In vitro drug sensitivity testing in Plasmodium vivax.

The possibility of short-term in vitro cultivation, i.e. growth of asexual erythrocytic stages up to the stage of mature schizonts, permits in principle the development of drug sensitivity tests also for Plasmodium vivax. In the absence of a sequestration of erythrocytes carrying the advanced stages of schizogony, asexual parasites of all stages may be seen in the peripheral blood of patients infected with P. vivax. This precludes schizont maturation tests since schizont development will be unduly influenced by the number of advanced trophozoites. A test system reflecting the age composition of the parasite population and its progression without and under the influence of inhibitors was found to yield precise results also in the higher IC ranges. The population-based test procedure would also permit the identification of any stage-specific impact of antimalarial agents.

Pharmacodynamic interaction between 4-aminoquinolines and retinol in Plasmodium falciparum in vitro.

The pharmacodynamic interaction between retinol and 4-aminoquinolines has been investigated in 29 fresh isolates of Plasmodium falciparum. Although the parasites were highly resistant against 4-aminoquinolines, significant synergism was observed between chloroquine and retinol as well as amodiaquine and retinol, the latter at physiological concentrations. Combination with retinol reduced the geometric mean concentrations effecting complete inhibition (GMCOC) by chloroquine from 14425 nM to 8943 nM in CHL-RET low, 7042 nM in CHL-RET medium, and 4920 nM in CHL-RET high. Synergism between amodiaquine and retinol was greater, with strong and highly significant reductions of the GMCOC, from 2520 nM for amodiaquine to 1092 nM for AMO-RET low, 800 nM for AMO-RET medium, and 745 nM for AMO-RET high. While it is obviously too late for making practical use of the activity enhancement for chloroquine, the situation is different for amodiaquine, where supplementation with retinol may extend the usefulness of the medicament.

Synergism between monodesbutyl-benflumetol and artemisinin in Plasmodium falciparum in vitro.

The sensitivity to artemisinin, monodesbutyl-benflumetol (DBB) and a 1:1 m/m combination of the two compounds was successfully investigated on 34 fresh isolates of Plasmodium falciparum. On a molar basis the combination was most active, followed by DBB and artemisinin. The geometric mean concentrations effecting full inhibition (GMCOC) were 49.25 nM for the combination, 279.12 nM for DBB, and 494.05 for artemisinin. The difference between the efficacy of the combination and that of its components was highly significant. Interaction between artemisinin and DBB showed moderate synergism at the EC(50) and strong synergism at EC(90) and EC(99). The individual parasite isolates showed a significant inverse correlation between the ECs and the degree of synergism. Positive specific pharmacodynamic interaction was therefore most marked in isolates with reduced sensitivity against artemisinin and DBB.

Interaction between lumefantrine and monodesbutyl-benflumetol in Plasmodium falciparum in vitro.

The pharmacodynamic interaction between lumefantrine and its monodesbutyl analogue (DBB) has been investigated in 35 fresh isolates of Plasmodium falciparum. Both compounds showed highly significant activity correlation. The geometric mean values for complete inhibition of schizont maturation (GMCOC) were 536,8 nM for lumefantrine, 246.0 nM for DBB, 235,5 nM for LUM-DBB 999:1, and 155,2 nM for LUM-DBB 995:5, with significant activity differences between lumefantrine and DBB as well as the LUM-DBB combinations. For the combination of lumefantrine and DBB 995:5 the sums of the fractional inhibitory concentrations according to Berenbaum (SFIC) indicated marked synergism, the intensity of interaction rising with the effective inhibitory concentrations.

Pharmacodynamic interaction between monodesbutyl-benflumetol and artemisinin as well as proguanil in Plasmodium falciparum in vitro.

The sensitivity of Plasmodium falciparum against artemisinin, monodebutyl-benflumetol (DBB) and a 1:3 m/m combination of both compounds was assessed in 51 fresh parasite isolates. Although a comparison between fully inhibitory concentrations (GMCOC) of artemisinin alone (63.33 nM), DBB alone (50.15 nM) and the combination (23.92 nM) indicated significant synergism between artemisinin and DBB, this was less evident when comparing the log-probit regressions. Moreover, the geometric mean values of the fractional inhibitory concentrations (SFIC) showed a rising tendency with increasing EC level. In a study comprising 24 fresh isolates of P. falciparum, the interaction between DBB and proguanil was explored with a 3:1 m/m combination of both compounds. Proguanil alone showed weak blood schizontocidal activity. The log-probit regressions indicated higher activity of the combination as compared to DBB alone. The SFIC values indicated moderate synergism between DBB and proguanil that could be an advantage in an eventual therapeutic and prophylactic use of DBB.

Malariological baseline survey and in vitro antimalarial drug resistance in Gulu district, Northern Uganda.

A comprehensive, representative malaria survey has been carried out in a population of internally displaced persons (IDP) in the district of Gulu, Northern Uganda. It included 74 households and 390 persons, and covered socio-economic and environmental information, individual physical data, malaria and the drug sensitivity of Plasmodium falciparum. The prevalence of infections with Plasmodium falciparum was 54.4% at a geometric mean asexual parasitaemia of 229/microl blood, typical for hyperendemic conditions. P. falciparum turned out to be highly resistant to chloroquine and amodiaquine. It showed also reduced sensitivity against lumefantrine and artemisinin, obviously the result of the liberal use of the lumefantrine-artemether combination without evidence-based indication.

Synergism between quinine and retinol in fresh isolates of Plasmodium falciparum.

Following earlier reports of synergism between retinol and various antimalarial compounds, the pharmacodynamic interaction between retinol and quinine was investigated in 38 fresh isolates of Plasmodium falciparum. The study was carried out in western Thailand, an area with quinine-resistant P. falciparum. The combination of quinine with retinol in concentrations corresponding to the 50(th), 65(th) and 80(th) percentile of the physiological values in healthy subjects, significantly reduced the EC(50), EC(90), EC(99) and GMCOC for quinine. The FIC values at EC(90) and EC(99) indicate increasing synergism with rising EC and retinol concentration. The mean SFIC value dropped to a level as low as 0.2420, indicating strong synergism.

Synergistic interaction between atovaquone and retinol in Plasmodium falciparum in vitro.

The study has been conducted with the objective of assessing the blood schizontocidal activities of atovaquone (ATO), retinol (RET) and combinations of both (ATO-RET) at set retinol concentrations corresponding to the 50th, 65th and 80th percentile of the physiological serum retinol levels. The in vitro tests followed the WHO standard protocol Mark II for measuring the inhibition of schizont maturation in Plasmodium falciparum. Valid results for all 5 test lines were obtained with 26 fresh parasite isolates from northwestern Thailand, an area affected by multidrug-resistance. The EC(50) values for atovaquone, retinol and for ATO in ATO-RET low, medium and high were 3.1 nM, 561.8nM, 0.85 nM, 0.73 nM and 0.45 nM, respectively, the EC(90) values 33.7 nM, 9338.6 nM, 25.31 nM, 8.89 nM, and 5.42 nM. The geometric mean cut-off concentrations of schizont maturation of atovaquone alone and for atovaquone in ATO-RET low, medium and high were 282.5 nM, 79.0 nM, 38.7 nM and 23.7 nM, respectively. These results and those of the Berenbaum analysis based on the fractional inhibitory concentrations indicate synergistic pharmacodynamic interaction between atovaquone and retinol, a phenomenon suggesting that the antimalarial activity of atovaquone could be enhanced by supplementation with retinol.

Synergistic interaction between monodesbutyl-benflumetol and retinol in Plasmodium falciparum.

The blood schizontocidal activity of monodesbutyl-benflumetol (DBB), retinol (RET) and combinations (DBB-RET) at retinol concentrations corresponding to the 50th, 65th and 80th percentile of physiological retinol concentrations in healthy adults has been investigated in Plasmodium falciparum. Parallel in vitro tests with DBB, RET and the 3 DBB-RET combinations were carried out with 26 fresh parasite isolates from northwestern Thailand, following the WHO standard protocol Mark II for determining the inhibition of schizont maturation. The EC(50) values for DBB, RET and for DBB in DBB-RET low, medium and high were 5.72 nM, 561.83 nM, 1.68 nM, 0.60 nM and 0.07 nM, respectively, the EC(90) values 44.14 nM, 9338.60 nM, 49.00 nM, 28.48 nM and 8.94 nM. The geometric mean cut-off concentrations of schizont maturation for DBB alone and for DBB in DBB-RET low, medium and high were 153.20 nM, 62.93nM, 34.00 nM and 13.74 nM, respectively, indicating significant synergistic interaction between DBB and retinol. The degree of synergism increases with the retinol concentration in the combination and is highest at the EC(99) level for DBB.

Specific pharmacokinetic interaction between lumefantrine and monodesbutyl-benflumetol in Plasmodium falciparum.

The blood schizontocidal activity of lumefantrine, monodesbutyl-benflumetol (DBB) and a 999:1 combination of both compounds has been investigated in 26 fresh isolates of Plasmodium falciparum from northwestern Thailand, using the WHO standard protocol Mark II for determining the inhibition of schizont maturation. The geometric mean cut-off concentrations of schizont maturation (GMCOC) were 943.2 nM for lumefantrine, 146.3 nM for DBB and 182.2 nM for the 999:1 combination of lumefantrine and DBB. The EC(50) values were 27.3 nM for lumefantrine, 5.7 nM for DBB, and 16.5 nM for the combination, and the EC(90) values 163.1 nM for lumefantrine, 44.1 nM for DBB, and 78.3 nM for the combination. Despite the very low concentration in the combination, DBB exerted significant synergistic activity with lumefantrine that was strongest at the EC(90) and EC(99) levels. Correlation analysis indicates that DBB is the leading determinant for the activity of the combination.

Susceptibility to chloroquine, mefloquine and artemisinin of Plasmodium vivax in northwestern Thailand.

The in vitro study had the objectives of monitoring the sensitivity of Plasmodium vivax to chloroquine and artemisinin, and to assess its baseline sensitivity to mefloquine in northwestern Thailand in an area near the border to Myanmar. The investigations were carried out in 2004 at the malaria clinics of Mae Sot, Chedi Ko and Mae Ka Sa, all in the district of Mae Sot, Province of Tak. The in vitro tests followed the method of Tasanor. Successful tests were obtained with 45 fresh isolates of P. vivax. The EC(50) and EC(90) values for chloroquine were 120.9 nM and 655.7 nM, respectively, the GMCOC was 1699.7 nM. There was a significant decrease of the chloroquine sensitivity since 1998/1999. However, results of parallel investigations continue to indicate clinical-parasitological sensitivity to chloroquine. With mefloquine the EC(50) and EC(90) the (baseline) values were 131.6 nM and 972.6 nM, respectively, the GMCOC was 1987.0 nM. For artemisinin the EC(50) and EC(90) values were 8.7 nM and 105.2 nM, respectively, the GMCOC was 310.5 nM. As compared to 2002, the sensitivity of P. vivax to artemisinin has shown a slight but not significant increase.

In vitro interaction between artemisinin and chloroquine as well as desbutyl-benflumetol in Plasmodium vivax.

Malaria resulting from infection with Plasmodium vivax rarely causes death, however, patients usually suffer acute debilitating clinical symptoms and the recovery is slow. This study had the objective of assessing the pharmacodynamic interaction between artimisinin and chloroquine with a view of a potential acceleration of the clinicalparasitological response, and the investigation of therapeutic alternatives in the event of chloroquine resistance in Plasmodium vivax. Tests were based on the growth inhibition of Plasmodium vivax, determined by morphological differential counts of 200 asexual parasites. In total 45 isolates were evaluated successfully with parallel tests for artemisinin, chloroquine and desbutylbenflumetol (DBB) alone and combinations of artemisinin + chloroquine and artemisinin + DBB. Total inhibition was reached at a mean concentration of 1274.8 nM (95% CI 898.5 to 1808.7 nM), and 1852.2 nM (95% CI 1539.5 to 2228.6 nM) for artemisinin, and chloroquine respectively, whilst the 1:1 (m/m) combination of artemisinin and chloroquine was 1860.2 nM (95% CI 1454.4 to 2379.3 nM). EC(50) and EC(90) were 129.9 nM and 1058.5 nM for chloroquine, 32.6 nM and 735.5 nM for artemisinin, and 73.6 nM and 1103.0 nM for the 1:1 combination of both drugs. Interaction analysis according to Berenbaum yielded for the artemisinin + chloroquine combination at the EC(50) a mean SigmaFIC of 1.1126, at the EC(90) a mean SigmaFIC of 1.0331, and at the EC(99) a mean SigmaFIC of 1.1857. These results revealed marked additive interaction. For desbutylbenflumetol (DBB) the EC(50) and EC(90) were 1.5 nM and 28.8 nM, complete growth inhibition was observed at 90.4 nM (95% CI 75.1 to 108.7 nM). Interaction analysis indicated moderate antagonism at the lower concentration ranges, at the EC(90) additive interaction with a mean SigmaFIC of 1.0300, and synergism at the therapeutically most important EC(99) with a mean SigmaFIC of 0.5990.

Pharmacodynamic interaction between atovaquone and other antimalarial compounds against Plasmodium falciparum in vitro.

Atovaquone, a 2-hydroxy-1,4-naphthoquinone, was first introduced as a drug against opportunistic infections in immuno-compromised patients. Early clinical-parasitological experiences in the treatment of malaria were disappointing due to highly variable and poor absorption, a phenomenon typical for naphthoquinones. Proguanil was found to potentiate the activity of atovaquone and the combination of the two drugs was introduced as an antimalarial drug with blood schizontocidal and causal prophylactic activity. It is now widely used in therapy and prophylaxis. Despite the enhanced activity, the combination does not always overcome the problem of poor absorption of atovaquone, especially in the presence of gastro-intestinal disorders. Therefore, further combination with a fast-acting blood schizontocide, e.g. one of the artemisinins, could accelerate clinical improvement and normalization of absorption. The interaction between artemisinin and atovaquone and that of artemisinin and atovaquone + proguanil has been investigated in 37 fresh isolates of Plasmodium falciparum from northwestern Thailand, an area with high prevalence of multi-drug resistance. Interaction between atovaquone and artemisinin was synergistic above the EC(30), with mean SigmaFIC (Berenbaum) values of 0.9679 at the EC(50), 0.4014 at the EC(90) and 0.2214 at the EC(99). Synergism was more pronounced with the triple combination, i.e. atovaquone + proguanil and artemisinin, starting at the EC(10) level. The mean SigmaFIC values were 0.7626 at the EC(50), 0.2939 at the EC(90), and 0.1527 at the EC(99). The strong synergism at the therapeutically relevant effective concentrations suggests that the therapeutic efficacy of atovaquone-proguanil can be considerably enhanced by the additional administration of a suitable artemisinin derivative, e.g. artesunate.

Synergism of desbutyl-benflumetol and retinol against Plasmodium falciparum in vitro.

This in vitro study was conducted to assess the blood schizontocidal activity of desbutyl-benflumetol (DBB), a new benzindene derivative, retinol and a combination of both compounds. The tests were carried out according to the methodology of the WHO standard test Mark II, measuring the drug-dependent inhibition of schizont maturation, and using 43 fresh isolates of Plasmodium falciparum from northwestern Thailand, an area with established multidrug-resistance. DBB and retinol showed a mean 50% effective concentration (EC-50) of 3.73 nM and 466.86 nM and 90% effective concentration (EC-90) of 19.83 nM and 5531.69 nM respectively. The combination of DBB and 3.50 muM retinol showed strong inhibition of schizont maturation, with an EC-90 for DBB of 0.67 nM. At the therapeutically relevant EC-99, the combination was about 10 times more effective than expected, suggesting that retinol potentiated the effect of DBB. A concentration of 3.50 muM retinol corresponds to the 95th percentile of the physiological serum levels. It is well known that retinol levels are significantly decreased in acute falciparum malaria. Supplementation with retinol during malaria treatment may improve the therapeutic results of blood schizontocides of the fluorene class.

In vitro activity of artemisinin alone and in combination with retinol against Plasmodium falciparum.

Increasing resistance of Plasmodium falciparum to antimalarial drugs is an important public health problem, demanding novel therapeutic approaches. This study had the objective of assessing the in vitro activity of artemisinin and its combination with retinol in fresh isolates of P. falciparum in an area with a high proportion of multidrug-resistant strains. The tests were based on the inhibition of schizont maturation. In 45 successfully tested isolates, the mean effective concentrations (ECs) of artemisinin were 10.29 nM for the EC-50 and 34.86 nM for the EC-90. The EC50 and EC90 for artemisinin in the artemisinin-retinol mixture were 2.71 nM and 13.37 nM, respectively. The combination showed synergistic activity. Retinol appears to be a promising partner for the antimalarial therapy with artemisinins.

In vitro activity of tafenoquine alone and in combination with artemisinin against Plasmodium falciparum.

Emergence and spread of drug-resistant falciparum malaria has created an urgent demand for alternative therapeutic agents. This study was conducted to assess the in vitro blood schizontocidal activity of tafenoquine, the most advanced candidate drug of the 8-aminoquinolines, and of its 1:1 combination with artemisinin in fresh isolates of Plasmodium falciparum in an area with multi-drug resistance, measuring the inhibition of schizont maturation. In 43 successfully tested parasite isolates, the mean effective concentrations (ECs) of tafenoquine were 209 nmol/L for the EC50, and 1,414 nmol/L for the EC90. Tafenoquine showed no significant activity relationships with mefloquine, artemisinin, and chloroquine. With quinine, a highly significant activity relationship was observed at the EC50, but not at the EC90. The EC50, and EC90 of the tafenoquine-artemisinin combination were 15.9 nmol/L and 84.3 nmol/L. The combination was synergistic. Tafenoquine appears to be a promising candidate for treating multidrug-resistant falciparum malaria, especially in combination with artemisinin derivatives.

Malaria at the turn from the 2nd to the 3rd millenium.

With an annual incidence of 300-500 million clinically manifest cases and a death toll of 1.1-2.7 million, malaria is still one of the most important communicable diseases. Currently about 40% of the world's population live in areas where malaria is endemic, as against 80% in 1950. Although this reflects considerable impact of intensive malaria control, especially between 1950 and 1970, the disease continues to affect large populations in all parts of the tropics and subtropics, and remains most deeply rooted in tropical Africa, the region with 90% of the global malaria incidence. As malaria in tropical Africa is predominantly caused by Plasmodium falciparum, this area also suffers from the highest specific mortality. Drug resistance of P. falciparum is the most formidable obstacle in the fight against the disease since it jeopardizes the most elementary objective of malaria control, namely the elimination of mortality and the reduction of suffering from malaria.

In-vitro sensitivity testing of Plasmodium vivax: response to lumefantrine and chloroquine in northwestern Thailand.

The acquisition of resistance to chloroquine by Plasmodium vivax in parts of the Australasian and Malaysian epidemiological zones and hitherto unconfirmed reports of such resistance in neighbouring zones show the need for monitoring the drug response of P. vivax. In this study, a recently developed in-vitro micro-technique for the assessment of the parasite's sensitivity to chloroquine was adapted to and validated for lumefantrine. In 21 P. vivax isolates tested at Mae Hong Son, northwestern Thailand, in 2001, the mean geometric cut-off concentration for full inhibition for lumefantrine was 2080 nM. The EC50 and EC90 were 12 nM and 237 nM, respectively. The response was well within the putative therapeutic range. Sensitivity to chloroquine was assessed in 18 P. vivax isolates, showing a geometric mean cut-off concentration of 1095 nM and a wider variation of the individual cut-off points compared with lumefantrine. The EC50 and EC90 for chloroquine were 16 nM and 511 nM, respectively. One of the isolates, from Myanmar, showed low sensitivity to chloroquine.

Comparative study of the in vitro sensitivity of Plasmodium falciparum to artemisinin in two border areas of Thailand.

Artesunate was introduced in Thailand in 1995 for the treatment of falciparum malaria in areas of multidrug resistance, where it is used in combination with mefloquine. The studies were conducted between May and August 1999, 2000 and 2001 in the provinces Mae Hong Son and Tak (Mae Sot District) in northwestern Thailand, both on the border to Myanmar. The province of Mae Hong Son is still largely unaffected by multidrug resistance and infections with Plasmodium falciparum are treated with mefloquine alone. In the district of Mae Sot, 350 km southwards, more than 60% of the Plasmodium falciparum isolates were found to be resistant to mefloquine. Between 1999 and 2001, a total of 227 fresh isolates of Plasmodium falciparum were successfully tested for their sensitivity to artemisinin using the WHO standard in vitro microtest. The weighted mean EC5o and EC90 values for 1999-2001 were 9.20 nM and 34.37 nM in Mae Hong Son and 11.18nM and 71.63nM in Mae Sot, respectively. The comparison of the sensitivity to artemisinin between Mae Hong Son and Mae Sot showed no significant difference in 1999, but significant differences in 2000 (p<0.05) and in 2001 (p<0.01). This phenomenon could be a consequence of different drug pressure. Furthermore, the lower sensitivity of Plasmodium falciparum to mefloquine in Mae Sot may play a minor (but amplifying) role, as the activities of artemisinin and mefloquine show a significant correlation.

In vitro sensitivity of Plasmodium falciparum to lumefantrine in north-western Thailand.

Lumefantrine (benflumetol) belongs to the class-2 blood schizontocidal compounds. In combination with artemether it serves as an alternative drug for treating chloroquine-resistant infections with Plasmodium falciparum. In view of activity correlations with mefloquine, it is important to monitor the parasite's intrinsic sensitivity to lumefantrine in areas with multi-drug resistant P. falciparum, the objective of this study. The observations were carried out in 2002 at Mae Sot, northwestern Thailand, near the border to Myanmar. The 41 successfully in-vitro tested parasite isolates yielded a geometric mean cut-off concentration of schizont maturation of 237.54 nM, and EC50, EC90 and EC90 values of 15.13 nM, 86.71 nM and 359.97 nM, respectively. As compared to the findings of 1998 and 1999, the susceptibility to lumefantrine has increased, possibly due to the improved therapeutic response of mefloquine-resistant P. falciparum infections to combined treatment with artesunate + mefloquine. The EC9o and EC99 data of 2002 for lumefantrine in the study area suggest fully curative clinical-parasitological efficacy.