Sporadic hereditary neuropathies misdiagnosed as chronic inflammatory demyelinating polyradiculoneuropathy: Pitfalls and red flags.

Hereditary neuropathies may be misdiagnosed with chronic inflammatory demyelinating polyradiculoneuropathy (CIDP). A correct diagnosis is crucial for avoiding unnecessary therapies and access genetic counseling. We report on nine patients (seven men, mean age 49.2 ± 16.1) diagnosed with and treated as CIDP, in whom mutations or variants of unknown significance (VUS) in genes associated with hereditary neuropathies were reported. All underwent neurological and neurophysiological examination, eight also cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) analysis. In 4/9, nerve ultrasound and/or MR-neurography were performed. All the patients complained of progressive upper or lower limbs sensory-motor symptoms, with heterogeneous disease duration (1-34 years, mean 8.6 ± 10.8). Neurophysiology showed demyelinating signs in seven patients, mixed findings with predominant axonal damage in two patients. Neuroimaging disclosed diffuse abnormalities at proximal and distal segments. Molecular screening showed PMP22 duplication in two patients, mutations in the MPZ, EGR2, and GJB1 genes were reported in each of the remaining patients. The two patients with mixed neurophysiological findings had p.Val30Met mutation in the transthyretin gene. Two patients had VUS in the MARS and HSPB1 genes. Four patients had partial response to immunomodulant therapies, and CSF and neurophysiological features suggesting an inflammatory condition concomitant with the hereditary neuropathy. Hereditary neuropathy may be misdiagnosed with CIDP. The most common pitfalls are CSF (high protein levels and oligoclonal bands), incorrect interpretation of neurophysiology, and transient benefit from therapies. Neuroimaging may be helpful in cases with atypical presentations or when severe axonal damage complicate the neurophysiological interpretation.

Ataxic Guillain-Barré syndrome and acute sensory ataxic neuropathy form a continuous spectrum.

BACKGROUND: Ataxic Guillain-Barré syndrome is characterised by profound ataxia with negative Romberg sign and no ophthalmoplegia. Its nosological relationship to acute sensory ataxic neuropathy has yet to be discussed. METHODS: Medical records were reviewed of patients suffering acute ataxia and reduced muscle stretch reflexes but without external ophthalmoplegia. Clinical features and laboratory findings were analysed. Rat muscle spindles were immunostained by anti-GQ1b and -GD1b antibodies. RESULTS: The Romberg sign was negative in 37 (69%) of 54 patients with acute ataxic neuropathy without ophthalmoplegia, but positive in the other 17 (31%). The negative and positive subgroups had similar features; preceding infectious symptoms (86% vs 83%), distal paraesthesias (70% vs 88%), superficial sense impairment (27% vs 24%), IgG antibodies to GQ1b (65% vs 18%) and GD1b (46% vs 47%) and cerebrospinal fluid albuminocytological dissociation (30% vs 39%). Findings did not differ between the subgroups of 466 patients with Fisher syndrome with and without sensory ataxia. Acute ataxic neuropathy patients more often had anti-GD1b (46% vs 26%) and less often anti-GQ1b (50% vs 83%) antibodies than Fisher syndrome. Anti-GQ1b and -GD1b antibodies strongly stained parvalbumin-positive nerves in rat muscle spindles, indicative that proprioceptive nerves highly express GQ1b and GD1b. CONCLUSION: Clinical and laboratory features suggest that ataxic Guillain-Barré syndrome and acute sensory ataxic neuropathy form a continuous spectrum. The two conditions could be comprehensively referred to as 'acute ataxic neuropathy (without ophthalmoplegia)' to avoid nosological confusion because Fisher syndrome is not classified by the absence or presence of sensory ataxia. That is, acute ataxic neuropathy can be positioned as an incomplete form of Fisher syndrome.

Increased systemic B- and T-lymphocyte responses in hereditary motor and sensory neuropathy (HMSN I).

Immune mechanisms of possible importance for the development and maintenance of peripheral nerve myelin breakdown in HMSN I were analysed by measuring B- and T-cell activation in blood, bone marrow and cerebrospinal fluid. Patients with polyneuropathies of other etiologies served as one control group and patients with tension headache as another. Flow cytometry of blood and bone marrow mononuclear cells revealed that an increased number of CD3+, CD4+ and CD4- CD8- T-cells expressed a late stage activation marker (Ta1). Analysis of T-cells primed for myelin antigens, by studies of IFN-gamma secretion in response to antigen in vitro, showed that both HMSN I and other polyneuropathy patients had low (but significant) numbers of T-cells recognizing whole PNS-myelin. Increased numbers of IgG- and IgM-producing cells were found in blood and bone marrow in the HMSN I patients. Patients with both HMSN I and the other polyneuropathies had few cells in peripheral blood and in bone marrow producing antibodies binding to P2, MAG and MBP in a solid phase immunospot assay. Many cells in the cerebrospinal fluid produced antibodies against MAG. Thus, there was a strong general activation of B- and T-cells in HMSN I while the immunity directed toward peripheral nerve was only slightly elevated. It is an open question if this immune activation is related to the primary gene defect or a secondary event to the nerve damage. The pathogenetic importance of the immune response in maintaining the nerve damage in HMSN I is unclear.

Changes in concanavalin A-reactive proteins in neurological disorders.

Changes of glycosylation of cerebrospinal fluid proteins such as alpha2-macroglobulin, and prostaglandin D synthase were studied by lectin blotting, using concanavalinA, in multiple sclerosis (n = 42) and neuropathies (n = 20) in comparison to neurological controls (n = 22). The concanavalinA-reactivity of alpha2-macroglobulin, which was increased in the neuropathies but not in multiple sclerosis compared to controls, correlated with the total concanavalinA-reactivity in controls and neuropathies but not in multiple sclerosis, indicating that the protein could be abnormally glycosylated in the latter disease. Although the concentration and the concanavalinA-reactivity of prostaglandin D synthase were not significantly different in the three groups, the two parameters correlated only in neuropathies but not in controls or multiple sclerosis, probably due to the high heterogeneity of the protein. These changes deserve to be studied in further detail in view of their potential clinical applications.

Sensory nerve pathology in multifocal motor neuropathy.

The nosological status of multifocal motor neuropathy remains controversial. The clinical and electrodiagnostic hallmarks suggest selective motor fiber involvement. In this study, we asked to what extent sensory nerves might be involved pathologically in multifocal motor neuropathy. Examination of sensory nerve biopsy specimens from 11 patients did reveal pathological findings in all, but they were very mild. An increased number of thinly myelinated, large-caliber fibers was the unifying feature common to each specimen. By electron microscopy, each biopsy specimen had thinly myelinated fibers surrounded by minor onion bulbs. Active demyelination, though scant, was seen in 3 nerves. Myelinated fiber density was normal. Subperineurial edema and inflammation were not present. We conclude that multifocal motor neuropathy is not an exclusively motor abnormality, although it appears to be so clinically and electrophysiologically. The frequent, albeit mild, pathological abnormalities in sensory fibers suggest that the demyelinating pathophysiology also affects sensory fibers, but to a lesser degree than motor fibers. Some investigators maintain that multifocal motor neuropathy is within the spectrum of chronic inflammatory demyelinating polyneuropathy. The very mild degree of sensory fiber involvement, the absence of inflammation or edema, and the distinctive clinical features support the concept of multifocal motor neuropathy as distinct from chronic inflammatory demyelinating polyneuropathy.