ABSTRACT
Biallelic variants in the ERLIN1 gene were recently reported as the cause of two motor neuron degeneration diseases, SPG62 and a recessive form of amyotrophic lateral sclerosis. However, only 12 individuals from five pedigrees have been identified so far. Thus, the description of the disease remains limited. Following the discovery of a homozygous pathogenic variant in a girl with SPG62, presenting with intellectual disability, and epilepsy, we gathered the largest series of SPG62 cases reported so far (13 individuals) to better understand the phenotype associated with ERLIN1. We collected molecular and clinical data for 13 individuals from six families with ERLIN1 biallelic variants. We performed RNA-seq analyses to characterize intronic variants and used Alphafold and a transcripts database to characterize the molecular consequences of the variants. We identified three new variants suspected to alter the bell-shaped ring formed by the ERLIN1/ERLIN2 complex. Affected individuals had childhood-onset paraparesis with slow progression. Six individuals presented with gait ataxia and three had superficial sensory loss. Aside from our proband, none had intellectual disability or epilepsy. Biallelic pathogenic ERLIN1 variants induce a rare, predominantly pure, spastic paraparesis, with possible cerebellar and peripheral nerve involvement.
ABSTRACT
Up to 80% of BRCA1 and BRCA2 genetic variants remain of uncertain clinical significance (VUSs). Only variants classified as pathogenic or likely pathogenic can guide breast and ovarian cancer prevention measures and treatment by PARP inhibitors. We report the first results of the ongoing French national COVAR (cosegregation variant) study, the aim of which is to classify BRCA1/2 VUSs. The classification method was a multifactorial model combining different associations between VUSs and cancer, including cosegregation data. At this time, among the 653 variants selected, 101 (15%) distinct variants shared by 1,624 families were classified as pathogenic/likely pathogenic or benign/likely benign by the COVAR study. Sixty-six of the 101 (65%) variants classified by COVAR would have remained VUSs without cosegregation data. Of note, among the 34 variants classified as pathogenic by COVAR, 16 remained VUSs or likely pathogenic when following the ACMG/AMP variant classification guidelines. Although the initiation and organization of cosegregation analyses require a considerable effort, the growing number of available genetic tests results in an increasing number of families sharing a particular variant, and thereby increases the power of such analyses. Here we demonstrate that variant cosegregation analyses are a powerful tool for the classification of variants in the BRCA1/2 breast-ovarian cancer predisposition genes.
Subject(s)
BRCA1 Protein/genetics , BRCA2 Protein/genetics , Breast Neoplasms/pathology , Genetic Predisposition to Disease , Genetic Variation , Ovarian Neoplasms/pathology , Breast Neoplasms/classification , Breast Neoplasms/genetics , Female , Genetic Testing , Genotype , Humans , Ovarian Neoplasms/classification , Ovarian Neoplasms/geneticsABSTRACT
Hereditary spastic paraplegia refers to rare genetic neurodevelopmental and/or neurodegenerative disorders in which spasticity due to length-dependent damage to the upper motor neuron is a core sign. Their high clinical and genetic heterogeneity makes their diagnosis challenging. Multigene panels allow a high-throughput targeted analysis of the increasing number of genes involved using next-generation sequencing. We report here the clinical and genetic results of 1550 index cases tested for variants in a panel of hereditary spastic paraplegia related genes analysed in routine diagnosis. A causative variant was found in 475 patients (30.7%) in 35/65 screened genes. SPAST and SPG7 were the most frequently mutated genes, representing 142 (9.2%) and 75 (4.8%) index cases of the whole series, respectively. KIF1A, ATL1, SPG11, KIF5A and REEP1 represented more than 1% (>17 cases) each. There were 661 causative variants (382 different ones) and 30 of them were structural variants. This large cohort allowed us to obtain an overview of the clinical and genetic spectrum of hereditary spastic paraplegia in clinical practice. Because of the wide phenotypic variability, there was no very specific sign that could predict the causative gene, but there were some constellations of symptoms that were found often related to specific subtypes. Finally, we confirmed the diagnostic effectiveness of a targeted sequencing panel as a first-line genetic test in hereditary spastic paraplegia. This is a pertinent strategy because of the relative frequency of several known genes (i.e. SPAST, KIF1A) and it allows identification of variants in the rarest involved genes and detection of structural rearrangements via coverage analysis, which is less efficient in exome datasets. It is crucial because these structural variants represent a significant proportion of the pathogenic hereditary spastic paraplegia variants (â¼6% of patients), notably for SPAST and REEP1. In a subset of 42 index cases negative for the targeted multigene panel, subsequent whole-exome sequencing allowed a theoretical diagnosis yield of â¼50% to be reached. We then propose a two-step strategy combining the use of a panel of genes followed by whole-exome sequencing in negative cases.
Subject(s)
Spastic Paraplegia, Hereditary , High-Throughput Nucleotide Sequencing , Humans , Kinesins/genetics , Membrane Transport Proteins/genetics , Mutation/genetics , Pedigree , Proteins/genetics , Spastic Paraplegia, Hereditary/diagnosis , Spastic Paraplegia, Hereditary/genetics , Spastin/genetics , Exome SequencingABSTRACT
Somatic/germline BRCA1/2 mutations (m)/(likely) pathogenic variants (PV) (s/gBRCAm) remain the best predictive biomarker for PARP inhibitor efficacy. As >95% of high-grade serous ovarian cancers (HGSOC) have a somatic TP53m, combined tumor-based BRCA1/2 (tBRCA) and TP53 mutation testing (tBRCA/TP53m) may improve the quality of results in somatic BRCAm identification and interpretation of the 'second hit' event, i.e., loss of heterozygosity (LOH). A total of 237 patients with HGSOC underwent tBRCA/TP53m testing. The ratio of allelic fractions (AFs) for tBRCA/TP53m was calculated to estimate the proportion of cells carrying BRCAm and to infer LOH. Among the 142/237 gBRCA results, 16.2% demonstrated a pathogenic/deleterious variant (DEL) gBRCA1/2m. Among the 195 contributive tumor samples, 43 DEL of tBRCAm (22.1%) were identified (23 gBRCAm and 20 sBRCAm) with LOH identified in 37/41 conclusive samples. The median AF of TP53m was 0.52 (0.01-0.93), confirming huge variability in tumor cellularity. Initially, three samples were considered as wild type with <10% cellularity. However, additional testing detected a very low AF (<0.05) in both BRCA1/2m and TP53m, thus reidentifying them as sBRCA1/2m. Combined tBRCA/TP53m testing is rapid, sensitive, and identifies somatic and germline BRCA1/2m. AF TP53m is essential for interpreting sBRCA1/2m in low-cellularity samples and provides indirect evidence for LOH as the 'second hit' of BRCA1/2-related tumorigenesis.
Subject(s)
BRCA1 Protein , Ovarian Neoplasms , Humans , Female , BRCA1 Protein/genetics , BRCA2 Protein/genetics , Mutation , Ovarian Neoplasms/diagnosis , Ovarian Neoplasms/genetics , Ovarian Neoplasms/pathology , Germ-Line Mutation , Tumor Suppressor Protein p53/geneticsABSTRACT
Hereditary papillary renal cell carcinoma (HPRC) is a rare inherited renal cancer syndrome characterized by bilateral and multifocal papillary type 1 renal tumors (PRCC1). Activating germline pathogenic variants of the MET gene were identified in HPRC families. We reviewed the medical and molecular records of a large French series of 158 patients screened for MET oncogenic variants. MET pathogenic and likely pathogenic variants rate was 12.4% with 40.6% among patients with familial PRCC1 and 5% among patients with sporadic PRCC1. The phenotype in cases with MET pathogenic and likely pathogenic variants was characteristic: PRCC1 tumors were mainly bilateral (84.3%) and multifocal (87.5%). Histologically, six out of seven patients with MET pathogenic variant harbored biphasic squamoid alveolar PRCC. Genetic screening identified one novel pathogenic variant MET c.3389T>C, p.(Leu1130Ser) and three novel likely pathogenic variants: MET c.3257A>T, p.(His1086Leu); MET c.3305T>C, p.(Ile1102Thr) and MET c.3373T>G, p.(Cys1125Gly). Functional assay confirmed their oncogenic effect as they induced an abnormal focus formation. The genotype-phenotype correlation between MET pathogenic variants and PRCC1 presentation should encourage to widen the screening, especially toward nonfamilial PRCC1. This precise phenotype also constitutes a strong argument for the classification of novel missense variants within the tyrosine kinase domain when functional assays are not accessible.
Subject(s)
Carcinoma, Renal Cell , Kidney Neoplasms , Neoplastic Syndromes, Hereditary , Proto-Oncogene Proteins c-met , Carcinoma, Renal Cell/genetics , Female , Germ Cells/metabolism , Humans , Kidney Neoplasms/genetics , Male , Phenotype , Proto-Oncogene Proteins c-met/geneticsABSTRACT
Modeling splicing is essential for tackling the challenge of variant interpretation as each nucleotide variation can be pathogenic by affecting pre-mRNA splicing via disruption/creation of splicing motifs such as 5'/3' splice sites, branch sites, or splicing regulatory elements. Unfortunately, most in silico tools focus on a specific type of splicing motif, which is why we developed the Splicing Prediction Pipeline (SPiP) to perform, in one single bioinformatic analysis based on a machine learning approach, a comprehensive assessment of the variant effect on different splicing motifs. We gathered a curated set of 4616 variants scattered all along the sequence of 227 genes, with their corresponding splicing studies. The Bayesian analysis provided us with the number of control variants, that is, variants without impact on splicing, to mimic the deluge of variants from high-throughput sequencing data. Results show that SPiP can deal with the diversity of splicing alterations, with 83.13% sensitivity and 99% specificity to detect spliceogenic variants. Overall performance as measured by area under the receiving operator curve was 0.986, better than SpliceAI and SQUIRLS (0.965 and 0.766) for the same data set. SPiP lends itself to a unique suite for comprehensive prediction of spliceogenicity in the genomic medicine era. SPiP is available at: https://sourceforge.net/projects/splicing-prediction-pipeline/.
Subject(s)
RNA Splice Sites , RNA Splicing , Humans , Bayes Theorem , RNA Splicing/genetics , Exons/genetics , RNA Splice Sites/genetics , Machine Learning , Introns/geneticsABSTRACT
PURPOSE: Hereditary spastic paraplegia type 4 is extremely variable in age at onset; the same variant can cause onset at birth or in the eighth decade. We recently discovered that missense variants in SPAST, which influences microtubule dynamics, are associated with earlier onset and more severe disease than truncating variants, but even within the early and late-onset groups there remained significant differences in onset. Given the rarity of the condition, we adapted an extreme phenotype approach to identify genetic modifiers of onset. METHODS: We performed a genome-wide association study on 134 patients bearing truncating pathogenic variants in SPAST, divided into early- and late-onset groups (aged ≤15 and ≥45 years, respectively). A replication cohort of 419 included patients carrying either truncating or missense variants. Finally, age at onset was analyzed in the merged cohort (N = 553). RESULTS: We found 1 signal associated with earlier age at onset (rs10775533, P = 8.73E-6) in 2 independent cohorts and in the merged cohort (N = 553, Mantel-Cox test, P < .0001). Western blotting in lymphocytes of 20 patients showed that this locus tends to upregulate SARS2 expression in earlier-onset patients. CONCLUSION: SARS2 overexpression lowers the age of onset in hereditary spastic paraplegia type 4. Lowering SARS2 or improving mitochondrial function could thus present viable approaches to therapy.
Subject(s)
Serine-tRNA Ligase , Spastic Paraplegia, Hereditary , Humans , Genome-Wide Association Study , Mutation , Serine-tRNA Ligase/genetics , Serine-tRNA Ligase/metabolism , Spastic Paraplegia, Hereditary/genetics , Spastin/genetics , Spastin/metabolismABSTRACT
SUMMARY: Alternative splicing is an important biological process widely analyzed in molecular diagnostic settings. Indeed, a variant can be pathogenic by splicing alteration and a suspected pathogenic variant (e.g. truncating variant) can be rescued by splicing. In this context, detecting and quantifying alternative splicing is challenging. We developed SpliceLauncher, a fast and easy to use open source tool that aims at detecting, annotating and quantifying alternative splice junctions at high resolution. AVAILABILITY AND IMPLEMENTATION: SpliceLauncher is available at https://github.com/raphaelleman/SpliceLauncher. SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: Supplementary data are available at Bioinformatics online.
Subject(s)
RNA Splicing , Software , Alternative SplicingABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: Branch points (BPs) map within short motifs upstream of acceptor splice sites (3'ss) and are essential for splicing of pre-mature mRNA. Several BP-dedicated bioinformatics tools, including HSF, SVM-BPfinder, BPP, Branchpointer, LaBranchoR and RNABPS were developed during the last decade. Here, we evaluated their capability to detect the position of BPs, and also to predict the impact on splicing of variants occurring upstream of 3'ss. RESULTS: We used a large set of constitutive and alternative human 3'ss collected from Ensembl (n = 264,787 3'ss) and from in-house RNAseq experiments (n = 51,986 3'ss). We also gathered an unprecedented collection of functional splicing data for 120 variants (62 unpublished) occurring in BP areas of disease-causing genes. Branchpointer showed the best performance to detect the relevant BPs upstream of constitutive and alternative 3'ss (99.48 and 65.84% accuracies, respectively). For variants occurring in a BP area, BPP emerged as having the best performance to predict effects on mRNA splicing, with an accuracy of 89.17%. CONCLUSIONS: Our investigations revealed that Branchpointer was optimal to detect BPs upstream of 3'ss, and that BPP was most relevant to predict splicing alteration due to variants in the BP area.
Subject(s)
Introns , RNA Precursors , RNA Splice Sites , RNA Splicing , Alternative Splicing , Computational Biology/methods , Humans , Nucleotide Motifs , Position-Specific Scoring Matrices , RNA Processing, Post-Transcriptional , ROC Curve , Reproducibility of ResultsABSTRACT
Variant interpretation is the key issue in molecular diagnosis. Spliceogenic variants exemplify this issue as each nucleotide variant can be deleterious via disruption or creation of splice site consensus sequences. Consequently, reliable in silico prediction of variant spliceogenicity would be a major improvement. Thanks to an international effort, a set of 395 variants studied at the mRNA level and occurring in 5' and 3' consensus regions (defined as the 11 and 14 bases surrounding the exon/intron junction, respectively) was collected for 11 different genes, including BRCA1, BRCA2, CFTR and RHD, and used to train and validate a new prediction protocol named Splicing Prediction in Consensus Elements (SPiCE). SPiCE combines in silico predictions from SpliceSiteFinder-like and MaxEntScan and uses logistic regression to define optimal decision thresholds. It revealed an unprecedented sensitivity and specificity of 99.5 and 95.2%, respectively, and the impact on splicing was correctly predicted for 98.8% of variants. We therefore propose SPiCE as the new tool for predicting variant spliceogenicity. It could be easily implemented in any diagnostic laboratory as a routine decision making tool to help geneticists to face the deluge of variants in the next-generation sequencing era. SPiCE is accessible at (https://sourceforge.net/projects/spicev2-1/).
Subject(s)
Computational Biology/methods , Computer Simulation , Genetic Variation , RNA Splice Sites/genetics , RNA Splicing , BRCA1 Protein/genetics , BRCA2 Protein/genetics , Breast Neoplasms/diagnosis , Breast Neoplasms/genetics , Female , Humans , International Cooperation , Internet , Ovarian Neoplasms/diagnosis , Ovarian Neoplasms/genetics , Reproducibility of Results , Sensitivity and SpecificityABSTRACT
Hereditary leiomyomatosis and renal cell carcinoma syndrome is characterized by an increased risk of agressive renal cell carcinoma, often of type 2 papillary histology, and is caused by FH germline mutations. A prominent eosinophilic macronucleolus with a perinucleolar clear halo is distinctive of hereditary leiomyomatosis and renal cell carcinoma syndrome-associated renal cell carcinoma according to the 2012 ISUP and 2016 WHO kidney tumor classification. From an immunohistochemistry perspective, tumors are often FH-negative and S-(2-succino)-cysteine (2SC) positive. We performed a pathology review of 24 renal tumors in 23 FH mutation carriers, and compared them to 12 type 2 papillary renal cell carcinomas from FH wild-type patients. Prominent eosinophilic nucleoli with perinucleolar halos were present in almost all FH-deficient renal cell carcinomas (23/24). Unexpectedly, they were also present in 58% of type 2 papillary renal cell carcinomas from wild-type patients. Renal cell carcinoma in mutation carriers displayed a complex architecture with multiple patterns, typically papillary, tubulopapillary, and tubulocystic, but also sarcomatoid and rhabdoid. Such pattern diversity was not seen in non-carriers. FH/2SC immunohistochemistry was informative as all hereditary leiomyomatosis and renal cell carcinoma-associated renal cell carcinomas were either FH- or 2SC+. For FH and 2SC immunohistochemistries taken separately, sensitivity of negative anti-FH immunohistochemistry was 87.5% and specificity was 100%. For positive anti-2SC immunohistochemistry, sensitivity, and specificity were 91.7% and 91.7%, respectively. All FH wild-type renal cell carcinoma were FH-positive, and all but one were 2SC-negative. In conclusion, multiplicity of architectural patterns, rhabdoid/sarcomatoid components and combined FH/2SC staining, but not prominent eosinophilic nucleoli with perinucleolar halos, differentiate hereditary leiomyomatosis and renal cell carcinoma-associated renal cell carcinoma from type 2 papillary renal cell carcinoma with efficient FH gene. Our findings are crucial in identifying who should be referred to Cancer Genetics clinics for genetic counseling and testing.
Subject(s)
Carcinoma, Renal Cell/diagnosis , Fumarate Hydratase/metabolism , Kidney Neoplasms/diagnosis , Leiomyomatosis/diagnosis , Carcinoma, Renal Cell/genetics , Carcinoma, Renal Cell/metabolism , Carcinoma, Renal Cell/pathology , Diagnosis, Differential , Fumarate Hydratase/genetics , Genetic Predisposition to Disease , Germ-Line Mutation , Humans , Kidney Neoplasms/genetics , Kidney Neoplasms/metabolism , Kidney Neoplasms/pathology , Leiomyomatosis/genetics , Leiomyomatosis/metabolism , Leiomyomatosis/pathologyABSTRACT
Malignant pheochromocytoma (PCC) and paraganglioma (PGL) are mostly caused by germline mutations of SDHB, encoding a subunit of succinate dehydrogenase. Using whole-exome sequencing, we recently identified a mutation in the FH gene encoding fumarate hydratase, in a PCC with an 'SDH-like' molecular phenotype. Here, we investigated the role of FH in PCC/PGL predisposition, by screening for germline FH mutations in a large international cohort of patients. We screened 598 patients with PCC/PGL without mutations in known PCC/PGL susceptibility genes. We searched for FH germline mutations and large deletions, by direct sequencing and multiplex ligation-dependent probe amplification methods. Global alterations in DNA methylation and protein succination were assessed by immunohistochemical staining for 5-hydroxymethylcytosine (5-hmC) and S-(2-succinyl) cysteine (2SC), respectively. We identified five pathogenic germline FH mutations (four missense and one splice mutation) in five patients. Somatic inactivation of the second allele, resulting in a loss of fumarate hydratase activity, was demonstrated in tumors with FH mutations. Low tumor levels of 5-hmC, resembling those in SDHB-deficient tumors, and positive 2SC staining were detected in tumors with FH mutations. Clinically, metastatic phenotype (P = 0.007) and multiple tumors (P = 0.02) were significantly more frequent in patients with FH mutations than those without such mutations. This study reveals a new role for FH in susceptibility to malignant and/or multiple PCC/PGL. Remarkably, FH-deficient PCC/PGLs display the same pattern of epigenetic deregulation as SDHB-mutated malignant PCC/PGL. Therefore, we propose that mutation screening for FH should be included in PCC/PGL genetic testing, at least for tumors with malignant behavior.
Subject(s)
Fumarate Hydratase/genetics , Germ-Line Mutation/genetics , Paraganglioma/genetics , Pheochromocytoma/genetics , Adolescent , Adult , Aged , Aged, 80 and over , Child , Exons/genetics , Female , Genetic Predisposition to Disease/genetics , Humans , Male , Middle Aged , Young AdultABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: Hereditary leiomyomatosis and renal cell carcinoma (HLRCC) is an autosomal dominant familial disorder due to FH mutation. Despite a considerable increase in information about the genetic background, inter- and intrafamilial phenotypic variability/penetrance are not well documented. OBJECTIVE: To describe a large French HLRCC family and provide new data on penetrance and intrafamilial variability. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The whole family was contacted for clinical examination, skin biopsy, uterine and kidney imagery and molecular analysis. RESULTS: The family included 22 members in 3 generations. The second generation consisted of 13 members who were older than the expected age of onset of disease manifestations. Of the 12 available members of this second generation, 6 (1 man and 5 women, aged 44-57 years) had a novel FH mutation. All had the same mild phenotype with cutaneous asymptomatic leiomyomas, uterine fibroids (if women) and no kidney tumor. The other 6 members not bearing the familial mutation had normal clinical and radiological findings. In this second generation, the penetrance was therefore complete, and there was no intrafamilial variability in the clinical expression of the mutation. CONCLUSION: This study provides additional data on genotype/phenotype correlation, intrafamilial variability and penetrance that should help to improve prognosis and genetic counseling.
Subject(s)
Carcinoma, Renal Cell/genetics , Fumarate Hydratase/genetics , Genetic Predisposition to Disease , Kidney Neoplasms/genetics , Leiomyomatosis/genetics , Mutation , Penetrance , Adolescent , Adult , Aged , Aged, 80 and over , Biopsy , Carcinoma, Renal Cell/complications , Carcinoma, Renal Cell/diagnosis , Child , DNA/genetics , DNA Mutational Analysis , Family , Female , Fumarate Hydratase/metabolism , Genotype , Humans , Kidney Neoplasms/complications , Kidney Neoplasms/diagnosis , Leiomyomatosis/complications , Leiomyomatosis/diagnosis , Male , Middle Aged , Pedigree , Phenotype , Prognosis , Skin/pathology , Young AdultABSTRACT
Biallelic mutations in the CYP7B1 gene lead to spastic paraplegia-5 (SPG5). We report herein the case of a patient whose clinical symptoms began with progressive lower limb spasticity during childhood, and who secondly developed amyotrophic lateral sclerosis/frontotemporal dementia (ALS/FTD) at the age of 67 years. Hereditary spastic paraplegia (HSP) gene analysis identified the compound heterozygous mutations c.825T>A (pTyr275*) and c.1193C>T (pPro398Leu) in CYP7B1 gene. No other pathogenic variant in frequent ALS/FTD causative genes was found. The CYP7B1 gene seems, therefore, to be the third gene associated with the phenoconversion from HSP to ALS, after the recently described UBQLN2 and ERLIN2 genes. We therefore expand the phenotype associated with CYP7B1 biallelic mutations and make an assumption about a link between cholesterol dyshomeostasis and ALS/FTD.
Subject(s)
Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis/genetics , Cytochrome P450 Family 7/genetics , Frontotemporal Dementia/genetics , Mutation/genetics , Paraplegia/genetics , Steroid Hydroxylases/genetics , Humans , Male , Middle Aged , Pedigree , PhenotypeABSTRACT
Hereditary spastic paraplegias (HSP) are heterogeneous disorders, with more than 70 causative genes. Variants in SPAST are the most frequent genetic etiology and are responsible for spastic paraplegia type 4 (SPG4). Age at onset can vary, even between patients from the same family, and incomplete penetrance is described. Somatic mosaicism is extremely rare with only three patients reported in the literature. We report here SPAST mosaic variants in four unrelated patients. We confirm that mosaicism in SPAST is a very rare event with only four identified cases on more than 300 patients with a SPAST variant previously described by our clinical diagnostic laboratory.
Subject(s)
Heterozygote , Mosaicism , Mutation , Spastic Paraplegia, Hereditary/diagnosis , Spastic Paraplegia, Hereditary/genetics , Spastin/genetics , Alleles , Child , Comparative Genomic Hybridization , Female , France , Gene Frequency , High-Throughput Nucleotide Sequencing , Homozygote , Humans , Male , Middle Aged , Pedigree , PhenotypeABSTRACT
PURPOSE: Fumarate hydratase-deficient (FHdef) renal cell carcinoma (RCC) is a rare entity associated with the hereditary leiomyomatosis and RCC syndrome with no standard therapy approved. The aim of this retrospective study was to evaluate the efficacy of different systemic treatments in this population. METHODS: We performed a multicentre retrospective analysis of Fhdef RCC patients to determine the response to systemic treatments. The endpoints were objective response rate (ORR), time-to-treatment failure (TTF), and overall survival (OS). The two latter were estimated using the Kaplan-Meier method. RESULTS: Twenty-four Fhdef RCC patients were identified, and 21 under systemic therapy were included in the analysis: ten received cabozantinib, 14 received sunitinib, nine received "other antiangiogenics" (sorafenib, pazopanib, and axitinib), three received erlotinib-bevacizumab (E-B), three received mTOR inhibitors, and 11 received immune checkpoint blockers (ICBs). ORR for treatments were 50% for cabozantinib, 43% for sunitinib, 63% for "other antiangiogenics," and 30% for E-B, whereas ORR was 0% for mTOR inhibitors and 18% for ICBs. The median TTF (mTTF) was significantly higher with antiangiogenics (11.6 months) than with mTOR inhibitors (4.4 months) or ICBs (2.7 months). In the first-line setting, antiangiogenics presented a higher ORR compared with nivolumab-ipilimumab (64% versus 25%) and a significantly superior mTTF (11.0 months vs 2.5 months; p = 0.0027). The median OS from the start of the first systemic treatment was 44.0 months (95% confidence interval: 13.0-95.0). CONCLUSIONS: We report the first European retrospective study of Fhdef RCC patients treated with systemic therapy with a remarkably long median OS of 44.0 months. Our results suggest that antiangiogenics may be superior to ICB/mTOR inhibitors in this population.
Subject(s)
Angiogenesis Inhibitors/therapeutic use , Biomarkers, Tumor/genetics , Fumarate Hydratase/genetics , Immune Checkpoint Inhibitors/therapeutic use , Kidney Neoplasms/drug therapy , Protein Kinase Inhibitors/therapeutic use , Adult , Angiogenesis Inhibitors/adverse effects , Biomarkers, Tumor/deficiency , Disease Progression , Female , France , Fumarate Hydratase/deficiency , Genetic Predisposition to Disease , Humans , Immune Checkpoint Inhibitors/adverse effects , Kidney Neoplasms/enzymology , Kidney Neoplasms/genetics , Male , Middle Aged , Molecular Targeted Therapy , Phenotype , Protein Kinase Inhibitors/adverse effects , Retrospective Studies , Spain , TOR Serine-Threonine Kinases/antagonists & inhibitors , TOR Serine-Threonine Kinases/metabolism , Time Factors , Treatment Failure , Young AdultABSTRACT
PRKAR1A encodes the regulatory subunit type 1-alpha (RIalpha) of the cyclic adenosine monophosphate (cAMP)-dependent protein kinase (PKA). Inactivating PRKAR1A mutations are known to be responsible for the multiple neoplasia and lentiginosis syndrome Carney complex (CNC). To date, at least 117 pathogenic variants in PRKAR1A have been identified (online database: http://prkar1a.nichd.nih.gov). The majority are subject to nonsense mediated mRNA decay (NMD), leading to RIalpha haploinsufficiency and, as a result, activated cAMP signaling. Recently, it became apparent that CNC may be caused not only by RIalpha haploinsufficiency, but also by the expression of altered RIalpha protein, as proven by analysis of expressed mutations in the gene, consisting of amino acid substitutions and in-frame genetic alterations. In addition, a new subgroup of mutations that potentially escape NMD and result in CNC through altered (rather than missing) protein has been analyzed-these are frame-shifts in the 3' end of the coding sequence that shift the stop codon downstream of the normal one. The mutation detection rate in CNC patients is recently estimated at above 60%; PRKAR1A mutation-negative CNC patients are characterized by significant phenotypic heterogeneity. In this report, we present a comprehensive analysis of all presently known PRKAR1A sequence variations and discuss their molecular context and clinical phenotype.
Subject(s)
Cyclic AMP-Dependent Protein Kinase RIalpha Subunit/genetics , Mutation/genetics , Polymorphism, Single Nucleotide/genetics , Alternative Splicing/genetics , Carney Complex/diagnosis , Carney Complex/enzymology , Carney Complex/genetics , Frameshift Mutation/genetics , Genetic Association Studies , Humans , Penetrance , Sequence Deletion/geneticsABSTRACT
Germline nonsense and canonical splice site variants identified in disease-causing genes are generally considered as loss-of-function (LoF) alleles and classified as pathogenic. However, a fraction of such variants could maintain function through their impact on RNA splicing. To test this hypothesis, we used the alternatively spliced BRCA2 exon 12 (E12) as a model system because its in-frame skipping leads to a potentially functional protein. All E12 variants corresponding to putative LoF variants or predicted to alter splicing (n = 40) were selected from human variation databases and characterized for their impact on splicing in minigene assays and, when available, in patient lymphoblastoid cell lines. Moreover, a selection of variants was analyzed in a mouse embryonic stem cell-based functional assay. Using these complementary approaches, we demonstrate that a subset of variants, including nonsense variants, induced in-frame E12 skipping through the modification of splice sites or regulatory elements and, consequently, led to an internally deleted but partially functional protein. These data provide evidence, for the first time in a cancer-predisposition gene, that certain presumed null variants can retain function due to their impact on splicing. Further studies are required to estimate cancer risk associated with these hypomorphic variants. More generally, our findings highlight the need to exercise caution in the interpretation of putative LoF variants susceptible to induce in-frame splicing modifications. SIGNIFICANCE: This study presents evidence that certain presumed loss-of-function variants in a cancer predisposition gene can retain function due to their direct impact on RNA splicing.