for 30 min. Baseline working heart parameters were documented and the heart was returned to nonworking mode. Working heart assessments were performed for 30 min every 6 h for 24 h. RESULTS: Twenty-four-hour NEHP on 9 consecutive hearts (280 ±â€…42.1 g) was successful and no significant differences were found between working heart parameters at baseline and after 24 h of perfusion. There was no difference between initial and final measurements of LA mean pressures (5.0 ±â€…3.1 versus 9.0 ±â€…6.5 mm Hg, P  = 0.22), left ventricular systolic pressures (44.3 ±â€…7.2 versus 39.1 ±â€…9.0 mm Hg, P  = 0.13), mean aortic pressures (30.9 ±â€…5.8 versus 28.1 ±â€…8.1 mm Hg, P  = 0.37), and coronary resistance (0.174 ±â€…0.046 versus 0.173 ±â€…0.066 mL/min/g, P  = 0.90). There were also no significant differences between lactate (2.4 ±â€…0.5 versus 2.6 ±â€…0.4 mmol/L, P  = 0.17) and glucose (173 ±â€…75 versus 156 ±â€…70 mg/dL, P  = 0.37). CONCLUSIONS: A novel model using intermittent LA perfusion to create a coronary flow-only working heart mode for assessment of ex vivo cardiac function has been successfully developed.

Assessment of performance and safety of Corneal Chamber hypothermic storage medium and PSS-L corneal rinsing solution in human and porcine corneas.

PURPOSE: To prove the safety and performance of the hypothermic corneal storage medium "Corneal Chamber" and the rinsing solution "PSS-L" in support of the new Conformité Européenne (CE) certification process in accordance with the Medical Device Regulation. METHODS: Fifteen (n=15) human donor corneas and 11 (n=11) porcine corneas were evaluated for the following parameters: endothelial cell density (ECD) and mortality, percentage of hexagonal cells (HEX%), coefficient of cellular area variation (CV%) and corneal transparency at Day 0 and after 14±1 days of storage in Corneal Chamber medium at 2-8°C. Then, the same parameters were assessed after rinsing of corneas in PSS-L for 1 min at room temperature. Evaluation of gentamicin sulfate carryover after corneal storage and PSS-L rinsing was performed by ultra-high performance liquid chromatography analysis on human corneas homogenates. RESULTS: Human and porcine corneas stored in Corneal Chamber medium showed a good overall quality of the tissue according to the quality parameters evaluated. In particular, mean ECD, HEX% and CV% did not show statistically significant changes at the end of storage and endothelial mortality increased to 3.1±3.3 and 7.8±3.5% in human and porcine corneas, respectively. Tissue rinsing with PSS-L did not affect the quality parameters evaluated before and gentamicin sulfate residues were absent in human corneas. CONCLUSIONS: Corneal preservation in Corneal Chamber medium at 2-8°C for 14 days and the corneal rinse with PSS-L are safe and effective procedures allowing the preservation of the corneal quality parameters as well as the complete elimination of gentamicin sulfate from the tissues before transplantation.Cite Now.

Indocyanine green: A novel marker for assessment of graft quality during ex situ normothermic machine perfusion of human livers.

BACKGROUND: Ex situ machine perfusion facilitates the assessment of livers prior to transplantation. However, currently available markers of liver function poorly predict long-term graft function. Indocyanine green (ICG) is a liver-specific dye which, although common in vivo, has never been comprehensively evaluated for the assessment of graft quality during ex situ machine perfusion. This study aimed to assess the utility of ICG in the ex situ setting. METHODS: Using a customized long-term perfusion system, human livers that were not suitable for transplantation were perfused using a red cell-based perfusate. ICG was delivered into the perfusate on days 0, 1, and 4 to assess ICG clearance (spectrophotometric absorbance at 805 nm) and ICG fluorescence (near-infrared camera). RESULTS: Sixteen partial livers were perfused for a median duration of 172 h (7.2 days). On day 0, the median ICG perfusate disappearance rate (PDR) was 7.5%/min and the median ICG retention at 15 min was 9.9%. Grafts that survived ≥7 days had a significantly higher median ICG PDR on day 0 (14.5%/min vs. 6.5%/min, p = 0.005) but not on days 1 or 4. ICG perfusion demonstrated that long-surviving grafts had a significantly lower median red-value (89.8 vs. 118.6, p = 0.011) and a significantly lower median blue-value (12.9 vs. 22.6, p = 0.045) than short-surviving grafts. CONCLUSION: ICG is a novel marker for the assessment of liver function during ex situ normothermic machine perfusion. ICG PDR and quantitative ICG perfusion can distinguish between long- and short-surviving grafts and demonstrate the utility of ICG in the assessment of graft quality prior to transplant.

Screening for mitochondrial function before use-routine liver assessment during hypothermic oxygenated perfusion impacts liver utilization.

BACKGROUND: To report on a concept of liver assessment during ex situ hypothermic oxygenated perfusion (HOPE) and its significant impact on liver utilization. METHODS: An analysis of prospectively collected data on donation after circulatory death (DCD) livers, treated by HOPE at our institution, during a 11-year period between January 2012 and December 2022. FINDINGS: Four hundred and fifteen DCD Maastricht III livers were offered during the study period in Switzerland, resulting in 249 liver transplants. Of those, we performed 158 DCD III liver transplants at our institution, with 1-year patient survival and death censored graft survival (death with functioning graft) of 87 and 89%, respectively, thus comparable to benchmark graft survivals of ideal DBD and DCD liver transplants (89% and 86%). Correspondingly, graft loss for primary non-function or cholangiopathy was overall low, i.e., 7/158 (4.4%) and 11/158 (6.9%), despite more than 82% of DCD liver grafts ranked high (6-10 points) or futile risk (>10 points) according to the UK-DCD score. Consistently, death censored graft survival was not different between low-, high-risk or futile DCD III livers. The key behind these achievements was the careful development and implementation of a routine perfusate assessment of mitochondrial biomarkers for injury and function, i.e., release of flavin mononucleotide from complex I, perfusate NADH, and mitochondrial CO2 production during HOPE, allowing a more objective interpretation of liver quality on a subcellular level, compared to donor derived data. INTERPRETATION: HOPE after cold storage is a highly suitable and easy to perform perfusion approach, which allows reliable liver graft assessment, enabling surgeons to make a fact based decision on whether or not to implant the organ. HOPE-treatment should be combined with viability assessment particularly when used for high-risk organs, including DCD livers or organs with relevant steatosis. FUNDING: This study was supported by the Swiss National Foundation (SNF) grant 320030_189055/1 to PD.

Viability assessment of livers donated after circulatory determination of death during normothermic regional perfusion.

BACKGROUND: Abdominal normothermic regional perfusion (A-NRP) allows in-situ reperfusion and recovery of abdominal organs metabolism in donors after circulatory death (DCD). Besides improving liver transplantation outcomes, liver injury and function can be assessed during A-NRP. METHODS: To refine liver viability assessment during A-NRP, prospectively collected data of controlled DCD donors managed at our Institution between October 2019 and May 2022 were retrospectively analyzed. Baseline characteristics, procedural variables and A-NRP parameters of donors whose liver was successfully transplanted were compared to those of donors whose liver was discarded. RESULTS: Twenty-seven donors were included and in 20 (74%) the liver was accepted (positive outcome). No differences between study groups were observed concerning baseline characteristics and warm ischemia times (WIT). Initial lactate levels were positively correlated with functional WIT (r2 = 0.4, p = 0.04), whereas transaminase levels were not. Blood flow during A-NRP was comparable, whereas oxygen consumption (VO2 ) was significantly higher in the positive outcome group after 1 h. Time courses of lactate, AST and ALT were significantly different between study groups (p < 0.001). Donors whose liver was accepted showed faster lactate clearance, a difference which was amplified by normalizing lactate clearance to oxygen delivery (DO2 ) and VO2 . Lactate clearance was correlated to transaminase levels and DO2 -normalized lactate clearance was the parameter best discriminating between study groups. CONCLUSIONS: DO2 -normalized lactate clearance may represent an element of liver viability assessment during A-NRP.

A Spectrofluorometric Method for Real-Time Graft Assessment and Patient Monitoring.

Biomarkers are powerful clinical diagnostics and predictors of patient outcome. However, robust measurements often require time and expensive laboratory equipment, which is insufficient to track rapid changes and limits direct use in the operating room. Here, this study presents a portable spectrophotometric device for continuous real-time measurements of fluorescent and non-fluorescent biomarkers at the point of care. This study measures the mitochondrial damage biomarker flavin mononucleotide (FMN) in 26 extended criteria human liver grafts undergoing hypothermic oxygenated perfusion to guide clinical graft assessment. Real-time data identified seven organs unsuitable for transplant that are discarded. The remaining grafts are transplanted and FMN values correlated with post-transplant indicators of liver function and patient recovery. Further, this study shows how this device can be used to monitor dialysis patients by measuring creatinine in real-time. Our approach provides a simple method to monitor biomarkers directly within biological fluids to improve organ assessment, patient care, and biomarker discovery.

Functional Assessment of Cardiac Arrest Hepatocytes and Effect of Mechanical Perfusion on Function in a Rat Model.

BACKGROUND: Hepatocyte transplantation has been reported to be useful for metabolic diseases and acute liver failure. However, the shortage of donors limits its widespread use. The use of livers from donors after circulatory death, which are currently unavailable for liver transplantation, may alleviate donor shortage. In this study, we investigated the effects of mechanical perfusion on cardiac arrest hepatocytes in a rat model using cardiac arrest donor livers, and we evaluated the function of cardiac arrest hepatocytes. METHODS: F344 rat hepatocytes isolated from livers removed during cardiac pulsation were compared with those isolated from livers removed after 30 minutes of warm ischemia after cardiac arrest. We then compared hepatocytes isolated from livers removed after 30 minutes of warm ischemia with those isolated after 30 minutes of mechanical perfusion before isolation. The yield per liver weight, ammonia removal capacity, and adenosine diphosphate/adenosine triphosphate ratio were evaluated. RESULTS: Thirty minutes of warm inhibition reduced hepatocyte yield but did not alter ammonia removal capacity and energy status. Mechanical perfusion increased hepatocyte yield and improved the adenosine diphosphate/adenosine triphosphate ratio after 30 minutes of warm inhibition. CONCLUSION: Thirty minutes of warm ischemic time may decrease isolated hepatocyte yield without degrading their function. If increased yields are obtained, livers from donors dying of cardiac arrest could be used for hepatocyte transplantation. The results also suggest that mechanical perfusion may positively affect the energy status of hepatocytes.

Indocyanine Green Angiography for Quality Assessment of Renal Graft Before Transplantation: A Pilot Study.

OBJECTIVES: Criteria for donation have been expanded to meet the great demand for organ transplant, resulting in different tools and classifications to help physicians to better assess the quality of the transplanted kidney. In this study, we evaluated the use of indocyanine green angiography as an additional tool to evaluate the renal microcirculation and the quality of the potential kidney graft. MATERIALS AND METHODS: All kidneys from extended criteria donors or donors after cardiac death available for transplant underwent indocyanine green angiog-raphy before implantation and after reconditioning, when hypothermic perfusion was required. We performed fluorescent angiography with a 10-mm-view laparoscope connected to a high-definition camera system while a solution of indocyanine green and Celsior was injected into the renal artery. We compared fluorescence intensities with postoperative graft function and then analyzed increases in fluorescence intensity before and after hypothermic machine perfusion treatment. RESULTS: In transplanted kidneys preserved in traditional cold storage, we found a statistically significant difference in fluorescence intensity values between groups with early graft function and delayed graft function. Fluorescence intensity increased significantly in all perfused kidneys after hypothermic machine perfusion treatment, indicating that intensity was directly proportional to improved renal microcirculation. Among 21 kidneys retrieved for transplant that adhered to the inclusion criteria, 11 were examined histopathologically, with a Karpinski score ranging from 2 to 7. The kidney that scored 7 was immediately discarded. Five underwent hypothermic pulsatile perfusion since they came from donors after cardiac death. Fluorescence intensity increased significantly in all perfused kidneys (4/5 were closest to doubling). Histopathological evaluations and Karpinski scores of the grafts indicated that all 5 were considered suitable for transplant. CONCLUSIONS: Indocyanine green angiography can be used in the future as an additional useful tool to help physicians to assess graft quality before implantation.