Theoretical model for gene-gene, gene-environment, and gene-sex interactions based on congenic-strain analysis of blood pressure in Dahl salt-sensitive rats.

There is a significant literature describing quantitative trait loci (QTL) controlling blood pressure (BP) in the Dahl salt-sensitive (S) rat. In studies to identify the genes underlying BP QTL it has been common practice to place chromosomal segments from low BP strains on the genetic background of the S rat and then reduce the congenic segments by substitution mapping. The present work suggests a model to simulate genetic interactions found using such congenic strains. The QTL are considered to be switches that can be either in series or in parallel represented by the logic operators AND or OR, respectively. The QTL switches can be on/off switches but are also allowed specific leak properties. The QTL switches are represented by a "universal" switch consisting of two molecules binding to form a complex. Genetic inputs enter the model as allelic products of one of the binding molecules and environmental variation (including dietary salt- and sex-related differences) enters as an influence on the concentration of the other binding molecule. The pairwise interactions of QTL are very well simulated and fall into recognizable patterns. There is, however, often more than one assumed model to predict a given pattern so that all patterns do not necessarily have a unique solution. Nevertheless, the models obtained provide a framework for placing the QTL in pathways relative to one another. Moreover, based on their leak properties pairs of QTL could be identified in which one QTL may alter the properties of the other QTL.

A mutation in the start codon of γ-crystallin D leads to nuclear cataracts in the Dahl SS/Jr-Ctr strain.

Cataracts are a major cause of blindness. The most common forms of cataracts are age- and UV-related and develop mostly in the elderly, while congenital cataracts appear at birth or in early childhood. The Dahl salt-sensitive (SS/Jr) rat is an extensively used model of salt-sensitive hypertension that exhibits concomitant renal disease. In the mid-1980s, cataracts appeared in a few animals in the Dahl S colony, presumably the result of a spontaneous mutation. The mutation was fixed and bred to establish the SS/Jr-Ctr substrain. The SS/Jr-Ctr substrain has been used exclusively by a single investigator to study the role of steroids and hypertension. Using a classical positional cloning approach, we localized the cataract gene with high resolution to a less than 1-Mbp region on chromosome 9 using an F1(SS/Jr-Ctr × SHR) × SHR backcross population. The 1-Mbp region contained only 13 genes, including 4 genes from the γ-crystallins (Cryg) gene family, which are known to play a role in cataract formation. All of the γ-crystallins were sequenced and a novel point mutation in the start codon (ATG → GTG) of the Crygd gene was identified. This led to the complete absence of the CRYGD protein in the eyes of the SS/Jr-Ctr strain. In summary, the identification of the genetic cause in this novel cataract model may provide an opportunity to better understand the development of cataracts, particularly in the context of hypertension.

Use of contiguous congenic strains in analyzing compound QTLs.

Genetic analysis of polygenic traits in rats and mice has been very useful for finding the approximate chromosomal locations of the genes causing quantitative phenotypic variation, so-called quantitative trait loci (QTL). Further localization of the causative genes and their ultimate identification has, however, proven to be slow and frustrating. A major technique for gene identification in such models utilizes series of congenic strains with progressively smaller chromosomal segments introgressed from one inbred strain into another inbred strain. Under the assumption that a single causative locus underlies a QTL, nested series of congenic strains were earlier suggested as an appropriate configuration for the congenic strains. It is now known that most QTL are compound, that is, the QTL signal is caused by clusters of loci where alleles exert positive, negative, and interactive effects on the trait in a given strain comparison. It is argued that in this situation an initial series of nonoverlapping contiguous congenic strains over a relatively large chromosomal region will lead to a better appreciation of the underlying complexity of the QTL and therefore more rapid gene identification. Examples from the literature where this strategy would be helpful, as well as a case where it would be potentially counterproductive, are given.

Positional identification of variants of Adamts16 linked to inherited hypertension.

A previously reported blood pressure (BP) quantitative trait locus on rat Chromosome 1 was isolated in a short congenic segment spanning 804.6 kb. The 804.6 kb region contained only two genes, LOC306664 and LOC306665. LOC306664 is predicted to translate into A Disintegrin-like and Metalloproteinase with Thrombospondin Motifs-16 (Adamts16). LOC306665 is a novel gene. All predicted exons of both LOC306664 and LOC306665 were sequenced. Non-synonymous variants were identified in only one of these genes, LOC306664. These variants were naturally existing polymorphisms among inbred, outbred and wild rats. The full-length rat transcript of Adamts16 was detected in multiple tissues. Similar to ADAMTS16 in humans, expression of Adamts16 was prominent in the kidney. Renal transcriptome analysis suggested that a network of genes related to BP was differential between congenic and S rats. These genes were also differentially expressed between kidney cell lines with or without knock-down of Adamts16. Adamts16 is conserved between rats and humans. It is a candidate gene within the homologous region on human Chromosome 5, which is linked to systolic and diastolic BP in the Quebec Family Study. Multiple variants, including an Ala to Pro variant in codon 90 (rs2086310) of human ADAMTS16, were associated with human resting systolic BP (SBP). Replication study in GenNet confirmed the association of two variants of ADAMTS16 with SBP, including rs2086310. Overall, our report represents a high resolution positional cloning and translational study for Adamts16 as a candidate gene controlling BP.

Dissecting Epistatic QTL for Blood Pressure in Rats: Congenic Strains versus Heterogeneous Stocks, a Reality Check.

Advances in molecular genetics have provided well-defined physical genetic maps and large numbers of genetic markers for both model organisms and humans. It is now possible to gain a fundamental understanding of the genetic architecture underlying quantitative traits, of which blood pressure (BP) is an important example. This review emphasizes analytical techniques and results obtained using the Dahl salt-sensitive (S) rat as a model of hypertension by presenting results in detail for three specific chromosomal regions harboring genetic elements of increasing complexity controlling BP. These results highlight the critical importance of genetic interactions (epistasis) on BP at all levels of structure, intragenic, intergenic, intrachromosomal, interchromosomal, and across whole genomes. In two of the three examples presented, specific DNA structural variations leading to biochemical, physiological, and pathological mechanisms are well defined. This proves the usefulness of the techniques involving interval mapping followed by substitution mapping using congenic strains. These classic techniques are compared to newer approaches using sophisticated statistical analysis on various segregating or outbred model-organism populations, which in some cases are uniquely useful in demonstrating the existence of higher-order interactions. It is speculated that hypertension as an outlier quantitative phenotype is dependent on higher-order genetic interactions. The obstacle to the identification of genetic elements and the biochemical/physiological mechanisms involved in higher-order interactions is not theoretical or technical but the lack of future resources to finish the job of identifying the individual genetic elements underlying the quantitative trait loci for BP and ascertaining their molecular functions. © 2019 American Physiological Society. Compr Physiol 9:1305-1337, 2019.

Transcriptional profiling with a blood pressure QTL interval-specific oligonucleotide array.

Although the evidence for a genetic predisposition to human essential hypertension is compelling, the genetic control of blood pressure (BP) is poorly understood. The Dahl salt-sensitive (S) rat is a model for studying the genetic component of BP. Using this model, we previously reported the identification of 16 different genomic regions that contain one or more BP quantitative trait loci (QTLs). The proximal region of rat chromosome 1 contains multiple BP QTLs. Of these, we have localized the BP QTL1b region to a 13.5-cM (20.92 Mb) region. Interestingly, five additional independent studies in rats and four independent studies in humans have reported genetic linkage for BP control by regions homologous to QTL1b. To view the overall renal transcriptional topography of the positional candidate genes for this QTL, we sought a comparative gene expression profiling between a congenic strain containing QTL1b and control S rats by employing 1) a saturated QTL1b interval-specific oligonucleotide array and 2) a whole genome cDNA microarray representing 20,465 unique genes that are positioned outside the QTL. Results indicated that 17 of the 231 positional candidate genes for this QTL are differentially expressed between the two strains tested. Surprisingly, >1,500 genes outside of QTL1b were differentially expressed between the two rat strains. Integrating the results from the two approaches revealed at least one complex network of transcriptional control initiated by the positional candidate Nr2f2. This network appears to account for the majority of gene expression differences occurring outside of the QTL interval. Further substitution mapping is currently underway to test the validity of each of these differentially expressed positional candidate genes. These results demonstrate the importance of using a saturated oligonucleotide array for identifying and prioritizing differentially expressed positional candidate genes of a BP QTL.

Two closely linked interactive blood pressure QTL on rat chromosome 5 defined using congenic Dahl rats.

Previously we reported the construction of a congenic strain, S.LEW, spanning a large region of rat chromosome 5. The Lewis (LEW) strain was the donor, and the Dahl salt-sensitive (S) strain was the recipient. The congenic strain included a blood pressure quantitative trait locus (QTL). In the present work, a series of nine congenic substrains were constructed from S.LEW which defined two closely linked blood pressure QTL in the region previously thought to contain only one. LEW low-blood-pressure alleles at both QTL were required for a major effect on blood pressure. Neither LEW allele alone had a significant effect on blood pressure. The two QTL were localized to regions 6.3 and 4.6 cM, and these were 1.0 cM apart.

Identification of blood pressure quantitative trait loci that differentiate two hypertensive strains.

OBJECTIVE: To describe genetic loci that differentiate blood pressures in two genetically hypertensive strains, the Dahl salt-sensitive (S) rat and the Albino Surgery (AS) rat. METHODS: A genome scan was performed using 222 genetic markers on an F2 population derived from two hypertensive strains, S and AS. The F2 rats were fed 8% NaCl for 5 weeks before blood pressure measurements were taken. RESULTS: Three blood pressure quantitative trait loci (QTL) were detected, one on each of rat chromosomes (RNO) 2, 4 and 8. The QTL on RNO4, unlike those on RNO2 and RNO8, was not detected in any of the previous seven linkage analyses reported with the S rat as one of the parental strains. Interactions between genetic loci throughout the genome were sought and interactions involving RNO4 with RNO8 and RNO4 with RNO14 were found. Including the new RNO4 locus identified in the present study, 16 distinct regions of the S rat genome have been demonstrated, by linkage analyses, to harbour loci that control blood pressure in the S rat. CONCLUSIONS: Increased blood pressure in two hypertensive strains, S and AS, is differentially regulated by genetic factors present on RNOs 2, 4 and 8. Therefore, of the 16 distinct genomic regions known to harbour blood pressure QTL in S rats, 13 are likely to contain blood pressure alleles that function similarly in the S rat and the AS rat, whereas three regions differentiate the two strains.

Substitution mapping of a blood pressure quantitative trait locus to a 2.73 Mb region on rat chromosome 1.

OBJECTIVE: To improve the localization of a blood pressure quantitative trait locus (BP QTL) on rat chromosome (RNO) 1. METHODS: Congenic substrains were derived from the progenitor congenic strains S.LEW(D1Mco4X1) and S.LEW(D1Mco4X5) which previously localized a BP QTL (region 2) to a 17cM interval on RNO1. The newly developed congenic substrains, along with control Dahl salt-sensitive (S) rats were fed a 2% NaCl diet for 24 days before their BP was compared by both tail-cuff and radiotelemetry methods. RESULTS: By comparing BP of these congenic substrains to that of S rats, we have refined the location of the BP QTL2 region to a 2.73 Mb genomic interval that contains 19 annotated genes in the latest rat genome assembly (version 2.1). Slc9a3, the gene encoding the Na(+)/H(+) exchanger 3, originally a candidate gene in the BP QTL2 region, is excluded based on its map location. CONCLUSION: Substitution mapping was used to reduce a BP QTL on RNO1 from 17 centimorgans (cM) to approximately 1.4 cM (= 2.73 Mb). This region now contains 19 annotated rat candidate genes.

Characterization of blood pressure and renal function in chromosome 5 congenic strains of Dahl S rats.

The present study examined whether transfer of overlapping regions of chromosome 5 that include (4A+) or exclude the cytochrome P-450 (CYP) 4A genes from the Lewis rat alters the renal production of 20-hydroxyeicosatetraenoic acid (20-HETE) and/or the development of hypertension in congenic strains of Dahl salt-sensitive (S) rats. The expression of CYP4A protein and the production of 20-HETE in the renal outer medulla was greater in the 4A+ congenic strain than the levels seen in S rats or in overlapping control congenic strains that exclude the CYP4A region. Mean arterial pressure (MAP) rose from 122 +/- 2 to 190 +/- 7 mmHg in S rats and from 119 +/- 2 and 123 +/- 2 to 189 +/- 7 and 187 +/- 3 mmHg in the two control congenic strains fed an 8.0% NaCl diet for 3 wk. In contrast, MAP only increased from 112 +/- 2 to 150 +/- 5 mmHg in the 4A+ congenic strain. Chronic blockade of the formation of 20-HETE with N-(3-chloro-4-morpholin-4-yl) phenyl-N'-hydroxyimido formamide (TS-011; 1 mg/kg bid) restored the salt-sensitive phenotype in the 4A+ congenic strain and MAP rose to 181 +/- 6 mmHg after an 8.0% NaCl dietary challenge. TS-011 had no effect on the development of hypertension in S rats or the two control congenic strains. The pressure-natriuretic and diuretic responses were fivefold greater in the 4A+ congenic strain than in S rats. These results indicate that transfer of the region of chromosome 5 between markers D5Rat108 to D5Rat31 from the Lewis rat into the Dahl S genetic background increases the renal production of 20-HETE, improves pressure-natriuresis and opposes the development of salt-induced hypertension.

Locating a blood pressure quantitative trait locus within 117 kb on the rat genome: substitution mapping and renal expression analysis.

Previously, a blood pressure (BP) quantitative trait locus (QTL) on rat chromosome 9 (RNO9) was localized to a <2.4 cM interval using congenic strains generated by introgressing segments of RNO9 from the Dahl salt-resistant (R) rat into the background of the Dahl salt-sensitive (S) rat. Renal gene expression using Affymetrix gene chips was profiled on S and a congenic strain spanning the 2.4-cM BP QTL interval. This analysis identified 20 differentially expressed genes/expressed sequence tags. Of these, the locus with the greatest differential expression (30- to 35-fold) was regulated endocrine-specific protein 18 (Resp18), which also mapped in the 2.4-cM BP QTL interval. Additional substitution mapping located the QTL to <0.4 cM or approximately 493 kb. This newly defined QTL region still included Resp18. Nucleotide variants were identified between S and R genomic DNA of Resp18 in the coding, 5' regulatory and 3' untranslated regions. The coding sequence variation (T/C) occurs in exon 2 and predicts an amino acid change (Ile/Val) in the protein product. Resp18 was considered a differentially expressed positional candidate for the QTL. To fine-map the BP QTL, we constructed a congenic strain with a smaller introgressed region. Compared with the S rat, this strain (1) had significantly lower BP, (2) did not contain the R form of Resp18, and (3) did not retain the rather spectacular differential expression of Resp18. Together, these results demonstrate that a BP QTL independent of Resp18 exists within the newly defined 117-kb QTL region on RNO9.

Defining the blood pressure QTL on chromosome 7 in Dahl rats by a 177-kb congenic segment containing Cyp11b1.

Previously we reported that there is a blood pressure quantitative trait locus (QTL) on rat Chromosome (Chr) 7 seen when comparing Dahl salt-sensitive (S) rats and Dahl salt-resistant (R) rats. Evidence was also presented that this QTL was due to genetic variants in the adrenal steroidogenic enzyme 11beta-hydroxylase ( Cyp11b1). A series of congenic strains supported this contention. In the present work we have constructed a final congenic substrain that retains a blood pressure effect and that has an introgressed congenic segment which includes Cyp11b1 and is < 177 kb in size. None of the other genes in the congenic region (eight known genes) have known biological functions for influencing blood pressure. We believe that we have reached the limit of resolution for congenic analysis of a QTL in a rodent animal model, and we conclude that Cyp11b1 causes the observed QTL on rat Chr 7 in Dahl rats.

Multiple blood pressure QTL on rat Chromosome 2 defined by congenic Dahl rats.

Linkage analysis previously demonstrated a blood pressure quantitative trait locus (QTL) on rat Chromosome 2 (Chr 2) in crosses utilizing Dahl salt-sensitive (S) rats. The present work dissects this QTL by using congenic strains in which segments of Chr 2 from Wistar Kyoto rats (WKY) are placed on the S genetic background. Two distinct QTLs were found where one QTL was anticipated. These each accounted for a blood pressure of 15-20 mm Hg in rats fed 2% NaCl diet for 24 days. One QTL was in the <9-cM interval between D2Rat35 and D2Wox18 (Fgg), and the other was in the <7-cM interval between D2Wox18 (Fgg) and D2Mgh10. A third tentative QTL was suggested, but not clearly established, in the <3-cM interval between D2Mgh10 and D2Rat259.

Time-course genetic analysis of albuminuria in Dahl salt-sensitive rats on low-salt diet.

The Dahl salt-sensitive hypertensive (S) rat develops albuminuria early in life even on a low-salt diet. In contrast, the spontaneously hypertensive rat (SHR) is highly resistant to developing albuminuria despite elevated BP. An F(1) hybrid of S and SHR showed a low urinary albumin excretion (UAE) and low urinary protein excretion (UPE) similar to SHR, i.e., SHR was dominant. A genetic analysis was carried out on a large population (n = 276) obtained by backcrossing F(1) rats to the recessive S strain; the population was fed a low-salt diet. Genome scans done at 8, 12, and 16 wk of age yielded ten quantitative trait loci (QTL) for UAE and/or UPE with variable time-course patterns on nine rat chromosomes (RNO), i.e., RNO1, RNO2, RNO6, RNO8, RNO9, RNO10, RNO11, RNO13, and RNO19. There were two UPE QTL on RNO6. At most of the UAE and/or UPE QTL, the S allele was associated with increased excretion, except for one of the QTL on RNO6 and the QTL on RNO11, where the S allele caused decreased excretion. Only the UAE and UPE QTL on RNO10 co-localized with a BP QTL. The S allele on RNO10 caused higher BP and higher UAE. Two additional BP QTL were detected on RNO1 and RNO6. Most of the UAE and UPE QTL co-localized with QTL for kidney lesions characteristic of S rats. Multiple interactions were observed for UAE, many of which involved RNO2. In summary, UAE is highly polygenic and the majority of the QTL altering UAE do not co-localize with QTL for BP as evaluated by tail-cuff measurements of BP.

Localization of a blood pressure QTL to a 2.4-cM interval on rat chromosome 9 using congenic strains.

A blood pressure (BP) quantitative trait locus (QTL) was previously found on rat chromosome 9 using Dahl salt-sensitive (S) and Dahl salt-resistant (R) rats. A congenic strain, S.R(chr9), constructed by introgressing an R chromosomal segment into the S background, previously proved the existence of a BP QTL in a large 34.2-cM segment of chromosome 9. In the current work congenic substrains were constructed from the progenitor congenic strain, S.R(chr9). BP and heart weight comparisons between these congenic substrains and their S control localized the BP QTL to a 4.6-cM interval. Two solute carrier (Na(+)/H(+) exchanger) genes, Nhe2 and Nhe4, were excluded as candidates based on their map locations. A second iteration of congenic substrains was used to localize the QTL further to a 2.4-cM interval. Another solute carrier (Cl(-)/HCO3- exchanger) gene, Ae3, is in this reduced interval and was sequenced for both S and R strains, but no coding sequence variations were found. Ae3 mRNA was not differentially expressed in the kidney of congenic compared to S rats. Although the identity of the QTL remains unknown its map location has been reduced from an interval of 34.2 to 2.4 cM.