Mortality of intrathoracic sarcoidosis in referral vs population-based settings: influence of stage, ethnicity, and corticosteroid therapy.

STUDY OBJECTIVES: To compare the sarcoidosis mortality in referral settings (RS) and population-based settings (PS), and to identify the contribution of stage, ethnicity, and corticosteroid therapy (CST) to their disparate outcomes. DESIGN: All observational studies identified in a MEDLINE search and bibliographic review published in the English language since 1960 dealing with the course and prognosis of sarcoidosis in large, unsorted, adult, ambulatory RS and PS providing long-term follow-up were reviewed and subjected to meta-analysis. MEASUREMENTS AND RESULTS: Sarcoidosis mortality in RS (4.8%), in which 17% of patients had the most unfavorable prognosis as judged by stage (stage III), was 10-fold that reported in PS (0.5%), in which 11% of patients were identified at this stage. The magnitude of this disparity could not be accounted for solely by adverse selection, as indicated by stage or by ethnicity. Patients in RS received CST with sevenfold the frequency of PS, and its provision was highly correlated with stage-normalized mortality. CONCLUSION: The prognosis of patients with intrathoracic sarcoidosis in PS is far more favorable than that obtained in RS. Sarcoidosis mortality is largely independent of ethnicity. The possibility cannot be excluded that excessive employment of CST may unfavorably influence the long-term course of the disease in some individuals.

Pulmonary sarcoidosis: comparison of patients at a university and a municipal hospital.

Charts and radiographs of sarcoidosis patients seen at a private university hospital and at a municipal hospital were reviewed to determine whether there was a difference in the severity of disease retrospectively. A standardized abstract form was used to identify and abstract information on new and continuing sarcoidosis patients seen at either Georgetown University Medical Center (GUMC) or District of Columbia General Hospital (DCGH) during a 2-year period. Because there were too few white sarcoidosis patients for comparison, analysis was done for African-American patients only. African-American patients at GUMC were slightly older, with a higher percentage of women. For GUMC patients, 76% had private insurance and 21% had public insurance, and for DCGH patients, one-half had public insurance and 29% had no insurance. Significantly fewer GUMC patients (7% versus 36%) reported moderate to severe dyspnea. Chest radiographs showed a larger percentage of patients with stage 1 disease at GUMC and more patients with stage 4 disease at DCGH. Spirometry showed more impairment of forced expired volume in one second (FEV1) in GUMC patients, but diffusing capacity of the lung for carbon monoxide (DLCO) values were significantly lower among DCGH patients. Less than 8% of GUMC patients showed disease progression compared with almost one-third of DCGH patients. These results demonstrate that substantially less severe pulmonary sarcoidosis was seen in African-American patients treated at a private, nonprofit university hospital compared with a municipal hospital. Factors that determine the use of municipal hospitals, such as limited financial access to care and sources of patients, may have played a major role in the differences seen.