Efficacy and safety of tianeptine in the treatment of depressive disorders in comparison with fluoxetine.

BACKGROUND: Depression is treated by a great variety of antidepressant treatments. SSRIs (such as fluoxetine) are well known: it is, however, sure that further progress is needed and the search for antidepressants with other mechanisms of action (such as tianeptine) or different efficacy is still of interest. METHODS: A multinational study compared tianeptine with fluoxetine in 387 patients with Depressive Episode, or Recurrent Depressive Disorder, or Bipolar Affective Disorder (ICD-10), in a double-blind parallel group design. They were treated for six weeks. RESULTS: At inclusion, no significant difference between groups was shown. Final MADRS scores were 15.7 and 15.8 with tianeptine and fluoxetine, respectively (ITT population) (p = 0.944). MADRS responders were 58% and 56% with tianeptine and fluoxetine, respectively (p = 0.710). No statistical difference was observed for the other efficacy parameters. Thirty-six withdrawals occurred in each group, without any difference for the reasons of discontinuation. There was no major difference between groups for the other safety parameters. CONCLUSIONS: In this study, both tianeptine and fluoxetine exhibited a good efficacy and safety.

Multicenter double-blind study of moclobemide and maprotiline.

A randomized double-blind, multicenter 6-week study was undertaken in 80 depressed patients to compare the effects of moclobemide, a selective and reversible monoamine oxidase-A inhibitor (300 mg daily), and maprotiline (75 mg daily). Efficacy was assessed by Hamilton Depression Rating Scale (HDRS) and Clinical Global Impression (CGI). Tolerability was assessed by adverse events reports. After 6 weeks of therapy, both groups of patients showed significant improvement in HDRS and CGI. Speed of onset of action was faster with moclobemide (significant difference at week 3, p = 0.025). There was a significant reduction of depression ratings (HDRS) in both the moclobemide and maprotiline group in all types of depression according to ICD-9 criteria (major depressive disorder, neurotic depression and adjustment-prolonged depressive reaction). Significantly fewer patients in the moclobemide group reported adverse events (28.9% compared with 70.2%) including weight gain (2.6% compared to 21.6%). Anticholinergic side effects were less frequent with moclobemide. It is concluded that both drugs are at least equivalent in terms of therapeutic efficacy, but moclobemide is better tolerated.

Efficacy and safety of tianeptine in the treatment of depressive disorders in comparison with fluoxetine*

Depression is treated by a great variety of antidepressant treatments. SSRIs (such as fluoxetine) are well known: it is, however, sure that further progress is needed and the search for antidepressants with other mechanisms of action (such as tianeptine) or different efficacy is still of interest. A multinational study compared tianeptine with fluoxetine in 387 patients with Depressive Episode, or Recurrent Depressive Disorder, or Bipolar Affective Disorder (ICD-10), in a double-blind parallel group design. They were treated for six weeks. At inclusion, no significant difference between groups was shown. Final MADRS scores were 15.7 and 15.8 with tianeptine and fluoxetine, respectively (ITT population) (p = 0.944). MADRS responders were 58% and 56% with tianeptine and fluoxetine, respectively (p = 0.710). No statistical difference was observed for the other efficacy parameters. Thirty-six withdrawals occurred in each group, without any difference for the reasons of discontinuation. There was no major difference between groups for the other safety parameters. In this study, both tianeptine and fluoxetine exhibited a good efficacy and safety. Copyright 1999 Elsevier Science B. V. All rights reserved.

Cost-effectiveness and budget impact of long-acting risperidone in Portugal: a modeling exercise.

BACKGROUND: Previous analyses have shown that long-acting risperidone (LAR) is cost-effective in several Western countries. In Portugal, however, the costs of key services are lower. Therefore, available evidence in other countries may have limited relevance. OBJECTIVE: To estimate costs and effects of LAR versus a conventional depot and a short-acting oral atypical antipsychotic over a 5-year period in Portugal. METHODS: An existing discrete event model was adapted to reflect the Portuguese healthcare setting, based on expert opinion, clinical, epidemiological, and cost data. The model compares three scenarios. In scenario 1, patients start with a conventional depot; in scenario 2, with LAR; and in scenario 3, with oral risperidone. The model simulates individual patient histories while taking into account patient characteristics such as risk to society and side-effects. Subsequently, the model simulates patient histories in terms of outpatient appointments, psychotic episodes, treatment, compliance, symptom scores, lack of ability to take care presenting an actual risk, and treatment setting. Outcomes were number of psychotic episodes, cumulative symptom score and direct medical costs. Univariate sensitivity analyses were carried out. RESULTS: Compared to a conventional depot and an oral atypical, LAR was estimated to save approximately euro 3603 and euro 4682 per patient (respectively) and avoid 0.44 and 0.59 relapses per patient in 5 years. Sensitivity analyses showed that the outcome of dominance was only sensitive to estimates about unit costs of hospital/institutionalization, potential risk, and to the reduction in symptoms by use of atypicals. CONCLUSION: Based on this modeling exercise, it could be expected that LAR may be a cost-effective treatment with limited budget impact in Portugal. However, further studies are required to test the generalizability of the results of the present modeling study to the larger population of Portugal.

The importance of family context in alcoholism.

In the present study, 56 chronic alcoholics were compared with 56 controls with no excessive drinking habits, all of them male. The drinking habits of their parents were studied, as were parental rearing, dyadic relations with the spouses, attachment to significant people, and the education they gave to their own children. It was noted that the alcoholics' parents had heavier drinking habits and could have acted as learning models. As regards the other characteristics, the dyadic cohesion, the global score of the education received from the father and the personal style of criticism/rejection in the education of their own children were underlined.

[Case of compulsive-obsessive neurosis. Clinical observations]. / Quelques considérations cliniques au sujet d'un cas de névrose obsessionnelle-compulsionnelle.

The authors describe a clinical case of obsessive-compulsive neurosis, from eight years of evolution. The out-lined therapy was in agreement with the principles of "behaviour therapy" and had two main goals. The first one, was obtaining the emotional desinhibition of the patient and, the second one, preventing him from doing any ritual, 24 hours per day, using the method of "response prevention". By now he has more than a year after treatment and is maintaining without medicines and leading a professional, active life.

[Value of the symptom in depression]. / La valeur du symptôme dans une dépression.

In the present paper the author tries to consider some of the variables that influence the symptomatological expression of depression, namely the social-cultural factors, the age or the personality of the patient. Considering works of other authors and personal works, analysing also the data that the epidemiological studies have revealed, he points out the importance of the biological symptoms of the clinical picture of depression, such as disturbances of sleep, weight, appetite, libido and diurnal mood swing. These symptoms seem to be a "common denominator" not influenced by the social-cultural environment of the patient with a real meaning as advising signals of the presence of a depression. They correspond to disturbances of phylogenetically old functions, what explains its general presence in the human beings. On the other hand, the other symptoms of depression are linked to the personality of the patient and are determined by learning factors to which the individual has been submitted.