An evaluation of chemical photoreactivity and the relationship to photogenotoxicity.

In the accompanying paper (Kleinman et al., submitted for publication), the link between phototoxicity and photoreactivity (i.e. production of singlet oxygen, superoxide and chemical photostability) has been established. It is proposed this may be used to refine existing triggers for photosafety testing. Using a series of compounds we have determined whether these photochemical reactivity measurements may be used to mechanistically predict phototoxic and/or photogenotoxic liability. Therefore, a subset of compounds tested in the in vitro 3T3 NRU assay from the accompanying paper were tested in the photo-chromosome aberration assay in CHO cells, using standard methodologies. The results of these studies indicate that photochemical analysis of compounds is a good predictor of in vitro phototoxicity, but not necessarily, photoclastogenicity. Further evidence from photostability experiments suggests that this is due to the differences in UVR irradiance and exposure conditions between the two assays. Nevertheless, this approach may provide a more robust trigger for the need to conduct in vitro and/or in vivo photosafety studies than simple UV/visible absorbance spectra.

Sensitivity of normal, paramalignant, and malignant human urothelial cells to inhibitors of the epidermal growth factor receptor signaling pathway.

Bladder cancer evolves via the accumulation of numerous genetic alterations, with loss of p53 and p16 function representing key events in the development of malignant disease. In addition, components of the epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) signaling pathway are frequently overexpressed, providing potential chemotherapeutic targets. We have previously described the generation of "paramalignant" human urothelial cells with disabled p53 or p16 functions. In this study, we investigated the relative responses of normal, paramalignant, and malignant human urothelial cells to EGFR tyrosine kinase inhibitors (PD153035 and GW572016), a mitogen-activated protein kinase/extracellular signal-regulated kinase (MAPK/ERK) kinase (MEK) inhibitor (U0126), and a phosphatidylinositol 3-kinase inhibitor (LY294002). The proliferation of normal human urothelial cells was dependent on signaling via the EGFR and MEK pathways and was abolished reversibly by inhibitors of EGFR or downstream MEK signaling pathways. Inhibitors of phosphatidylinositol 3-kinase resulted in only transient cytostasis, which was most likely mediated via cross-talk with the MEK pathway. These responses were maintained in cells with disabled p16 function, whereas cells with loss of p53 function displayed reduced sensitivity to PD153035 and malignant cell lines were the most refractory to PD153035 and U0126. These results indicate that urothelial cells acquire insensitivity to inhibitors of EGFR signaling pathways as a result of malignant transformation. This has important implications for the use of EGFR inhibitors for bladder cancer therapy, as combination treatments with conventional chemotherapy or radiotherapy may protect normal cells and enable better selective targeting of malignant cells.

Analysis of 75 marketed pharmaceuticals using the GADD45a-GFP 'GreenScreen HC' genotoxicity assay.

The GADD45a-GFP (GreenScreen HC) reporter assay detects genotoxic damage in the human lymphoblastoid TK6 cell line and gives positive results for all classes of genotoxin, including mutagens, aneugens and clastogens. In this study, a collection of 75 marketed pharmaceuticals were tested in the assay. Compounds in the collection represent a broad range of chemical structures, pharmacologies and therapeutic indications, including neoplasia and viral infection where positive genotoxicity results are often associated with the pharmacological activity. Based on the results of this study, two main conclusions can be drawn: (i) the GreenScreen HC is more predictive of in vivo genotoxicity (88%) and genotoxic carcinogenicity (93%) data than the any of the other regulatory in vitro genotoxicity assay and (ii) no compounds were uniquely positive in the GADD45a-GFP assay. This analysis therefore provides additional evidence to support the use of the GADD45a-GFP assay as an effective tool either in early genotoxic liability identification or non-clinical safety assessment of candidate pharmaceuticals during development.

Cycloheximide and disulfoton are positive in the photoclastogencity assay but do not absorb UV irradiation: another example of pseudophotoclastogenicity?

There is considerable concern regarding the biological plausibility of the response of certain chemicals in the in vitro photoclastogenicity assay, suggesting that this assay is oversensitive and lacks specificity. To explore this further, four coded compounds (aminotriazole, propantheline bromide, cycloheximide and disulfoton) were evaluated for their potential response in a photoclastogenicity assay in cultured Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells. None of the four compounds were shown to absorb ultraviolet radiation (UVR) or visible light in the 290- to 700-nm region of the electromagnetic spectrum. A fifth coded compound, tetracycline, which absorbs UVR, was also tested as this has previously been shown to be phototoxic in vitro (3T3-NRU assay) and is cytotoxic, but not genotoxic, at high concentrations in standard 'dark' genotoxicity assays in mammalian cells. The results showed that cycloheximide, disulfoton and tetracycline were clastogenic in CHO cells following UVR exposure (solar-simulated light at 700 mJ/cm(2)) but not in the absence of UVR. Aminotriazole and propantheline were negative in the presence and absence of UVR exposure. Follow-up testing showed that neither cycloheximide nor disulfoton was positive in the 3T3-NRU assay, the standard in vitro regulatory test for phototoxicity, a result consistent with their inability to absorb UVR. These data suggest that both cycloheximide and disulfoton are pseudophotoclastogens, like zinc oxide. Together, these data question the specificity of the in vitro photoclastogencity assay in CHO cells and raises further concern regarding its use for the assessment of chemical photosafety for regulatory purposes. At the very least, a review of the current guidance documents for the photosafety evaluation of pharmaceuticals and cosmetics should be undertaken urgently.

Is MutaMouse insensitive to clastogens?

Several studies suggest that MutaMouse is insensitive to clastogens, including the accompanying paper by Mahabir et al., which describes a study with bleomycin, camptothecin, m-AMSA (4'-(9-acridinylamino)-methanesulfon-m-anisidide) and its ortho-analogue, o-AMSA (4'-(9-acridinylamino)-methanesulfon-o-anisidide). Only camptothecin was clastogenic in MutaMouse and none of these four compounds induced mutations at the lacZ locus. However, to improve exposure, dose range-finding studies were performed in CD2F1 mice, the parental strain of MutaMouse. Male CD2F1 mice (n=3) were treated with bleomycin (25-100 mg/kg bw, p.o. and i.p.), camptothecin (1-10 mg/kg bw p.o.) and m-AMSA (10-50mg/kg bw p.o. and 1-5 mg/kg bw i.p.) for 5 days and blood was sampled on day 3 and/or day 6 for analysis by flow cytometry to determine % MN-RETs. Camptothecin (1 mg/kg bw, day 6) induced a 3.6-fold increase in % MN-RET (P<0.05) but was toxic at higher doses. All day-3 camptothecin samples were positive (P<0.05). Bleomycin was negative when administered p.o. but positive at all doses on both days when given i.p. (P<0.05) whereas m-AMSA was negative when given i.p. or orally. Based on these results, male MutaMouse mice (5 per group) were dosed daily with bleomycin (50 mg/kg bw) for 5 days or with camptothecin (5 mg/kg bw) for 2 days. Peripheral blood was sampled 24 h after the final dose in each group and tissues were sampled 37 days later. Both compounds induced significant increases in % MN-RET, but only bleomycin induced a significant increase in MF (6-fold in liver, 4.5-fold in kidney and 2-fold in lung) compared with the untreated control. These studies support the view that MutaMouse is insensitive to compounds where the genotoxic mechanism of action is predominantly clastogenesis, but demonstrates that the peripheral blood micronucleus test is a useful adjunct to the transgenic gene-mutation assay.

Evaluation of the Litron In Vitro MicroFlow Kit for the flow cytometric enumeration of micronuclei (MN) in mammalian cells.

We have evaluated the performance of the prototype In Vitro MicroFlow Kit (Litron Laboratories), which offers a flow cytometric method for scoring micronuclei (MN). This method uses sequential staining to differentiate MN from chromatin fragments derived from apoptotic or necrotic cells. Data were generated using the genotoxins methylmethane sulphonate (MMS), dimethylbenzanthracene (DMBA) and vinblastine, and the non-genotoxins dexamethasone and staurosporine, which are known to induce apoptosis in vitro. The results obtained with these agents were compared with conventional microscopy. For short-duration exposures (3-4h) both manual and flow methodologies demonstrated good concordance, with concentration-related increases in the percentage of MN for MMS, DMBA and vinblastine. Statistically significant increases were observed at > or = 20 and 40 microg/mL, for manual and flow analysis, respectively, for MMS; at 0.5 and 0.75 microg/mL for DMBA; and at 0.035 and 0.04 microg/mL, respectively, for vinblastine. Dexamethasone showed clear negative responses by manual and flow cytometric analysis, with comparable results for both methodologies (all <1.7-fold compared with concurrent vehicle controls). Data for staurosporine, however, were less consistent showing significantly higher flow cytometric MN frequencies compared with those seen after manual analysis. Continuous (24 h) treatments were also conducted with MMS, vinblastine, dexamethasone and staurosporine. There was good concordance between the methodologies for MMS, staurosporine and vinblastine. However, dexamethasone generated discordant results, i.e. microscopic analysis was clearly negative at all doses tested, whereas flow cytometry produced significant increases in MN frequency (up to 8.1-fold at 100 microg/mL compared with the concurrent vehicle control). The inconsistencies observed between flow cytometry and standard microscopy, and the differences in assay sensitivity, particularly for apoptosis-inducing compounds, suggest that the prototype In Vitro MicroFlow Kit requires further refinement. Studies to investigate new parameters to address these issues are now under way and will be reported separately.

Interlaboratory assessment of the GreenScreen HC GADD45a-GFP genotoxicity screening assay: an enabling study for independent validation as an alternative method.

Sixteen coded compounds were blind-tested at 4 laboratories using the recently described GADD45a-GFP genotoxicity assay. The compounds were chosen to include non-genotoxic compounds as well as weak and strong genotoxins. None of the compounds required metabolic activation in order to exhibit genotoxic effects. The participating laboratories included 2 global pharmaceutical companies, a global consumer goods company and the Gentronix laboratory in Manchester. Each compound was tested 4 times on different days following a protocol previously described. The tests were carried out after a 3-day training period from the parent lab (Manchester). Following the exclusion of data from tests with positive control failures and data series with 'spikes', 92% of assays gave the correct result: non-genotoxins giving negative results and genotoxins giving positive results. There were no randomly distributed problems suggesting that differences between the results from different sites reflected the use of different instruments, procedural differences and operator experience. In naïve operator laboratories the quality of data improved with operator practice. It was concluded that simple clarification of the protocol would provide the level of reliability required for widespread use of the assay in hazard assessment.

High-specificity and high-sensitivity genotoxicity assessment in a human cell line: validation of the GreenScreen HC GADD45a-GFP genotoxicity assay.

The battery of genetic toxicity tests required by most regulatory authorities includes both bacterial and mammalian cell assays and identifies practically all genotoxic carcinogens. However, the relatively high specificity of the Salmonella mutagenicity assay (Ames test) is offset by the low specificity of the established mammalian cell assays, which leads to difficulties in the interpretation of the biological relevance of results. This paper describes a new high-throughput assay that links the regulation of the human GADD45a gene to the production of Green Fluorescent Protein (GFP). A study of 75 well-characterised genotoxic and non-genotoxic compounds with diverse mechanisms of DNA-damage induction (including aneugens) reveals that the assay responds positively to all classes of genotoxic damage with both high specificity and high sensitivity. The current micro-well assay format does not include metabolic activation, but a separate low-throughput protocol demonstrates a successful proof-of-principle for an S9 metabolic activation assay with the model pro-mutagen cyclophosphamide. The test should be of value both as a tool in the selection of candidate compounds for further development, where additional data may be required because of conflicting information from the in vitro test battery, or in product development areas where the use of animals is to be discontinued. As a microplate assay however, it has the qualities of high throughput and low compound use that will facilitate its application in early screening for genotoxic liability.

The results of five coded compounds: genistein, metaproterenol, rotenone, p-anisidine and resorcinol tested in the pH 6.7 Syrian hamster embryo cell morphological transformation assay.

The pH 6.7 Syrian hamster embryo (SHE) cell morphological transformation assay is a short-term in vitro test that has been used to predict rodent carcinogenicity. Previous reports have indicated that the SHE assay has an overall concordance of approximately 80% with the 2 year rodent bioassay. We selected five compounds, genistein, metaproterenol, rotenone, p-anisidine and resorcinol, that had extensive genotoxicity and carcinogenicity data and tested them in the standard 7 day exposure SHE assay. Somewhat surprisingly, the SHE assay misclassified the actual rodent carcinogenicity of four out of the five test compounds. It is difficult to explain these findings as the actual mechanisms of SHE cell morphological transformation are currently unknown. However, it is obvious that in these studies there was no simple correlation between in vitro genotoxicity, morphological transformation in SHE cells and rodent carcinogenicity. Clearly, further research is required to accurately assess the role of the SHE assay in the carcinogenic risk assessment of new chemical entities.