Are root cause analyses recommendations effective and sustainable? An observational study.

OBJECTIVE: To assess the strength of root cause analysis (RCA) recommendations and their perceived levels of effectiveness and sustainability. DESIGN: All RCAs related to sentinel events (SEs) undertaken between the years 2010 and 2015 in the public health system in Victoria, Australia were analysed. The type and strength of each recommendation in the RCA reports were coded by an expert patient safety classifier using the US Department of Veteran Affairs type and strength criteria. PARTICIPANTS AND SETTING: Thirty-six public health services. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S): The proportion of RCA recommendations which were classified as 'strong' (more likely to be effective and sustainable), 'medium' (possibly effective and sustainable) or 'weak' (less likely to be effective and sustainable). RESULTS: There were 227 RCAs in the period of study. In these RCAs, 1137 recommendations were made. Of these 8% were 'strong', 44% 'medium' and 48% were 'weak'. In 31 RCAs, or nearly 15%, only weak recommendations were made. In 24 (11%) RCAs five or more weak recommendations were made. In 165 (72%) RCAs no strong recommendations were made. The most frequent recommendation types were reviewing or enhancing a policy/guideline/documentation, and training and education. CONCLUSIONS: Only a small proportion of recommendations arising from RCAs in Victoria are 'strong'. This suggests that insights from the majority of RCAs are not likely to inform practice or process improvements. Suggested improvements include more human factors expertise and independence in investigations, more extensive application of existing tools that assist teams to prioritize recommendations that are likely to be effective, and greater use of observational and simulation techniques to understand the underlying systems factors. Time spent in repeatedly investigating similar incidents may be better spent aggregating and thematically analysing existing sources of information about patient safety.

Advanced musculoskeletal physiotherapy clinical education framework supporting an emerging new workforce.

OBJECTIVE: A project, funded by the Department of Health and Human Services, was conducted with the aim of developing a clinical education framework that included an agreed competency standard and credentialing process to support advanced musculoskeletal physiotherapy roles. This paper describes the process undertaken to achieve this and presents the outcomes of implementation. METHODS: A multistep approach was taken. Initial steps included conducting a scoping review of the literature and focus groups of advanced musculoskeletal physiotherapists. The project team mapped out the structure of the framework. This was followed by a working party of subject matter experts developing an agreed competency standard. The framework was implemented at six hospitals across Australia and formally evaluated by an external evaluator. RESULTS: The clinical education framework developed includes a competency-based training and assessment program supported by learning resources and a mentoring program. It was successfully implemented across a diverse range of hospitals and received a positive evaluation. CONCLUSIONS: As the prevalence of musculoskeletal conditions increases, a new workforce of advanced musculoskeletal physiotherapists is emerging. A clinical education framework has been developed to address the specific needs of the population, organisations and experienced musculoskeletal physiotherapists recruited to these roles. A competent workforce has direct benefits for the community, healthcare organisations and the physiotherapy profession.

Patient experience of expanded-scope-of-practice musculoskeletal physiotherapy in the emergency department: a qualitative study.

OBJECTIVE: The increasing number of people presenting to hospital with musculoskeletal conditions places pressure on existing services, and has resulted in expanding the scope of practice of musculoskeletal physiotherapists working in emergency departments (ED). The aim of the present study was to qualitatively explore the perspectives of patients presenting with an isolated musculoskeletal condition seen by a musculoskeletal physiotherapist in the ED of two Australian hospitals situated in contrasting geographical locations. METHODS: Semistructured interviews were conducted with nine participants from a major metropolitan hospital and 16 participants from a remote hospital. Interviews were transcribed, coded and analysed using a thematic approach. RESULTS. The emerging themes from the two datasets were remarkably similar, so the final themes were merged. The major themes were: (1) participants were satisfied with the process and service provided by the physiotherapist; (2) the personal attributes of the physiotherapists were important to participants; (3) participant confidence in the skills and attributes of the physiotherapist made them a suitable alternative to a doctor in these situations; and (4) the timing and efficiency of the physiotherapy service was better than expected and valued. CONCLUSIONS: Participants from both settings described their experience in positive terms, reflecting satisfaction with their management by an expanded scope of practice musculoskeletal physiotherapist.

Comparing patient outcomes for care delivered by advanced musculoskeletal physiotherapists with other health professionals in the emergency department-A pilot study.

BACKGROUND: To compare advanced musculoskeletal physiotherapists with other health professionals by measuring outcomes for patients presenting to the emergency department with lower limb soft tissue injuries or acute low back pain. METHODS: A prospective study was conducted (Lower limb soft tissue injury cohort, n=88), (Acute low back pain cohort, n=29) at the emergency departments of two urban hospitals. A univariate analysis was completed for a number of outcome measures: Lower Extremity Functional Scale, Roland Morris Disability Questionnaire, imaging requirements, Patient Satisfaction Questionnaire, Numerical Pain Rating Scale and medication use. Data was obtained at discharge, two weeks and six weeks post-discharge. RESULTS: Advanced musculoskeletal physiotherapists ordered less imaging, had less opioids (lower limb soft tissue injury) administered to patients, and patients' described equal or more satisfaction when compared to another health professional (p<0.05). No significant differences were found between groups for functional or pain related outcomes in both cohorts (p>0.05). CONCLUSION: Advanced musculoskeletal physiotherapists are less likely to order imaging, obtain similar outcomes regarding pain medications and display equal or more patient satisfaction when compared to other health professionals for patients presenting to the emergency department with lower limb soft tissue injuries or acute low back pain.

A comparison of the contractile properties of myometrium from singleton and twin pregnancies.

OBJECTIVE: Over half of twin pregnancies in US and UK deliver prematurely but the reasons for this are unclear. The contractility of myometrium from twin pregnancies has not been directly investigated. The objective of this research was to determine if there are differences in the contractile activity and response to oxytocin, between myometrium from singleton and twin pregnancies, across a range of gestational ages. Furthermore, we wished to determine if contractile activity correlates with increasing level of stretch, using neonatal birth weights as a marker of uterine stretch. METHODS: This was an in vitro, laboratory based study of myometrial contractility in women pregnant with one or two babies, using biopsies obtained from non-labouring women undergoing Caesarean section. Spontaneous, oxytocin-stimulated and depolarization induced contractile activity was compared. RESULTS: Direct measurements of myometrial contractility under controlled conditions show that the frequency of contractions and responses to oxytocin are significantly increased in twins compared to singletons. The duration of contraction however was significantly reduced. We find that contractile activity correlates with increasing levels of stretch, using neonatal birth weights as a surrogate for uterine stretch, with response to oxytocin being significantly positively correlated with birth weight. CONCLUSIONS: We have found significant differences in contractile properties between myometrium from singleton and twin pregnancies and that increasing uterine stretch can alter the contractile properties of myometrium. We discuss the implication of these findings to preterm delivery and future studies.