Testing the reproducibility and robustness of the cancer biology literature by robot.

Scientific results should not just be 'repeatable' (replicable in the same laboratory under identical conditions), but also 'reproducible' (replicable in other laboratories under similar conditions). Results should also, if possible, be 'robust' (replicable under a wide range of conditions). The reproducibility and robustness of only a small fraction of published biomedical results has been tested; furthermore, when reproducibility is tested, it is often not found. This situation is termed 'the reproducibility crisis', and it is one the most important issues facing biomedicine. This crisis would be solved if it were possible to automate reproducibility testing. Here, we describe the semi-automated testing for reproducibility and robustness of simple statements (propositions) about cancer cell biology automatically extracted from the literature. From 12 260 papers, we automatically extracted statements predicted to describe experimental results regarding a change of gene expression in response to drug treatment in breast cancer, from these we selected 74 statements of high biomedical interest. To test the reproducibility of these statements, two different teams used the laboratory automation system Eve and two breast cancer cell lines (MCF7 and MDA-MB-231). Statistically significant evidence for repeatability was found for 43 statements, and significant evidence for reproducibility/robustness in 22 statements. In two cases, the automation made serendipitous discoveries. The reproduced/robust knowledge provides significant insight into cancer. We conclude that semi-automated reproducibility testing is currently achievable, that it could be scaled up to generate a substantive source of reliable knowledge and that automation has the potential to mitigate the reproducibility crisis.

A cancer stem cell origin for human endometrial carcinoma?

Endometrial cancer (EC) is the most common gynaecological malignancy affecting women in the western world. Cancer stem cells (CSCs) are defined as a subset of tumour cells with the capacity to self-renew and give rise to the differentiated cells that comprise the bulk of the tumour. Given that a rare population of epithelial stem/progenitor cells has been identified in human endometrium, it is possible that these cells or their progeny may be the source of the putative CSCs that may initiate and maintain EC. Studies have shown that some cells within EC have the capacity to initiate clones that undergo self-renewing cell division and form tumours in vivo that can be serially passaged, demonstrating self-renewal, proliferation and differentiation abilities of the potential EC stem cells (ECSCs). These potential ECSCs may be located within the tumour cell population expressing CD133 and/or within the side population. With the discovery of markers for ECSCs, it is hoped that ECSCs can be isolated and characterised, and that their role in the development of human EC will be further investigated. This knowledge opens the way for the development of new treatment modalities that target the CSCs, but spares normal endometrial stem/progenitor cells and other cells. Such treatments will be particularly useful for early-stage and pre-menopausal EC candidates where the uterus may be conserved, and for late-stage cases where hysterectomy is not curative and current treatments target the bulk tumour cells rather than CSCs.

Optimization of a solid phase extraction procedure for prostaglandin E2, F2 alpha and their tissue metabolites.

The primary prostaglandins PGE(2) and PGF(2 alpha) are metabolized in tissues by a series of enzymatic and non-enzymatic reactions. To measure metabolic rates and individual reaction rates it is necessary to extract the parent prostaglandins and metabolites before the separation and quantification of each compound is achieved. Here we have established and optimized a solid phase extraction (SPE) procedure to recover PGE(2), PGF(2 alpha) and their six enzymatic and non-enzymatic tissue metabolites from aqueous solutions including urine, plasma and tissue homogenate. We have used octadecyl-bonded silica gel as the stationary phase and methanol-water mixtures as binary mobile phases. The volumes and concentrations of the washing and elution solutions were optimized individually for each PG. Recoveries of all PG standards were quantitative except for PGEM, which was recovered at 80% efficiency. Biological matrix components interfered with the extraction in a PG- and matrix-specific fashion. Inclusion of 1% formic acid in the loading mixture raised recoveries from urine, plasma and tissue homogenate to >or=90%. This SPE method is the first that has been optimized by systematic elution studies for PGE(2), PGF(2 alpha) and the complement of their tissue metabolites. The procedure is simple, robust and can serve as an effective pre-purification step before downstream separation and quantification of each tissue metabolite of PGE(2) and PGF(2 alpha) from complex biological matrices.

Sensitivity and specificity of a novel classifier for the early diagnosis of dengue.

BACKGROUND: Dengue is the commonest arboviral disease of humans. An early and accurate diagnosis of dengue can support clinical management, surveillance and disease control and is central to achieving the World Health Organisation target of a 50% reduction in dengue case mortality by 2020. METHODS: 5729 children with fever of <72 hrs duration were enrolled into this multicenter prospective study in southern Vietnam between 2010-2012. A composite of gold standard diagnostic tests identified 1692 dengue cases. Using statistical methods, a novel Early Dengue Classifier (EDC) was developed that used patient age, white blood cell count and platelet count to discriminate dengue cases from non-dengue cases. RESULTS: The EDC had a sensitivity of 74.8% (95%CI: 73.0-76.8%) and specificity of 76.3% (95%CI: 75.2-77.6%) for the diagnosis of dengue. As an adjunctive test alongside NS1 rapid testing, sensitivity of the composite test was 91.6% (95%CI: 90.4-92.9%). CONCLUSIONS: We demonstrate that the early diagnosis of dengue can be enhanced beyond the current standard of care using a simple evidence-based algorithm. The results should support patient management and clinical trials of specific therapies.

Evidence for cancer stem cells in human endometrial carcinoma.

Emerging evidence indicates that the highly regenerative human endometrium harbors rare populations of epithelial progenitor cells. In tumors of other regenerative epithelial tissues, rare cancer stem cells (CSC) have been identified that may have originated from normal epithelial stem/progenitor cells. We hypothesized that CSC are responsible for epithelial neoplasia associated with endometrial carcinoma, the most common gynecologic malignancy in women. Stem cell characteristics of single cells isolated from endometrial carcinoma tissues from women ages 62 +/- 11.8 years (n = 34) were assessed. Twenty-five of 28 endometrial carcinoma samples contained a small population of clonogenic cells [0.24% (0-1.84%)], with no significant difference in cloning efficiency between the three grades of endometrial carcinoma or between endometrial carcinoma and normal endometrial epithelial samples. Isolated endometrial carcinoma cells transplanted under the kidney capsule of immunocompromised mice in serial dilution (2 x 10(6)-1 x 10(4) cells) generated tumors in 8 of 9 samples with morphologies similar to the parent tumors. These tumors recapitulated cytokeratin, vimentin, estrogen receptor-alpha, and progesterone receptor expression of the parent tumor, indicating that tumor-initiating cells likely differentiated into cells comprising the endometrial carcinoma tissue. Individual clones underwent serial clonal subculture 2.5 to 4 times, with a trend of increasing number of subclonings with increasing tumor grade, indicating increasing self-renewal with greater malignancy. Clonally derived endometrial carcinoma cells also expressed the self-renewal genes BMI-1, NANOG, and SOX-2. Isolated cells from primary tumors were serially transplanted 3 to 5 times in nonobese diabetic/severe combined immunodeficient mice, showing self-renewal in vivo. This evidence of cells with clonogenic, self-renewing, differentiating, and tumorigenic properties suggests that a CSC population may be responsible for production of endometrial carcinoma tumor cells.