Cross-Binding of Four Adenosine/ATP Aptamers to Caffeine, Theophylline, and Other Methylxanthines.

The classical DNA aptamer for adenosine and ATP was selected twice using ATP as the target in 1995 and 2005, respectively. In 2022, this motif appeared four more times from selections using adenosine, ATP, theophylline, and caffeine as targets, suggesting that this aptamer can also bind methylxanthines. In this work, using thioflavin T fluorescence spectroscopy, this classical DNA aptamer showed Kd values for adenosine, theophylline, and caffeine of 9.5, 101, and 131 µM, respectively, and similar Kd values were obtained using isothermal titration calorimetry. Binding to the methylxanthines was also observed for the newly selected Ade1301 aptamer but not for the Ade1304 aptamer. The RNA aptamer for ATP also had no binding to the methylxanthines. Molecular dynamics simulations were performed using the classical DNA and RNA aptamers based on their NMR structures, and the simulation results were consistent with the experimental observations, explaining the selectivity profiles. This study suggests that a broader range of target analogues need to be tested for aptamers. For the detection of adenosine and ATP, the Ade1304 aptamer is a better choice due to its better selectivity.

Cross-Binding of Adenosine by Aptamers Selected Using Theophylline.

We recently reported that some adenosine binding aptamers can also bind caffeine and theophylline with around 20-fold lower affinities. This discovery led to the current work to examine the cross-binding of adenosine to theophylline aptamers. For the DNA aptamer for theophylline, cross-binding to adenosine was observed, and the affinity was 18 to 38-fold lower for adenosine based on assays using isothermal titration calorimetry and ThT fluorescence spectroscopy. The binding complexes were characterized using NMR spectroscopy, and both adenosine and theophylline showed an overall similar binding structure to the DNA theophylline aptamer, although small differences were also observed. In contrast, the RNA aptamer did not show binding to adenosine, although both aptamers have very similar relative selectivity for various methylxanthines including caffeine. After a negative selection, a few new aptamers with completely different primary sequences for theophylline were obtained and they did not show binding to adenosine. Thus, there are many ways for aptamers to bind theophylline and some can have cross-binding to adenosine. In biology, theophylline, caffeine, and adenosine can bind to the same protein receptors to regulate sleep, and their binding to the same DNA motifs may suggest an early role of nucleic acids in similar regulatory functions.

Gold Nanoparticles Synthesized Using Various Reducing Agents and the Effect of Aging for DNA Sensing.

Gold nanoparticles (AuNPs) are one of the most commonly used reagents in colloidal science and biosensor technology. In this work, we first compared AuNPs prepared using four different reducing agents including citrate, glucose, ascorbate, and 4-(2-hydroxyethyl)-1-piperazineethanesulfonic acid (HEPES). At the same absorbance at the surface plasmon peak of 520-530 nm, citrate-AuNPs and glucose-AuNPs adsorbed more DNA and achieved higher affinity to the adsorbed DNA. In addition, citrate-AuNPs had better sensitivity than glucose-AuNPs for label-free DNA detection. Then, using citrate-AuNPs, the effect of aging was studied by incubation of the AuNPs at 22 °C (room temperature) and at 4 °C for up to 6 months. During aging, the colloidal stability and DNA adsorption efficiency gradually decreased. In addition, the DNA sensing sensitivity using a label-free method also dropped around 4-fold after 6 months. Heating at boiling temperature of the aged citrate-AuNPs could not rejuvenate the sensing performance. This study shows that while citrate-AuNPs are initially better than the other three AuNPs in their colloid properties and sensing properties, this edge in performance might gradually decrease due to constantly changing surface properties caused from the aging effect.

Simultaneous Detection of L-Lactate and D-Glucose Using DNA Aptamers in Human Blood Serum.

L-lactate is a key metabolite indicative of physiological states, glycolysis pathways, and various diseases such as sepsis, heart attack, lactate acidosis, and cancer. Detection of lactate has been relying on a few enzymes that need additional oxidants. In this work, DNA aptamers for L-lactate were obtained using a library-immobilization selection method and the highest affinity aptamer reached a Kd of 0.43 mM as determined using isothermal titration calorimetry. The aptamers showed up to 50-fold selectivity for L-lactate over D-lactate and had little responses to other closely related analogs such as pyruvate or 3-hydroxybutyrate. A fluorescent biosensor based on the strand displacement method showed a limit of detection of 0.55 mM L-lactate, and the sensor worked in 90 % serum. Simultaneous detection of L-lactate and D-glucose in the same solution was achieved. This work has broadened the scope of aptamers to simple metabolites and provided a useful probe for continuous and multiplexed monitoring.

Selection of Aptamers for Sensing Caffeine and Discrimination of Its Three Single Demethylated Analogues.

With the growing consumption of caffeine-containing beverages, detection of caffeine has become an important biomedical, bioanalytical, and environmental topic. We herein isolated four high-quality aptamers for caffeine with dissociation constants ranging from 2.2 to 14.6 µM as characterized using isothermal titration calorimetry. Different binding patterns were obtained for the three single demethylated analogues: theobromine, theophylline, and paraxanthine, highlighting the effect of the molecular symmetry of the arrangement of the three methyl groups in caffeine. A structure-switching fluorescent sensor was designed showing a detection limit of 1.2 µM caffeine, which reflected the labeled caffeine concentration within 6.1% difference for eight commercial beverages. In 20% human serum, a detection limit of 4.0 µM caffeine was achieved. With the four aptamer sensors forming an array, caffeine and the three analogues were well separated from nine other closely related molecules.

Adsorption of DNA Oligonucleotides by Self-Assembled Metalloporphyrin Nanomaterials.

Porphyrin assemblies have controllable morphology, high biocompatibility, and good optical properties and were widely used in biomedical diagnosis and treatment. With the development of DNA biotechnology, combining DNA with porphyrin assemblies can broaden the biological applications of porphyrins. Porphyrin assemblies can serve as nanocarriers for DNA, although the fundamental interactions between them are not well understood. In this work, zinc meso-tetra(4-pyridyl)porphyrin (ZnTPyP) assemblies were prepared in the presence of various surfactants and at different pH values, yielding a variety of aggregation forms. Among them, the hexagonal stacking form exposes more pyridine substituents, and the hydrogen bonding force between the substituents and the DNA bases allows the DNA to be quickly adsorbed on the surface of the assemblies. The effects of DNA sequence and length were systematically tested. In particular, the adsorption of duplex DNA was less efficient compared to the adsorption of single-stranded DNA. This fundamental study is useful for the further combination of DNA and porphyrin assemblies to prepare new functional hybrid nanomaterials.

Homogeneous assays for aptamer-based ethanolamine sensing: no indication of target binding.

Ethanolamine is an important analyte for environmental chemistry and biological sciences. A few DNA aptamers were previously reported for binding ethanolamine with a dissociation constant (Kd) as low as 9.6 nM. However, most of the previous binding assays and sensing work used either immobilized ethanolamine or immobilized aptamers. In this work, we studied three previously reported DNA sequences, two of which were supposed to bind ethanolamine while the other could not bind. Isothermal titration calorimetry revealed no binding for any of these sequences. In addition, due to their guanine-rich sequences, thioflavin T was used as a probe. Little fluorescence change was observed with up to 1 µM ethanolamine. Responses within the millimolar range of ethanolamine were attributed to the general fluorescence quenching effect of ethanolamine instead of aptamer binding. Finally, after studying the adsorption of ethanolamine to gold nanoparticles (AuNPs), we confirmed the feasibility of using AuNPs as a probe when the concentration of ethanolamine was below 0.1 mM. However, no indication of specific aptamer binding was observed by comparing the three DNA sequences for their color changing trends. This work articulates the importance of careful homogeneous binding assays using free target molecules.

Probing Metal-Dependent Phosphate Binding for the Catalysis of the 17E DNAzyme.

The RNA-cleaving 17E DNAzyme exhibits different levels of cleavage activity in the presence of various divalent metal ions, with Pb2+ giving the fastest cleavage. In this study, the metal-phosphate interaction is probed to understand the trend of activity with different metal ions. For the first-row transition metals, the lowest activity shown by Ni2+ correlates with the inhibition by the inorganic phosphate and its water ligand exchange rate, suggesting inner-sphere metal coordination. Cleavage activity with the two stereoisomers of the phosphorothioate-modified substrates, Rp and Sp, indicated that Mg2+, Mn2+, Fe2+, and Co2+ had the highest Sp:Rp activity ratio of >900. Comparatively, the activity was much less affected using the thiophilic metals, including Pb2+, suggesting inner-sphere coordination. The pH-rate profiles showed that Pb2+ was different than the rest of the metal ions in having a smaller slope and a similar fitted apparent pKa and the pKa of metal-bound water. Combining previous reports and our current results, we propose that Pb2+ most likely plays the role of a general acid while the other metal ions are Lewis acid catalysts interacting with the scissile phosphate.

Dissecting the Effect of Salt for More Sensitive Label-Free Colorimetric Detection of DNA Using Gold Nanoparticles.

Taking advantage of the protection effect of single-stranded DNA oligonucleotides, gold nanoparticles (AuNPs) remain dispersed and retain a red color with the addition of a low concentration of salt, while AuNPs would aggregate in the presence of double-stranded DNA. This difference has been used to design label-free colorimetric sensors for DNA detection. NaCl is the most commonly used salt to induce the aggregation of AuNPs. In this work, we aimed to test if other salts can provide even better sensor performance and to understand the effects of the cations and anions in salts. We first studied the effect of anions, including halides (NaF, NaCl, NaBr, and NaI), and other common salts (NaNO3, NaClO4, Na2SO4, Na2S2O3, sodium phosphate, and sodium citrate). Among them, weakly adsorbing ones such as F-, citrate, and phosphate appeared to yield better sensitivity than Cl-. Anions can directly adsorb on the AuNPs and affect DNA adsorption. We then tested cations, and only group 1A metals (LiCl, NaCl, KCl, RbCl, and CsCl) can signal DNA adsorption, while divalent metals (MgCl2, CaCl2, MnCl2, and NiCl2) barely showed the effect of DNA. CsCl only works for strongly adsorbing DNA, such as A15, but not weakly adsorbing T15. Overall, NaF is a better salt than NaCl by having a 2.3-fold higher sensitivity, which was confirmed in a DNA sensing assay. This work has identified a better salt yielding higher sensitivity, and sensing work relying on the change of the aggregation state of AuNPs can benefit from this study.

The Two Classic Pb2+ -Selective DNAzymes Are Related: Rational Evolution for Understanding Metal Selectivity.

In 1994, the first DNAzyme named GR5 was reported, which specifically requires Pb2+ for its RNA cleavage activity. Three years later, the 8-17 DNAzyme was isolated. The 8-17 DNAzyme and the related 17E DNAzyme are also most active with Pb2+ , although other divalent metals can work as well. GR5 and 17E have the same substrate sequence, and their catalytic loops in the enzyme strands also have a few similar and conserved nucleotides. Considering these, we hypothesized that 17E might be a special form of GR5. To test this hypothesis, we performed systematic rational evolution experiments to gradually mutate GR5 toward 17E. By using the activity ratio in the presence of Pb2+ and Mg2+ for defining these two DNAzymes, the critical nucleotide was identified to be T12 in 17E for metal specificity. In addition, G9 in GR5 is a position not found in most 17E or 8-17 DNAzymes, and G9 needs to be added to rescue GR5 activity if T12 becomes a cytosine. This study highlights the links between these two classic and widely used DNAzymes, and offers new insight into the sequence-activity relationship related to metal selectivity.

Sensitivity of a classic DNAzyme for Pb2+ modulated by cations, anions and buffers.

GR5 is the first reported DNAzyme, which has RNA cleavage activity in the presence of Pb2+. Due to its excellent selectivity, GR5 has been a popular DNAzyme for developing biosensors for Pb2+. The activity of DNAzymes is often affected by pH and salt, which may in turn affect the sensitivity of related sensors. Although pH can be readily controlled by using a buffer, the effect of salt is more complex. To have a systematic understanding, we herein measured the cleavage activity of GR5 in various concentrations of Na+ and Mg2+. Both metals inhibited the DNAzyme with Pb2+, and the inhibition constants were 1.8 mM Mg2+ and 33.4 mM Na+. For anions, F- inhibited GR5 more strongly than Br-, while Cl- was the least inhibiting anion, which was consistent with the solubility of their lead salts. The reaction can work similarly in many Good's buffers, while phosphate buffer should be avoided. Finally, GR5 is an optimal sequence based on the truncation and elongation studies. This study reveals important solution conditions that should be considered when designing and testing related biosensors for metal detection.

Misfolding of a DNAzyme for ultrahigh sodium selectivity over potassium.

Herein, the excellent Na+ selectivity of a few RNA-cleaving DNAzymes was exploited, where Na+ can be around 3000-fold more effective than K+ for promoting catalysis. By using a double mutant based on the Ce13d DNAzyme, and by lowering the temperature, increased 2-aminopurine (2AP) fluorescence was observed with addition of both Na+ and K+. The fluorescence increase was similar for these two metals at below 10 mM, after which K+ took a different pathway. Since 2AP probes its local base stacking environment, K+ can be considered to induce misfolding. Binding of both Na+ and K+ was specific, since single base mutations could fully inhibit 2AP fluorescence for both metals. The binding thermodynamics was measured by temperature-dependent experiments revealing enthalpy-driven binding for both metals and less coordination sites compared to G-quadruplex DNA. Cleavage activity assays indicated a moderate cleavage activity with 10 mM K+, while further increase of K+ inhibited the activity, also supporting its misfolding of the DNAzyme. For comparison, a G-quadruplex DNA was also studied using the same system, where Na+ and K+ led to the same final state with only around 8-fold difference in Kd. This study provides interesting insights into strategies for discriminating Na+ and K+.

Graphene oxide as a cartridge enable on-line assembly of photosensitizer for 1O2-based electrochemical aptasensing.

An ultrasensitive 1O2-based electrochemical aptasensor by on-line assembly of photosensitizers using graphene oxide (GO) as a cartridge is reported. In the presence of target protein lysozyme, the interaction of lysozyme with aptamer led to the dissociation of dsDNA and release of the aptamer-lysozyme complex to solution, with DNA-c retaining on the electrode; then, the photosensitizer phloxine B (PB) was assembled on the electrode since GO can simultaneously adsorb DNA-c and PB molecules. Upon irradiation by a green LED, 1O2 was generated by photocatalysis of PB molecules and then cleaved the DNA-c, leading to remarkably decreased impedance signals that linearly respond with the logarithm of lysozyme concentration. Benefitting from the efficient photosensitization ability of PB and the high PB-loading capacity of GO, the developed sensor allowed determination of 0.001 to 100 nM lysozyme with a limit of detection of about 0.14 pM. The relative standard deviation (RSD) for five independent electrodes with 1 nM lysozyme was 3.1%, indicating satisfactory reproducibility. The sensor also showed excellent selectivity toward lysozyme in the presence of interfering substances and was applied to the determination of lysozyme in urine samples with recoveries ranging from 91 to 101%. The on-line assembly of photosensitizer technique opens a new way for amplified electrosensing of biomolecules. Graphical abstract An on-line assembly of photosensitizers and DNA on electrode was developed using graphene oxide a cartridge and the photocatalytic electrosensor can be used for label-free detection of lysozyme as low as 1 pM.

Target Self-Enhanced Selectivity in Metal-Specific DNAzymes.

Highly selective recognition of metal ions by rational ligand design is challenging, and simple metal binding by biological ligands is often obscured by nonspecific interactions. In this work, binding-triggered catalysis is used and metal selectivity is greatly increased by increasing the number of metal ions involved, as exemplified in a series of in vitro selected RNA-cleaving DNAzymes. The cleavage junction is modified with a glycyl-histidine-functionalized tertiary amine moiety to provide multiple potential metal coordination sites. DNAzymes that bind 1, 2, and 3 Zn2+ ions, increased their selectivity for Zn2+ over Co2+ ions from approximately 20-, 1000-, to 5000-fold, respectively. This study offers important insights into metal recognition by combining rational ligand design and combinatorial selection, and it provides a set of new DNAzymes with excellent selectivity for Zn2+ ions.

A DNAzyme requiring two different metal ions at two distinct sites.

Most previously reported RNA-cleaving DNAzymes require only a single divalent metal ion for catalysis. We recently reported a general trivalent lanthanide-dependent DNAzyme named Ce13d. This work shows that Ce13d requires both Na(+) and a trivalent lanthanide (e.g. Ce(3+)), simultaneously. This discovery is facilitated by the sequence similarity between Ce13d and a recently reported Na(+)-specific DNAzyme, NaA43. The Ce13d cleavage rate linearly depends on the concentration of both metal ions. Sensitized Tb(3+) luminescence and DMS footprinting experiments indicate that the guanines in the enzyme loop are important for Na(+)-binding. The Na(+) dissociation constants of Ce13d measured from the cleavage activity assay, Tb(3+) luminescence and DMS footprinting are 24.6, 16.3 and 47 mM, respectively. Mutation studies indicate that the role of Ce(3+) might be replaced by G23 in NaA43. Ce(3+) functions by stabilizing the transition state phosphorane, thus promoting cleavage. G23 competes favorably with low concentration Ce(3+) (below 1 µM). The G23-to-hypoxanthine mutation suggests the N1 position of the guanine as a hydrogen bond donor. Together, Ce13d has two distinct metal binding sites, each fulfilling a different role. DNAzymes can be quite sophisticated in utilizing metal ions for catalysis and molecular recognition, similar to protein metalloenzymes.

An Exceptionally Selective DNA Cooperatively Binding Two Ca2+ Ions.

Ca2+ is a highly important metal ion in biology and in the environment, and thus there is extensive work in developing sensors for Ca2+ detection. Although many Ca2+ -binding proteins are known, few nucleic acids can selectively bind Ca2+ . DNA-based biosensors are attractive for their high stability and excellent programmability. We report a RNA-cleaving DNAzyme, EtNa, cooperatively binding two Ca2+ ions but to only one Mg2+ . Four DNAzymes with known Ca2+ -dependent activity were compared, and the EtNa had the best selectivity for Ca2+ . The EtNa is 90 times more active in Ca2+ than in Mg2+ . Phosphorothioate (PS) modification showed that both non-bridging oxygen atoms at the scissile phosphate contribute equally to Ca2+ binding. The pH-rate profile suggests two concurrent deprotonation reactions. EtNa was further engineered for Ca2+ sensing, and found to have a detection limit of 17 µm Ca2+ and excellent selectivity. The detection of Ca2+ in tap water was performed, and the result was comparable with that by ICP-MS. This study offers new fundamental insights into Ca2+ binding by nucleic acids and improved metal selectivity by having multiple cooperative metal binding sites.

Rational evolution of Cd2+-specific DNAzymes with phosphorothioate modified cleavage junction and Cd2+ sensing.

In vitro selection of RNA-cleaving DNAzymes is a powerful method for isolating metal-specific DNA. A few successful examples are known, but it is still difficult to target some thiophilic metals such as Cd(2+) due to limited functional groups in DNA. While using modified bases expands the chemical functionality of DNA, a single phosphorothioate modification might boost its affinity for thiophilic metals without complicating the selection process or using bases that are not commercially available. In this work, the first such in vitro selection for Cd(2+) is reported. After using a blocking DNA and negative selections to rationally direct the library outcome, a highly specific DNAzyme with only 12 nucleotides in the catalytic loop is isolated. This DNAzyme has a cleavage rate of 0.12 min(-1) with 10 µM Cd(2+) at pH 6.0. The Rp form of the substrate is cleaved ∼100-fold faster than the Sp form. The DNAzyme is most active with Cd(2+) and its selectivity against Zn(2+) is over 100 000-fold. Its application in detecting Cd(2+) is also demonstrated. The idea of introducing single modifications in the fixed region expands the scope of DNA/metal interactions with minimal perturbation of DNA structure and property.

A new heavy lanthanide-dependent DNAzyme displaying strong metal cooperativity and unrescuable phosphorothioate effect.

In vitro selection of RNA-cleaving DNAzymes was performed using three heavy lanthanide ions (Ln(3+)): Ho(3+), Er(3+) and Tm(3+). The resulting sequences were aligned together and about half of the library contained a new family of DNAzyme. These DNAzymes have a simple loop structure, and they are active only with the seven heavy Ln(3+). Among the tested non-lanthanide ions, only Y(3+) induced cleavage and even Pb(2+) failed to cleave, suggesting a very high specificity. A representative DNAzyme, Tm7, has a sigmoidal metal binding curve with a Hill coefficient of 3, indicating that three metal ions are involved in the catalytic step. Its pH-rate profile has a slope of 1, suggesting a single deprotonation step is involved in the rate-limiting step. Tm7 has a cleavage rate of 1.6 min(-1) at pH 7.8 with 10 µM Er(3+). Phosphorothioate substitution at the cleavage junction completely inhibits the activity, which cannot be rescued by Cd(2+) alone, or by a mixture of Er(3+) and Cd(2+), suggesting that two interacting metal ions are involved in direct bonding to both non-bridging oxygen atoms. A new model involving three lanthanide ions is proposed based on this study. A biosensor is engineered using Tm7 to detect Dy(3+) down to 14 nM.

In Vitro Selection of a DNAzyme Cooperatively Binding Two Lanthanide Ions for RNA Cleavage.

Trivalent lanthanide ions (Ln(3+)) were recently employed to select RNA-cleaving DNAzymes, and three new DNAzymes have been reported so far. In this work, dysprosium (Dy(3+)) was used with a library containing 50 random nucleotides. After six rounds of in vitro selection, a new DNAzyme named Dy10a was obtained and characterized. Dy10a has a bulged hairpin structure cleaving a RNA/DNA chimeric substrate. Dy10a is highly active in the presence of the five Ln(3+) ions in the middle of the lanthanide series (Sm(3+), Eu(3+), Gd(3+), Tb(3+), and Dy(3+)), while its activity descends on the two sides. The cleavage rate reaches 0.6 min(-1) at pH 6 with just 200 nM Sm(3+), which is the fastest among all known Ln(3+)-dependent enzymes. Dy10a binds two Ln(3+) ions cooperatively. When a phosphorothioate (PS) modification is introduced at the cleavage junction, the activity decreases by >2500-fold for both the Rp and Sp diastereomers, and thiophilic Cd(2+) cannot rescue the activity. The pH-rate profile has a slope of 0.37 between pH 4.2 and 5.2, and the slope was even lower at higher pH. On the basis of these data, a model of metal binding is proposed. Finally, a catalytic beacon sensor that can detect Ho(3+) down to 1.7 nM is constructed.

An Ultrasensitive Light-up Cu(2+) Biosensor Using a New DNAzyme Cleaving a Phosphorothioate-Modified Substrate.

Cu(2+) is a very important metal ion in biology, environmental science, and industry. Developing biosensors for Cu(2+) is a key topic in analytical chemistry. DNAzyme-based sensors are highly attractive for their excellent sensitivity, stability, and programmability. In the past decade, a few Cu(2+) biosensors were reported using DNAzymes with DNA cleavage or DNA ligation activity. However, they require unstable ascorbate or imidazole activation. So far, no RNA-cleaving DNAzymes specific for Cu(2+) are known. In this work, a phosphorothioate (PS) RNA-containing library was used for in vitro selection, and a few new Cu(2+)-specific RNA-cleaving DNAzymes were isolated. Among them, a DNAzyme named PSCu10 was studied further. It has only eight nucleotides in the enzyme loop with a cleavage rate of 0.1 min(-1) in the presence of 1 µM Cu(2+) at pH 6.0 (its optimal pH). Between the two diastereomers of the PS RNA chiral center, the R(p) isomer is 37 times more active than the S(p) one. Among the other divalent metal ions, only Hg(2+) can cleave the substrate due to its extremely high thiophilicity. A catalytic beacon sensor was designed with a detection limit of 1.6 nM Cu(2+) and extremely high selectivity. PSCu10 is specific for Cu(2+), and it has no cleavage in the presence of ascorbate, which reduces Cu(2+) to Cu(+).