The Monomer-Dimer Equilibrium of Triscatechol Titanium(IV)-Based Hierarchical Helicates as a Tool for the Development of Molecular Balances and Molecular Switches.

ConspectusHierarchical helicates are formed by noncovalent connection of two or more monomeric metal complex units, e.g., by bridging metal cations. A unique kind of hierarchical helicate is obtained from 3-carbonyl substituted catechol ligands with titanium(IV) ions in the presence of lithium cations. This kind of supramolecular complex shows in solution a "monomer-dimer" equilibrium. There are different possibilities (solvent, countercation, substituents at carbonyl unit, etc.) to shift this equilibrium to either the monomer or the dimer side. Thus, the lithium-bridged catecholate-based hierarchical helicates resemble a molecular switch. In this Account, different aspects are discussed of how this unique behavior of the dimeric titanium catecholates can be used for application.Thorough investigation of the energetics of the monomer-dimer equilibrium leads to a deeper understanding of the thermodynamic and kinetic effects of the dimerization (or dissociation) process. In this context, even weak interaction of substituents in the periphery of the complexes can be observed. Hereby on the one hand, solvent effects have an important influence and can be easily evaluated. The thorough understanding of the behavior of the monomer-dimer equilibrium allows one to develop some novel applications. In this respect, the use of the hierarchical helicate-based switch as a platform for reaction control and catalysis is described. Decent enantioselectivities up to ee = 58% can be found in Diels-Alder reactions in the periphery of the dimers, while switching to the monomer as a reaction platform still allows the cycloaddition reaction but turns the selectivity off. Additionally, it is described that catalytically important units can be introduced and hydrogenation reactions as well as Michael-type reactions are catalyzed at the helicates.Covalent connection of two catechol ester units leads to classical helicates. Depending on the alkaline metal cation, those can be switched from a compressed to an expanded form or vice versa. Hereby the monomer-dimer equilibrium is transformed into a structural switch. The switching process can be initiated by removal or addition of lithium cations (e.g., by addition of [2.1.1]cryptand). Alternative switching possibilities are based in the case of glycol bridged helicates on cation translocation isomerism and with thioester derivatives it occurs spontaneously in DMSO. Introduction of chiral tethers results in a three state switch allowing expansion/compression as well as switching of the helicity.

7Li NMR Spectroscopy: A Tool for Determining Dimerization Constants and Averaged Dimerization Constants of the Monomer/Dimer Equilibrium of Hierarchical Helicates.

7Li nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy is an ideal tool to study hierarchically assembled helicates of the form Li[Li3L6Ti2]. Internally bound and external lithium ions can be well distinguished by solution- or solid-state NMR spectroscopy and dimerization constants of the monomer/dimer equilibrium can be easily determined in solution. Averaged dimerization constants can be estimated in case of statistical mixtures of helicates formed from mixtures of ligands.

Solvent Dependence of the Monomer-Dimer Equilibrium of Ketone-Substituted Triscatecholate Titanium(IV) Complexes.

Hierarchical helicates based on ketone-substituted titanium(IV)triscatecholates show different monomer-dimer behavior depending on different solvents. The dimerization constants of a whole series of differently alkyl-substituted complexes is analyzed to show that the solvent has a very strong influence on the dimerization. Hereby, effects like solvophobicity/philicity, sterics, electronics of the substituents and weak side-chain-side-chain interactions seem to act in concert.

Catechol Thioesters: Ligands for Hierarchically Formed Lithium-Bridged Titanium(IV) Helicates and Helicate-Based Switches.

The thioester moiety is introduced as a lithium binding unit for the hierarchical formation of titanium(IV) catecholate-based lithium-bridged helicates. In solution, the coordination compounds show a monomer-dimer equilibrium which -in comparison to the oxo esters- is significantly shifted towards the monomers. In addition, the influence of the thioester side chain on the dimerization behavior is investigated and an expansible/compressible molecular switch is synthesized. In the latter case expansion and compression are performed reversibly in methanol, whereas in DMSO spontaneous expansion occurs.

Shedding Light on the Interactions of Hydrocarbon Ester Substituents upon Formation of Dimeric Titanium(IV) Triscatecholates in DMSO Solution.

The dissociation of hierarchically formed dimeric triple lithium bridged triscatecholate titanium(IV) helicates with hydrocarbyl esters as side groups is systematically investigated in DMSO. Primary alkyl, alkenyl, alkynyl as well as benzyl esters are studied in order to minimize steric effects close to the helicate core. The 1 H NMR dimerization constants for the monomer-dimer equilibrium show some solvent dependent influence of the side chains on the dimer stability. In the dimer, the ability of the hydrocarbyl ester groups to aggregate minimizes their contacts with the solvent molecules. Due to this, most solvophobic alkyl groups show the highest dimerization tendency followed by alkenyls, alkynyls and finally benzyls. Furthermore, trends within the different groups of compounds can be observed. For example, the dimer is destabilized by internal double or triple bonds due to π-π repulsion. A strong indication for solvent supported London dispersion interaction between the ester side groups is found by observation of an even/odd alternation of dimerization constants within the series of n-alkyls, n-Ω-alkenyls or n-Ω-alkynyls. This corresponds to the interaction of the parent hydrocarbons, as documented by an even/odd melting point alternation.

Iron(III) Chloride as a Mild Catalyst for the Dearomatizing Cyclization of N-Acylindoles.

A catalytic approach for the preparation of indolines by dearomatizing cyclization is presented. FeCl3 acts as a catalyst to afford tetracyclic 5a,6-dihydro-12H-indolo[2,1-b][1,3]benzoxazin-12-ones in good yields. The cyclization also proceeds with tosylamides forming C-N bonds in 53% yield.

Stability of Hierarchically Formed Titanium(IV) Tris(catecholate ester) Helicates with Cyclohexyl Substituents in DMSO.

A cyclohexyl substituent strongly prefers the chair conformation with large substituents in equatorial positions, while other cycloalkyls are structurally more flexible. In hierarchically formed dimeric titanium(IV) tris(catecholates) equatorial versus axial connection of the cyclohexane to the ester results in either a more compact (axial) or more expanded (equatorial) structure. In DMSO solution the axial position results in a compact structure which minimizes solvophobic effects, leading to higher stability. However, computational investigations indicate that additionally intramolecular London dispersion interactions significantly contribute to the stability of the dimer. Thus, weak side-chain-side-chain interactions are responsible for the high stability of cyclohexyl ester derivatives with axial compared to equatorial ester connection.

Hierarchically assembled helicates as reaction platform - from stoichiometric Diels-Alder reactions to enamine catalysis.

The stereoselectivity of a Diels-Alder reaction within the periphery of hierarchically assembled titanium(IV) helicates formed from mixtures of achiral, reactive and chiral, unreactive ligands was investigated in detail. Following the pathway of the chiral induction, the chiral ligands, solvents as well as substituents at the dienophile were carefully varied. Based on the results of the stoichiometric reaction, a secondary amine-catalyzed nitro-Michael reaction is performed as well which afforded reasonable diastereoselectivities.

From Hierarchical Helicates to Functional Supramolecular Devices.

Catechol ligands with aldehyde, ketone or ester groups attached in 3-position form, in the presence of titanium(IV) triscatecholate, titanium(IV) complexes. If lithium cations are the counterions, they can bind in a successive step to the salicylate units of the complex and form a dimeric triple-lithium-bridged dinuclear helicate. In solution, the dimer is in equilibrium with the monomer and the thermodynamics of the dimerization can be easily evaluated. Thus, the hierarchically assembled titanium(IV) helicates represent a lithium-dependent molecular switch. The investigation of different derivatives of the complex allows for an estimation of the influence of side chain functionalities on the energetics of the dimerization. Thus, the hierarchically assembled helicates can be used as a kind of molecular balance to determine weak interaction energies (solvophobic effects and even dispersive effects). In addition, tethering of two ligands leads to "classical" helicates. Removal or addition of lithium cations allows for a reversible switching between a compressed and expanded state, which in the case of chiral ligands can be even performed stereospecifically.

Cation-Controlled Formation and Interconversion of the fac/fac and mer/mer Stereoisomers of a Triple-Stranded Helicate.

Two biscatecholester ligands with oligoether spacers were used to prepare dinuclear titanium(IV) triscatecholate based helicates. In the case of Li4 [(1/2)3 Ti2 ], "classical" helicates with three internally bound Li+ ions and syn-oriented ligands in the complex units (fac/fac isomer) were obtained. In the case of the sodium salt Na4 [(2)3 Ti2 ], a different homochiral dinuclear triple-stranded helicate with two internally bound Na+ ions was formed. The complex units are anti-configured, and two of the ligand spacers are connecting internal with external positions of the helicate (mer/mer isomer). Removal of the sodium ions and addition of lithium ions leads to the switching from one topology to the other with an expanded helicate [(2)3 Ti2 ]4- as an intermediate. Switching back to the "non-classical" helicate cannot be observed because severe structural rearrangements would be required.

A Helicate-Based Three-State Molecular Switch.

The control of structural transformations triggered by external signals is important for the development of novel functional devices. In the present study, it is demonstrated that helicates can be designed to structurally respond to the presence of different counterions and to adopt either a compressed or an expanded structure. Reversible switching is not only possible between those two states, furthermore, the twist of the aggregate also can be controlled. Thus, three out of four possible states of a helicate (expanded/left-handed, expanded/right-handed, compressed/left-handed) based on an enantiomerically pure ester bridged dicatecholate ligand are specifically addressed by introduction, exchange, or removal of countercations. This approach is used to reversibly switch between the different states or to successively address them.

Chasing Weak Forces: Hierarchically Assembled Helicates as a Probe for the Evaluation of the Energetics of Weak Interactions.

London dispersion forces are the weakest interactions between molecules. Because of this, their influence on chemical processes is often low, but can definitely not be ignored, and even becomes important in cases of molecules with large contact surfaces. Hierarchically assembled dinuclear titanium(IV) helicates represent a rare example in which the direct observation of London dispersion forces is possible in solution even in the presence of strong cohesive solvent effects. Hereby, the dispersion forces do not unlimitedly support the formation of the dimeric complexes. Although they have some favorable enthalpic contribution to the dimerization of the monomeric complex units, large flexible substituents become conformationally restricted by the interactions leading to an entropic disadvantage. The dimeric helicates are entropically destabilized.

A Supramolecular Chiral Auxiliary Approach: "Remote Control" of Stereochemistry at a Hierarchically Assembled Dimeric Helicate.

Dimeric hierarchically-assembled titanium(IV) helicates are in solvent-dependent equilibrium with the corresponding monomers. Statistically formed mixtures of such complexes bearing chiral stereocontrolling ligands and achiral diene-substituted ligands show high diastereoselectivity and reasonable enantioselectivity in the Diels-Alder reaction with maleimides if the reaction proceeds with the dimer but not with the monomer. Thus, solvent dependent switching between the monomer and dimer enables on/off switching of the enantioselectivity.

CF3 : An Electron-Withdrawing Substituent for Aromatic Anion Acceptors? "Side-On" versus "On-Top" Binding of Halides.

The ability of multiple CF3 -substituted arenes to act as acceptors for anions is investigated. The results of quantum-chemical calculations show that a high degree of trifluoromethyl substitution at the aromatic ring results in a positive quadrupole moment. However, depending on the polarizability of the anion and on the substitution at the arene, three different modes of interaction, namely Meisenheimer complex, side-on hydrogen bonding, or anion-π interaction, can occur. Experimentally, the side-on as well as a η(2) -type π-complex are observed in the crystal, whereas in solution only side-on binding is found.

Coordinatively Unsaturated Lanthanide(III) Helicates: Luminescence Sensors for Adenosine Monophosphate in Aqueous Media.

Coordinatively unsaturated double-stranded helicates [(H2 L)2 Eu2 (NO3 )2 (H2 O)4 ](NO3 )4 , [(H2 L)2 Tb2 (H2 O)6 ](NO3 )6 , and [(H2 L)2 Tb2 (H2 O)6 ]Cl6 (H2 L=butanedioicacid-1,4-bis[2-(2-pyridinylmethylene)hydrazide]) are easily obtained by self-assembly from the ligand and the corresponding lanthanide(III) salts. The complexes are characterized by X-ray crystallography showing the helical arrangement of the ligands. Co-ligands at the metal ions can be easily substituted by appropriate anions. A specific luminescence response of AMP in presence of ADP, ATP, and other anions is observed. Specificity is assigned to the perfect size match of AMP to bridge the two metal centers and to replace quenching co-ligands in the coordination sphere.

Stereocontrol in dinuclear triple lithium-bridged titanium(IV) complexes: solving some stereochemical mysteries.

Compounds 1 a-f-H2 form "monomeric" triscatecholate titanium(IV) complexes [Ti(1 a-f)3](2-), which in the presence of Li cations are in equilibrium with the triple lithium-bridged "dimers" [Li3(Ti(1 a-f)3)2](-). The equilibrium strongly depends on the donor ability of the solvent. Usually, in solvents with high donor ability, the stereochemically labile monomer is preferred, whereas in nondonor solvents, the dimer is the major species. In the latter, the stereochemistry at the complex units is "locked". The configuration at the titanium(IV) triscatecholates is influenced by addition of chiral ammonium countercations. In this case, the induced stereochemical information at the monomer is transferred to the dimer. Alternatively, the configuration at the metal complexes can be controlled by enantiomerically pure ester side chains. Due to the different orientation of the ester groups in the monomer or dimer, opposite configurations of the triscatecholates were observed by circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy for [Ti(1 c-e)3](2-) or [Li3(Ti(1 c-e)3)2](-). A surprising exception was found for the dimer [Li3(Ti(1 f)3)2](-). Herein, the dimer is the dominating species in weak donor (methanol), as well as strong donor (DMSO), solvents. This is due to the bulkiness of the ester substituent destabilizing the monomer. Due to the size of the substituent in [Li3(Ti(1 f)3)2](-) the esters have to adopt an unusual conformation in the dimer resulting in a stereocontrol of the small methyl group. Following this, opposite stereocontrol mechanisms were observed for the central metal-complex units of [Li3(Ti(1 c-e)3)2](-) or [Li3(Ti(1 f)3)2](-).

Sensing of phosphates by using luminescent Eu(III) and Tb(III) complexes: application to the microalgal cell Chlorella vulgaris.

Phenanthroline-based chiral ligands L(1) and L(2) as well as the corresponding Eu(III) and Tb(III) complexes were synthesized and characterized. The coordination compounds show red and green emission, which was explored for the sensing of a series of anions such as F(-), Cl(-), Br(-), I(-), NO3(-), NO2(-), HPO4(2-), HSO4(-), CH3COO(-), and HCO3(-). Among the anions, HPO4(2-) exhibited a strong response in the emission property of both europium(III) and terbium(III) complexes. The complexes showed interactions with the nucleoside phosphates adenosine triphosphate (ATP), adenosine diphosphate (ADP), and adenosine monophosphate (AMP). Owing to this recognition, these complexes have been applied as staining agents in the microalgal cell Chlorella vulgaris. The stained microalgal cells were monitored through fluorescence microscopy and scanning electron microscopy. Initially, the complexes bind to the outer cell wall and then enter the cell wall through holes in which they probably bind to phospholipids. This leads to a quenching of the luminescence properties.

Red/near-infrared luminescence tuning of group-14 element complexes of dipyrrins based on a central atom.

A dipyrrin complex has been one of the most utilized fluorescent dyes, and a variety of dipyrrin complexes show intriguing functions based on the various coordination structures of the central element. We now report the synthesis, structure, and photophysical properties of germanium and stannane complexes of the N2O2-type tetradentate dipyrrin, L·Ge and L·Sn, which are heavier analogues of the previously reported dipyrrin silicon complex, L·Si. The central group-14 atoms of the monomeric complexes have geometries close to trigonal bipyramidal (TBP), in which the contribution of the square-pyramidal (SP) character becomes higher as the central atom is heavier. Interestingly, L·Sn formed a dimeric structure in the crystal. All complexes L·Si, L·Ge, and L·Sn showed a fluorescence in the red/NIR region. Fluorescence quantum yields of L·Ge and L·Sn are higher than that of L·Si. These results indicated that the central atom on the dipyrrin complexes contributes not only to the geometry difference but also to tuning the fluorescence properties.

Di-, tri-, and tetra(pentafluorophenyl) derivatives for oligotopic anion-π interactions.

The present study describes a series of pentafluorobenzyl ammonium salts with two, three, or four C6F5 units in order to investigate simultaneous interactions of several perfluorinated arenes with anions in the crystalline state. Most of the structures show multiple anion-π contacts. However, only 6·2HI reveals an effective encapsulation of the iodide ion by the aromatic units. For comparison, the structure of 4b is investigated because it offers two π-systems with inverse charge distribution to a bromide anion. Only the electron-deficient π-system of the pentafluorophenyl group interacts with the anion.

Lanthanide(III) complexes of bis-semicarbazone and bis-imine-substituted phenanthroline ligands: solid-state structures, photophysical properties, and anion sensing.

Phenanthroline-based hexadentate ligands L(1) and L(2) bearing two achiral semicarbazone or two chiral imine moieties as well as the respective mononuclear complexes incorporating various lanthanide ions, such as La(III), Eu(III), Tb(III), Lu(III), and Y(III) metal ions, were synthesized, and the crystal structures of [ML(1)Cl(3)] (M=La(III), Eu(III), Tb(III), Lu(III), or Y(III)) complexes were determined. Solvent or water molecules act as coligands for the rare-earth metals in addition to halide anions. The big Ln(III) ion exhibits a coordination number (CN) of 10, whereas the corresponding Eu(III), Tb(III), Lu(III), and Y(III) centers with smaller ionic radii show CN=9. Complexes of L(2), namely [ML(2)Cl(3)] (M=Eu(III), Tb(III), Lu(III), or Y(III)) ions could also be prepared. Only the complex of Eu(III) showed red luminescence, whereas all the others were nonluminescent. The emission properties of the Eu derivative can be applied as a photophysical signal for sensing various anions. The addition of phosphate anions leads to a unique change in the luminescence behavior. As a case study, the quenching behavior of adenosine-5'-triphosphate (ATP) was investigated at physiological pH value in an aqueous solvent. A specificity of the sensor for ATP relative to adenosine-5'-diphosphate (ADP) and adenosine-5'-monophosphate (AMP) was found. (31)P NMR spectroscopic studies revealed the formation of a [EuL(2)(ATP)] coordination species.