Therapy matchmaking: Patient-therapist match in personality traits and attachment style.

OBJECTIVE: This study examined the relationships between patient-therapist similarity and therapy outcome. We aimed to explore whether patient-therapist match in personality and attachment styles leads to a better therapy outcome. METHOD: We collected data from 77 patient-therapist dyads in short-term dynamic therapy. Patients' and therapists' personality traits (Big-5 Inventory) and attachment styles (ECR) were assessed prior to beginning therapy. Outcome was measured on the OQ-45. RESULTS: When patients and therapists scored either high or low on neuroticism and conscientiousness we found a decrease in symptoms from beginning to end of therapy. When patients' and therapists' combined scores were either high or low on attachment anxiety, we found an increase in symptoms. CONCLUSION: Match or mismatch on personality and attachment style in therapy dyads contributes to therapy outcome.

Therapists' responsiveness in the process of ruptures and resolution: Are patients and therapists on the same page?

OBJECTIVE: This study examined the association between the rupture-repair process and patients' and therapists' perceptions of the therapist's responsiveness. METHOD: We used the Rupture Resolution Rating System to rate early sessions (3-5) in 35 short-term psychodynamic psychotherapy cases. The patients and therapists rated their perceptions of the therapist's responsiveness after each session using the Patient's Experience of Attunement and Responsiveness (PEAR) Scale. RESULTS: Therapists' contribution to ruptures was negatively associated with both patients' and therapists' PEAR ratings. Confrontation ruptures were negatively associated with patients' PEAR ratings, whereas there was no significant association with withdrawal ruptures. Resolution was positively associated with both patients' and therapists' PEAR ratings. In addition, resolution moderated the negative association between ruptures and patients' PEAR ratings. CONCLUSION: The findings emphasize the link between therapists' responsiveness and the rupture-repair process. They also highlight the significance of providing therapists with the necessary training to recognize these dynamics and engage in discussions about them with their patients when appropriate.

Changes in clients' relational patterns with parents and therapist during psychodynamic psychotherapy: Their association and relation to treatment outcome.

OBJECTIVE: The study aimed to explore how changes in clients' relational patterns during psychodynamic psychotherapy relate to treatment outcomes and therapy effectiveness. METHOD: Seventy clients receiving psychodynamic psychotherapy in a university counseling center were interviewed three times and filled out the OQ-45 questionnaire five times during therapy. We used the Core Conflictual Relationship Theme (CCRT) to study clients' relational patterns. Mixed models were used to assess the interaction between clients' CCRT intensity toward their parents and toward their therapists, treatment effectiveness, and treatment outcome. RESULTS: First, we found that clients' relational patterns with their parents correlated with relational patterns with their therapists across several time points in therapy. Then, we found significant interactions, indicating that treatment effectiveness moderates the relationship between clients' CCRT intensity and treatment outcomes. CONCLUSIONS: The findings suggest that the transference phenomenon is related to therapy outcomes differently in effective and less-effective therapies, depending on the transference intensity. Further research is needed to expand knowledge about the intensity of transference and its possible impact on treatment choice and management.

Countertransference awareness and treatment outcome.

Countertransference (CT) is considered a central component in the therapy process. Research has shown that CT management does not reduce the number of CT manifestations in therapy, but it leads to better therapy outcomes. In this study, we examined therapists' awareness of their CT using a structured interview. Our hypotheses were (a) treatments in which therapists were more aware of their CT would have a better outcome and (b) different definitions of CT would be related to different therapy outcomes. Twenty-nine patients were treated by 19 therapists in 16 sessions of short-term psychodynamic therapy. We used the core conflictual relationship theme to measure CT, a special interview was developed to study CT awareness. Results show that awareness of CT defined as the relationship with the patient moderated 10 outcome measures and awareness of CT defined as the relationship with the patient that repeats therapist conflicts with significant others moderated three outcome measures We present examples from dyads in this study and discuss how awareness can help the therapist talk to and handle patient challenges. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2022 APA, all rights reserved).

How therapists' emotion recognition relates to therapy process and outcome.

Empathy is an essential characteristic for therapists that explained 9% of the variance in treatment outcomes. Many measures of empathy are based on self-report questionnaires. Therefore, they reflect how a person perceives his empathic abilities, which can be biased from his true abilities. The ability to recognize emotions has been found to be related to empathy and serves as a measure for the use of empathic abilities. In this study, we examined therapists' empathic abilities, using a novel task for recognizing emotions, and looked at how they related to the therapy process and outcomes. The study included 33 patient-therapist dyads. Therapist empathy was assessed with an emotion detection task, the JeFEE. Clients filled questionnaires after each session regarding therapy progress and their symptoms. We found that emotion recognition moderated the change in (a) client secure attachment to therapist, (b) client avoidant attachment to therapist, (c) client working alliance, (d) client rate of tense or upset they felt during the session, (e) client lack of emotional clarity of emotions, (f) client non-acceptance of emotional responses, (g) client overall emotion regulation and (h) client main target complaint. Implication for therapy and therapists' selection and training are discussed.

Countertransference types and their relation to rupture and repair in the alliance.

Background Ruptures in the alliance are co-constructed by clients and therapists, reflecting an interaction between their respective personality configurations [Safran, J. D., & Muran, J. C. (2000). Negotiating the therapeutic alliance: A relational treatment guide. Guilford Press]. In order to work effectively with ruptures, therapists should be aware of their own feeling states, acknowledging the subjectivity of their perceptions [Safran, J. D. (2002). Brief relational psychoanalytic treatment. Psychoanalytic Dialogues, 12(2), 171-195. https://doi.org/10.1080/10481881209348661]. Lack of such awareness may be a product of countertransference (CT), which has been shown to be inversely related to outcome. However, when effectively managed, CT contributes to positive outcome [Hayes, J. A., Gelso, C. J., Goldberg, S., & Kivlighan, D. M. (2018). Countertransference management and effective psychotherapy: Meta-analytic findings. Psychotherapy, 55(4), 496-507. https://doi.org/10.1037/pst0000189]. Objectives: The present study examined the associations between types of CT and therapists' reports of ruptures and resolutions. Method: Data were collected from 27 therapists, who treated 67 clients in yearlong psychodynamic psychotherapy. CT patterns were assessed based on therapists' Core Conflictual Relationship Themes with their parents, which were repeated in narratives about their clients [Tishby, O., & Wiseman, H. (2014). Types of countertransference dynamics and their impact on the client-therapist relationship. Psychotherapy Research, 24(3), 360-375. https://doi.org/10.1080/10503307.2014.893068]. Results: Negative CT patterns were associated with more ruptures and less resolution. Positive patterns predicted resolution when the therapists repeated positive patterns with parents, but predicted ruptures when they tried to "repair" negative patterns with the parents. These results point to the importance of therapists' awareness of their CT in order to deal effectively with ruptures and facilitate resolution.

Changes in clients and therapists experiences of therapeutic distance during psychodynamic therapy.

Attachment theory provides a framework for examining closeness-distance experiences in the development of the therapeutic relationship. OBJECTIVE: To examine changes in clients' and therapists' experiences of therapeutic distance along with psychodynamic therapy. HYPOTHESES: Clients' and therapists' comfort with closeness and distance will increase, and the client's autonomy and engagement will increase with time. METHOD: A total of 67 clients and their 27 therapists underwent Relationship Paradigm interviews in which they told narratives about their experience with each other, three times during therapy. The narratives were rated on the Therapeutic Distance Scale-Observer (TDS-O) version. RESULTS: Growth curve analysis of the TDS-O ratings showed that clients decrease in perceiving therapists as too distant and increase in engagement. Therapists showed a decrease in perceiving clients as too close and an increase in granting autonomy and engagement. A clinical illustration depicts these experiences in a client-therapist dyad. CONCLUSIONS: Therapists' awareness of clients' changing needs of closeness and autonomy may enhance attunement.

Therapeutic distance in client-therapist narratives: client attachment, therapist attachment, and dyadic effects.

Based on the attachment framework, therapeutic distance conceptualization focuses on closeness-distance dynamics in the therapeutic relationship. We aimed to evaluate the psychometric properties of the Therapeutic-Distance-Scale, Observer-version (TDS-O) and apply a dyadic approach to examine associations between attachment characteristics and therapeutic distance experiences of clients, therapists, and mutual effects. Sixty-six clients and their 29 therapists completed the ECR and relational narratives collected in RAP interviews at early, mid, and late psychodynamic-therapy were rated on TDS-O scales: too close, too distant, autonomy, and engagement. The TDS-O showed good IRR, internal reliability and content validity. Client anxiety was not associated with therapeutic distance but associated with autonomy. Client avoidance associated with clients' experiencing therapist as too close, and lower engagement only at early therapy, but was not associated with therapists' experience. Therapist anxiety was not related to closeness-distance at early therapy but related to gaps between client and therapist experiences at mid and late therapy. Therapist avoidance related to clients experiencing therapists as too close and granting less autonomy at early and mid-therapy, and to therapist experience of distance at late therapy. The findings underscore the importance of therapists' regulating therapeutic distance through attunement to client's interpersonal needs and therapy phase.

Changes in playfulness, creativity and honesty as possible outcomes of psychotherapy.

Objectives: This study comprised an examination of whether clients' playfulness, creativity, honesty, humor, and happiness changed during psychotherapy. Methods: Sixty-two clients who underwent psychotherapy in a naturalistic setting completed questionnaires at five time points throughout treatment. An HLM analytic approach was applied to account for the hierarchical nature of the data. Results: Mental distress declined during treatment, while playfulness and creativity increased significantly. Honesty decreased significantly in the course of the treatment, while no significant change was found in the level of affiliative humor or the level of happiness. Conclusions: Changes in personality variables that can serve as positive constructs defining mental health, namely playfulness, creativity, and honesty, might be a possible outcome of psychotherapy.

Therapist effects in yearlong psychodynamic therapy: An exploratory study.

A large body of research indicates that therapists can have a strong impact on treatment outcome, but little is known about the relationship between therapist effects and treatment phase. Our objective was to examine the interactive effect of therapist effectiveness and treatment phase on the outcome of 1 year of dynamic therapy. Therapists' effectiveness scores were defined as the extent of change for each therapist on the OQ-45 scores across their clients at five time points. The sample included 24 therapists who conducted psychodynamic therapy with 65 clients in a naturalistic setting. A three-level hierarchical linear model was applied. In accordance with the hypotheses, a significant main effect was found for effectiveness (estimate = 1.69, p < .05), for the two-way interactions between effectiveness and time (estimate = 1.36, p < .01), and for effectiveness and initial severity of symptoms (estimate = -0.02, p < .05). Simple slope analysis was conducted showing that among the less effective therapists, no significant change in outcome was found as time progressed; among the more effective therapists, outcome improved as time progressed. In addition, therapists were more influential in the treatments of clients with low initial severity. Our findings lend some support to the notion that therapist effects become increasingly influential as therapy progresses. The findings highlight the need for further research into changes in the magnitude of therapists' effect in various phases of therapy. Furthermore, the severity level of the initial symptoms of the client should be taken into account.

Therapists' honesty, humor styles, playfulness, and creativity as outcome predictors: A retrospective study of the therapist effect.

OBJECTIVE: This study examined whether therapists' honesty, humor style, playfulness, and creativity would retrospectively predict the outcomes of therapies ended five years earlier. METHOD: In the Jerusalem-Haifa study, 29 therapists treated 70 clients in dynamic psychotherapy for 1 year. The Outcome Questionnaire 45 scores were collected at five time points. Five years later, the therapists were contacted via email and asked to fill out honesty, humor styles, playfulness, and creativity self-report questionnaires. Five were excluded since they had only one client in the study each. The remaining 24 therapists treated 65 clients out of whom 20 therapists with 54 clients completed the questionnaires. RESULTS: Therapists' Aggressive Humor Style (AHS) was a significant negative predictor of clients' symptom change over time. The therapists' honesty scores were positively correlated with symptom change. That is, higher AHS therapists were more effective, while higher honesty therapists were less effective. CONCLUSIONS: Therapists' inferred traits of Honesty-Humility and AHS may influence the effectiveness of their treatments.

Relational Patterns and the Development of the Alliance: A Systematic Comparison of two Cases.

A systematic case study approach was taken to explore the impact of client and therapist relational patterns on the development of the therapeutic alliance and symptom reduction in two cases of psychodynamic psychotherapy treated by the same therapist. The cases were selected from a larger sample and represent two distinct trajectories of alliance development: improvement versus deterioration. The comparison was based on participants' ongoing narratives about each other and about significant others, using the Relationship Anecdote Paradigm (RAP) interview. The qualitative findings were triangulated with process and outcome measures assessed at four time points during the year of treatment. We hypothesized that different therapeutic processes, including different handling by the therapist of interpersonal difficulties as they arose in treatment, could explain the two distinct trajectories of alliance development and symptom change within the caseload of one therapist. Results indicate two linked elements that may explain a steady increase in alliance and decrease in symptoms in one case, compared with the second case that started with an increase in alliance and symptom improvement, but gradually reached an impasse and a setback in symptoms. One element was the extent to which client's and therapist's relational patterns clashed, impacting each other negatively. The second was the extent to which differences and disagreements were stated openly and negotiated so that the therapist could flexibly adapt to meet the client's relational patterns in one case versus inability to do so in the other. Implications for training and other psychotherapy orientations are discussed. Copyright © 2016 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. KEY PRACTITIONER MESSAGE: The interaction of client and therapist relational patterns may be a key factor in the development of the therapeutic alliance and might potentially impact client outcome. Therapeutic practice will likely be improved if therapists are more aware of their own relational patterns and the ways these interact with their clients' relational patterns. Striving for this awareness should probably be a main focal point for therapists throughout their careers, in their training, supervisions and personal therapies.

Applying relationship anecdotes paradigm interviews to study client-therapist relationship narratives: Core conflictual relationship theme analyses.

OBJECTIVE: We describe client-therapist relational narratives collected in relationship anecdotes paradigm (RAP) interviews during psychotherapy and the application of the core conflictual relationship theme (CCRT) method. Changes in clients' and therapists' CCRT in relation to each other are examined and associations between their CCRTs and self-reported ruptures and repairs are explored. METHOD: Sixty-seven clients and 27 therapists underwent RAP interviews and completed self-report rupture and repair items at early, middle, and late psychodynamic psychotherapy. Client-therapist relationship narratives were rated on the CCRT and the relational interplay within dyads was explored qualitatively. RESULTS: CCRT changes from early to late therapy showed that with time clients perceived the therapist (RO) and the self (RS) more positively, and the therapist perceived the self (RS) less negatively. Some associations were found between tension in the session and clients' and therapists' negative RO and RS. Therapists' reports of alliance repairs were associated with positive RO and RS. CONCLUSIONS: Relational narratives that clients and therapists tell in RAP interviews about meaningful interactions between them, enhance our understanding of clients' and therapists' inner experiences during interpersonal dances in the therapeutic relationship. Limitations and directions for future research are discussed, and implications for training are suggested.

Pseudosecure vs. individuated-secure client attachment to therapist: Implications for therapy process and outcome.

OBJECTIVE: We differentiated two hypothesized client subtypes: (a) Pseudosecure clients have high Client Attachment to Therapist Scale (CATS) Secure and high CATS Preoccupied scores, tend to idealize their therapist, and exhibit maladaptive dependency; (b) Individuated-secure clients combine high Secure with low Preoccupied scores and function more autonomously. Clients who, despite insecure attachment to others, "earn" individuated-secure attachment to their therapist benefit most from therapy. METHOD: We examined regression suppressor effects by reanalyzing raw data from four published studies. If pseudosecure attachment is present, when covariance between CATS Secure and Preoccupied scores is removed, residual Secure scores should be significantly better predictors of process/outcome indicators than raw Secure scores. RESULTS: Suppressor effects were observed in eight of nine analyses. Two were statistically significant. Earned individuated-secure attachment predicted improvement in interpersonal relationship symptoms, but only for clients with Avoidant pre-therapy attachment patterns. Finally, significant meta-analytic effect size estimates were obtained for CATS subscales, Secure r = .274 (95% CI = .177, .366), Avoidant, r = -.296 (95% CI = -.392, -193), and Preoccupied, r = -.192 (95% CI = -.289, -.092). CONCLUSIONS: Clients with pre-therapy Avoidant attachment who nevertheless "earn" individuated-secure attachment to their therapist appear to benefit more from therapy.

Relationship representations and change in adolescents and emerging adults during psychodynamic psychotherapy.

OBJECTIVE: Two groups of clients at sequential developmental stages, adolescents and emerging adults, were compared regarding their presenting problems, psychological distress, and relationship representations over one year of psychotherapy. METHOD: Thirty adolescents aged 14-18 years and 30 emerging adults aged 22-28 years, with similar demographic background, completed outcome measures and interviews according to the Core Conflictual Relationship Theme (CCRT) method. RESULTS: The groups differed significantly in the presenting problems but did not differ in their initial levels of distress; their symptoms improved to a similar extent after one year of psychotherapy; differences between the groups in the representations of others were consistent with age-specific developmental challenges; levels of representations were associated with levels of symptoms at the end-point of treatment. CONCLUSION: Clinicians need to be attuned to the specific difficulties and challenges of these continuous yet distinct developmental stages.

Internal Representations of the Therapeutic Relationship Among Adolescents in Psychodynamic Psychotherapy.

UNLABELLED: This study examined changes in adolescents' internal representations of their relationship with their therapist and the extent to which these changes were related to changes in their representations of their relationship with their parents and to treatment outcomes. METHOD: Thirty adolescents (aged 15-18 years, 70% women) undergoing psychodynamic psychotherapy participated in relationship anecdote paradigms interviews based on the core conflictual relationship theme method and completed outcome measures at the beginning of treatment and a year later. RESULTS: Adolescents' positive representations of their therapists increased throughout the year of treatment, whereas their negative representations did not change. There was an association between the development of the therapeutic relationship and improvement in the perception of the relationship with parents over the course of therapy. Increases in the level of positive representations and decreases in the level of negative representations of the therapist were associated with greater satisfaction with treatment but not with the other outcome measures. These results support the centrality of the therapeutic relationship in the process of change during adolescents' psychodynamic psychotherapy. KEY PRACTITIONER MESSAGE: The finding that positive representations of the therapist increased throughout treatment but that negative representations remained steady suggests that therapists who treat adolescents should expect and be able to hear adolescent clients' positive and negative internal representations of themselves. Therapists need to realize that although adolescents often experience negative emotions and perceptions in therapy as in other significant relationships, this does not necessarily block the development of positive emotions. The finding that changes in the representations of the therapist are associated with changes in the representations of parents is in line with psychodynamic theory, which posits that psychotherapy facilitates new interpersonal experiences and new insights through the exploration of the therapeutic relationship. Working in the 'here and now' may eventually impact the nature of other significant relationships, particularly with parents in the case of adolescents.

Client attachment, attachment to the therapist and client-therapist attachment match: how do they relate to change in psychodynamic psychotherapy?

OBJECTIVE: We examined the associations between client attachment, client attachment to the therapist, and symptom change, as well as the effects of client-therapist attachment match on outcome. Clients (n = 67) and their therapists (n = 27) completed the ECR to assess attachment. METHOD: Clients completed also the Client Attachment to Therapist scale three times (early, middle, and late sessions) and the OQ-45 at intake and four times over the course of a year of psychodynamic psychotherapy. RESULTS: Clients characterized by avoidant attachment and by avoidant attachment to their therapist showed the least improvement. A low-avoidant client-therapist attachment match led to a greater decrease in symptom distress than when a low-avoidant therapist treated a high-avoidant client. CONCLUSIONS: These findings suggest the importance of considering client-therapist attachment matching and the need to pay attention to the special challenges involved in treating avoidant clients in order to facilitate progress in psychotherapy.

Types of countertransference dynamics: an exploration of their impact on the client-therapist relationship.

OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to develop a typology of countertransference (CT) based on therapists' narratives about their parents and their clients. METHOD: Data are based on interviews conducted in the early, middle and late phases of ongoing psychodynamic psychotherapy with five therapists who treated 12 clients. Narratives were analyzed using the Core Conflictual Relationship Theme Method (CCRT). CT was defined as repetition of CCRT components from therapists' relationship with their parents in their narratives with their clients. RESULTS: Raters identified five types of CT in the narratives: Wish from parent transferred to client, Projection of the parent Response from Other (RO) to client, Repetition of the Response of Self (RS), Repeating the negative parent RO, and Repair of the parent RO. CONCLUSIONS: A preliminary analysis of two psychodynamic therapies, one with good outcome and one with poor outcome, showed that CT types could be reliably rated.

Adolescents in psychodynamic psychotherapy: changes in internal representations of relationships with parents.

This study explored whether and how internal representations of adolescents' relationship with their parents--a fundamental concept in psychodynamic theory--changed in the course of a year of treatment and whether the observed changes were related to changes in symptoms. Seventy two adolescents (ages 15-18; 30 in treatment and 42 in a non-treatment "community group") underwent Relationship Anecdote Paradigm (RAP) interviews according to the Core Conflictual Relationship Theme method (CCRT; Luborsky & Crits-Christoph, 1998) and completed outcome measures at two time points. A novel data-driven approach to clustering CCRT categories was used to characterize internal representations. The potential contribution of this approach to the CCRT method is discussed. The results indicate that adolescents' internal representations of their relationships with their parents changed significantly throughout treatment, and were related to changes in symptoms.