CASE-DFT Structure Elucidation of Proton-Deficient Chlorodepsidones from the Indonesian Lichen Teloschistes flavicans and Structure Revision of Flavicansone.

Biodiscovery efforts in Indonesia have aimed to explore the understudied chemical diversity of its rich lichen flora, seeking to find new products endowed with significant biological properties. The chemical screening of a Teloschistes flavicans extract led to selection of this species for further investigation. LC/MS and 1H NMR-based dereplication pinpointed six chlorodepsidones from the thallus of a sample of this lichen. This led to the streamlined isolation and the subsequent structure elucidation of the three new compounds norflavicansone 1, flavicansone 2, and isocaloploicin 3, along with the known chlorodepsidones 4-6, stictic acid 7, aurantiamide acetate 8, and parietin 9. The challenging structure elucidation of these proton-deficient metabolites benefited from a state-of-the-art workflow involving a synergistic combination of Computer-Assisted Structure Elucidation (CASE) and Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations of the top-ranked candidates. This investigation also led to the revision of flavicansone's structure, previously described from this species. The three new molecules that are being reported here are remarkable in that they represent hybrid depsidones in which one of the aromatic rings is derived from orsellinic acid and the other is derived from ß-orcinol, a rare structural feature for lichen depsidones.

Ominoxanthone-The First Xanthone Linearly Fused to a γ-Lactone from Cortinarius ominosus Bidaud Basidiomata. CASE- and DFT-Based Structure Elucidation.

The UHPLC-HRMS analysis of Cortinarius ominosus basidiomata extract revealed that this mushroom accumulated elevated yields of an unreported specialized metabolite. The molecular formula of this unknown compound, C17H10O8, indicated that a challenging structure elucidation lay ahead, owing to its critically low H/C atom ratio. The structure of this new isolate, namely ominoxanthone (1), could not be solved from the interpretation of the usual set of 1D/2D NMR data that conveyed too limited information to afford a single, unambiguous structure. To remedy this, a Computer-Assisted Structure Elucidation (CASE) workflow was used to rank the different possible structure candidates consistent with our scarce spectroscopic data. DFT-based chemical shift calculations on a limited set of top-ranked structures further ascertained the determined structure for ominoxanthone. Although the determined scaffold of ominoxanthone is unprecedented as a natural product, a plausible biosynthetic scenario involving a precursor known from cortinariaceous sources and classical biogenetic reactions could be proposed.

Enhancing computer-assisted structure elucidation with DFT analysis of J-couplings.

Computer-assisted structure elucidation (CASE) is the class of expert systems that derives molecular structures primarily from one-dimensional and two-dimensional nuclear magnetic resonance data. Contemporary CASE systems, including Advanced Chemistry Development/Structure Elucidator (ACD/SE), consider cross-peaks in heteronuclear multiple bond coherence (HMBC) and correlation spectroscopy (COSY) spectra as two- or three-bond correlations by default. However, four and more bond correlations (nonstandard correlations [NSCs]) could be present in these spectra too. The indiscriminate addition of NSCs to the CASE computations is prohibitively expensive. To address this problem, the ACD/SE program performs a logical analysis of observed correlations and determines the minimum number of NSCs. Guided by this information, a more efficient fuzzy structure generation (FSG) algorithm is subsequently applied. Until now, the FSG algorithm was utilized without any verification of the reliability of found NSCs. Here, we report a verification method for NSCs based on the relationship between NSCs and J-couplings computed with high accuracy density functional theory (DFT) methods. We used the example of strychnine to show that 41 (32%) of 8-Hz HMBC cross-peaks were NSCs and were consistent with 4-6 JCH couplings greater than 0.3 Hz. This cutoff value was largely confirmed by the analysis of NSCs in 11 real-world natural products elucidated by ACD/SE. Additionally, utilizing the example of the CASE study of cleospinol A, we showed that the DFT-computed J-couplings of NSCs can distinctively differentiate the correct structure among six proposed isomers. The proposed approach of NSC verification should further improve the robustness of CASE analysis and can help reveal potential problems with reported experimental data.

Towards unbiased and more versatile NMR-based structure elucidation: A powerful combination of CASE algorithms and DFT calculations.

Computer-assisted structure elucidation (CASE) is composed of two steps: (a) generation of all possible structural isomers for a given molecular formula and 2D NMR data (COSY, HSQC, and HMBC) and (b) selection of the correct isomer based on empirical chemical shift predictions. This method has been very successful in solving structural problems of small organic molecules and natural products. However, CASE applications are generally limited to structural isomer problems and can sometimes be inconclusive due to insufficient accuracy of empirical shift predictions. Here, we report a synergistic combination of a CASE algorithm and density functional theory calculations that broadens the range of amenable structural problems to encompass proton-deficient molecules, molecules with heavy elements (e.g., halogens), conformationally flexible molecules, and configurational isomers.

Synergistic Combination of CASE Algorithms and DFT Chemical Shift Predictions: A Powerful Approach for Structure Elucidation, Verification, and Revision.

Structure elucidation of complex natural products and new organic compounds remains a challenging problem. To support this endeavor, CASE (computer-assisted structure elucidation) expert systems were developed. These systems are capable of generating a set of all possible structures consistent with an ensemble of 2D NMR data followed by selection of the most probable structure on the basis of empirical NMR chemical shift prediction. However, in some cases, empirical chemical shift prediction is incapable of distinguishing the correct structure. Herein, we demonstrate for the first time that the combination of CASE and density functional theory (DFT) methods for NMR chemical shift prediction allows the determination of the correct structure even in difficult situations. An expert system, ACD/Structure Elucidator, was used for the CASE analysis. This approach has been tested on three challenging natural products: aquatolide, coniothyrione, and chiral epoxyroussoenone. This work has demonstrated that the proposed synergistic approach is an unbiased, reliable, and very efficient structure verification and de novo structure elucidation method that can be applied to difficult structural problems when other experimental methods would be difficult or impossible to use.

Enhanced automated structure elucidation by inclusion of two-bond specific data.

The availability of cryogenically cooled probes permits routine acquisition of data from low sensitivity pulse sequences such as inadequate and 1,1-adequate. We demonstrate that the use of cryo-probe generated 1,1-adequate data in conjunction with HMBC dramatically improves computer-assisted structure elucidation (CASE) both in terms of speed and accuracy of structure generation. In this study data were obtained on two dissimilar natural products and subjected to CASE analysis with and without the incorporation of two-bond specific data. Dramatic improvements in both structure calculation times and structure candidates were observed by the inclusion of the two-bond specific data.

The application of empirical methods of (13)C NMR chemical shift prediction as a filter for determining possible relative stereochemistry.

The reliable determination of stereocenters contained within chemical structures usually requires utilization of NMR data, chemical derivatization, molecular modeling, quantum-mechanical (QM) calculations and, if available, X-ray analysis. In this article, we show that the number of stereoisomers which need to be thoroughly verified, can be significantly reduced by the application of NMR chemical shift calculation to the full stereoisomer set of possibilities using a fragmental approach based on HOSE codes. The applicability of this suggested method is illustrated using experimental data published for a series of complex chemical structures.

Blind trials of computer-assisted structure elucidation software.

BACKGROUND: One of the largest challenges in chemistry today remains that of efficiently mining through vast amounts of data in order to elucidate the chemical structure for an unknown compound. The elucidated candidate compound must be fully consistent with the data and any other competing candidates efficiently eliminated without doubt by using additional data if necessary. It has become increasingly necessary to incorporate an in silico structure generation and verification tool to facilitate this elucidation process. An effective structure elucidation software technology aims to mimic the skills of a human in interpreting the complex nature of spectral data while producing a solution within a reasonable amount of time. This type of software is known as computer-assisted structure elucidation or CASE software. A systematic trial of the ACD/Structure Elucidator CASE software was conducted over an extended period of time by analysing a set of single and double-blind trials submitted by a global audience of scientists. The purpose of the blind trials was to reduce subjective bias. Double-blind trials comprised of data where the candidate compound was unknown to both the submitting scientist and the analyst. The level of expertise of the submitting scientist ranged from novice to expert structure elucidation specialists with experience in pharmaceutical, industrial, government and academic environments. RESULTS: Beginning in 2003, and for the following nine years, the algorithms and software technology contained within ACD/Structure Elucidator have been tested against 112 data sets; many of these were unique challenges. Of these challenges 9% were double-blind trials. The results of eighteen of the single-blind trials were investigated in detail and included problems of a diverse nature with many of the specific challenges associated with algorithmic structure elucidation such as deficiency in protons, structure symmetry, a large number of heteroatoms and poor quality spectral data. CONCLUSION: When applied to a complex set of blind trials, ACD/Structure Elucidator was shown to be a very useful tool in advancing the computer's contribution to elucidating a candidate structure from a set of spectral data (NMR and MS) for an unknown. The synergistic interaction between humans and computers can be highly beneficial in terms of less biased approaches to elucidation as well as dramatic improvements in speed and throughput. In those cases where multiple candidate structures exist, ACD/Structure Elucidator is equipped to validate the correct structure and eliminate inconsistent candidates. Full elucidation can generally be performed in less than two hours; this includes the average spectral data processing time and data input.

Toward more reliable 13C and 1H chemical shift prediction: a systematic comparison of neural-network and least-squares regression based approaches.

The efficacy of neural network (NN) and partial least-squares (PLS) methods is compared for the prediction of NMR chemical shifts for both 1H and 13C nuclei using very large databases containing millions of chemical shifts. The chemical structure description scheme used in this work is based on individual atoms rather than functional groups. The performances of each of the methods were optimized in a systematic manner described in this work. Both of the methods, least-squares and neural network analyses, produce results of a very similar quality, but the least-squares algorithm is approximately 2--3 times faster.

Fuzzy structure generation: a new efficient tool for Computer-Aided Structure Elucidation (CASE).

Contemporary Computer-Aided Structure Elucidation (CASE) systems are heavily based on the utilization of 2D NMR spectra. The utilization of HMBC/GHMBC and COSY/GCOSY correlations generally assumes that these correlations result from (2-3)JCH and (2-3)JHH spin-spin couplings, respectively, and consequently these values are used as the default setting in these systems. Our previous studies1,2 have shown that about half of the problems studied actually contain some correlations of 4-6 bonds, so-called "nonstandard" correlations. In such cases the initial 2D NMR data are contradictory, and the correct solution is therefore not directly attainable. Unfortunately nonstandard correlations and the number of intervening bonds usually cannot be identified experimentally. In this work we suggest a new approach that we term Fuzzy Structure Generation. This allows the solution of structural problems whose 2D NMR data contain an unknown number of nonstandard correlations having different and unknown lengths. Suggested methods for the application of Fuzzy Structure Generation are described, and their application is illustrated by a series of real-world examples. We conclude that Fuzzy Structure Generation is efficient, and there is no real alternative at present in terms of a universal practical method for the structure elucidation of organic molecules from 2D NMR data.

Are deterministic expert systems for computer-assisted structure elucidation obsolete?

Expert systems for spectroscopic molecular structure elucidation have been developed since the mid-1960s. Algorithms associated with the structure generation process within these systems are deterministic; that is, they are based on graph theory and combinatorial analysis. A series of expert systems utilizing 2D NMR spectra have been described in the literature and are capable of determining the molecular structures of large organic molecules including complex natural products. Recently, an opinion was expressed in the literature that these systems would fail when elucidating structures containing more than 30 heavy atoms. A suggestion was put forward that stochastic algorithms for structure generation would be necessary to overcome this shortcoming. In this article, we describe a comprehensive investigation of the capabilities of the deterministic expert system Structure Elucidator. The results of performing the structure elucidation of 250 complex natural products with this program were studied and generalized. The conclusion is that 2D NMR deterministic expert systems are certainly capable of elucidating large structures (up to about 100 heavy atoms) and can deal with the complexities associated with both poor and contradictory spectral data.

Application of a new expert system for the structure elucidation of natural products from their 1D and 2D NMR data.

Described herein are applications of the latest version of the StrucEluc expert software system, enhanced to use 2D NMR data, to the structure elucidation of 60 recently isolated natural products. In this study, selected molecules containing between 15 and 65 skeletal atoms and having molecular masses ranging from 200 to 900 amu have been investigated. The correct structure was determined unambiguously for 58 of these molecules. The structures for 75% of the data sets were determined in less than one minute, while 90% of the analyses required no more than 30 minutes. The strategy of structure elucidation by this expert system is described, and several examples are discussed. These illustrate that StrucEluc is a powerful and versatile analytical tool for the structure elucidation of natural products.

Structure Elucidator: a versatile expert system for molecular structure elucidation from 1D and 2D NMR data and molecular fragments.

StrucEluc is an expert system that allows the computer-assisted elucidation of chemical structures based on the inputs of a series of spectral data including 1D and 2D NMR and mass spectra. The system has been enabled to allow a chemist to utilize fragments stored in a fragment database as well as user-defined fragments submitted by the chemist in the structure elucidation process. The association of fragments in this way has been shown to dramatically speed up the process of structure generation from 2D NMR data and has helped to minimize or eliminate the need for user intervention thereby further enabling the vision of automated elucidation. The use of fragments has frequently transformed very difficult 2D NMR elucidation challenges into easily solvable tasks. A strategy to utilize molecular fragments has been developed and optimized based on specific challenging examples. This strategy will be described here using real world examples. Experience gained by solving more than 150 structure elucidation problems from a variety of literature sources is also reviewed in this work.

Structure elucidation from 2D NMR spectra using the StrucEluc expert system: detection and removal of contradictions in the data.

The elucidation of chemical structures from 2D NMR data commonly utilizes a combination of COSY, HMQC/HSQC, and HMBC data. Generally COSY connectivities are assumed to mostly describe the separation of protons that are separated by 1 skeletal bond (3JHH), while HMBC connectivities represent protons separated from carbon atoms by 1 to 2 skeletal bonds (2JCH and 3JCH). Obviously COSY and HMBC connectivities of lengths greater than those described have been detected. Though experimental techniques have recently been described to aid in the identification of the nature of the couplings the detection of whether a coupling is 2-bond or greater still remains a challenge in most laboratories. In the StrucEluc software system the common lengths of the connectivities, 1-bond for COSY and 1- or 2-bond for HMBC, derived from 2D NMR data are set as the default. Therefore, in the presence of any extended connectivities contradictions can appear in the 2D NMR data. In this article, algorithmic methods for the detection and removal of contradictions in 2D NMR data that have been developed in support of StrucEluc are described. The methods are based on the analysis of molecular connectivity diagrams, MCDs. These methods have been implemented in the StrucEluc system and tested by solving 50 structural problems with 2D NMR spectral data containing contradictions. The presence of contradictions was detected by the algorithm in 90% of the cases, and the contradictions were automatically removed in approximately 50% of the problems. A method of "fuzzy" structure generation in the presence of contradictions has been suggested and successfully tested in this work. This work will demonstrate examples of the application of developed methods to a number of structural problems.