RESUMEN
We investigated frequencies of HER2-low breast cancer (BC) (immunohistochemistry [IHC] 1+ or 2+ without gene amplification) before and after IHC conditions were modified in order to understand the impact of IHC staining conditions on frequencies of HER2-low BC. Primary BC cases diagnosed at the Yeungnam University Hospital (YUH, n = 728) or Keimyung University Dongsan Hospital (KUDH, n = 290) in 2022 were reviewed, and data on HER2 status and IHC conditions were collected (cohort 1). Both institutions used the 4B5 antibody for HER2 IHC but had different staining protocols. After modifications of the IHC conditions at both institutions, primary BC cases (YUH, n = 324 and KUDH, n = 135) diagnosed from April to July 2023 (cohort 2) were reviewed to assess any changes in the frequency of HER2 status. In cohort 1, of the 728 cases diagnosed at YUH, 556 (76.4%) were HER2-zero, 76 (10.4%) were HER2-low, and 96 (13.2%) were HER2-positive, and of the 290 cases diagnosed at KUDH, 135 (46.6%) were HER2-zero, 82 (28.3%) were HER2-low, and 73 (25.2%) were HER2-positive. Modifications in HER2 IHC staining conditions dramatically increased the frequencies of HER2-low BC in cohort 2 (YUH 38.9% and KUDH 49.6%), but they did not result in significant changes in the HER2-positive rates (YUH 15.4% and KUDH 25.2%) compared to cohort 1. In conclusion, minor modifications in HER2 IHC staining conditions significantly affected the frequency of HER2-low BC but had little impact on the HER2-positivity rate. Each pathology laboratory should verify IHC conditions using control slides (including 1+) to enable the accurate identification of HER2-low BC.
RESUMEN
Purpose: Notable effectiveness of trastuzumab deruxtecan (T-DXd) in patients with HER2-low advanced breast cancer (BC) has focused pathologists' attention. We studied the incidence and clinicopathologic characteristics of HER2-low BC, and the effects of immunohistochemistry (IHC) associated factors on HER2 IHC results. Materials and Methods: The Breast Pathology Study Group of the Korean Society of Pathologists conducted a nationwide study using real-world data on HER2 status generated between January 2022 and December 2022. Information on HER2 IHC protocols at each participating institution was also collected. Results: Total 11,416 patients from twenty-five institutions included in this study. Of these patients, 40.7% (range: 6.0%-76.3%) were classified as HER2-zero, 41.7% (range: 10.5%-69.1%) as HER2-low, and 17.5% (range: 6.7%-34.0%) as HER2-positive. HER2-low tumors were associated with positive ER and PR statuses (p<0.001 and p<0.001, respectively). Antigen retrieval times (≥ 36 min vs. < 36 min) and antibody incubation times (≥ 12 min vs. < 12 min) affected on the frequency of HER2 IHC 1+ BC at institutions using the PATHWAY HER2 (4B5) IHC assay and BenchMark XT or Ultra staining instruments. Furthermore, discordant results between core needle biopsy (CNB) and subsequent resection specimen HER2 statuses were observed in 24.1% (787/3259) of the patients. Conclusion: The overall incidence of HER2-low BC in South Korea concurs with those reported in previously published studies. Significant inter-institutional differences in HER2 IHC protocols were observed, and it may have impact on HER2-low status. Thus, we recommend standardizing HER2 IHC conditions to ensure precise patient selection for targeted therapy.