Assessment of twelve echovirus virus-neutralisation assays in Europe: recommendations for harmonisation of non-polio enterovirus sero-surveillance studies.

Non-polio enteroviruses (NPEV) cause significant disease worldwide. Population-based sero-surveillance, by measuring antibodies against specific NPEV types, provides additional information on past circulation and the prediction for future upsurges. Virus neutralisation assays (VNA), the current method of choice for measuring NPEV type specific antibodies, are not entirely standardised. Via the European Non-Polio Enterovirus Network, we organised a VNA quality assessment in which twelve laboratories participated. We provided five echovirus (E) types (E1, E18, E30 G2, E30 G6 and E6) and intravenous immunoglobulins (IVIG) as a sample for the NPEV VNA quality assessment. Differences in VNA protocols and neutralising Ab (nAb) titres were found between the participating laboratories with geometric coefficients of variation ranging from 10.3-62.9 %. Mixed-effects regression analysis indicated a small but significant effect of type of cell line used. Harmonisation of cell line passage number, however, did not improve variation between laboratories. Calibration by making use of a reference sample, reduced variation between laboratories but differences in nAb titres remained higher than two log2 dilution steps. In conclusion, sero-surveillance data from different laboratories should be compared with caution and standardised protocols are needed.

Neutralization of African enterovirus A71 genogroups by antibodies to canonical genogroups.

Enterovirus 71 (EV-A71) is a major public health problem, causing a range of illnesses from hand-foot-and-mouth disease to severe neurological manifestations. EV-A71 strains have been phylogenetically classified into eight genogroups (A to H), based on their capsid-coding genomic region. Genogroups B and C have caused large outbreaks worldwide and represent the two canonical circulating EV-A71 subtypes. Little is known about the antigenic diversity of new genogroups as compared to the canonical ones. Here, we compared the antigenic features of EV-A71 strains that belong to the canonical B and C genogroups and to genogroups E and F, which circulate in Africa. Analysis of the peptide sequences of EV-A71 strains belonging to different genogroups revealed a high level of conservation of the capsid residues involved in known linear and conformational neutralization antigenic sites. Using a published crystal structure of the EV-A71 capsid as a model, we found that most of the residues that are seemingly specific to some genogroups were mapped outside known antigenic sites or external loops. These observations suggest a cross-neutralization activity of anti-genogroup B or C antibodies against strains of genogroups E and F. Neutralization assays were performed with diverse rabbit and mouse anti-EV-A71 sera, anti-EV-A71 human standards and a monoclonal neutralizing antibody. All the batches of antibodies that were tested successfully neutralized all available isolates, indicating an overall broad cross-neutralization between the canonical genogroups B and C and genogroups E and F. A panel constituted of more than 80 individual human serum samples from Cambodia with neutralizing antibodies against EV-A71 subgenogroup C4 showed quite similar cross-neutralization activities between isolates of genogroups C4, E and F. Our results thus indicate that the genetic drift underlying the separation of EV-A71 strains into genogroups A, B, C, E and F does not correlate with the emergence of antigenically distinct variants.

Animal enteroviruses: a glimpse of a wide evolutionary landscape.

The genus Enterovirus (family Picornaviridae) contains numerous viruses, most of which have been identified in humans. Among them, the three serotypes of poliovirus, coxsackieviruses A and B, echoviruses, rhinoviruses and other enteroviruses (EVs) responsible in humans for a wide spectrum of clinical manifestations. There are also 60 identified EVs in different mammals. Some have been found in both humans and animals, demonstrating the possibility of zoonotic transmission of certain EVs. Compared to human EVs, genetic and epidemiological data about animal EVs are scarce. However, the detection of EVs in various species of mammals and their presence on all continents suggest that the number of EVs still to be discovered is very important. Some EVs found in animals have characteristics never seen in human EVs. Furthermore, the unique phylogenetic relationships observed between some animal EVs raise interesting questions about the rules that govern the evolution of these viruses. The aim of this review is to present the salient data on animal EVs and to highlight the questions they raise.

[Animal enteroviruses: a glimpse of a wide evolutionary landscape]. / Entérovirus des animaux : lumière sur l'immensité de l'espace évolutif des entérovirus.

The genus Enterovirus (family Picornaviridae) contains numerous viruses, most of which have been identified in humans. Among them, the three serotypes of poliovirus, coxsackieviruses A and B, echoviruses, rhinoviruses and other enteroviruses (EVs) responsible in humans for a wide spectrum of clinical manifestations. There are also 60 identified EVs in different mammals. Some have been found in both humans and animals, demonstrating the possibility of zoonotic transmission of certain EVs. Compared to human EVs, genetic and epidemiological data for animal EVs are scarce. However, the detection of EV in various species of mammals and their presence on all continents suggest that the number of EV still to be discovered is very important. Some EVs found in animals have characteristics never seen in human EVs. Furthermore, the unique phylogenetic relationships observed between animal EVs raise interesting questions about the rules that govern the evolution of these viruses. The aim of this review is to present the salient data on animal EVs and to highlight the questions they raise.

Strengthened surveillance revealed a rapid disappearance of the poliovirus serotype 2 vaccine strain in Madagascar after its removal from the oral polio vaccine.

To assess circulation of the Sabin 2 poliovirus vaccine strain in Madagascar after its withdrawal from the oral polio vaccine in April 2016, a reinforced poliovirus surveillance was implemented in three regions of Madagascar from January 2016 to December 2017. Environmental samples and stool specimens from healthy children were screened using the Global Polio Laboratory Network algorithm to detect the presence of polioviruses. Detected polioviruses were molecularly typed and their genomes fully sequenced. Polioviruses were detected during all but 4 months of the study period. All isolates were related to the vaccine strains and no wild poliovirus was detected. The majority of isolates belong to the serotype 3. The last detection of Sabin 2 occurred in July 2016, 3 months after its withdrawal. No vaccine-derived poliovirus of any serotype was observed during the study. Only few poliovirus isolates contained sequences from non-polio origin. The genetic characterization of all the poliovirus isolates did not identify isolates that were highly divergent compared to the vaccine strains. This observation is in favor of a good vaccine coverage that efficiently prevented long-lasting transmission chains between unvaccinated persons. This study underlines that high commitment in the fight against polioviruses can succeed in stopping their circulation even in countries where poor sanitation remains a hurdle.

Enterovirus detection in different regions of Madagascar reveals a higher abundance of enteroviruses of species C in areas where several outbreaks of vaccine-derived polioviruses occurred.

BACKGROUND: Poliomyelitis outbreaks due to pathogenic vaccine-derived polioviruses (VDPVs) are threatening and complicating the global polio eradication initiative. Most of these VDPVs are genetic recombinants with non-polio enteroviruses (NPEVs) of species C. Little is known about factors favoring this genetic macroevolution process. Since 2001, Madagascar has experienced several outbreaks of poliomyelitis due to VDPVs, and most of VDPVs were isolated in the south of the island. The current study explored some of the viral factors that can promote and explain the emergence of recombinant VDPVs in Madagascar. METHODS: Between May to August 2011, we collected stools from healthy children living in two southern and two northern regions of Madagascar. Virus isolation was done in RD, HEp-2c, and L20B cell lines, and enteroviruses were detected using a wide-spectrum 5'-untranslated region RT-PCR assay. NPEVs were then sequenced for the VP1 gene used for viral genotyping. RESULTS: Overall, we collected 1309 stools, of which 351 NPEVs (26.8%) were identified. Sequencing revealed 33 types of viruses belonging to three different species: Enterovirus A (8.5%), Enterovirus B (EV-B, 40.2%), and Enterovirus C (EV-C, 51.3%). EV-C species included coxsackievirus A13, A17, and A20 previously described as putative recombination partners for poliovirus vaccine strains. Interestingly, the isolation rate was higher among stools originating from the South (30.3% vs. 23.6%, p-value = 0.009). EV-C were predominant in southern sites (65.7%) while EV-B predominated in northern sites (54.9%). The factors that explain the relative abundance of EV-C in the South are still unknown. CONCLUSIONS: Whatever its causes, the relative abundance of EV-C in the South of Madagascar may have promoted the infections of children by EV-C, including the PV vaccine strains, and have favored the recombination events between PVs and NPEVs in co-infected children, thus leading to the recurrent emergence of recombinant VDPVs in this region of Madagascar.

Vaccine-Derived Polioviruses, Central African Republic, 2019.

Since May 2019, the Central African Republic has experienced a poliomyelitis outbreak caused by type 2 vaccine-derived polioviruses (VDPV-2s). The outbreak affected Bangui, the capital city, and 10 districts across the country. The outbreak resulted from several independent emergence events of VDPV-2s featuring recombinant genomes with complex mosaic genomes. The low number of mutations (<20) in the viral capsid protein 1-encoding region compared with the vaccine strain suggests that VDPV-2 had been circulating for a relatively short time (probably <3 years) before being isolated. Environmental surveillance, which relies on a limited number of sampling sites in the Central African Republic and does not cover the whole country, failed to detect the circulation of VDPV-2s before some had induced poliomyelitis in children.

[A cold case: non-replicative recombination in positive-strand RNA viruses]. / Une affaire non résolue : la recombinaison non réplicative chez les virus à ARN de polarité positive.

Genetic recombination is a major force driving the evolution of some species of positive sense RNA viruses. Recombination events occur when at least two viruses simultaneously infect the same cell, thereby giving rise to new genomes comprised of genetic sequences originating from the parental genomes. The main mechanism by which recombination occurs involves the viral polymerase that generates a chimera as it switches templates during viral replication. Various experimental systems have alluded to the existence of recombination events that are independent of viral polymerase activity. The origins and frequency of such events remain to be elucidated to this day. Furthermore, it is not known whether non-replicative recombination yields products that are different from recombinants generated by the viral polymerase. If this is the case, then non-replicative recombination may play a unique role in the evolution of positive sense RNA viruses. Finally, the sparse data available suggest that non-replicative recombination does not necessarily involve only virus-specific sequences. It is thus possible that the non-replicative recombination observed in virus-focused studies may in fact reveal a more generalized mechanism that is non-specific to virus RNAs.

A cold case: non-replicative recombination in positive-strand RNA viruses.

Genetic recombination is a major force driving the evolution of some species of positive sense RNA viruses. Recombination events occur when at least two viruses simultaneously infect the same cell, thereby giving rise to new genomes comprised of genetic sequences originating from the parental genomes. The main mechanism by which recombination occurs involves the viral polymerase that generates a chimera as it switches templates during viral replication. Various experimental systems have alluded to the existence of recombination events that are independent of viral polymerase activity. The origins and the frequency of such events remain to be elucidated to this day. Furthermore, it is not known whether non-replicative recombination yields products that are different from recombinants generated by the viral polymerase. If this is the case, then non-replicative recombination may play a unique role in the evolution of positive sense RNA viruses. Finally, the sparse data available suggest that non-replicative recombination does not necessarily involve only virus-specific sequences. It is thus possible that the non-replicative recombination observed in virus-focused studies may in fact reveal a more generalized mechanism that is non-specific to virus RNAs.

High Permissiveness for Genetic Exchanges between Enteroviruses of Species A, including Enterovirus 71, Favors Evolution through Intertypic Recombination in Madagascar.

Human enteroviruses of species A (EV-A) are the leading cause of hand-foot-and-mouth disease (HFMD). EV-A71 is frequently implicated in HFMD outbreaks and can also cause severe neurological manifestations. We investigated the molecular epidemiological processes at work and the contribution of genetic recombination to the evolutionary history of EV-A in Madagascar, focusing on the recently described EV-A71 genogroup F in particular. Twenty-three EV-A isolates, collected mostly in 2011 from healthy children living in various districts of Madagascar, were characterized by whole-genome sequencing. Eight different types were identified, highlighting the local circulation and diversity of EV-A. Comparative genome analysis revealed evidence of frequent recent intra- and intertypic genetic exchanges between the noncapsid sequences of Madagascan EV-A isolates. The three EV-A71 isolates had different evolutionary histories in terms of recombination, with one isolate displaying a mosaic genome resulting from recent genetic exchanges with Madagascan coxsackieviruses A7 and possibly A5 and A10 or common ancestors. The engineering and characterization of recombinants generated from progenitors belonging to different EV-A types or EV-A71 genogroups with distantly related nonstructural sequences indicated a high level of permissiveness for intertypic genetic exchange in EV-A. This permissiveness suggests that the primary viral functions associated with the nonstructural sequences have been highly conserved through the diversification and evolution of the EV-A species. No outbreak of disease due to EV-A has yet been reported in Madagascar, but the diversity, circulation, and evolution of these viruses justify surveillance of EV-A circulation and HFMD cases to prevent possible outbreaks due to emerging strains.IMPORTANCE Human enteroviruses of species A (EV-A), including EV-A71, are the leading cause of hand-foot-and-mouth disease (HFMD) and may also cause severe neurological manifestations. We investigated the circulation and molecular evolution of EV-A in Madagascar, focusing particularly on the recently described EV-A71 genogroup F. Eight different types, collected mostly in 2011, were identified, highlighting the local circulation and diversity of EV-A. Comparative genome analysis revealed evidence of frequent genetic exchanges between the different types of isolates. The three EV-A71 isolates had different evolutionary histories in terms of recombination. The engineering and characterization of recombinants involving progenitors belonging to different EV-A types indicated a high degree of permissiveness for genetic exchange in EV-A. No outbreak of disease due to EV-A has yet been reported in Madagascar, but the diversity, circulation, and evolution of these viruses justify the surveillance of EV-A circulation to prevent possible HFMD outbreaks due to emerging strains.

Reinforced poliovirus and enterovirus surveillance in Romania, 2015-2016.

Due to the risk of poliovirus importation from Ukraine in 2015, a combined surveillance program monitoring the circulation of enteroviruses (EVs) in healthy children from at-risk areas and in the environment was conducted in Romania. Virological testing of stool samples collected from 155 healthy children aged from two months to six years and of 186 sewage water samples collected from different areas was performed. A total of 58 (37.42%) stool samples and 50 (26.88%) sewage water samples were positive for non-polio EVs, but no poliovirus was detected. A high level of circulation of echovirus (E) types 6 and 7 and coxsackievirus (CV) type B5 was observed.

Metagenomic analysis identifies human adenovirus 31 in children with acute flaccid paralysis in Tunisia.

A variety of viruses can cause acute flaccid paralysis (AFP). However, the causative agent, sometimes, remains undetermined. Metagenomics helps in identifying viruses not diagnosed by conventional methods. Stool samples from AFP (n = 104) and non-AFP (n = 114) cases that tested enterovirus-negative by WHO standard methods were investigated. A metagenomics approach, first used on five pools of four samples each, revealed the presence of adenovirus sequences. Amplification in A549 cells and full-genome sequencing were used for complete virus identification and for designing a PCR assay to screen individual related samples. Metagenomic analysis showed that adenovirus sequences that were closely to the A31 and A61 genotypes were the most abundant. Two out of the corresponding 20 individual samples were found positive by PCR, and isolates were obtained in cell culture. Phylogenetic analysis based on complete genome sequences showed that the viruses belong to HAdV-A31 genotype (98-100% nucleotide sequence identity). PCR analysis of stool samples from all AFP and non-AFP cases revealed that a larger proportion of the positive samples were from AFP cases (17.3%) than from non-AFP cases (2.4%). These results open the way to studies aiming to test a possible role of HAdV-A31 in the pathogenesis of AFP.

Genetic Characterization of Enterovirus A71 Circulating in Africa.

We analyzed whole-genome sequences of 8 enterovirus A71 isolates (EV-A71). We confirm the circulation of genogroup C and the new genogroup E in West Africa. Our analysis demonstrates wide geographic circulation and describes genetic exchanges between EV-A71 and autochthonous EV-A that might contribute to the emergence of pathogenic lineages.

[Nomenclature and classification of the enteroviruses: story of a long history]. / Nomenclature et classification des entérovirus : quelle histoire !

Since the identification of the first enteroviruses, the classification and the nomenclature of these viruses were modified several times. Even the base of the classification was changed during the 2000s when genetic criteria superseded the historical serological criteria used to identify enteroviruses. Product of these modifications, the current classification and nomenclature are confusing for students, researchers and practitioners who discover them for the first time; coxsackieviruses A and B, echoviruses and polioviruses are gathered into different species while surprisingly, in view of the etymology, the rhinoviruses now belong the genus Enterovirus. This review aims to summarize the history of the methods and concepts that were used to elaborate the successive classifications and to feature the discoveries that led to their modifications. Mostly slight, sometimes drastic, these modifications underline the history of our knowledge about the enteroviruses and their diversity; indirectly, they highlight our profound ignorance.

Evolution and Emergence of Enteroviruses through Intra- and Inter-species Recombination: Plasticity and Phenotypic Impact of Modular Genetic Exchanges in the 5' Untranslated Region.

Genetic recombination shapes the diversity of RNA viruses, including enteroviruses (EVs), which frequently have mosaic genomes. Pathogenic circulating vaccine-derived poliovirus (cVDPV) genomes consist of mutated vaccine poliovirus (PV) sequences encoding capsid proteins, and sequences encoding nonstructural proteins derived from other species' C EVs, including certain coxsackieviruses A (CV-A) in particular. Many cVDPV genomes also have an exogenous 5' untranslated region (5' UTR). This region is involved in virulence and includes the cloverleaf (CL) and the internal ribosomal entry site, which play major roles in replication and the initiation of translation, respectively. We investigated the plasticity of the PV genome in terms of recombination in the 5' UTR, by developing an experimental model involving the rescue of a bipartite PV/CV-A cVDPV genome rendered defective by mutations in the CL, following the co-transfection of cells with 5' UTR RNAs from each of the four human EV species (EV-A to -D). The defective cVDPV was rescued by recombination with 5' UTR sequences from the four EV species. Homologous and nonhomologous recombinants with large deletions or insertions in three hotspots were isolated, revealing a striking plasticity of the 5' UTR. By contrast to the recombination of the cVDPV with the 5' UTR of group II (EV-A and -B), which can decrease viral replication and virulence, recombination with the 5' UTRs of group I (EV-C and -D) appeared to be evolutionarily neutral or associated with a gain in fitness. This study illustrates how the genomes of positive-strand RNA viruses can evolve into mosaic recombinant genomes through intra- or inter-species modular genetic exchanges, favoring the emergence of new recombinant lineages.

Coxsackievirus A24 Variant Associated with Acute Haemorrhagic Conjunctivitis Cases, French Guiana, 2017.

In 2017, numerous cases of acute haemorrhagic conjunctivitis (AHC) were reported in the Caribbean and in South America. Preliminary reports identified adenoviruses and enteroviruses in some patient samples but, until now, none of the etiologic agents have been fully characterized. We report the full-length genomic sequences of 4 coxsackievirus A24 (CV-A24) isolates collected from AHC patients in French Guiana during this outbreak (May and June 2017). These isolates are very closely related and belong to the genotype IV of CV-A24 variant, which consists of strains sampled worldwide during AHC outbreaks in the 2000s and 2010s. No recombination events were detected within the genomic sequences, indicating that members of this genotype have continuously circulated worldwide for more than 10 years without undergoing recombination with other enteroviruses. This unusual trait could be due to their ocular tropism that could impede genetic exchanges between these viruses and other enteroviruses, which replicate mainly in the gut.

Recrutement des kinases PI4KIII aux organelles de réplication virale au cours de l'infection par le poliovirus et d'autres virus à ARN de polarité positive.

One characteristic of infections with RNA viruses of positive polarity is the generation of new specialized membrane structures acting as platforms accommodating the complexes involved in replication of the viral genome. The functionality of these "replication organelles" is dependent on interactions between viral nonstructural proteins, recruited host factors and viral RNAs. Poliovirus, the causal agent of paralytic poliomyelitis, is the model most frequently used for identification of the viral and cellular components involved in this process. Several recent studies have suggested that the efficiency of genome replication for poliovirus and other members of the Picornaviridæ family results from the recruitment of a phosphatidylinositol (PI) kinase, PI4KIIIß (phosphatidylinositol-4-kinase IIIß), which generates a lipid membrane microenvironment rich in PI4P (phosphatidylinositol-4-phosphate) at sites of replication. The nonstructural protein 3A of these viruses has been shown to play a role in the enrichment of replication organelle membranes in PI4KIIIß, but the mechanisms of kinase recruitment seem to differ between members of this family of viruses. Hepatitis C, from the Flaviviridæ family, recruits another PI4KIII kinase, PI4KIIIα, to sites of replication, through another nonstructural protein, NS5A. In this review, we will describe the various recently proposed models and the potential role of PI4P lipids. Finally, we will show that PI4KIII kinases are potential targets for the development of antiviral drugs targeting many positive-polarity RNA viruses.

Opening a 60-year time capsule: sequences of historical poliovirus cold variants shed a new light on a contemporary strain.

Polioviruses (PVs) are positive strand RNA viruses responsible for poliomyelitis. Many PVs have been isolated and phenotypically characterized in the 1940s-50s for the purpose of identifying attenuated strains that could be used as vaccine strains. Among these historical PVs, only few are genetically characterized. We report here the sequencing of four PV strains stored for more than 60 years in a sealed box. These PVs are cold variants that were selected by Albert Sabin based on their capacity to multiply at relatively low temperatures. Inoculation of permissive cells at 25°C showed that two of the four historical virus stocks still contained infectious particles. Both viruses reached titres that were higher at 25°C than at 37°C, thus demonstrating that they were genuine cold variants. We obtained sequences that span virtually all the genome for three out of the four strains; a short sequence that partly covers the 5' untranslated region was recovered for the last one. Unexpectedly, the genome of one historical cold variant (which derives from PV-3 Glenn) displayed a very high nucleotide identity (above 95%) with that of a PV strain (PV-3 strain WIV14) sampled in China in 2014 and then classified as a highly evolved vaccine-derived PV. Our analyses made this hypothesis very unlikely and strongly suggested that Glenn and WIV14 shared a very recent common ancestor with one another. Some strains used to produce the inactivated polio vaccine were also very close to Glenn and WIV14 in the capsid-encoding region, but they had not been sequenced beyond the capsid. We therefore sequenced one of these strains, Saukett A, which was available in our collection. Saukett A and WIV14 featured an identity higher than 99% at the nucleotide level. This work provides original data on cold variants that were produced and studied decades ago. It also highlights that sequences of historical PV strains could be crucial to reliably characterize contemporary PVs in case of release from a natural reservoir or from a facility, which is of highest importance for the PV eradication program.

Characterization of enteroviruses circulating among farm animals and children in Central African Republic.

To characterize enteroviruses (EVs) circulating in farm animals in Central African Republic (CAR), we screened 192 stools of animals under 12 months belonging to family farms located in or near Bangui. To assess whether EV exchanges exist between these animals and humans, we also screened 195 stools of children who lived in contact with farm animals, as well as control stools of 358 children with no contact with farm animals. EVs were typed based on their capsid sequences.In children, all EVs belonged to species A, B and C, with EV-Cs accounting for 60%. Some EV-Cs shared recent common ancestors with lineages of vaccine-derived poliovirus that emerged in the country in 2019-2020. In animals, we identified EV-Gs that belonged to 10 different types, including a previously unknown one that we named EV-G28, while no EV-E or EV-F were observed. The CAR EV-Gs were genetically closely related to specimens sampled in other continents and some of them harboured the torovirus-derived insertion already reported in some EV-Gs. The worldwide circulation of EV-Gs is likely due the massive international trade of live animals. Besides, two human EV-Cs (coxsackievirus A17 and coxsackievirus A24) were detected in pigs, suggesting that these viruses could cross the species barrier. Our work provides original data on the epidemiology and ecology of EVs circulating among herd animals in Africa.